If a drama is good or bad, there are different aspects about that. There are objective criteria imo, like the…
"Every review under a 6 cannot be taken seriously because they obviously didn’t take into account the quality."
That's the thing, though. For you the quality must be taken into account. For others the quality doesn't override failings in the story, characters, etc. I think both are valid ways of arriving at a rating. We all come to a drama for different reasons and want different things from it.
"This is a ML centric drama. I wonder if people also complained so much about the lack of character growth of the FL in Legend of Zhang Hai for example."
I wish I had watched that drama just so I could see how I viewed the FL and compared my reactions. I've never really gotten this detailed about how I feel about a drama before. It's been interesting to discuss it with everyone here. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
Most people say the story went downhill because of the FL. I understand why people feel that way. Her character…
I agree with much of what you said. One of the failures of the drama, for me, is that FL's character starts strong and then almost becomes an afterthought and it's really disappointing. I think they missed out on making a really great drama by not letting Ping Jun grow as much as Chang Xuan.
Still working my way through the final episodes (currently watching 34). I've had issues with FL but have given…
That was cruel to ask Gu Rui Tong to lie for you. This really turns my stomach. Tell CX you don't want to be with him, make him understand (you know you can do it), but coming between him and Rui Tong is just wrong on so many levels. You've now made RT carry a burden that he should never have to. He told you he couldn't lie to CX, but you pressured him anyway (did you forget how you felt being pressured?) You didn't care how it might impact his relationship with CX or how CX would feel when he finds out. I'm so mad I can't hold it in.
Still working my way through the final episodes (currently watching 34). I've had issues with FL but have given her a lot of leeway because she's been forced, pushed around, lied to, etc. This is the first time I think I've really been full-on angry with her.
Thank you for this review. I just started watching without knowing that end game was a 17 year old to her 27. I searched for some reviews because I thought surely he's not the one she ends up with, but alas. And so many reviews liked this drama.
I'm sorry you spent ten hours watching, but I'm glad you made the effort to write your thoughts. You helped me quit after 25 minutes.
I have to respectfully disagree here. IMO, the reviews giving this drama less than 5 stars come across as more…
OK, no more 🚍 I'll probably have dreams about them in my food!
"But some of the things you're calling bugs are also matters of interpretation and personal expectations. For example, a character making decisions we don't agree with doesn't necessarily mean the writing is bad. We can question those decisions without automatically treating them as failures of the story."
Absolutely true. And that's what made the discussions about this drama so enjoyable. Some comments gave a point of view I hadn't even considered and that made it much more interesting.
I'm really glad to have met everyone in the discussions of this drama. As I said to MiMo I hope we might be able to gather again for Cheng Lei's upcoming drama. It would be fun to discuss it. We'd have to come up with a new commenter group name for The Leading Stars. :)
I have to respectfully disagree here. IMO, the reviews giving this drama less than 5 stars come across as more…
"For example, even if someone wasn't happy with the writing or the way a particular character was developed, does that take away from the acting, cinematography, OST, costume design, directing or all those little details that made this drama stand out? I don't think so. These elements can still be excellent, even when some writing choices fall short."
I think this is where different people are going to answer differently. For some the writing is paramount. If it's bad the drama is bad no matter how good the other aspects are. Same with a particular character, though for me it would depend upon how prominent the character was. If it's a main character then yes, that might override the whole story.
"We all have our preferences, of course, but one character or storyline shouldn't necessarily determine how we judge the entire production."
But that's the thing. There is no right or wrong way to judge a drama (assuming people are honestly rating the drama and not hate/praise rating for their favorite actors). Some people might give equal weight to every aspect of a production and some people will consider a failure of one character enough to ruin the entire drama. Neither is right or wrong. We all start watching a drama from different perspectives and want different things from it.
I wish so much that this drama had continued the way it started. I was looking forward to the relationship developing between ML/FL because it was fun to watch him be so befuddled by her and see the powerful man get taken down by a powerless innocent. Alas not the first time a drama hasn't gone the way I'd hoped. Not to say I didn't love lots about this drama, but that just made it all the more disappointing in the way the story proceeded.
Good news is Cheng Lei has another drama coming out in the not too distant (I hope) future. Maybe we'll gather here for that one, too. That would be fun.
I have to respectfully disagree here. IMO, the reviews giving this drama less than 5 stars come across as more…
Hahaha!!!!! A bug in my food is not a small flaw. I'd be out of there so fast and never return and they'd be lucky to get 1*.
I think the show has more than a few bugs. The writing, FL, ML's obsession with FL, ML's brilliance in every area except containing the major villain and discovering the other major villain hiding under his nose. ML forgiving his father for his attempts to harm FL and not taking her away. Lots of bugs!
I looked forward to this drama so much. I love the Republican era, love Cheng Lei's work, the story started off so good, the visuals/music were great and some of the characters became favorites. ML's character growth was so well acted.
But gradually the story tripped on itself and I can't ignore that because so much else was good. A drama stands or falls on its story and this one fell hard.
I have to respectfully disagree here. IMO, the reviews giving this drama less than 5 stars come across as more…
"but I wish ppl would also take a step back and look at the bigger picture instead of focusing on just one character or the ending"
For me it's not just one character or the ending, but when the one character is the FL that's not "just" one character. That's a major portion of what the whole drama rests on. And if one character stops making sense that can pretty much ruin the drama for me.
