I would actually agree with the controversy if we had concrete evidence that that's the plot. Political activists…
bc they are intentionally being obtuse and that's the worst part to me lol and that's part of the issue with teh responses. they genuinely know what would happen with this or they were privileged enough to be like 'eh whatever' and are not putting out statements to negate this but there is also something to be said about the handling of this would be poor in general from like a radical standpoint (which these activists were. they were radical. and they did not like their government, america, the military, nor the cops. and many were communists, marxists, what have you) there's so many layers to this so even humanizing an agent of a regime and inserting that is a disservice these people did not like The Pigs and. the immense torture and stuff it's just this is so irresponsible culturally, as an artist, and it shows in our responses. it's sad. but they are going to fuck this narrative up regardless it's just a shame that they didnt give themselves a chance to prove themselves and their ideas and lead with that instead of leading with allowing this to happen and taking ZERO responsibility when being asked to reply and evaluate the stupid synopses that /they released/ starting off with "satirical black comedy" like from beginning to end this was a mess that aaaaaaaaabsolutely could have been avoided and fixed when it appeared and they chose not to. like jisoo being cast was already a big deal right and obviously not comparable but these people know what they're doing in terms of outrage marketing of that i am sure and asking people not to make accusations when they're the ones that put it out and refuse to clarify is beautiful. we would have been able to get through it and evaluate the art including its content in the technical piece; i watch shows about cops unfortunately all the time but i can understand the messages trying to be conveyed and what i wish could be done better in the mainstream and the limits of the mainstream and art so it's literally like they put this in their own way. the black panther party's legacy (nor i or many other annoying commies) doesn't love when it's invoked in the name of celebrity and moneymaking even from black celebrities but there's at least the acknowledgement of its core tenets and theyre not even doing that here! idk what im more mad at the stupidity from a production standpoint, artistic standpoint, or crazy commie standpoint ( all 3 i also just realized with more clarity how intentional this all is lmao)
I was always thinking that the staff and the cast and the whole team working on this drama from directors and…
you have to understand the intense long connotations of this and this is in part of our understanding of media but i am going to try to explain what i can (my tone is staunch and my values/beliefs are what they are so my opinion is in here but everything about the history is literally a fact but i am one of those crazy leftists but im talking about this on several levels as an artist as well and hopefully it makes sense bc people do not realize the gravity of this if i sound emphatic it's towards this whole thing but not you yourself and i cannot I CANNOT overstate how amazing i find these students and these activists and they deserve respect in their mission and legacy and are role models in how we love each other and the world full stop and respecting them alone for forcing material change and those who take up that torch now it is not easy, glamorous, or whatever but that is truly a life worth living but we should not romanticize martyrdom either)
they arent doing due diligence as creators but what's worse is that they are also doing this on purpose. i do not agree that this is all because of the CCP and think that in itself is misinformation and the history of these events needs to be known so i suggest people do their research.
this is a common trope in TV/media over there (and in general where they obfuscate an issue and lie about the events) about using the claim of NK spies to prop up that it was not a dictatorship, not inebted to america and imperialism, and their people did not have a hand in it.
it's extremely irresponsible and even more so given the CURRENT climate and the inability to enact material change and oppression and experiencing it doesn't mean you are free of it yourselves.
the mere mention of thse people, their names, the time frame, the similarities means that it is exactly an indication of where they are drawing from and we know that as human beings the likeness is there and to tell a story. THEY were the ones that wrote that synopsis so they need to figure it out and, since one of the woman is still alive after she had to move to canada bc her own government along with the US created murderous madness and silenced her and her friends for demanding freedom, has a friend that said this:
"The fact that a 'black comedy' drama deals with the story of a spy who hid among the protestors of the democracy movement can only be seen as hate crime act, mocking those who dedicated their lives to the cause of democracy in Korea."
