My opinion on the likability of Jom: The biggest thing the show was missing that the novel had was Jom's inner dialogue. IMO, I really loved it and it did change the flavor a bit. That could potentialy change the likeability of Jom. I appreciated the character more after reading the novel.
Comparing the two, I actually really loved the show and while reading the novel thought many times about how much I liked the adaptation. That being said, I get why the adaptation strayed from that. I think overall, they made the right choice for the show because of how it turned out. However, as a fan, I feel I would have missed out if I had not also read it, especially regarding Jom.
My 2 cents. I am an artsy person and absolutely loved the cinematography, usage of poems, script, maturity, and... I feel it blows a lot of love stories out of the water. Rather than the firey passion take on love, it was one of the most beautifully executed potrayals of intimate timeless love. I don't know how it happened but the novel, director, screenwriters, full cast, and staff made some magic. Nonkul and Bright- wow. They are excelllent actors, very professional, and it shows. They were shooting 3-4 other shows at the time too! Bright passed on the role a few times and had to be talked into it. I don't think it would be close to what it is without him so, thank you Bright, for taking it on.
The novel was good and I will only comment on the first part to keep on topic. Comparing the two, I actually really loved the show and while reading the novel thought many times about how much I liked the adaptation. The biggest thing the show was missing was Jom's inner dialogue. IMO, I really loved it and it did change the flavor a bit. That being said, I get why the adaptation strayed from that. I think overall, they made the right choice for the show because of how it turned out. However, as a fan, I feel I would have missed out if I had not also read it.
Because the caliber of ifylita is so high (imo), it pales in comparison across the board. It felt like one of those mediocre responses to fan demand. I didn't expect that from ifylita so it really threw me. I love ifylita and would love a sequel or more like most fans -- but ONLY IF it matches or exceeds the first season. Otherwise, don't mess with it and let ifylita stand alone as an awesome piece. I felt that they possibly made this to soothe the audience demand incase there is no season 2.
Also -Uncutversion, TV version, BTS, and special all on Youku. It's a subscription but I got a heller deal -a…
It is titled I Feel You Linger In The Air Special. They have all uncut episodes 1 -12 then 13-24 have "TV" listed on them. Directly under that is the icon for the special. Directly under the special are the extras. The link attached to the special is pasted below.
IFYLITA Special EP now available for purchase on Heavenly (No ENGSUB, ONLY KOREAN SUB): https://heavenly.tv/en/detail/509
Also -Uncutversion, TV version, BTS, and special all on Youku. It's a subscription but I got a heller deal -a month for 5.00 just to watch it. +Incl Eng Subs. [Has commentary bullets but you can easily turn those off] And not sure if this matters or not but my VPN was set to the US.
My 2 cents. I am an artsy person and absolutely loved the cinematography, usage of poems, script, maturity, and... I feel it blows a lot of love stories out of the water. Rather than the firey passion take on love, it was one of the most beautifully executed potrayals of intimate timeless love. I don't know how it happened but the novel, director, screenwriters, full cast, and staff made some magic. Nonkul and Bright- wow. They are excelllent actors, very professional, and it shows. They were shooting 3-4 other shows at the time too! Bright passed on the role a few times and had to be talked into it. I don't think it would be close to what it is without him so, thank you Bright, for taking it on.
I watched the uncut version but I posted this here because, in this case, I give the same accolades. Lovely regardless of the version.
I liked it. It's dark, short, and sweet. I watched it after reading crazysexycoolpal's review and I think that helped me grasp how the three episodes were connected. I see a lot of kudos to Jeff (agreed except I am not a fan of his eye popping in ep 1), so I want to say that I liked Gameplay's performance a lot.
I really love the theme (paraphrasing) that-- in reality, you don't know who is performing and, during performances, you don't know who is being real.
Even if it isn't your thing, it is very short and worth it for the music.
Ummmm.... WOW! A bow to Park Sung Woong and Oh Seung Hoon. But seriously, Oh Seung Hoon, literally jaw dropping performance. I got disoriented, reoriented, then disoriented again.
About the 2 endings... Original ("sad"): I definitely had to pause for a few min. Without spoiling it... I think this is a much better ending. The quality is flat out is better than the first or all of the second up until the split where the endings change. Considering that alone, I can't say the alternate ending was better. And on an artistic level it also blew everything before that part away. Considering what happens at the end, the way it was presented in the ending scenes captured the thoughts, feelings, and how life looks when you are frozen, which I feel is quite a challenge to show in a few minutes. Kudos.
