Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 1 hour ago
  • Location:
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: February 29, 2024
  • Awards Received: Flower Award2
Replying to MiMo • 10 days ago
From what I understand, it's not necessarily about having the most votes. The “not helpful” votes may also…
Thanks for replying. I didn't even think about the not helpful votes. That makes sense. At least now I won't have to spend anymore time trying to figure it out!
1 10
On The Lament of Autumn • 10 days ago
Can someone explain something to me? I see the reviews default to most helpful. I assumed the ones with the highest votes would be listed at the top, but that's not the case. Is it just random or is there something I'm missing?
0 13
Replying to Eleison • 10 days ago
Title The Lament of Autumn Spoiler
From what I've gathered, it's a chinese version of a makjang with an obsessive, aggressive ML (who goes through…
I love character arcs that show growth, too. That's why I was so disappointed in this drama because they showed the growth when Chang Xuan came back from the war and it was really touching and wonderful to see how his perspective grew and changed him because of the way the soldiers were treated and seeing them die. But then the writers promptly forgot all about it and CX went right back to his old ways with PJ. I don't know that I've ever seen such a case of writer amnesia before.

I've only been watching Chinese/Korean dramas for a few years so haven't watched many older ones, but the themes of aggression and obsession as romantic was apparent from the beginning. I watch a lot of short dramas and verticals and it's rampant there. The toxicity can be through the roof and all the ML has to do is apologize in the end and all is forgiven and the FL takes him back. Sometimes he doesn't even need to apologize! Thankfully there is frequently a lot of pushback in comments. I was surprised at how little there was for this drama here, though there was in the comments on Viki.

But you put an attractive, sexy man in great clothes with beautiful lighting and lovely music and you can make anything romantic, I guess. I'm not immune to it, myself. ;)
1 1
Replying to 16972008 • 10 days ago
At the Battle, Yu Changxuan and his older brother, Yu Mingxuan, were fighting together. Mingxuan had an original…
Thank you for such a great explanation. The scene where Chang Xuan realizes what really happened was such great acting from Cheng Lei.
1 0
Replying to melan_oleuca26 • 10 days ago
I saw this post on X https://x.com/Allcbizmelons/status/1899764363894091873?a=SsCG_8rwPCr9BG_XH4Y&s=19is it…
I don't think ZLH could play such a complex character as Chang Xuan. He's just not that good an actor. I've only seen Li Landi in Filter so I have no opinion about her.

I agree that Xu Rouhan was very inconsistent in this drama. A lot had to do with how the writers destroyed her character, because she was good at the beginning. They really needed a strong actress to match Cheng Lei and XR isn't there yet.
1 1
Replying to Ti02 • 10 days ago
Cheng Lei, Xu Ruohan and Zhang Yunlong attended Mango Tv Double 11 x Hello Saturday Gala today.Their red carpet…
Thank you for posting all these. The things these actors have to do astounds me, but it's also so much fun to watch them.
1 1
Replying to Eleison • 10 days ago
Title The Lament of Autumn Spoiler
From what I've gathered, it's a chinese version of a makjang with an obsessive, aggressive ML (who goes through…
"It's fiction. You don't have to support the characters to enjoy the drama/story."

I personally feel people use "It's fiction." when they can't refute what someone says. Obsession and possession don't suddenly turn into love because it's a drama. And I can't enjoy a drama if I can't support a ML when the story is trying to make him out to be a good guy when too many of his actions weren't good.

Now if the story had made him unapologetically bad and not tried to whitewash his behavior that's totally different. Or if he'd actually had an awakening and that awakening changed him for the rest of the drama I would have been cheering. Unfortunately that didn't happen. I am so puzzled by people talking about the ML's amazing character growth with regards to the FL because it just isn't there.

Thank you for being honest. It's nice to have someone to talk with who shares my same beliefs about this drama.
1 3
Replying to AmelieLucan • 10 days ago
Title The Lament of Autumn Spoiler
He, his father and his mother died.
Yeah, same.