it is beyond beyond beyond irresponsible. this could be an easy fix; be clear about the script, what it will be about, and at least do not make it ahistorical since the radicalism in the message will be diluted anyway via the mainstream co-opting progressive rhetoric to repackage it and fit their narrative and give people false ideas about the truth and rate of change. covid has shown that so many of us are not doing this bullshit anymore.
i want to reiterate how offensive this is and how much it is based on legacy and the privilege for us as non-koreans (i mean in general; i am black idk readers race or culture/wheover stumbles on it) but also even for let’s say koreans or asians who do not understand the clash how that is a place of our ignorance and understanding. but we also gain understanding from everything we see, right? media is on hand so people may be experiencing this type fo subbject for the first time if they are maybe a gen z er or may not know much as a millenial and this is what they garner. the myth of the NK spy has prevailed as a boogeyman propped by the US which emboldens the military here and there and puts power back into the hands of those at the top—we already know we have not reached true freedom and unfortunately leftist voices are fewer and far between for us (as viewers) to access alternate viewpoints from people who rae conscious about this and frfom artists who are as well. this is so much based in pro-authority, anti-communism and division and directly props up imperialism and continues to do wonders for the US' extreme involvement and the korean government's involvement and compliance for gain with the US to literally murder THOUSANDS of their own people and others post WWII and the cold war era to vietnam (and onwards btw this shit has not stopped and we are constantly in crisis what helps our people is informing them on the reality and by our people i mean us as human beings on this earth)
this is extremely crucial to get right tbh and all the experts said they do not want to censor the show but that people have cultural responsibility and that these people and companies should be clear to them but many of these places, people, companies, and yes many artists either suck, hav eno integrity, what have you, whatever do NOT CARE and that's the reality. it's the content and misinforming the public about it and allowing a silent narrative to stay or complicity and we know that frankly people are not as interested in the truth or dont have time or whatever.
like to be very clear: the korean government murdered hundreds of thousands during the red scare with the support and sanctioning by the US (designated survivor does an accurate laywork of this and really puts blame on america well and the domestic responsibility and failures i think though it's been a while since i've watched it) and, again, this is not easy history. koreans that were in germany at the time, about 200, which they immigrated and GER is trying to repair the aftermath of their genocide infliction, the axis (and omg post-occupation as well) etc so these german koreans are abducted by their own government, accused of being spies, tortured and sentenced to extract bullshit confessions like pigs do, and killed. these shows like to represent the police and NIS, military/imperial forces as some sort of allies as well when they are the direct enemies of the people and continue to be in the eyes of the people of this movement (and in mine too but i'm saying even though on emay not agree it doesn't matter bc that is the factual truth for those involved)
so when you misrepresent this even on a base level it absolves the most evil forms of hatred. it absolves america who should never be absolved, it absolves the people domestically content on destroying their own people and content on aiding in the destruction of freedom and happiness for their power.
it is history denial, it is rewriting history, and it is dangerous. it is illegal in certain parts of the world to fabricate things and regarded highly as DISGUSTING (as it shhould be) to try and prove the holocaust didn’t happen.
in america and the way america wants to view our specific brand of slavery it is spun as something of choice, or not that bad, or not as ddehumanizing, genocidal, and life-changing literally it changed the world immensely as it is. we are literally told that and have thigns that imply that. multiple series. human pain and suffering and the authoritarians ruling always do this they minimize and editorialize and obfuscate and the answer is pretty much still denying their responsibility and continuing to tell people that we are divided as human beings and that there is some Other force to get them when it isnt external voices it’s the legacy of slaveyr, capital, imperialism, harm, hatred
on a base level it’s just being a lazy artist and production team especially since they are on cable and can be way more radical and progressive, romanticizing a really horrific time because people do not realize that revolutionaries and revolutions are not glamorous and it takes immense courage, and creates a “complex” area when there is none.
