Entire Personality: "I Read The Metamorphosis by Franz Kafka"
TL;DR: A pretentious drama crutching so much on metaphors relating it to another story that it ends up being not only exceptionally dull but also extremely grating.Whump meter: ▲▲▲▲◭ (there's a lot, ok).
── ⋅ ⋅ ── ⋅ ⋅ ── ⋅ ⋅ ── ⋅ ⋅ ── ⋅ ⋅
I won't make this long because I honestly don't want to waste any more time with this drama. The worst offender regarding this drama is just how pretentious it feels. It really took the "It's all a metaphor related to The Metamorphosis by Franz Kafka" and made that its entire personality. Because trust me when I say, the drama has little identity other than that. The characters are shallow, most being shy of a caricature we unfortunately and for some reason spend HOURS following. Especially SML (portrayed by Lee Dong Wook) was an inconsistent nightmare (LDW acted the crap out of this role, though, I'm in awe). I'm not gonna lie, for most of the drama I thought he was gonna end up being a slenderman-like entity with how all-over-the-place he was (which might've single-handedly made this drama a 9 for me) but that obviously wasn't the case. Even the phenomenal performances from literally every single actor in this drama couldn't save such midcore writing.
The best thing the drama does (casting aside) is the unsettling vibe. I will admit, that was well captured and executed. From the claustrophobic feel to the overall 'wtf is wrong with this place' vibe. Kudos. Cinematography, production quality, OST, etc were all serviceable to good so no real complaints there either.
Without going into spoiler territory, the ending was bad. Nonsensical and not well executed. All tying back to this overly presumptuous superiority complex either the screenwriter or the original IP's writer had of making it 'poetic' and 'subverting expectations' and being 'deep'. I heard a lot of people call this a descent into madness, and I guess you could call it that? But even that feels a too generous. The drama has an unreliable narrator, but rather than being engaging and exciting to follow the main character's story from his unstable POV, it felt more dumb, boring, and irritating. Especially with the ending 'plot twist', it really brings to question the rest of the drama and how it unfolded, and not in the 'wow, I missed so much' kind of way but rather in the 'wtf, this makes no sense' kind of way. It's also strange for a drama already almost half the length of the usual Kdramas to still somehow be so exceptionally slow. So much time is spent meandering around half-baked side characters or just, standing... If this were an hour and a half long indie film, then whatever, but come on.
In the end, the drama is merely alright. It does some things good, some things bad, like most dramas out there. However, this drama somehow manages to have mostly 9s and 10s across the ratings, which is shocking to me but I'm glad people like it. Would I have enjoyed watching this more if people didn't unanimously claim that it was the best thing since slice bread? Probably. But that wasn't the case, so I'm not only disappointed I watched a mid show; I'm also disappointed I watched a pretentious show everyone claimed to be phenomenal.
This isn't the first time something referencing The Metamorphosis by Franz Kafka was midcore and irritating so I think it's best for me to just stay away from that all together, lmao.
── ⋅ ⋅ ── ⋅ ⋅ ── ⋅ ⋅ ── ⋅ ⋅ ── ⋅ ⋅
◇ Was it what I was expecting? No.
◆ Did it live up to its potential? No.
◇ Would I watch it again? Definitely no.
◆ Would I recommend it to others? Probably not.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Mind-blowing and Fantastic
Strangers from Hell was unlike anything I had seen before. Im Siwan's rent must have been due because he bodied JongU. The acting, especially Siwan's was impeccable. Lee Dongwook is my favorite acter and watching this after seeing him as Lee Yeon in Tale of the Nine-Tailed was crazy. The twists and turns in Strangers from Hell we're just twisty and turny enough to make it mind-blowing but not completely unbelievable. Strangers from Hell had one of the craziest endings in anything I'd ever seen. When I finished it for the first time, I was completely shocked by it. Watching JongU's sanity deteriorate was fascinating yet heartbreaking. Strangers from Hell is truly one of, not only Kdramas, but piece of media I've ever seen.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Why the ML Can’t See Red Flags
I am only partway through this drama but it’s dawned on me that part of the overall horror and a big part of what keeps the plot going is that Jong-woo, the ML, doesn’t have a healthy instinct for self-preservation. if he did he would have left Eden Boarding House in 5 minutes even though his rolling suitcase was broken.It’s not that he’s stupid or oblivious or anything like that. We do see early on that he has a knack for making not-great choices. The big problem is that he’s just so accustomed to dealing with dysfunction, humiliation, and outright abuse in his day-to-day life and just brushing away all the ill feeling it gives him that he can no longer recognize when he’s in a dangerous situation and react appropriately.
Look at how he gets treated by the people in his workplace and elsewhere: he’s told he’s too sensitive, has his emotions invalidated, and even gets told to smile more! A lot of women are probably all too familiar with this kind of treatment. Jong-woo has internalized a lot of it too. He keeps telling himself to ignore really bizarre and awful things at the boarding house, insisting to himself that he’s being ridiculous, so by the time he realizes how bad the situation really is, it’s almost too late.