The father was pretty much an awful human being so his death wasn't sad at all.

The mother's death was tragic, but she was refusiing to do what the Japanese wanted her to do so it had great meaning. It was awful because I think most people loved her.

And of course watching the ML die was awful. Still it's all very typical of Republican-era dramas.
4 0
Replying to Robs • 10 days ago
Title The Lament of Autumn Spoiler
soo... is worth it or can i just ignore this drama?
Have you watched Republican dramas before? It was a brutal time in Chinese history with warlords ruling over people and fighting each other for territory.

Do you like red flag men? There are several and it can be rough to watch the way the FL was treated.

Do you like angst ratcheted up? The FL endures tragedy, torture and sexual assault. It becomes very melodramatic.

Do you like Cheng Lei (Ryan Cheng)? He's an amazing actor and he's outstanding in the role he plays.

Do you love other aspects of dramas? The cinematography is beautiful, music was great, acting was overall very good, lots of postivie female characters.

But really, as always, only you can decide. Watch some and see. Just be aware that it's not a light and fluffy drama.
3 0
Replying to lovedarkchocolate • 10 days ago
Title The Lament of Autumn Spoiler
I saw a post on IG it said that "he and his family died" is it true?
He, his father and his mother died.
1 3
Replying to Eleison • 10 days ago
Title The Lament of Autumn Spoiler
From what I've gathered, it's a chinese version of a makjang with an obsessive, aggressive ML (who goes through…
"Just because people pamper their dogs, cuddle with them, give them treats and roll out the red carpet for them, doesn't mean they stop seeing them as dogs."

It's funny that you mention pets, because that's how I felt CX treated PJ when she was in a coma. It was like he finally got her in the position he wanted where she couldn't resist him and he could feel like he was a wonderful person for taking care of her.

I never felt like CX loved PJ for the very reasons you mentioned. Treating someone like a possession, being obsessed with them isn't love. But a lot of people here and in the comments on Viki talked about this great love he had and it just boggled my mind.
1 5
Replying to Alida3 • 11 days ago
This drama gets voted down in part by people who would give it a high rating if the gender roles were reversed…
I have pointed out the flaws in the drama and why I think it's fairly rated. And apparently I'm not a CL fan by your definition so I think we'll have to leave it at that.
0 0
Replying to Alida3 • 11 days ago
This drama gets voted down in part by people who would give it a high rating if the gender roles were reversed…
"Exactly, it’s Cheng Lei! If you admire Cheng Lei you don’t come to his drama page and keep telling people how bad his drama is.
Has it ever occurred to you that it could contribute to some people‘s decision not to watch this drama? And maybe also avoid his dramas in the future? People are like that."

You think admiring Cheng Lei means keeping quiet if you don't like something in his drama. I don't. And I'm not responsible for what someone might decide if they read my comments. There are enough people praising the drama so it more than balances out.

I don't really care if someone rates the acting a 4. I'm sure the high ratings far exceed those anyway.

How people rate based on male-centric vs female-centric dramas doesn't really matter. People will rate the way they want anyway.
0 2
Replying to Nedolino • 11 days ago
I have to say, I’m really impressed by Cheng Lei’s performance. He has left such a strong impression on me…
Cheng Lei is one of the best actors around in my opinion. I'm really glad to see him getting so much recognition for his talent, even from people who disliked the drama.
3 0
Replying to khuki • 11 days ago
is the chemistry good
Sometimes yes, a majority of the time no because he was obsessed with having her whether she wanted him or not. She was alternately running away from him and coming back to him.
0 0
Replying to oeib67 • 11 days ago
I actually enjoyed The Lament of Autumn. The storyline was interesting, and it was a good drama overall, but I…
I agree with almost everything you said. The only area I differ is that I don't think he loved her until the very end of the drama. The rest of the time he was obsessed with having her regardless of whether she wanted him in return. There was nothing loving in most of what he did. I think the rating is very fair, too.
0 0