Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 6 minutes ago
  • Location:
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: February 29, 2024
  • Awards Received: Flower Award2
Replying to MiMo • 12 days ago
As I said earlier, I'd prefer a straightforward discussion rather than turning my comments and every word into…
How thoughtful you are to post this! Thank you. ❤️
2 1
Replying to NBravo18 • 12 days ago
I often second guess whether I should write a review/comment. Sadly, for me, the ML is unforgivable and has soured…
I'm sorry that you have to feel that way. I saw comments from people on another drama that disagreed with the mainstream view that the drama was a masterpiece and they were attacked so much that they said they wouldn't comment anymore.

I'll be interested to read your review if you write one.
1 4
Replying to MiMo • 12 days ago
As I said earlier, I'd prefer a straightforward discussion rather than turning my comments and every word into…
Not sure why you're angry with me. I quote comments so people know what I'm talking about when I respond.

Your discussions are not the only ones that reference haters and it's not just for people rating episodes that haven't aired yet. I read a review where several people attacked the reviewer for their opinions and the reviewer was called a hater. I found it disgusting.

I'm sorry if you find my comments repetitive. This is not the only drama where people with opposing views are called haters and the reasoning interests me.
3 7
Replying to AmelieLucan • 12 days ago
Why do you call people haters when they have a different view of this drama? For me the rating slowly went down…
Did you mean what I think of rating unaired episodes? I don't think rating an episode before it's aired should be allowed. I've seen it go both ways, downrating and uprating. It's most likely upvoting one's favorite actor(s) or downvoting in an attempt to help one's favorites. Neither is fair.

Did you mean what I thought of the episodes themselves?
1 1
Black tulip • 12 days ago
This review was like reading my own thoughts while watching the drama. I'm as disappointed as you that the story we were excited about at the beginning disappeared only to be replaced by a melodramatic mess.
1 1
pattagobi • 12 days ago
"They refused to retreat, fought until their last breath, and it all went to waste."

I just finished the drama last night and that is something that really struck me, too. It was such a foolish decision, because they couldn't win and by continuing to fight they lost soldiers who could have fought elsewhere. It was totally senseless.
1 1
Replying to Lloudkat • 12 days ago
Everyone shud have freedom to express their opinions . Positive or negative and not b picked on …ganged up on
I agree. I've just read some comments on a low-rated review which was extremely detailed as to why the person rated the way they did. The reviewer was attacked as a hater. Really sad.
1 0
Replying to AmelieLucan • 12 days ago
Why do you call people haters when they have a different view of this drama? For me the rating slowly went down…
"And honestly, the fact that all the upcoming episodes were already receiving 1-star ratings from the very beginning says quite a lot. How can you rate episodes that haven't even aired yet? It's hard to see how those ratings could possibly reflect people's actual viewing experience."

This is obviously true and for me this is the only type of person who can be fairly called a hater. I haven't seen more than a couple people in the comment section who seemed to be here just to drag the drama or antagonize people.

"And that's what I find unfair. A rating should reflect someone's viewing experience, not become a tool to influence how others perceive a drama."

How can you determine what a rating reflects? Ratings don't carry explanations.

"I'm not saying TLAO is flawless, nor does enjoying it mean we have to overlook its shortcomings. But I do think it deserves to be judged on its actual merits, just like any other drama, rather than dismissed on the basis of repetitive, unsubstantiated or non-constructive criticism."

I'm not really understanding what you mean by this drama being "dismissed on the basis of repetitive, unsubstantiated or non-constructive criticism?" The criticism's I've read and the criticisms I have are based on what I watched.

As to whether criticism is constructive or not, I disagree. First, how does one judge whether a criticism is constructive or not? Second, why is it the reviewer's/rater's job to provide constructive criticism? They aren't getting paid for their feedback. When I rate or comment I just say what I feel. I'm not interested in telling creators how they can improve. They need to do that work themselves.
0 4
Replying to Tricimc • 12 days ago
I dont understand it either. Besides Im reading a lot of good reviews here so I thought ratio would go up too…
I was curious to see what the numbers would show because I also am seeing a lot of good reviews, so I counted the positive reviews (I used 8+) and the negative (-8).