and on a higher level it’s dangerous, truly, because even with this information the talk about why people are objecting becomes more about how people want to “silence others” and their “moral outrage” and the bullshit argument about cancel culture. the woman in this that the actress plays is alive today but, after she had to literally move and flee and years of torture and seeing 100s of thousands murdered by ROK and US support for communist elimination that set us ALL BACK, she got into a car accident, became blind, and is functioning with very little cognitive abilities residing in the countryside and i think maybe she has a son with her. no matter how we slice it it’s just so rresponsible and it could have been fixed but they simply do not care. and their statements about it are so unhe lpful.
this will be out there probably along with allll the other neoliberal ahistorical faux progressive things as well that harp about unity but aren’t promoting it and are swaying people into a direction of potential neutrality at its best. i hope people stumble upon this and understand this more because it’s a problem and as viewers it’s insulting, those of us hwo are artists should recognize the laziness and lack of integrity, and people should be ashamed for letting the drama stir up and REFUSING to properly clarify but even basing it off of this, a black comedy, and a romance. my god and it’s not focusing and honoring what these people did as extremeley amazing, brave, courageous, beautiful, and loving for their family, friends, school, country, world to be the beautiful place it should be. they had a hand in that. if they want to highlight the beauty of it then they damn sure better get it right otherwise they are lying and taking the beauty out of it with even this drop of falsehood, that their government and america and all the evil fucks who hate citizens and solidarity and exchanging information and culture all of that which art SHOULD stand for and humanity, does not cut it.
it says wonders that it could have been avoided but they chose not to. that’s the real issue; why be so emboldened? especially within a culture that’s more strict in some social rules (as opposed to in the US where you can be a dumbass or more autonomous in the public eye with way less pressure from society for several reasons) they knew complaints would come lol the intentions are there and glaring
also they lied about the death toll and since the 50s up until these historical events they had been killing people they deemed to be communist/north korean/literally anything/immigrant laborers/mixed people etc like anyone they didnt want at the behest of the fucking US government and ROK military might. it’s pathetic. pathetic.
theyre NOT dumb they wrote this synopsis, scripts get leaked all the time, worse has been seen and has been released and is on air. the people playing into it not recognizing their intentions and being concerned about these intentions are the ones being played tbh and that's another thing we have been coerced into so many modes of thinking and being that we dont even notice it. there is no way in hell these people didnt know that these words thgouths would be extrapolated from this release and NO WAY in hell that they didnt know signifiying that he is a korean-german man who shows up at a /college dorm/ bloody and tortured given teh information above about the kidnapping of actually german korean people being forced back to a country trying to harm them to uphold authority. and they shoudl absolutely make more of an effort to make it clear that is it a TRUE satire meaning they are going to go all in with it and attack the status quou but they did nooooooneeeee of that. none. it shows just how common this belief is and how easy it is to have shit like this seep into our minds and be the truth god i could go on but yea
also it's ugly history it will have to namecall itself, its own values, AMERICA, it will have to give power and the truth to the true ideas behind communism adn what these kids believed in and how literally being a person who knows they deserve dignity and freedom just like eveyrone else and not to be punished for being an Other but that doesn't mesh with a huge production either and bet people arent gonna give you money to admonish propaganda and give america and ROK a huge fucking lashing along with all other authoritarian regimes that tsill exist very much so in all our societies. it would be ironic if they got it right while doing such poor rollout but the rollout and promotion shows me they don't care enough about it and it's jsut another story of victory that was like half reckless youth and the other have super well meaning government officials lmao and if it ends happily ever after and they are rich at the end it's just...WOW im gonna stop it's just so hypocritical, empty, unimaginative and frankly sad way to drum up hype and conversation that shows me that theyre not too confident in this work in itself that they had to do alladat. my god. do betterrrrr!!!!!!!
lmao i cannot believe they are going to release this in this day and age with this pandemic with the misinformation. they better not fuck it up but i do not trust it. jesus so sirresponsible
i respect the hell otu of the writer, i respect the premise, i like both of the leads and it feels visually age appropriate and that it could be funny AND the name reminds me of my fav show about a civil servant (special labor inspector mr jo!) so this could be some decently progressive innovative fun AND lee sang hee. wow this may be a good year of dramas even though the pandemic is very much still on and the stories really reflect our realities. cool, looking forward. i hpoe they fit each other since though their talent is a bit lacking they have extreme charm and good presence that makes you want to see where it's headed!
