I love your theories and here are my thoughts. 1) Agree that one of the twins is fake Paik Sa Eon and the real…
Love this, love your theories. Had fun reading it. Here are some of mine. 1. I agree with you on that as well as Sang U not fully telling the story. Making me think either he is the other twin who lost his brother and is looking for him hence digging out old case or he lost a beloved friend that he (now have credibility) trying to bring the dark past of that family to light.
But yes he could be the ultimate villain giving orders. But someone points that Sang U can't be twisted (psychopath) given the fact that he can show affection and special we see him falling for Hee Joo in that broadcasting room. And that's the time when Hee Joo was not married hence is not useful to him (if he was approaching her with a motive then)
2. I agree to this as well that park do jae is red herring here cause they won't show us him wearing black and purposefully revealing someone who pushed her was also wearing black. Now I think I'm more sure cause of the preview. In preview they had sketch of the kidnapper (the Unnie-ya guys). I'm guessing they will check CCTV of that day and will find him hence the sketch being available.
On you side theory- I had the same thought process. I thought the Unnie-ya guys and fake baek sa-eon can be twin and him not being adopted made him resentful or he was made resentful towards YYS through manipulation cause he keeps claiming he knows sa-eon better
3. On second hand I have even more wild than that. Everything we know so far comes with a twist that I started to suspect the death of chairman hong youngest kid. For a second I that park do jae maybe him. Hee Joo mom address his as "dongsaeng" to hee Joo making Hee Joo middle child once she is adopted; hence the age sits right between hee Joo and do jae. Cause for someone reason he was way more disdain when sa-eon and hee Joo was close on the retreat. (Cause he knows sa-eon married his sister In-a) I know way far fetched.
4. I know Unnie-ya guys is not the main villain and also the resources the "Master" can pull makes me think he is high up who has much power and money to do so and these recent episode I am becoming more and more suspecting of Hee Joo's adoptive father, chairman hong. He is getting more and more sus episode by episode to me.
Side note: the drowning accident initially I thought it's a false memory or tempered one. I mean they did kidnapped the fake sa-eon mainly because they didn't want to have paperwork done hence leaving no proof that he is adopted for media to do the digging (hence people not knowing it was 4 kid who went missing, not three) i thought in that time he might have drowned and to cope with trauma his mind made a false memory of him being drowned by the guy wearing dragon ring (I'm guessing him his adoptive grandfather) who would have been harsh towards him in beginning like all other parents in his adoptive family.
But your theory makes more sense. Only issue I find is the ring worm by the guy doing it makes no sense
I also think park do jae is the red herring here. I also thought sa-eon is the twin but instead of do jae i thought…
Let me give you the wildest theory I had. The kid of chairman hong who died. What if he is alive and he is park do jae. The most craziest theory I had cause what we know so far is nothing so I started suspecting the death of that kid as well.
Now my theory makes sense cause when mom said to sa-eon that her sister when deaf and her "dongsaeng" died making Hee Joo the middle child. This fits with their ages. Heejoo is older than Park do jae. But park do jae always seems more interfering with Sa-eon wife cause he thinks it's his sister (In-a). I also noticed he shows more disdain than other when so-eon is closed to hee Joo on the retreat
Your theories are more confusing than the drama. Also the drowning dream was of sa-eon not sang u.1. That's a…
It's the first time the dream was shown so I don't have a theory regarding that. But the age he was shown in drowning scene is around the time he was adopted as the age of Sang u playing with Seoul master(the deranged kid who knifed the cat) was also same (saying it's around that time they switched the real son with adopted one). Maybe sa-eon (ml) was kidnapped to be adopted rather than proper paperwork or he saw how bad the real son was and the guy with dragon ring is either punishing him in same way or that memory is of the day he got kidnapped but it's a bit tampered cause of trauma
EPISODE 6 Theories1. The fake Baek Sa Eon (male lead) is one of the twins. Chances are, the real Baek Sa Eon murdered…
I also think park do jae is the red herring here. I also thought sa-eon is the twin but instead of do jae i thought the other twin was the kidnapper who is getting orders. I thought since he was not adopted and his brother was. He grew resentful towards him hence claiming he knows Sa-eon.
But honestly your Theory is interesting too. Cause the way Park do jae behave makes him look like second Sa-eon the only hiccup is the ages difference if they are twins park do jae has to be same age as sa eon but he looks younger than him.