Total Reviews: 136
Total Positive: 82
Total Negative: 54
Good: 60%
Negative: 40%

From a total of 3,969 ratings there are 82 positive reviews, which is 2%. So the good reviews aren't really giving us an accurate assessment of how people are rating.
0 3
Replying to AmelieLucan • 12 days ago
Why do you call people haters when they have a different view of this drama? For me the rating slowly went down…
Writing or responding to a comment isn't evidence of my feelings about this drama.

I don't care whether characters were written to please me and I expect characters to have flaws. The only thing I care about is if they and the story make sense. Too often in this drama they didn't.
0 0
On The Lament of Autumn • 12 days ago
I'm not understanding why those who loved this drama are calling people haters because they think the rating is too low. Is it impossible for people to believe that their favorite drama is not universally loved?

I came to this drama full of expectation after having looked forward to it from the time I saw Cheng Lei was the ML. Republican era is one of my favorites for many reasons. I was primed to love it which I did at the beginning. But gradually I started seeing holes in the fabric of the drama.

Despite the beautiful cinematography, set design, costumes, music and most of all Cheng Lei amazing performance I couldn't ignore the story descending into a makjang of the worst sort. The FL lost all her original character and became someone almost brainless. The villains became laughable caricatures. I had to force myself to finish the final episodes. I was disappointed in the extreme. I rated it 7.5, which was generous.

Does that make me a hater? I'm not saying haters don't exist, but the rating here is pretty much in line with Douban's score of 6.7 (MDL rating is generally higher than Douban's from what I've seen). I read early on lots of comments here that deplored the ML and hated the sexual assault aspect of his character. Are those people not allowed to rate according to their opinions? One may think it's unfair to rate that way, but there isn't any universal standard for rating. People rate what they feel.

Curious what other people think.
4 29
Replying to mrschloe • 12 days ago
How the rating has not moved up an inch after the end is somewhat baffling to me!! Common guys let’s win over…
Why do you call people haters when they have a different view of this drama?

For me the rating slowly went down after a certain point in the drama as I watched and I had to force myself to finish it to the end. There was so much wrong with the story and characters being turned into caricatures. Is it impossible for those who loved the drama to understand that not everyone views it the same way as you?
0 11
Replying to NotOkay • 12 days ago
A "princess Gambit" Dej-Vu where m/f lead annoy the crap out of each other to a point where it's just…
I love the description "plot bending" because it is so accurate. Good thing you dropped when you did, because they not only bent the plot, they twisted it into a pretzel that could never be undone.
1 0
Replying to Folah • 12 days ago
comment 2: ep 31 so far and I can’t understand why the rating is low! could it be the pacing that people don’t…
I don't think it's haters at all. For me there was just too much wrong with how the story went, how it was turned into a makjang, how some of the characters became caricatures. I watched Against the Current, too, and while I did have problems with it I thought it was a much better drama overall than this one.

I came for Cheng Lei and stayed for Cheng Lei and that's not a compliment to the drama.
2 0
Replying to NBravo18 • 12 days ago
I am on Ep 18 and I keep coming back to the comments ... I feel like I am watching a completely different show…
Totally understand. I contemplated dropping it, but I wanted to know what happened so I kept going. The last episodes were a slog to get through.
1 0
Replying to Eleison • 13 days ago
From what I've gathered, it's a chinese version of a makjang with an obsessive, aggressive ML (who goes through…
Agreeing with your assessment!
1 0
OneWinterDay • 13 days ago
"Having watched the whole drama, my opinion flipped a few times as the story speed kept changing, I wonder if someone else experienced the same."

Yep, same! I vascillated so much while watching this drama. I liked it better than you (rated it 7.5), but didn't think it was nearly the masterpiece that so many reviews claimed.

I came for Cheng Lei and he didn't disappoint in his acting. Unfortunately the story, which started well, fell apart and lapsed into melodrama of the worst kind and it was a chore to finish. All the fun moments with the buddies and spark-filled encounters with Ping Jun died out and it became tragedy after tragedy after tragedy and characters so absurd they became caricatures. It's not surprising that people would quit. It was exhausting to watch.

I just finished and I'm glad to put it behind me!
2 0
Replying to AmelieLucan • 13 days ago
I think I was enjoying it at that point, too, but for me the story/characters stopped making sense and it turned…
Agree, though I had to slog my way through the last episodes.
0 0