I have to disagree about the flashback part. I have read the novel, and we can read that the flashback indeed…
I think you might have misunderstood what I said. I didn't say that the flashback comes after he wakes in the new body or that it's like that in novel. I said (in my opinion) it would have been better if it had been done that way in the show regardless of how it happens in the novel (as I have not read it yet, like I said).
To me it introduces too many things without enough context and I was left wondering "who are these people?" "what are they doing?" "why are certain people so hostile with each other?", and right when things seem to start to get going the flashback starts. Based on other comments I'm not the only person who was confused in the beginning.
Perhaps it's written better or makes more sense in the novel but I found it to be odd in both the drama and donghua. I felt that most of what was shown ultimately didn't enhance the flashback section and could have been put off until after that section was over.
I have to say I only have three complaints about the show and they're pretty minor. 1) the blood on people's faces I found distracting at points. like please... just wipe it off lmao. 2) the way the intro is set up is strange and confusing. obviously opening with a Big Fight is a pretty common tv trope so i'm not talking about that, but the start of the "flashback" should've happened right after WWX wakes up in the new body, rather than after all that stuff happens. once i got to the episode where it goes back to the present i actually went back and watched those first two episodes again because i found them very confusing the first time. but at least the drama put all the "flashback" at once rather than going back & forth like the anime. making the past and present more like two acts rather than jumping around is better imo. (no idea what the novel does since i have not read it yet). 3) occasionally the OST would confuse me because i'd be like "is that just the bgm or is a character actually playing" lol
You know how big anime series will often have spin-off movies that are essentially filler/non-canon? That's how I'm going to treat this movie. I wished this movie had been more like a montage of Wen Ning's development after the series, rather than focusing on one random haunting where in the end I did not care about any new characters introduced. Seeing actual bonding between Wen Ning and Sizhui would have been nice, but unfortunately almost all of their conversation is about the investigation.
But like okay, what the hell was up with his powers? Is it like that in the novel? Is it like that in the series and I just misremembered? Has he always had fire chains and other abilities like that? And whew, the plot was predictable as hell, but I was expecting the Yin Metal to actually be some sort of fake or cheap imitation that would break in the end or something. But no, this movie just casually gave Wen Ning one of the series' most powerful items.
Also I have to mention the scene of the "sister" dying. That scene of her in the fire looked absolutely horrendous and they showed it like 4 times. The scene of Wen Ning and Sizhui walking in Gusu had pretty obvious green screen too.
I suppose I'm glad I least gave it a shot, but I have absolutely no plans on watching this again.
Honestly if I didn't know about the original novel and was also unaware of the censorship I'd probably argue that…
Spoiler tag just in case. I would say it's less of his characteristics and more of certain actions? I was surprised to learn that the drama makes it so a lot of deaths aren't actually WWX's fault at all (Jin Zixuan's and his sister's deaths in particular). The way he acts is probably pretty similar, but I guess I prefer how in the drama there's actually a bigger villain behind a lot of things. Also, I have to admit that right now I'm busy binge-ing all the fanfics I can get my hands on lol.
Honestly if I didn't know about the original novel and was also unaware of the censorship I'd probably argue that…
I just finished the show last night and originally I was planning on watching the animation, and then perhaps reading the novel afterwards, but I read somewhere that WWX's character is a bit different in the novel and I'm not sure if I'd enjoy that version of him as much? Based on what I read on the wiki, many of the changes the drama made (aside from the censorship of course) are things I liked about it? idk if that makes sense lol. I might still try reading it eventually though!
Not sure I agree with this article at all, mostly about the fact about the no romance part. There was definitely…
Honestly if I didn't know about the original novel and was also unaware of the censorship I'd probably argue that their relationship is toeing on queer-baiting (edit to clarify just in case: I don't think the show actually QB, I just mean that the romantic undertones are imo pretty overt). I find it difficult to imagine watching this and seeing their relationship as 100% platonic, but maybe that's my lesbian brain looking for Gay in everything LOL.