I mean she was not mute or deaf by birth after accident she became deaf maybe that why she had stopped speaking and after surgery she can hear her voice again so she is talking
Who pushed Hee Jo that she fell off the cliff? I saw that hand. Seems intentional.
It's to think that assistant park is the one cause he was only the one wearing black in that team and since his story is not explore he will be the next perfect the suspect in viewer eyes after Sang U
Okay, after episode 6, I have 3 theories for WhenThePhoneRings - 1. The Sang U we know and the assistant are twins.…
The problem with the theory I come up it is it can be wrong as it's a theory. But after episode 3/4 i comment here thinking that sa-eon is illegitimate child of the father (presidential candidate) cause I didn't think a family that upright will choose any kid to adopt and I found that father weird, he was openly flirting with his son's mother in law. 🤷🏻♀️
But someone who read the novel corrected me by saying I'm half right. Sa-eon is blood related to Baek family but not in the way I think. So that where my theory fail cause if he is blood related (and if writer didn't choose to change that part from the novel) he can't have a twin in orphanage
Okay, after episode 6, I have 3 theories for WhenThePhoneRings - 1. The Sang U we know and the assistant are twins.…
Your theories are more confusing than the drama. Also the drowning dream was of sa-eon not sang u. 1. That's a interesting take didn't thought of that (cause I don't think the assistant is the one who pushed her just cause of black clothing) 2. The kidnapper can only be real son in one and only case if the master is either of the parents (sa-eon's mom in my view) otherwise the real son having a master who orders him doesn't make sense. 3. I don't get it. Am I missing something here. Could you expand on that.
My theory was; sa-eon and kidnapper are twins and the master giving order to the kidnapper is either real son (or someone we haven't suspected enough) sang u is just friends with the real son who turns out to be a psychopath. Sa-eon got adopted and the twin brother stayed in orphanage and with time he became resentful towards his brother (the sa-eon we know) that's why him saying he knows sa-eon better.
Just a theory, haven't read the novel so if you are someone please ignore this comment but if have not read it. I would like to hear your take on this.
The twins, what if the twin is the kidnapper and Sa-eon. We already know he (sa-eon) is not the real son. As well as, kidnapper is not the real son cause he has a master. What if they are twin brother and Sa-eon got adopted and the kidnapper stayed in the orphanage. Maybe that's why he said he knows sa-eon well.
Also, what if the master is someone we are seeing from start but haven't suspected enough. NGL Hee Joo's adoptive father is getting sus-ier episode by episode
P.S. Early i thought sa-eon is illegitimate child of the father but someone who read the novel corrected me saying I'm half right. Sa-eon is related by blood with Baek family. So I exactly don't know how my twin theory fit here but still I wanted to share this.
why everyone in the comment section saying that the assistant (park do jae) is the culprit/mastermind , i have…
I think he is just mysterious and since his stories is not shown more he is new Sang woo these few episode. But honestly with the twist of one of the twins missing he is next possible suspect
I don't get some people in this comment. The drama specifies that it's a thriller, mystery and romance as it genre, so it obvious as it goes the two will sort out there issue and romance will take a little extra scene while the plot of who is behind all this space out throughout 12 episodes.
It not like for 12 episodes she will keep blackmailing and he will keep brooding over the guy 406 is; that will be the stupidest storyline. And you guys will hate that plot even more. People talking it's boring and only first 4 episode were good is like they want to continue that. It's not a crime show guys. But then I felt that how it will goes. Once the show's goes way too viral and zillion reels are on socials everything feels like I have seen it already so watching episode is boring now.
1. I agree with you on that as well as Sang U not fully telling the story. Making me think either he is the other twin who lost his brother and is looking for him hence digging out old case or he lost a beloved friend that he (now have credibility) trying to bring the dark past of that family to light.
But yes he could be the ultimate villain giving orders. But someone points that Sang U can't be twisted (psychopath) given the fact that he can show affection and special we see him falling for Hee Joo in that broadcasting room. And that's the time when Hee Joo was not married hence is not useful to him (if he was approaching her with a motive then)
2. I agree to this as well that park do jae is red herring here cause they won't show us him wearing black and purposefully revealing someone who pushed her was also wearing black. Now I think I'm more sure cause of the preview. In preview they had sketch of the kidnapper (the Unnie-ya guys). I'm guessing they will check CCTV of that day and will find him hence the sketch being available.