It’s this dynamic that makes the progression of the story so natural and adds to the subtle sense of horror/dread.
Was this review helpful to you?
Better a movie than a drama!! overhyped
I know it’s a 2019 drama, but seriously! I’ve watched slow-paced dramas before, but this one was just repeating scenes over and over. From episode 1 to 7, that was basically the whole plot! Jong-Ju’s character wasn’t used properly same people kept annoying me for seven episodes straight, and he didn’t even react!
The detective was frustrating, and the characters who kept bothering Jong-Ju made me want to slap them through the screen!
They tried to make the female police officer seem tough and dedicated, but all her decisions were just plain foolish.
I get that it’s based on a webtoon, but K-dramas need to understand that live-action is different! They didn’t need to drag things out just because that’s how it was in the original story.
Honestly, it was a waste of a strong cast and a good premise. This is exactly why I don’t trust Asian drama ratings!
Was this review helpful to you?
best drama ive seen yet
my all time favorite kdrama, and actually just show in general. noticed i never wrote a review, sooo im doing exactly that now :Pthe story line is crazy good and i love how jongwoo isnt a reliable narrator. the ost by the rose, the casting, the styling (i literally had nightmares of nambok the first day after watching it), the narrating and idk its all just perfect and goes together so well
the only thing that bothers me about sfh is the lack of screentime for my glorious king lee dongwookT-T
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Masterpiece ig
Honestly I was avoiding this drama for a long time but it actually turned out really good.The only thing that really pissed me off was Jong-woos girlfriend why didn't she belived him when he told her things abt the residence, she just said that he prob imaginate it all.
Overall I think it was masterpiece that I would rewatch I wouldn't say that the end was really that predictable. (Im talking abt the how it turned out that Jong Woo was the one who killed everyone in the residence)
And I was really hoping that he would move out after all.
Sadly there is not gonna be season 2 but I get it.
Was this review helpful to you?
Great premise but painfully ableist
I started watching the first episode and I was very happy with it. I loved the main character instantly and it had very good dry humor. As far as I understood the premise of the story was basic but that doesn't mean anything, I'm sure they made something great out of it.What wasn't great was that carricature of a disabled person. I was in physical discomfort seeing the actor act like that. The character is a harmful stereotype of disabled people being stupid, strange and - what I found worst - dangerous. Of course disabled people can be bad people, but the drama implied he's bad because of his disability. It would have been very easy to come up with a different character, just saying.
Was this review helpful to you?
eu não sou tão chegado em terror, mas Strangers From Hell entrega o que promete. a escolha de sequência dos acontecimentos é muito perspicaz, conseguimos acompanhar o desenvolvimento do protagonista com muita proximidade e os mistérios acerca dos outros personagens fazem com que a obra fique ainda mais instigante. a trilha sonora foi uma das coisas que eu mais gostei – beijos pro Woosung. te amo, amor – mas a atuação é sem dúvidas o que mais me impressiona, desde as sutis expressões até às cenas de maior violência, pode-se ver um elenco extremamente imerso em seus papéis.
Was this review helpful to you?
Wer Serien mag wo man mitdenken/mitfühlen kann ...das ist so eine Serie. :) Die Serie zieht einen so in den Bann das du selber denkst..du wirst langsam verrückt XD und ohne Witz der Titel konnte nicht passender sein!Der Hauptcharakter hat einen mega Leid getan (ohne zu viel zu veratten) :(
Die Leistungen von allen Schauspielern kann nur gelobt werden!
LG
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Et si l'enfer, c'était chez toi ?!?
Tu commences le drama… et tu ne sais pas si t’es dans une auberge, un hôpital psychiatrique, ou tout simplement en enfer... 🤷🏼♀️, mais un truc est sûr, l’ambiance est glauque à souhait. J'ai senti le malaise dès l’entrée dans la résidence Eden 😵💫🔪Lee Dong Wook... Une ENTITÉ GLACIALE 😱🩶, même avec le chauffage à 40°C, il te file des frissons dans l’âme... Zéro cliché... Juste une présence malsaine, subtile, ultra maîtrisée. Il sourit sans bouger un muscle, il parle doucement... mais je savais que je ne serais pas en sécurité en sa présence... Jamais !!! 🥶
Et tout le reste du cast ?!? Et bien standing ovation malaisante... La proprio creepy, le pervers, les jumeaux en bug mental permanent... Personne ne surjoue. Ils sont tous subtilement anormaux, et c’est ça le pire... 🤪🕷️
La vraie réussite du drama, c’est ça, tu ne sais plus si tu regardes un mec en danger... ou un mec qui devient le danger... Si c’est la vraie vie ?!? Son roman ?!? Ou juste un esprit en train de vriller pour de bon... Et moi, spectatrice, je sombrais avec lui, sans même m’en rendre compte… 😰📖😂
Et alors cette fin... Une fin ouverte, mais bien sombre et bien vicieuse. Il n’était pas un monstre… mais Eden l’a façonné comme tel... Ce n’est pas juste l’histoire d’un tueur… c’est la naissance du mal... En silence, sous nos yeux 😶🌫️🩸✌🏻
Was this review helpful to you?
