That is an interesting take 🙊 Kind of echos with part of the premise that OG Timeline Sunjae was too mentally…
True, adding depression to the mix in his first death gives it more depth! The way they used the suite table to show his deferred mental state right before he was attacked between ep 1 and 8 was a nice touch.
For Sol's sake, SJ may have tried to fight off the killer even in the OG timeline, but was too weak (since logically Sol would be the killer's next target). Honestly this just makes things even more depressing, imagining his desperation. What do you think?
I can't remember the exact details but in the script book, the writer did mention that one of the possible reasons why the watch got activated in the original timeline was because it was his dying wish to protect Sol🥲 (i might be remembering it wrong though)🙈
Second death (technically 3rd death/ coma since we don't actually get to see his second death)- Sunjae was more optimistic but i love how they gave more insight as to why SJ may have wanted to retire in his first life by sharing details about his stressful Idol life in ep 8. (Imagine dealing with his idol life along with his guilt? It's too much🫠).
PS: The hidden container was the Candy egg jar Sol gave him as part of his recovery pack in 2008- not meds (ikr?! It's so sweet that he kept it close to him all this time even after "Sol" rejected him🙈🤩)
On Sunjae's first death -- I think he still met the killer taxi driver, but he was already suicidal too. I think…
That is an interesting take 🙊 Kind of echos with part of the premise that OG Timeline Sunjae was too mentally exhausted/ inebriated to fight off the killer before he was chloroformed.
Exactly! most of these LR fans are inexperienced. They have only watched LR or a few more dramas.
Totally agree with you on this- one can love all kinds of dramas. You shouldn't have to choose one/ justify.
@Lovetoloveyou- since you blocked me i can't reply directly, but since you called me out, I am the last person who should be accused of being a BL hater/ homophobe- my watchlist is filled with highly rated BLs and I have never made such comments.
Please research before making accusations.
💙💛 Edit (since you blocked me again): @Lovetoloveyou- wouldn't it be simpler to just admit that you made a mistake this time instead of twisting my words (in your next comment) AGAIN by editing your original comment to say that I'm bored now instead of the original weirdo/homophobe comment?
Edit 2: @Love2- Nobody is being complacent. The original "BL" comment was extra but it was taken out of context seeing as it wasn't aimed at anybody but was a response in agreement that the 9.1 rating and hype may have raised unrealistic expectations🤷♀️ The rest of the thread is just too juvenile to waste time on.
(I'm only referring to yesterday's comment btw- idk if anything else happened in MDL in a homophobic context. If somebody was really attacking another user with slurs, then shame on them)
That's what special of this drama: haters CANT MOVE ON & camp here to spread hate from time to time 😉
Ah my bad...i see that *Lovetoloveyou* did reply but again, blocking me basically meant that I wouldn't see all that research done.
Dear Love2,
First of- kudos 👏 , that's alot of research done.
Comment 1 👇 https://kisskh.at/750099-time-walking-on-memory#comment-18273469 I am glad that you shared this particular comment as it is another example of twisting what i say. The reply wasn't at the OP but another commenter. I never mentioned about biases and literally just told to ignore ALL HYPE (good and bad)- but alas, the commentor chose to half read my comment and assume i was amping the show When really all i said was to ignore even the good hype.
This link that YOU shared is a perfect example of why fans can be harsh. Criticism is acceptable but if you look at the thread and some of the other threads that were there on that day, there was a sudden surge of anti-HY comments that crossed the line. HY is not my bias and I've only seen one of her other dramas, but being viscious over somebody relentlessly for no reason is pathetic right? Just like it's not right to give exaggerate hateful comments about Suzy's looks and performance, the same applies to HY too.
I admit it could have been handled better but context is important as there were alot of harsh threads below this particular comment thread so the user snapped. But as you can see, the so called Subeoum sheep DID NOT drag the Suzy bashing and even discouraged it unlike the thread that started the HY hate/ Suzy comparison in the first place.
Sure, I admit my response might come off as know-it-all/ arrogant since the OP didn't ask any questions in the original post. My response was in response to the OP's comment that HY wasn't a reason for the show's success which in my opinion wasn't fair. I cannot talk on behalf of the other's comments since I actually don't have a posy so can't control them.
I honestly can't see what's manipulative with my comment so please clarify. If any fans were rude, then they should haave known better.