I don't think you're entirely wrong, but I think by completely dismissing the source material, your entire point became skewed. Are pretty boys a draw factor? Certainly. But you completely failed to recognize that the original novel is BL, and so it's not quite "fangirls having the boys to themselves", it's more like "fangirls wanting to see the two leads kiss". And then maybe have the others to themselves? (I'll take miss Wen Qing if no one minds). Even if the drama isn't explicitly romantic (mostly due to censorship), the bromance is /heavy/, and I'm only a little over half way through the show. Every single time I've seen someone on my social media feeds mention this show, it's pretty much always about relationship between Wei Ying and Lan Zhan. Even if the show couldn't be a completely faithful adaptation, there was still buzz about how the novel is BL and that you can consider the relationship in the show to be implied.
Sorry if this is repetitive as I'm a bit tired, but anyway, I think you missed the chance at a deeper analysis by throwing the source material out the window.
Just picked this up again after putting it on hold for a while. Currently on episode 6.
As a huge fan of the original show, but also someone who likes dramas, I've been trying really hard not compare the adaption to the original too much, but it's difficult.
So far it's been enjoyable, some changes have been really interesting and engaging, but I'm still not hooked like the way I get with the original show.
Regarding the bullying, I think you mean So Yeong? And I agree that in the end her misdeeds were glossed over…
I'm not sure if it was just about looks, I think she partially just didn't like his hyperactive/troublemaker personality, but there were times where she was definitely mean to him and others without a real reason. I just think it was strange that even after seeing her sister attempt suicide due to bullying, there was never any sign of remorse for the mean things she had done herself?
I mean Eun Byul and her friends certainly weren't as outright villainous as So Yeong (I mean that whole video thing was kept pretty vague but the implication was sexual harassment at least right?) but it bothered me that the girl they extorted money from gave them all cute little drawings when she transferred and the girls faced no consequences.
Regarding the bullying, I think you mean So Yeong? And I agree that in the end her misdeeds were glossed over…
No, I was referring to how Eun Byul and her friends treated that girl who ended up stealing her mother's Jewelry, I think? I forgot her name, I'm sorry. I think the friend (Song Joo?) was actually worst offender in that situation, but it ended up being brushed off.
How funny would you rate this show? For example, I find Psychopath diary, leverage and Inspector Labour Jo quite…
I wouldn't say this show has a lot of outright comedy, but there are plenty of lighthearted and funny moments between the characters. It's not a constant doom and gloom type of show. I haven't finished the kdrama remake of Leverage but the original show is one of my favorites of all time, and Healer is probably my favorite drama of all time, so I would recommend it if you liked Leverage.
I forgot most of the details of this drama so I've been rewatching it, and man, this is still definitely my top…
I forgot about how infuriating the former cop in episode 16 is. Why are you blaming someone who was framed for getting you fired instead of blaming the people who framed him and fired you? Jeong Hu should have just knocked his ass out. (This isn't something I consider a flaw of the show btw, but it was a little rage-inducing lol)
I forgot most of the details of this drama so I've been rewatching it, and man, this is still definitely my top drama. There are still a few flaws of course, but overall the combination of action, mystery, and romance is still the best.
I'd really love to see how alternate version of this drama would play out where instead of disappearing, EunByul just reveals herself to EunBi when she learns about the bullying and takes her to Seoul. I really wanted to see more more of the sisters together than we got. I also wanted to learn more about EunByul in general, and see her held accountable for some of the things her and her friends did that we're just kinda brushed over.
it was explained by bong joon ho in many interviews that none of the characters are likeable as they were supposed…
It makes sense that they weren't supposed to be, but my own expectations of the film based on what I had heard from others unfortunately made me focus more on "this isn't what I thought it would be like at all" than the film itself :/
Many mixed feelings about this film. I think it's well made and well acted, but based on the way people talked about it I assumed I was supposed to be rooting for the poor family. Don't get me wrong, I didn't decide to root for the rich family instead (me? rooting for the rich? LMAO), but I guess I expected the poor family to be likeable.
GiWoo/Kevin who is definitely in his 20s making out with a high school girl was not something I was warned about, and I don't see anyone bringing it up. I think I understand now that he wasn't supposed to be likeable in the first place, but I still feel salty that GiJung/Jessica died instead of him.
While the story was rather predictable, it was still engaging and the acting was great. I think this would make a great introductory for someone who hasn't watched kdramas before. It's also good for people like me who have trouble finishing dramas (honestly, most dramas are 2-5 episodes longer than they need to be imo).
I didn't say that the flashback comes after he wakes in the new body or that it's like that in novel. I said (in my opinion) it would have been better if it had been done that way in the show regardless of how it happens in the novel (as I have not read it yet, like I said).