É um ótimo suspense criminal/policial, que é o meu gênero favorito. Fiquei muito feliz de encontrar um dorama nesse estilo, já que é tão raro. Inclusive a Coreia deve investir muito mais nesse gênero de dorama.
A história começa com o personagem principal, Jong Woo, um jovem recém-formado, se mudando pra Seul, onde ele conseguiu um estágio. Por não ter condições financeiras ele tem que se mudar pra um goshiwon, e com o tempo o prota vai perceber que tem alguma coisa muito estranha no lugar e com seus moradores. E é aí que a história vai se desenrolar.
É um dorama que prende a nossa atenção desde o início e que você não quer parar de assistir, pra saber o que vai acontecer. Eu normalmente não maratono doramas, mas esse eu tive que maratonar.
Além do mais, o dorama tem uma aura de suspense e tensão o tempo todo, mesmo o suspense/terror sendo o meu gênero favorito de filmes e séries, eu fiquei bem assustada assistindo esse dorama. A sensação que você tem é que pode acontecer alguma coisa a qualquer tempo.
Já o roteiro dele é muito bom, ele foi muito bem produzido, não tem furos na história e tudo é verossímil, poderia acontecer facilmente na realidade. Também as atuações são excelentes, inclusive eu tinha asco e raiva de vários personagens, de tão bem interpretados, eu especialmente fiquei muito surpresa com a atuação do Lee Dong Wook, o personagem dele é totalmente diferente dos outros trabalhos que eu já vi dele, ele deu um show de atuação.
Fora os crimes, o dorama trata de outros temas. Ele mostra bem o ambiente de trabalho extremamente estressante da Coreia, onde os chefes e colegas humilham e exploram os que estão em posição inferior, e também a pressão que os jovens adultos sofrem pra serem bem-sucedidos, e em pouco tempo conquistar bens materiais.
E por último, a principal mensagem que o dorama passou pra mim é que os seres humanos são influenciáveis, que nós podemos mudar totalmente por causa das pessoas a nossa volta e de situações que acontecem conosco. Além disso, que ninguém é totalmente uma boa pessoa.
Então recomendo muito esse dorama, tenho certeza de que você vai gostar! Ainda mais se você estiver procurando um dorama fora do comum.
Was this review helpful to you?
L’enfer, c’est les autres…
Ce drama fait partie de ceux que j’ai essayé et laissé de côté. Puis, j’ai fini par y revenir & étonnamment, malgré l’atmosphère des plus glauques, j’ai voulu savoir la finalité.Quel est le sujet de cette histoire ? Les tueurs en série… & la folie. (C’est plus ou moins tout… Mais c’est tellement bien travaillé qu’on reste scotché devant notre écran…)
J’ai admiré la prestation de Lee Dong-Wook que je n’avais jamais vu dans ce type de registre ! Il m’a littéralement glacée ! (Je pense que si je l’avais rencontré en rue dans ce rôle, je ne serai pas restée longtemps dans les parages ^^’) Son personnage semble tellement détaché de tout, comme si rien n’avait d’importance… C’est sans doute, ce qui le rend si dangereux…
Im Si-Wan m’a également « régalée » (Si on veut hein, car lui aussi, il est flippant !) dans sa prestation, la montée de sa folie semblait tellement réelle…
Si je devais vous dire si j’ai aimé ou non cette histoire, je pense que je ne saurais que répondre car il ne s’agit pas d’un drama que je regarderai à nouveau mais il m’a apporté des sensations (Cette sensation horrible, insidieuse, telle un serpent qui se promène le long de la colonne vertébrale & fini par me glacer… ) que je n’avais pas encore ressenti avec d’autres histoires… Comme mentionné plus haut, l’histoire n’a pas de réelle prétention et ne parle que de meurtres & de la folie qui en résulte (enfin, en résulte-t-elle ou est-elle l’enclencheur de tout ça ? Aller savoir…) mais quelque part, c’est surtout un drama visant la psychologie de chacun des protagonistes/antagonistes.
Je terminerai cet avis en disant que ce drama me laisse une impression étrange… Durant tout mon visionnage, j’ai été mal à l’aise… Alors que je suivais le parcours du « héros » j’avais la sensation que moi aussi la folie allait me prendre à la gorge… L’ambiance est tellement lourde, glauque & malsaine que j’ai parfois eu l’impression que je pourrais étouffer… [Vous me direz, ce n’est qu’un drama. Certes, mais je ne saurai comment expliquer la sensation qu’il m’a insufflé… C’est la première fois que j’étais aussi « étrange » en regardant un(e) série/film (& pourtant j’en ai vu des séries/films glauques !!)]
Was this review helpful to you?