"Happy ending:" My thoughts are that it felt like it was exactly what it was, a forced revision. It felt like it followed the fake/common bl formula for a quick exit without making the audience feel bad. I watched this ending first so, I didn't quite get (without spoiling) why the event that happened after Nian left was thrown in there, but after I watched the orig ending it made more sense.
I know I am in the minority, but I wouldn't have cared for or remembered the pic as much if the orig ending didn't exist.
Also regarding Nian being "wooden" comments- I went in after already reading those comments and my impression was that even though it def looks weird and I would have liked to see Nian express himself differently in those moments, it kind of felt like "that's just Nian." He has some past emotional traumas, no self worth, and is taken aback/frozen when he is around the one he loves. He is different when Yan isn't around -and that behavior started when he was a child. So, I thought it was intentional. Who knows, I am on the outside looking in.
**I must add** if you are feeling down, or are prone to get moody or effected by shows after the fact, or melancholy-- I would avoid the original ending because, imo, it leaves you feeling heavy for awhile.
Might be true to life, but Ming is still an a**hole and Joe is sweet. I expect to see more of these comments.
Of course. Totally agree That's just my 2 cents. I feel like I've crossed paths with a lot of Mings but that doesn't make the character any lesser of an ass.
I do understand the loving Joe and upset with Ming comments. However, imo, (up to ep 2 and ep 3 teaser) Ming's behavior is true to life of the experiences in my circles. Not the whole uber rich and superstar crush bit, but the emotions, behavior, and projecting your hot mess onto others. It's not who we want to be or be with but if I had a dime for every....
The biggest thing the show was missing that the novel had was Jom's inner dialogue. IMO, I really loved it and it did change the flavor a bit. That could potentialy change the likeability of Jom. I appreciated the character more after reading the novel.
Comparing the two, I actually really loved the show and while reading the novel thought many times about how much I liked the adaptation. That being said, I get why the adaptation strayed from that. I think overall, they made the right choice for the show because of how it turned out. However, as a fan, I feel I would have missed out if I had not also read it, especially regarding Jom.
The novel was good and I will only comment on the first part to keep on topic. Comparing the two, I actually really loved the show and while reading the novel thought many times about how much I liked the adaptation. The biggest thing the show was missing was Jom's inner dialogue. IMO, I really loved it and it did change the flavor a bit. That being said, I get why the adaptation strayed from that. I think overall, they made the right choice for the show because of how it turned out. However, as a fan, I feel I would have missed out if I had not also read it.
I felt that they possibly made this to soothe the audience demand incase there is no season 2.
https://www.youku.tv/local_midway/call_app_share?action=play&vid=XNjE4MTcyNjc0NA==&lan=en_US&source=default&refer==qita_operation.chengqian.cq_00009655_000000_y2ABRj_23072800&sharekey=3ea08375178825506a4e45c3003959472
+Incl Eng Subs. [Has commentary bullets but you can easily turn those off]
And not sure if this matters or not but my VPN was set to the US.
I watched the uncut version but I posted this here because, in this case, I give the same accolades. Lovely regardless of the version.
I really love the theme (paraphrasing) that-- in reality, you don't know who is performing and, during performances, you don't know who is being real.
Even if it isn't your thing, it is very short and worth it for the music.
Wow. 🤩 Jeff Satur's song "Comedy" was amazing. Seriously, wow.
HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
Original ("sad"): I definitely had to pause for a few min. Without spoiling it... I think this is a much better ending. The quality is flat out is better than the first or all of the second up until the split where the endings change. Considering that alone, I can't say the alternate ending was better. And on an artistic level it also blew everything before that part away. Considering what happens at the end, the way it was presented in the ending scenes captured the thoughts, feelings, and how life looks when you are frozen, which I feel is quite a challenge to show in a few minutes. Kudos.
"Happy ending:" My thoughts are that it felt like it was exactly what it was, a forced revision. It felt like it followed the fake/common bl formula for a quick exit without making the audience feel bad. I watched this ending first so, I didn't quite get (without spoiling) why the event that happened after Nian left was thrown in there, but after I watched the orig ending it made more sense.
I know I am in the minority, but I wouldn't have cared for or remembered the pic as much if the orig ending didn't exist.
Also regarding Nian being "wooden" comments- I went in after already reading those comments and my impression was that even though it def looks weird and I would have liked to see Nian express himself differently in those moments, it kind of felt like "that's just Nian." He has some past emotional traumas, no self worth, and is taken aback/frozen when he is around the one he loves. He is different when Yan isn't around -and that behavior started when he was a child. So, I thought it was intentional. Who knows, I am on the outside looking in.
**I must add** if you are feeling down, or are prone to get moody or effected by shows after the fact, or melancholy-- I would avoid the original ending because, imo, it leaves you feeling heavy for awhile.