This review may contain spoilers
I'm curious about what was happening with the Muslim minority in non-Muslim countries.
I watched it as an Arab Muslim who wanted to know what was happening with the Muslim minority in non-Muslim countriesKazakhs and Mongols I have always known that their customs and traditions are similar to those of the Turkish tribes, their clothes are also similar to them, Kazakhs are known to be Muslims and even when the religion was not mentioned in the drama, it was clear that they are Muslims. I do not know about the traditions of the Kazakhs, so I have no authority to judge whether the director was able to portray them in a good or bad way, but I am a Muslim and I think that I have the right to criticize those things that contradict my religion.
first of all : Alcohol is Haram(forbidden) for Muslims
It is not (you CANNOT drink alcohol) but (you MUST NEVER drink alcohol)
It is not something that can be taken lightly in Islam, I admit that in our time there are many who drink alcohol despite their Islam (but they are considered deviants from the religion and their action does not make drinking alcohol permissible)
Everyone in the drama drank alcohol and danced together at the wedding
Which makes me remember the second thing: Intermingling.
It is wonderful to spread a cheerful culture about Kazakh traditions but mixing that image with alcohol while both men and women dance together? That is not something Muslims would do.
Finally and most critically was: Why did no one object to Tuoken's relationship with that non-muslim Mongol guy?
In the Mongol tent there was a statue of Buddha and paintings of the Buddhist religion, if Su Li Tan family was really Muslim how did they allow their dead son's children (the children were born Muslims) to be raised with a husband from another religion? It is okay for a Muslim man to marry a non-Muslim woman (because the children will follow their father's religion) but for a Muslim woman to marry a non-Muslim man? This is HARAM.
actually I don't understand many parts.
Is it because the writer was interested in conveying the suffering of the Kazakhs without paying attention to the details related to Islam? Or is this really what happens to the Kazakhs? I hope to get my answer from a real Kazakh !!
Was this review helpful to you?
A window to the China the world does not much know about
I have just completed one episode and I could not resist expressing how lovely the show is. It is cinematic in its treatment, the cinematography, natural acting, stunning visuals...I am so looking forward to watching the remaining episodes.This is a China and people the world does not know much about beyond the news about unrest that trickles out to the world.
I had to pause at several places to start reading about Xinjiang, about Altay, about the Uyghur language and in just one episode the show is opening a window to China that outsiders like me barely know about.
I am hoping that as episodes pass by I can give higher scores to the story and overall to the show.
Was this review helpful to you?
Eu vejo você
❝Na cultura cazaque, a amizade ou o amor entre humanos florescem ao serem vistos. Então, "Eu gosto de você" em Cazaquistão, "Men seni zhaksy koremin", significa "Eu vejo você claramente.❞Uma obra prima! Em seus poucos episódios conseguiu transmitir leveza e profundidade. A fotografia parecendo que saiu direto do Studio Ghibli. Atuações excelentes, apenas com o olhar foi possível ver os sentimentos que queriam demostrar. Tudo muito bem dirigido e produzido. O desenvolvimento da história e a finalização sem defeitos. Terminei com gostinho de quero mais.
Was this review helpful to you?
Diferentes mundos, sob diferentes versões e isso é o que realmente são.
Estou realmente encantada por ter assistido essa obra. É uma história realista, de pessoa com desejos reais, reações reais e relações construídas.Cada um tem seu próprio mundo, sua própria forma de viver, e constantemente enquanto eu assistia parava pensando: "Puxa, esse não é um estilo de vida que eu levaria nunca! Olhe como é sofrido, as dificuldades, porque alguém escolheria viver sua vida assim? Eu não consigo entender." E mesmo terminando o drama não encontrei respostas, mas acredito que deve ser assim, não se deve tentar encaixar um povo, uma cultura, na minha.
De fato.
É um mundo diferente para mim, uma cultura peculiar nômade, que sofre com o avanço da modernidade mas que luta pela sobrevivência de sua cultura.
É uma ótima experiência cinematográfica, com um soundtrack impecável, atuação ímpar, ótima ambientação.
Was this review helpful to you?
"Eu experimentei a vida."
"To The Wonder" me fez ter saudades de casa, e por casa quero dizer a casa da minha avó, os cavalos de lá...os que estão lá e os que são só memória..., me fez ter saudades das palavras que só escuto lá, das comidas que como lá, das risadas que dou lá e das lágrimas que já derramei por lá também. Por isso, esse drama ganhou um lugar especial no meu coração."To The Wonder" entregou uma história simples, aconchegante, divertida e triste... bem realista, mas com uma faísca de esperança que é mágica. Foi encantador conhecer cada personagem e suas nuances, e cada cantinho de uma terra tão bonita e tão cheia de vida.
Was this review helpful to you?
El amor a la vida y a los sueños, nunca va hacer un motivo para detenerse
Este drama por mucho arrasa sobre otras obras, con los paisajes que muestra, como estos fueron llevados a la pantalla desde un punto muy hermoso. La actuación te deja con la boca abierta, y ves en su totalidad las emociones que van pasando los personajes, una historia que conmueve y lleva al vidente sobre un viaje de emociones.Was this review helpful to you?
