Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 24 seconds ago
  • Location:
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: February 29, 2024
  • Awards Received: Flower Award2
Replying to Luv Peony • 18 days ago
i think cheng lei was awesome when he was the 2ML in journey to you!
I pretty much skipped to his scenes. He stole that whole show, along with his younger brother. And the scene on the horse with his side eye, love that one so much!
2 2
scenophile • 18 days ago
Very much agree with most everything you said. I haven't actually finished it (currently on ep 33), but I've read enough about how the last episodes go.

This drama is very much Republican era and I was prepared for a lot of it, though not the SA parts (even though toxic is Republican era's nickname). Thankfully Chang Xuan stopped after a few forced kisses, but in that era he'd probably have had Ping Jun killed for talking back to him and being a suspect in the assassination attempt so there's that!

I, too, was really loving the relationship between ML/FL at the beginning. She was so bold, in his face and yet still innocent and he was smacked over the head with how she didn't crumble under the weight of his status and wealth and war lordiness. But once the writers seemed to decide she was superfluous except as a tragedy magnet everything fell apart. The main villain became a caricature totally opposite from how he started out and I'm not sure why because he didn't really seem all that interested in Ping Jun as a person.

I don't know if the writing or acting of FL is more to blame, but she really didn't have a whole lot to work with the way they wrote her. One would have to be a really gifted actress to portray her character with any kind of sympathy because she never could make up her mind what she thought.

I do love a good amnesia trope, but you are so right that it's empty time as far as FL's character is concerned. And when she wakes up, though she doesn't remember her past she is still the same wishy-washy female that she was before. So frustrating.

As far as redeeming the vile BIL, this is something that happens so often in Chinese dramas and makes me crazy. When a character earns redemption I love it. When a character basically is forgiven for no apparent reason I hate it. One of my least favorite things.

As sad as it makes me I think the MDL score is really fair. I would rate it higher than you because of Cheng Lei's acting, the cinematography, side characters that I loved, Chang Xuan's character growth, music. I liked the opera singer storyline and loved how it tied into CX's brother's life and I loved when CX found out he was responsible for his brother's death. That whole arc was so well done and his acting was about the best I've seen for such a tragic scene.

I know a lot of people think it's a masterpiece, but I think that's because they want it to be. I wanted that, too, but sadly we didn't get it. Gotta enjoy what we get and be honest about the rest.
3 2
On The Lament of Autumn • 18 days ago
The one thing I'm most happy about concerning this drama is that Cheng Lei is finally getting the recognition for his acting that he has deserved for so long. From the first drama I ever saw him in (I think it was Queen of Attack) I have appreciated watching him take on a character and making him real. There are too few actors who are so good they can play any type of role and can be praised for their acting and not just their looks. (He's fine on that count, too, though!)

I loved reading comments from people who said they didn't like this drama, but Cheng Lei is a great actor! That's praise fully earned.

Well done, Léi gē! Keep up the good work and enjoy your new fans.
14 6
Replying to Kbeauty • 18 days ago
when did she actually agree to love him like he did so much awful.shit to her
"Idk if it was the actress’s bad acting or just a writing issue"

I think it was both, but mostly bad writing where Ping Jun's character is concerned. The drama focused pretty much solely on Chang Xuan's character growth and everyone else was just there to move that along.

In my opinion Cheng Lei is made for any role. I've seen most every drama he's been in and he takes on a character like nobody else. I'm happy he's finally getting the recognition he deserves.
1 0
Replying to LFox • 19 days ago
Episode 36Okay, say what you want about ChangXuan’s past actions, but this man has learned from his mistakes…
"Why do characters feel they have to threaten their own lives just to be heard?"

Because the writers only wrote Chang Xuan. They pretty much used the other characters to aid in CX's growth, only trotting them out when they needed a fresh tragedy to spur him on.

Even Jiang Xue Ting is a caricature of the consummate villain. His character arc doesn't really make much sense. He started out seeking justice and ended up living his whole life around jealously for woman that he didn't seem to really like.

Even Chang Xuan, for all his brilliance in commanding an army and seeing through the enemy's plans can't figure out the traitor in his own family and doesn't know how to put an end to XT's plans. The whole drama devolved into a giant wartime soap opera.
5 0
Replying to carleighn • 19 days ago
I honestly expected Lament of Autumn to have a sad ending. Republican era romance dramas rarely give us happy…
I feel the same. I thought I was prepared having seen tons of Replublican dramas (mostly short form), but knowing the truth was another thing entirely. And I haven't even watched the final episodes!
1 0
Replying to Tricimc • 19 days ago
My first breakfast without Changxuan… The curtains have fallen, the Emperor is gone, and I’m officially a…
My condolences. Wear your widow's weeds proudly.
5 1
Replying to justjacky • 19 days ago
Title The Lament of Autumn Spoiler
I just finished the final episodes so my thoughts are fresh here. Starting in chronological order.Rapist husband…
Thanks for replying. I hate revenge plots when they are for things that didn't even happen.
1 0
Replying to AmelieLucan • 19 days ago
Thanks. That's interesting. Considering how brutal the time period was it also makes sense that endings would…
"I think there is a general notion that if you give a sad ending, it becomes more memorable, people talk about it way more. Maybe that's why."