👇 Script book comment: While the OP did not ask for an opinion, they did list out a long list of "plot holes" which were not really plot holes. Since part of the reason MDL is used to discuss about plot holes and theories, the fan probably took the extra step to add the scriptbook links out of excitement since the comment came out around the time X started to circulate the translations and many like myself were looking for them. The script book is part of LR, so it's not an unnecessary/ spam link to all MDL users. The fan even used the spoiler tag to minimize the web space used. Again if there were any harsh unjust comments on this thread, the commentor should have known better
*** I'm not sure if you'll see this and apologies for the detailed message. But i hope I've answered all your accusations.
About my so called posy- i have no idea why you keep telling me I'm "second in command" . Believe me, I don't want that title. 🫶
That's what special of this drama: haters CANT MOVE ON & camp here to spread hate from time to time 😉
It's easy to "silence" people when you block them as your dear friend has proven throughout this thread 😉
PS: I said "rabid fans" not "rabid haters". At least please read carefully before twisting words/ encouraging those who twist what others say.
It's too exhausting to use incognito to check Love2loveyou's responses all the time, so this will be my last.
If they do bother to reply, instead of twisting my words, I'd love to hear back from them about the original accusation they made about manipulating new fans. 🫶
That's what special of this drama: haters CANT MOVE ON & camp here to spread hate from time to time 😉
Ehhh can't be bothered to send another "Dear L" note again- I already know that the next response would be another tidal wave of disconnected insults and name calling instead of actually replying to my original question😴
Actions speak louder than words- name calling instead of answering a simple question says more 🫶
I mean yeah cuz HATERS GONNA HATE (js ignore them)
In episode 16, Sol prioritized her job over the man you claim she was being 1 dimensional about.
Hell even her proposal got postponed just so she can pursuit her dreams. If anything, Sol is an inspiration that it's never too late to try.
I won't compare the FLs from KTL, QoT, and MD with Sol because like you said, they all are inspirational in their own way. But this doesn't mean that Sol is any less. Why pit fictional women against eachother?
They are all amazing in their own way-they fought for their independance and saved their love 🤷♀️
The marriage announcement of SongJiEun and Park We, is almost like LR's 1st life, if they end up together...The…
I just love how inspiring their story is 💗
It's also nice to imagine that even in the original timelie, if 🚕 wasn't in the picture after 2008's events, they still could have had a chance to be together- eventually.
That's what special of this drama: haters CANT MOVE ON & camp here to spread hate from time to time 😉
See this is the problem- they talk a big game about how rabid fans are and call themselves victims but when you try to have a rational conversation, they bark, growl, and bite, and then block us to make it look like we are speechless🤷♀️
Good thing MDL is transparent enough to show their true faces eh?
That's what special of this drama: haters CANT MOVE ON & camp here to spread hate from time to time 😉
Dear *Lovetoloveyou*
Can you keep me unblocked long enough so I can reply to you? You do realize that I don't need an account to see your replies right?🤦♀️
Seeing as you spent long enough to write that last long message but refuse to give a proper comeback (even to prove that I'm being as delusional as you say) says a lot.
That's what special of this drama: haters CANT MOVE ON & camp here to spread hate from time to time 😉
Dear "lovetoloveyou"- thanks for blocking me. It's pathetic to say that i am speechless when you won't let me reply (it's been barely 4 minutes).
But here you go-this is my answer since i cannot comment on your comment-i look forward to hearing back from you someday 🎤🤷♀️
"Can you actually share at least 1 RECENT comment that confirms what you are saying? That fans are manipulating new viewers?
As far as i recall, most old fans suggest new viewers to TRY to watch till at least episode 2 to give it a fair chance since this is the point where the drama shifts.
Long explanations and script book links- please don't try to rewrite history. The script book links were mostly shared specifically because users asked for them. If a link was used to justify an answer, it's most likely because somebody refused to accept facts.
Most long winded answers were in response to fan related queries on certain scenes. How is that manipulating new viewers eh?
Just because the drama wasn't compelling enough to hold your attention doesn't mean that there are others who genuinely want to know things "🤷♀️
That's what special of this drama: haters CANT MOVE ON & camp here to spread hate from time to time 😉
That's true and you are free to spend the rest of your days here 🤗
I never said that a person can't share their opinion here. BUT "rabid fans" and "haters" should equally accept who they are without giving sorry half baked excuses as to why they are acting out like tortured matyrs.