what happened at the end? i never finished and i dont remember the details of the ending tho i was around for…
omg what forreal?!??!? yea im p sure there were production issues or it may have been canceleed but omg...this is a sin :( that sucks so bad!!!! i cannot believe yall had 2 witness that!!! they have good chemistry so i hope they can act in another thing
CANNOT WAIT to have this in my eyeballs IF it is good bc the two of them together in a meaningful drama absolutely woudl be amazing! talents that care about acting so it's a pleasure to see them in things with other people who are great. njh really proved himself with SNF and with a competent partner/partners (acting wise) around it's great. story seems kinda dull i sorta hate these kinda time period ones but man this could be great they always choose interesting different projects (even if i cant watch them like mr sunshine or njh's last drama and 'here' but still the subejct matters are always something and the characters complex and challenging!)
Although the ending was kinda shitty, it was overall a very fun drama as a whole. Go eun seop and oh dae gi STOLE…
what happened at the end? i never finished and i dont remember the details of the ending tho i was around for it lol but i know there were some issues with production iirc or timing of the eps
no crime if there's no law! here's hoping it's some good anarcho cop-hating badass girl fun. love the picture and i hope they do this character justice. excited to see where the story could lead. i dont know much about her but i like her so i'm here for it (not nevertheless but im finna follow her around, shes got potential)
Shes 28..no we wouldnt. Lol we have ariana grande shes just tiny shes N actual adult nothing she can do about…
the AOC in fr you mean? bc that's 13 and they have a grotesque history with it (like actually grotesque and the reason the AOC was put into place more forcefully is partly because of a well known sexual abuser being in the public eye and th ecase against the AOC was proposed by multiple piece of shit french scholars who dont know a damn thing during the sexual revolution so it's a bit diff.) in terms of why we (americans) couldnt handle it, it was because of a lot of misrepresentation and just being over the top in the reporting of it considering how lax we are with, say, things like 'call me by your name' that was a selective choice. mignonnes is a special case and is much more of a nuanced conversation. not to mention those girls are obviously not adults. this woman is.
idg your point lol the girl is 28, she looks young but it's fine. it would fly in the US because we, like everywhere, suck. we love shows about teachers and students so. plus ag has that whole intentional ~lolita~ (misreading, of course) thing going on and a baby voice. so it isnt just china
This is the first c drama romance i watched and it was a….like the dude sucked so bad and i did the whole thing i still cant believe it ??? i need to see some good ones cos :( the kissing was also bad
Just started my 2nd viewing & I love it as much as ever. It’s so effing weird and wonderful.Btw…do we ever…
yes to the above but also ducks mean conformity. ducks like to travel in a pack and find it's leader that's why they're always there to mirror the system so to speak
they arent doing due diligence as creators but what's worse is that they are also doing this on purpose. i do not agree that this is all because of the CCP and think that in itself is misinformation and the history of these events needs to be known so i suggest people do their research.
this is a common trope in TV/media over there (and in general where they obfuscate an issue and lie about the events) about using the claim of NK spies to prop up that it was not a dictatorship, not inebted to america and imperialism, and their people did not have a hand in it.
it's extremely irresponsible and even more so given the CURRENT climate and the inability to enact material change and oppression and experiencing it doesn't mean you are free of it yourselves.
the mere mention of thse people, their names, the time frame, the similarities means that it is exactly an indication of where they are drawing from and we know that as human beings the likeness is there and to tell a story. THEY were the ones that wrote that synopsis so they need to figure it out and, since one of the woman is still alive after she had to move to canada bc her own government along with the US created murderous madness and silenced her and her friends for demanding freedom, has a friend that said this:
"The fact that a 'black comedy' drama deals with the story of a spy who hid among the protestors of the democracy movement can only be seen as hate crime act, mocking those who dedicated their lives to the cause of democracy in Korea."