People are certainly talking about this ending!
1 0
Replying to Ti02 • 19 days ago
Someone in X wrote why Republican dramas tend to have sad endings, I am sharing the link here, for anyone who…
Thanks. That's interesting. Considering how brutal the time period was it also makes sense that endings would be tragic.

However that link doesn't explain why so many other Chinese non-Republican dramas have bad endings, even when everything seems to point to a happy ending. I think there must be something in the Chinese psyche that leans towards tragic rather than happy. Just my uneducated view!
0 2
Replying to moonbunni • 19 days ago
Finally done watching every crumb! And honestly, the ending isn't as bad as y'all make it out to be.These men,…
In my rational mind I think you're right, but my heart doesn't care. I want happy endings for all the characters I came to love and painful endings for the ones I came to hate.
0 0
Replying to Waig baby • 19 days ago
You people are so funny😂😂😂some of you think production teams be naming dramas for the sake of it…The…
Let people get their feelings out with rage. Aside from the ending there was a lot that the production team (actually the writers) have to atone for. They messed up Ping Jun's character a lot.

But I actually agree with most of what you said. I've watched tons of Republican dramas and I fully expected and was prepared for a bad ending though I always hold out hope for a happy one. (Can't help wanting to see my Cheng Lei, I mean Chang Xuan smiling.) And I also hope people won't down rate just because of the ending.

Chinese writers as a whole, not just in Republican dramas, seem to love bad/sad/open endings. Maybe because of Chinese history it's bred in the bone, but it's why I always want to know the ending of any drama that isn't a comedy before I start so I can decide if I want to watch it. I don't like my heart breaking!
0 0
Replying to justjacky • 19 days ago
Title The Lament of Autumn Spoiler
I just finished the final episodes so my thoughts are fresh here. Starting in chronological order.Rapist husband…
I'm on ep 32 and contemplating not finishing because my heart already hurts just knowing how it ends. Though I fully expected it (having seen my share of Republican dramas, how could I not) I still held onto a flimsy hope.

At least the evil siblings-not siblings died, but man I wanted a full and complete comeuppance for them. Did they ever reveal why they hated the Yu father/family so much?

Totally agree about Cheng Lei's acting. He is even more awesome than I already thought he was in this drama.
1 2
Replying to Fiona • 19 days ago
Title The Lament of Autumn Spoiler
As expected, the ending turned out exactly as I anticipated. Republican-era dramas tend to have endings like this.…
Same. I've watched too many myself to expect less, but I still want it!
1 1
Replying to Yulin_rain • 19 days ago
Title The Lament of Autumn Spoiler
This is a fitting ending that was true to the realities of that time. Watching this drama made me research a bit…
All that you said I agree with, except I want happy endings whether realistic or not. My heart doesn't like hurting for fictional characters as if they were real!

As far as realism goes I don't think Ping Jun would have survived her first encounter with Chang Xuan. Most warlords were brutal, (though I did read about a famous one who really tried to do good).

CX's whole demeanor and growth would be surprising, I think, considering the times and the fact that he actually stopped his sexual assault several times is likely unrealistic as well since warlords took what they wanted and citizens were terrified of them.

I was watching a youtube channel that talks about Chinese dramas and the creator (Chinese born) said there are several time periods in Chinese history you would not want to live in and the Republican era was one. What I've read about it sounds frightening. So happy your grandparents were able to get out. Do they talk about it much? It would be fascinating to listen to them talk about what their lives were like in China, but I'd understand if they just wanted to forget.
0 0
Replying to Chi gua qunzhong • 19 days ago
Title The Lament of Autumn Spoiler
dont torture yourself watching this drama, bad ending. The correct title for this drama are the torment of every…
Great new title!
0 0
Replying to Xi Qua Long • 19 days ago
Title The Lament of Autumn Spoiler
Ctrauma of the year😊
Hahahahaha!!!!!!!! Ctrauma is the best. I've got to start using it and I'll be using it a lot because I watch mostly Chinese dramas! You made my day!
0 0
Replying to moonbunni • 19 days ago
Title The Lament of Autumn Spoiler
If you prefer a more fictional type of ending, then Episode 39 is the perfect ending. But if you want an ending…
Don't blame you. I haven't even finished yet and just knowing the ending breaks my heart. Not that I didn't expect it, especially in a Republican drama. But if you like Cheng Lei I'd watch at least some of it because he looks and acts great.
1 0
Replying to mrschloe • 20 days ago
Hoping to see the rating go up and not down. Despite everything the show is a masterpiece deserving of a better…
"Please be just!"

This is all I want for every drama. All the people who put their hard work into creating it deserve to be judged fairly, not upvoted because your favorite actor is in it or downvoted because it's taking away from your favorite actor's dramas. Fairness and honesty in ratings. That's not too much to ask.
3 0