New viewers (fans/ non fans) only care about the k-drama...not the silly nonsense that's been going on in here from months ago.🤷♀️
That's what special of this drama: haters CANT MOVE ON & camp here to spread hate from time to time 😉
It makes sense for fans to camp in the page for months- that's the whole point about being an obsessed fan. It may be toxic but at least it doesn't harm anybody. If you look at the recent comments, most fans ignore the negative comments since it's their opinion. Fans only get involved if the comments are unreasonable/ misleading/ spews unjust hate.
But "non-fans" camping here for months is a joke at this point- you officially can call them haters since it's been 3 months now and yet they still lurk around here playing "victim" instead of doing the healthier thing by moving on (i know for a fact that the ones who are making a fuss have been going at it since the time LR originally aired. )🤷♀️
LR isn't a radical religious cult- you don't need to make it your personal crusade to "save" as many k-drama enthusiasts as possible🤷♀️
2 
For Sol's sake, SJ may have tried to fight off the killer even in the OG timeline, but was too weak (since logically Sol would be the killer's next target). Honestly this just makes things even more depressing, imagining his desperation.
What do you think?
I can't remember the exact details but in the script book, the writer did mention that one of the possible reasons why the watch got activated in the original timeline was because it was his dying wish to protect Sol🥲
(i might be remembering it wrong though)🙈
Second death (technically 3rd death/ coma since we don't actually get to see his second death)- Sunjae was more optimistic but i love how they gave more insight as to why SJ may have wanted to retire in his first life by sharing details about his stressful Idol life in ep 8. (Imagine dealing with his idol life along with his guilt? It's too much🫠).
PS:
The hidden container was the Candy egg jar Sol gave him as part of his recovery pack in 2008- not meds (ikr?! It's so sweet that he kept it close to him all this time even after "Sol" rejected him🙈🤩)
Guess it's all about boundaries
I love how Sarang built everything out of nothing. Truly Super.
Sol is brilliant in her own way too but the fan shouldn't have compared the 2- different circumstances, at least in my opinion🙊
@Lovetoloveyou- since you blocked me i can't reply directly, but since you called me out, I am the last person who should be accused of being a BL hater/ homophobe- my watchlist is filled with highly rated BLs and I have never made such comments.
Please research before making accusations.
💙💛
Edit (since you blocked me again):
@Lovetoloveyou-
wouldn't it be simpler to just admit that you made a mistake this time instead of twisting my words (in your next comment) AGAIN by editing your original comment to say that I'm bored now instead of the original weirdo/homophobe comment?
Edit 2: @Love2-
Nobody is being complacent. The original "BL" comment was extra but it was taken out of context seeing as it wasn't aimed at anybody but was a response in agreement that the 9.1 rating and hype may have raised unrealistic expectations🤷♀️ The rest of the thread is just too juvenile to waste time on.
(I'm only referring to yesterday's comment btw- idk if anything else happened in MDL in a homophobic context. If somebody was really attacking another user with slurs, then shame on them)
Take care🫶
Dear Love2,
First of- kudos 👏 , that's alot of research done.
Comment 1 👇
https://kisskh.at/750099-time-walking-on-memory#comment-18273469
I am glad that you shared this particular comment as it is another example of twisting what i say. The reply wasn't at the OP but another commenter. I never mentioned about biases and literally just told to ignore ALL HYPE (good and bad)- but alas, the commentor chose to half read my comment and assume i was amping the show
When really all i said was to ignore even the good hype.
👇Comment 2:
https://kisskh.at/750099-time-walking-on-memory#comment-18304025
This link that YOU shared is a perfect example of why fans can be harsh. Criticism is acceptable but if you look at the thread and some of the other threads that were there on that day, there was a sudden surge of anti-HY comments that crossed the line. HY is not my bias and I've only seen one of her other dramas, but being viscious over somebody relentlessly for no reason is pathetic right? Just like it's not right to give exaggerate hateful comments about Suzy's looks and performance, the same applies to HY too.
👇Comment 3:
https://kisskh.at/750099-time-walking-on-memory#comment-18301965
I admit it could have been handled better but context is important as there were alot of harsh threads below this particular comment thread so the user snapped. But as you can see, the so called Subeoum sheep DID NOT drag the Suzy bashing and even discouraged it unlike the thread that started the HY hate/ Suzy comparison in the first place.