it is beyond beyond beyond irresponsible. this could be an easy fix; be clear about the script, what it will be about, and at least do not make it ahistorical since the radicalism in the message will be diluted anyway via the mainstream co-opting progressive rhetoric to repackage it and fit their narrative and give people false ideas about the truth and rate of change. covid has shown that so many of us are not doing this bullshit anymore.
i want to reiterate how offensive this is and how much it is based on legacy and the privilege for us as non-koreans (i mean in general; i am black idk readers race or culture/wheover stumbles on it) but also even for let’s say koreans or asians who do not understand the clash how that is a place of our ignorance and understanding. but we also gain understanding from everything we see, right? media is on hand so people may be experiencing this type fo subbject for the first time if they are maybe a gen z er or may not know much as a millenial and this is what they garner. the myth of the NK spy has prevailed as a boogeyman propped by the US which emboldens the military here and there and puts power back into the hands of those at the top—we already know we have not reached true freedom and unfortunately leftist voices are fewer and far between for us (as viewers) to access alternate viewpoints from people who rae conscious about this and frfom artists who are as well. this is so much based in pro-authority, anti-communism and division and directly props up imperialism and continues to do wonders for the US' extreme involvement and the korean government's involvement and compliance for gain with the US to literally murder THOUSANDS of their own people and others post WWII and the cold war era to vietnam (and onwards btw this shit has not stopped and we are constantly in crisis what helps our people is informing them on the reality and by our people i mean us as human beings on this earth)
this is extremely crucial to get right tbh and all the experts said they do not want to censor the show but that people have cultural responsibility and that these people and companies should be clear to them but many of these places, people, companies, and yes many artists either suck, hav eno integrity, what have you, whatever do NOT CARE and that's the reality. it's the content and misinforming the public about it and allowing a silent narrative to stay or complicity and we know that frankly people are not as interested in the truth or dont have time or whatever.
like to be very clear: the korean government murdered hundreds of thousands during the red scare with the support and sanctioning by the US (designated survivor does an accurate laywork of this and really puts blame on america well and the domestic responsibility and failures i think though it's been a while since i've watched it) and, again, this is not easy history. koreans that were in germany at the time, about 200, which they immigrated and GER is trying to repair the aftermath of their genocide infliction, the axis (and omg post-occupation as well) etc so these german koreans are abducted by their own government, accused of being spies, tortured and sentenced to extract bullshit confessions like pigs do, and killed. these shows like to represent the police and NIS, military/imperial forces as some sort of allies as well when they are the direct enemies of the people and continue to be in the eyes of the people of this movement (and in mine too but i'm saying even though on emay not agree it doesn't matter bc that is the factual truth for those involved)
so when you misrepresent this even on a base level it absolves the most evil forms of hatred. it absolves america who should never be absolved, it absolves the people domestically content on destroying their own people and content on aiding in the destruction of freedom and happiness for their power.
it is history denial, it is rewriting history, and it is dangerous. it is illegal in certain parts of the world to fabricate things and regarded highly as DISGUSTING (as it shhould be) to try and prove the holocaust didn’t happen.
in america and the way america wants to view our specific brand of slavery it is spun as something of choice, or not that bad, or not as ddehumanizing, genocidal, and life-changing literally it changed the world immensely as it is. we are literally told that and have thigns that imply that. multiple series. human pain and suffering and the authoritarians ruling always do this they minimize and editorialize and obfuscate and the answer is pretty much still denying their responsibility and continuing to tell people that we are divided as human beings and that there is some Other force to get them when it isnt external voices it’s the legacy of slaveyr, capital, imperialism, harm, hatred
on a base level it’s just being a lazy artist and production team especially since they are on cable and can be way more radical and progressive, romanticizing a really horrific time because people do not realize that revolutionaries and revolutions are not glamorous and it takes immense courage, and creates a “complex” area when there is none.