On you side theory- I had the same thought process. I thought the Unnie-ya guys and fake baek sa-eon can be twin and him not being adopted made him resentful or he was made resentful towards YYS through manipulation cause he keeps claiming he knows sa-eon better
3. On second hand I have even more wild than that. Everything we know so far comes with a twist that I started to suspect the death of chairman hong youngest kid. For a second I that park do jae maybe him. Hee Joo mom address his as "dongsaeng" to hee Joo making Hee Joo middle child once she is adopted; hence the age sits right between hee Joo and do jae. Cause for someone reason he was way more disdain when sa-eon and hee Joo was close on the retreat. (Cause he knows sa-eon married his sister In-a) I know way far fetched.
4. I know Unnie-ya guys is not the main villain and also the resources the "Master" can pull makes me think he is high up who has much power and money to do so and these recent episode I am becoming more and more suspecting of Hee Joo's adoptive father, chairman hong. He is getting more and more sus episode by episode to me.
Side note: the drowning accident initially I thought it's a false memory or tempered one. I mean they did kidnapped the fake sa-eon mainly because they didn't want to have paperwork done hence leaving no proof that he is adopted for media to do the digging (hence people not knowing it was 4 kid who went missing, not three) i thought in that time he might have drowned and to cope with trauma his mind made a false memory of him being drowned by the guy wearing dragon ring (I'm guessing him his adoptive grandfather) who would have been harsh towards him in beginning like all other parents in his adoptive family.
But your theory makes more sense. Only issue I find is the ring worm by the guy doing it makes no sense
Now my theory makes sense cause when mom said to sa-eon that her sister when deaf and her "dongsaeng" died making Hee Joo the middle child. This fits with their ages. Heejoo is older than Park do jae. But park do jae always seems more interfering with Sa-eon wife cause he thinks it's his sister (In-a). I also noticed he shows more disdain than other when so-eon is closed to hee Joo on the retreat
But the age he was shown in drowning scene is around the time he was adopted as the age of Sang u playing with Seoul master(the deranged kid who knifed the cat) was also same (saying it's around that time they switched the real son with adopted one).
Maybe sa-eon (ml) was kidnapped to be adopted rather than proper paperwork or he saw how bad the real son was and the guy with dragon ring is either punishing him in same way or that memory is of the day he got kidnapped but it's a bit tampered cause of trauma
But honestly your Theory is interesting too. Cause the way Park do jae behave makes him look like second Sa-eon the only hiccup is the ages difference if they are twins park do jae has to be same age as sa eon but he looks younger than him.
But someone who read the novel corrected me by saying I'm half right. Sa-eon is blood related to Baek family but not in the way I think. So that where my theory fail cause if he is blood related (and if writer didn't choose to change that part from the novel) he can't have a twin in orphanage
1. That's a interesting take didn't thought of that (cause I don't think the assistant is the one who pushed her just cause of black clothing)
2. The kidnapper can only be real son in one and only case if the master is either of the parents (sa-eon's mom in my view) otherwise the real son having a master who orders him doesn't make sense.
3. I don't get it. Am I missing something here. Could you expand on that.
My theory was; sa-eon and kidnapper are twins and the master giving order to the kidnapper is either real son (or someone we haven't suspected enough) sang u is just friends with the real son who turns out to be a psychopath. Sa-eon got adopted and the twin brother stayed in orphanage and with time he became resentful towards his brother (the sa-eon we know) that's why him saying he knows sa-eon better.
I would like to hear your take on this.
The twins, what if the twin is the kidnapper and Sa-eon. We already know he (sa-eon) is not the real son. As well as, kidnapper is not the real son cause he has a master. What if they are twin brother and Sa-eon got adopted and the kidnapper stayed in the orphanage. Maybe that's why he said he knows sa-eon well.
Also, what if the master is someone we are seeing from start but haven't suspected enough. NGL Hee Joo's adoptive father is getting sus-ier episode by episode
P.S. Early i thought sa-eon is illegitimate child of the father but someone who read the novel corrected me saying I'm half right. Sa-eon is related by blood with Baek family. So I exactly don't know how my twin theory fit here but still I wanted to share this.
It not like for 12 episodes she will keep blackmailing and he will keep brooding over the guy 406 is; that will be the stupidest storyline. And you guys will hate that plot even more. People talking it's boring and only first 4 episode were good is like they want to continue that. It's not a crime show guys. But then I felt that how it will goes. Once the show's goes way too viral and zillion reels are on socials everything feels like I have seen it already so watching episode is boring now.
Also sa-eon the entire retreat 🤦🏻♀️