To me it introduces too many things without enough context and I was left wondering "who are these people?" "what are they doing?" "why are certain people so hostile with each other?", and right when things seem to start to get going the flashback starts. Based on other comments I'm not the only person who was confused in the beginning.
Perhaps it's written better or makes more sense in the novel but I found it to be odd in both the drama and donghua. I felt that most of what was shown ultimately didn't enhance the flashback section and could have been put off until after that section was over.
1) the blood on people's faces I found distracting at points. like please... just wipe it off lmao.
2) the way the intro is set up is strange and confusing. obviously opening with a Big Fight is a pretty common tv trope so i'm not talking about that, but the start of the "flashback" should've happened right after WWX wakes up in the new body, rather than after all that stuff happens. once i got to the episode where it goes back to the present i actually went back and watched those first two episodes again because i found them very confusing the first time.
but at least the drama put all the "flashback" at once rather than going back & forth like the anime. making the past and present more like two acts rather than jumping around is better imo. (no idea what the novel does since i have not read it yet).
3) occasionally the OST would confuse me because i'd be like "is that just the bgm or is a character actually playing" lol
I wished this movie had been more like a montage of Wen Ning's development after the series, rather than focusing on one random haunting where in the end I did not care about any new characters introduced. Seeing actual bonding between Wen Ning and Sizhui would have been nice, but unfortunately almost all of their conversation is about the investigation.
But like okay, what the hell was up with his powers? Is it like that in the novel? Is it like that in the series and I just misremembered? Has he always had fire chains and other abilities like that?
And whew, the plot was predictable as hell, but I was expecting the Yin Metal to actually be some sort of fake or cheap imitation that would break in the end or something. But no, this movie just casually gave Wen Ning one of the series' most powerful items.
Also I have to mention the scene of the "sister" dying. That scene of her in the fire looked absolutely horrendous and they showed it like 4 times.
The scene of Wen Ning and Sizhui walking in Gusu had pretty obvious green screen too.
I suppose I'm glad I least gave it a shot, but I have absolutely no plans on watching this again.
I would say it's less of his characteristics and more of certain actions? I was surprised to learn that the drama makes it so a lot of deaths aren't actually WWX's fault at all (Jin Zixuan's and his sister's deaths in particular). The way he acts is probably pretty similar, but I guess I prefer how in the drama there's actually a bigger villain behind a lot of things.
Also, I have to admit that right now I'm busy binge-ing all the fanfics I can get my hands on lol.
I find it difficult to imagine watching this and seeing their relationship as 100% platonic, but maybe that's my lesbian brain looking for Gay in everything LOL.
Are pretty boys a draw factor? Certainly. But you completely failed to recognize that the original novel is BL, and so it's not quite "fangirls having the boys to themselves", it's more like "fangirls wanting to see the two leads kiss". And then maybe have the others to themselves? (I'll take miss Wen Qing if no one minds).
Even if the drama isn't explicitly romantic (mostly due to censorship), the bromance is /heavy/, and I'm only a little over half way through the show.
Every single time I've seen someone on my social media feeds mention this show, it's pretty much always about relationship between Wei Ying and Lan Zhan. Even if the show couldn't be a completely faithful adaptation, there was still buzz about how the novel is BL and that you can consider the relationship in the show to be implied.
Sorry if this is repetitive as I'm a bit tired, but anyway, I think you missed the chance at a deeper analysis by throwing the source material out the window.
As a huge fan of the original show, but also someone who likes dramas, I've been trying really hard not compare the adaption to the original too much, but it's difficult.
So far it's been enjoyable, some changes have been really interesting and engaging, but I'm still not hooked like the way I get with the original show.
I mean Eun Byul and her friends certainly weren't as outright villainous as So Yeong (I mean that whole video thing was kept pretty vague but the implication was sexual harassment at least right?) but it bothered me that the girl they extorted money from gave them all cute little drawings when she transferred and the girls faced no consequences.
I agree with what you said about So Yeong though
GiWoo/Kevin who is definitely in his 20s making out with a high school girl was not something I was warned about, and I don't see anyone bringing it up. I think I understand now that he wasn't supposed to be likeable in the first place, but I still feel salty that GiJung/Jessica died instead of him.