Uncanny valley ruins the potential
The biggest issue for me, is the uncanny valley being so jarring and prevalent that I couldn't get invested in the actual good parts. Maybe some people are less sensitive to that, and if you are, you may be able to enjoy this drama more than me.
BAD CGI & DUBBING
I guess one of the second leads is using an CGI filter on her face? It does not look good, especially when speaking or emoting. Her partner also frequently has an eerie effect on her, it seems like her face is real but her eye movements have some weird smoothing or something, idk.
It actually feels like the "filter" use may even be broader than that, but sometimes it isn't clear whether the uncanny feeling is from a filter making faces look weird, or just the dubbing being bad / the actors lipsyncing poorly because they know it will be dubbed? (I don't know if that is a thing, but it would explain a lot, because it often doesn't even look like they are actually speaking)
GOOD EMOTIONAL BEATS
The primary story for the main couple is actually pretty strong. If you can ignore the other problems, this actually could have made it a pretty good watch.
Even the secondary couple has good ...writing. But saying that their arc is good would be difficult when they look like 1.5 animatronics.
BAD CONFLICT WRITING
Okay, I normally don't like to criticize actors. What do I know, I am sure I would be worse than the worst actor. But in this case, the combination of acting/directing/writing for the 2 main antagonists was actually painful enough to make me dislike the whole show (a second time, even if the uncanny valley hadn't been ruining it enough).
The villains just act incredibly cartoonish. Like way beyond even shows where the genre expects a villain to be cartoonish. These 2 characters act like they are in a vshort and honestly many vshort villains are more believable than this.
Many of these conflicts also have writing that is barely coherent. If you have your brain on even the slightest bit, many of the scenes will not even have internally consistent logic. They really do just throw some tropes at the wall to fill out the plot. :(
DISAPPOINTING TONE
Okay this one may just be my preconceived notions, but I felt like this show was trying to be a combination of Thai GL and Chinese vShort and did both poorly. If you actually combined them well I would probably have enjoyed it. But what I had REALLY hoped this would be, was for it to be a new style distinct to better quality Chinese dramas.
China already has some stuff like this with its own tone that are really great! Very disappointing that this one failed to focus.
Examples of Chinese GL tone already being distinct (and good to me!):
Indie films (Actual GLs)
- https://kisskh.at/749131-fireworks-of-yesteryear
- https://kisskh.at/700737-fragrance-of-the-first-flower
Historicals (Sismance)
- https://kisskh.at/62355-couple-of-mirrors
- https://kisskh.at/788444-be-her-resilience
- https://kisskh.at/777852-shuang-shu-mei-tan
Fantasy vShorts (Sismance+, these have vibes but are often chopped up)
- https://kisskh.at/764425-shuang-tu
- https://kisskh.at/716845-the-fox-spirit-and-the-little-priest
- https://kisskh.at/764425-shuang-tu
- https://kisskh.at/726937-the-vampires
- Pretty much anything with https://kisskh.at/people/35259-yang-fu-yu
- Pretty much anything with https://kisskh.at/people/79893-sheng-wei
BAD CGI & DUBBING
I guess one of the second leads is using an CGI filter on her face? It does not look good, especially when speaking or emoting. Her partner also frequently has an eerie effect on her, it seems like her face is real but her eye movements have some weird smoothing or something, idk.
It actually feels like the "filter" use may even be broader than that, but sometimes it isn't clear whether the uncanny feeling is from a filter making faces look weird, or just the dubbing being bad / the actors lipsyncing poorly because they know it will be dubbed? (I don't know if that is a thing, but it would explain a lot, because it often doesn't even look like they are actually speaking)
GOOD EMOTIONAL BEATS
The primary story for the main couple is actually pretty strong. If you can ignore the other problems, this actually could have made it a pretty good watch.
Even the secondary couple has good ...writing. But saying that their arc is good would be difficult when they look like 1.5 animatronics.
BAD CONFLICT WRITING
Okay, I normally don't like to criticize actors. What do I know, I am sure I would be worse than the worst actor. But in this case, the combination of acting/directing/writing for the 2 main antagonists was actually painful enough to make me dislike the whole show (a second time, even if the uncanny valley hadn't been ruining it enough).
The villains just act incredibly cartoonish. Like way beyond even shows where the genre expects a villain to be cartoonish. These 2 characters act like they are in a vshort and honestly many vshort villains are more believable than this.
Many of these conflicts also have writing that is barely coherent. If you have your brain on even the slightest bit, many of the scenes will not even have internally consistent logic. They really do just throw some tropes at the wall to fill out the plot. :(
DISAPPOINTING TONE
Okay this one may just be my preconceived notions, but I felt like this show was trying to be a combination of Thai GL and Chinese vShort and did both poorly. If you actually combined them well I would probably have enjoyed it. But what I had REALLY hoped this would be, was for it to be a new style distinct to better quality Chinese dramas.
China already has some stuff like this with its own tone that are really great! Very disappointing that this one failed to focus.
Examples of Chinese GL tone already being distinct (and good to me!):
Indie films (Actual GLs)
- https://kisskh.at/749131-fireworks-of-yesteryear
- https://kisskh.at/700737-fragrance-of-the-first-flower
Historicals (Sismance)
- https://kisskh.at/62355-couple-of-mirrors
- https://kisskh.at/788444-be-her-resilience
- https://kisskh.at/777852-shuang-shu-mei-tan
Fantasy vShorts (Sismance+, these have vibes but are often chopped up)
- https://kisskh.at/764425-shuang-tu
- https://kisskh.at/716845-the-fox-spirit-and-the-little-priest
- https://kisskh.at/764425-shuang-tu
- https://kisskh.at/726937-the-vampires
- Pretty much anything with https://kisskh.at/people/35259-yang-fu-yu
- Pretty much anything with https://kisskh.at/people/79893-sheng-wei
Was this review helpful to you?