and on a higher level it’s dangerous, truly, because even with this information the talk about why people are objecting becomes more about how people want to “silence others” and their “moral outrage” and the bullshit argument about cancel culture. the woman in this that the actress plays is alive today but, after she had to literally move and flee and years of torture and seeing 100s of thousands murdered by ROK and US support for communist elimination that set us ALL BACK, she got into a car accident, became blind, and is functioning with very little cognitive abilities residing in the countryside and i think maybe she has a son with her. no matter how we slice it it’s just so rresponsible and it could have been fixed but they simply do not care. and their statements about it are so unhe lpful.
this will be out there probably along with allll the other neoliberal ahistorical faux progressive things as well that harp about unity but aren’t promoting it and are swaying people into a direction of potential neutrality at its best. i hope people stumble upon this and understand this more because it’s a problem and as viewers it’s insulting, those of us hwo are artists should recognize the laziness and lack of integrity, and people should be ashamed for letting the drama stir up and REFUSING to properly clarify but even basing it off of this, a black comedy, and a romance. my god and it’s not focusing and honoring what these people did as extremeley amazing, brave, courageous, beautiful, and loving for their family, friends, school, country, world to be the beautiful place it should be. they had a hand in that. if they want to highlight the beauty of it then they damn sure better get it right otherwise they are lying and taking the beauty out of it with even this drop of falsehood, that their government and america and all the evil fucks who hate citizens and solidarity and exchanging information and culture all of that which art SHOULD stand for and humanity, does not cut it.
it says wonders that it could have been avoided but they chose not to. that’s the real issue; why be so emboldened? especially within a culture that’s more strict in some social rules (as opposed to in the US where you can be a dumbass or more autonomous in the public eye with way less pressure from society for several reasons) they knew complaints would come lol the intentions are there and glaring
also they lied about the death toll and since the 50s up until these historical events they had been killing people they deemed to be communist/north korean/literally anything/immigrant laborers/mixed people etc like anyone they didnt want at the behest of the fucking US government and ROK military might. it’s pathetic. pathetic.
theyre NOT dumb they wrote this synopsis, scripts get leaked all the time, worse has been seen and has been released and is on air. the people playing into it not recognizing their intentions and being concerned about these intentions are the ones being played tbh and that's another thing we have been coerced into so many modes of thinking and being that we dont even notice it. there is no way in hell these people didnt know that these words thgouths would be extrapolated from this release and NO WAY in hell that they didnt know signifiying that he is a korean-german man who shows up at a /college dorm/ bloody and tortured given teh information above about the kidnapping of actually german korean people being forced back to a country trying to harm them to uphold authority. and they shoudl absolutely make more of an effort to make it clear that is it a TRUE satire meaning they are going to go all in with it and attack the status quou but they did nooooooneeeee of that. none. it shows just how common this belief is and how easy it is to have shit like this seep into our minds and be the truth god i could go on but yea
also it's ugly history it will have to namecall itself, its own values, AMERICA, it will have to give power and the truth to the true ideas behind communism adn what these kids believed in and how literally being a person who knows they deserve dignity and freedom just like eveyrone else and not to be punished for being an Other but that doesn't mesh with a huge production either and bet people arent gonna give you money to admonish propaganda and give america and ROK a huge fucking lashing along with all other authoritarian regimes that tsill exist very much so in all our societies. it would be ironic if they got it right while doing such poor rollout but the rollout and promotion shows me they don't care enough about it and it's jsut another story of victory that was like half reckless youth and the other have super well meaning government officials lmao and if it ends happily ever after and they are rich at the end it's just...WOW im gonna stop it's just so hypocritical, empty, unimaginative and frankly sad way to drum up hype and conversation that shows me that theyre not too confident in this work in itself that they had to do alladat. my god. do betterrrrr!!!!!!!
idg your point lol the girl is 28, she looks young but it's fine. it would fly in the US because we, like everywhere, suck. we love shows about teachers and students so. plus ag has that whole intentional ~lolita~ (misreading, of course) thing going on and a baby voice. so it isnt just china