Kate

I did enjoy the show a lot for most of it, but the lack of cohesiveness in terms of themes and tone made what could have been an amazing drama, into just a decent one.

Here’s the thing - most of the show did not have one big plot that puts it all together. It felt like a borderline investigation slice of life - and I enjoyed it, but mostly because of the leads. I loved how Jiu Xuan Ye was not this powerful, cold male lead that changes thanks to love. I appreciated how Duan Ban Xia was not this badass lady warrior with no fears. They were both well written characters with great chemistry that felt more like a cosy fireplace than hell fires. Even the supporting characters were enjoyable, not following the typical copy paste filler roles.

Honestly - Ban Xia was perfect. She was so real with her reactions, the effect her traumas had on her, with how her character developed and progressed. One of my favorite female leads so far from the dramas I have seen in 2025. She was both adorable and vulnerable, but also brave. She was not fearless, but she was willing to act despite her fears.

But then the characters are kind of all the show had to offer for me. I know many people loved the demon stories, but for me they tried to both keep them eerie and dark, but also many scenes felt more whimsical and fairytale-like. On paper they worked, emotionally they felt shallow. The tone was neither this nor that and it made me disconnect from the story.

And that leads me to the biggest disappointment - the ending. I’m not even saying the ending was bad because it was bitter sweet. It was just an ending to a completely different drama than I was watching the whole time. While I agree that the theme of sacrifice was present throughout most of the cases, it was always related to sacrificing yourself for the person you love or cherish. So if the drama ended around episode 34-35 with Jiu Xuan Ye using the sword to set it all back to how it was before they met to save Ban Xia - I would be far more okay with it. It would make sense in the context of the show.

But then the last two episodes happened. Why is Jiu Xuan Ye’s conclusion about him saving the demon realm? This was never part of his arc until the last second twist. Why is Ban Xia’s conclusion letting Jiu Xuan leave? When her whole arc was about fighting to be with him - her choosing to stay with him no matter what was her gaining the agency for herself. Because no matter what happened and what everyone said - it was her decision. And now she is like: well, I guess that would be a goodbye.

I just simply do not feel satisfied with the ending, because it does not make much sense for him with how the characters were throughout the episodes. I don’t even want to talk about the fake cheap deaths - that’s another story. The last few episodes are a typical case of ending leaving a bad taste in my mouth, even though most of the meal was great. Sadly, the last bite is what we often remember the most.

No matter how many complaints I might have about the conclusion, I have to compliment the acting. Song Zu Er - she knows how to cry! The angst she delivered was pure perfection. At the same time the bubbly happy moments were also delivered in a way they were charming and fun to watch.

We all know Ren Jia Lun is great. I do think he might need to move away from romance though. My man is 36 years old and still delivered some of the worst kissing scenes.

Overall, somehow disappointed. I wish they would keep the lighter tone till the end. I loved how normal the supernatural plot felt, but then by the end they tried to turn it into something bigger and more grand than they were setting up.