👇Comment 4:
https://kisskh.at/750099-time-walking-on-memory#comment-18280673
Sure, I admit my response might come off as know-it-all/ arrogant since the OP didn't ask any questions in the original post. My response was in response to the OP's comment that HY wasn't a reason for the show's success which in my opinion wasn't fair. I cannot talk on behalf of the other's comments since I actually don't have a posy so can't control them.
👇Comment 5:
https://kisskh.at/750099-time-walking-on-memory#comment-18289959
I honestly can't see what's manipulative with my comment so please clarify.
If any fans were rude, then they should haave known better.
👇 Script book comment:
While the OP did not ask for an opinion, they did list out a long list of "plot holes" which were not really plot holes. Since part of the reason MDL is used to discuss about plot holes and theories, the fan probably took the extra step to add the scriptbook links out of excitement since the comment came out around the time X started to circulate the translations and many like myself were looking for them. The script book is part of LR, so it's not an unnecessary/ spam link to all MDL users. The fan even used the spoiler tag to minimize the web space used. Again if there were any harsh unjust comments on this thread, the commentor should have known better
***
I'm not sure if you'll see this and apologies for the detailed message. But i hope I've answered all your accusations.
About my so called posy- i have no idea why you keep telling me I'm "second in command" . Believe me, I don't want that title.
🫶
PS: I said "rabid fans" not "rabid haters". At least please read carefully before twisting words/ encouraging those who twist what others say.
It's too exhausting to use incognito to check Love2loveyou's responses all the time, so this will be my last.
If they do bother to reply, instead of twisting my words, I'd love to hear back from them about the original accusation they made about manipulating new fans. 🫶
Actions speak louder than words- name calling instead of answering a simple question says more 🫶
Truly an inspiration 💗
Hell even her proposal got postponed just so she can pursuit her dreams. If anything, Sol is an inspiration that it's never too late to try.
I won't compare the FLs from KTL, QoT, and MD with Sol because like you said, they all are inspirational in their own way. But this doesn't mean that Sol is any less. Why pit fictional women against eachother?
They are all amazing in their own way-they fought for their independance and saved their love 🤷♀️
It's also nice to imagine that even in the original timelie, if 🚕 wasn't in the picture after 2008's events, they still could have had a chance to be together- eventually.
Good thing MDL is transparent enough to show their true faces eh?
Can you keep me unblocked long enough so I can reply to you? You do realize that I don't need an account to see your replies right?🤦♀️
Seeing as you spent long enough to write that last long message but refuse to give a proper comeback (even to prove that I'm being as delusional as you say) says a lot.
Take care 🫶
But here you go-this is my answer since i cannot comment on your comment-i look forward to hearing back from you someday 🎤🤷♀️
"Can you actually share at least 1 RECENT comment that confirms what you are saying? That fans are manipulating new viewers?
As far as i recall, most old fans suggest new viewers to TRY to watch till at least episode 2 to give it a fair chance since this is the point where the drama shifts.
Long explanations and script book links- please don't try to rewrite history. The script book links were mostly shared specifically because users asked for them. If a link was used to justify an answer, it's most likely because somebody refused to accept facts.
Most long winded answers were in response to fan related queries on certain scenes. How is that manipulating new viewers eh?
Just because the drama wasn't compelling enough to hold your attention doesn't mean that there are others who genuinely want to know things "🤷♀️
I never said that a person can't share their opinion here. BUT "rabid fans" and "haters" should equally accept who they are without giving sorry half baked excuses as to why they are acting out like tortured matyrs.
New viewers (fans/ non fans) only care about the k-drama...not the silly nonsense that's been going on in here from months ago.🤷♀️
But "non-fans" camping here for months is a joke at this point- you officially can call them haters since it's been 3 months now and yet they still lurk around here playing "victim" instead of doing the healthier thing by moving on (i know for a fact that the ones who are making a fuss have been going at it since the time LR originally aired. )🤷♀️
LR isn't a radical religious cult- you don't need to make it your personal crusade to "save" as many k-drama enthusiasts as possible🤷♀️
This gives a more balanced approach since we got to see around 5 different kinds of "first love" love stories🙊