I have to respectfully disagree here. IMO, the reviews giving this drama less than 5 stars come across as more…
"but it's a shame when one aspect overshadows everything else the drama got right."
But that's the thing. One aspect can overshadow everything else the drama got right. If one character spoils the drama, then all those other aspects aren't going to be good enough. I often love costumes in dramas, especially Republican era. Qipaos are my favorite. But the most beautiful clothes and fantastic cinematography or music are going to keep me watching if the storyline falls apart or characters stop making sense.
I looked forward to this drama for a long time and I was prepped to love it. There are many things I still love about it, but the storyline/characters let me down and I can't give the drama an A for effort. My rating isn't going to be as low as the review I mentioned, but it's about where the drama stands now on MDL.
I have to respectfully disagree here. IMO, the reviews giving this drama less than 5 stars come across as more…
"They enjoyed it at some point but rating it 4.5 means they haven't enjoyed it."
I've enjoyed dramas at the beginning and would have rated them very highly. Then everything falls apart and I either drop the drama or rate it low.
If you're eating a good meal and suddenly find a dead bug in it, do you give a good rating to the restaurant because you liked the meal before you found the bug?
I have to respectfully disagree here. IMO, the reviews giving this drama less than 5 stars come across as more…
I haven't read the low-rated reviews you have so I can't speak to them. I'm sure there are ones that deserve the term hateful. After all we know there were people who down rated episodes before they were even out. It's just too easy to call anyone who doesn't give a drama the highest praise a hater.
I disagree with this, though:
"We don't have to love every aspect of a drama or every character to recognize the effort, talent and dedication behind it."
If I buy a car and it breaks down I'm going to say that the car is not a good car. All the hard work that went into the car doesn't matter because the end product wasn't good.
While I can appreciate the effort that went into making a drama I don't take it into consideration when I give my views on a drama. I assume a production team is putting forth effort in making the drama else why are they there? I also assume that actors are putting forth effort, but effort alone doesn't make a good actor.
"We don't have to love every aspect of a drama or every character to recognize the effort, talent and dedication behind it."
Here I only agree with one aspect: talent. I don't really care how much effort or dedication the actors/team put into a drama. They can be the laziest people on the planet as far as I'm concerned if the end result is brilliant.
"I won't go into a lengthy debate about this"
Please do, if you want to. I've enjoyed discussing this drama with you. It's fun to trade ideas and see how we view things, especially if we disagree! :)
What the heck is controversial about a Pacemaker? Is it that the person pushed him at some point? Still doesn’t…
It's against the rules for someone to be pushed. So yeah, if that's the case he did cheat. Does the fact that he ran a marathong cancel breaking the rules?
I've loved reading/writing comments about this drama. I think Cheng Lei did an awesome job portraying Yu Chang Xuan. I loved many of the side characters and some of the side stories. The cinematography was off the charts and the songs/bgm were perfect.
That said, I'm not going to complain about the rating. I know a lot of people think the low-rated reviews are haters. I can't speak to that because I've only read one. It's currently the most helpful review (scenophile: 4.5 stars). I agree with the majority of what that reviewer said.
No matter how good I think many aspects of the drama were I can't ignore its glaring failures. The FL started as a strong, willful, innocent young woman and devolved into a pathetic, wishy-washy, brainless dish rag. That alone destroyed much of the drama. Then we have a caricature of a villain who also takes a steep dive from his original motive of fighting for justice. The faces he makes alone were so Snidely Whiplash that I had to laugh. Probably not the reaction the drama was going for. These are just two examples among many.
There were impressive highlights (when Chang Xuan finds out he was basically responsible for his brother's death. Outstanding acting from an actor whose acting was impressive throughout) followed by unbelievable lowlights (who runs away from home without a coat, luggage or plans for transportation when she's just found out she was pregnant? Is she 20 or 2?)
I wanted this to be a 10, believe me. (Bias alert: I want all of Cheng Lei's dramas to be a 10.) But honesty compels me more. A good drama can have bad aspects; a bad drama can have good aspects. Not even sure where to place this one.
When I researched I found that there was video that appeared to confirm that a person was running behind him and pushed him (once, more than once?) to keep him on course and boost his pace (not a runner so research this yourself for accurate information).
This is apparently against the rules (makes sense) thus the apology.
That's the thing, though. For you the quality must be taken into account. For others the quality doesn't override failings in the story, characters, etc. I think both are valid ways of arriving at a rating. We all come to a drama for different reasons and want different things from it.
"This is a ML centric drama. I wonder if people also complained so much about the lack of character growth of the FL in Legend of Zhang Hai for example."
I wish I had watched that drama just so I could see how I viewed the FL and compared my reactions. I've never really gotten this detailed about how I feel about a drama before. It's been interesting to discuss it with everyone here. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
I'm sorry you spent ten hours watching, but I'm glad you made the effort to write your thoughts. You helped me quit after 25 minutes.
"But some of the things you're calling bugs are also matters of interpretation and personal expectations. For example, a character making decisions we don't agree with doesn't necessarily mean the writing is bad. We can question those decisions without automatically treating them as failures of the story."
Absolutely true. And that's what made the discussions about this drama so enjoyable. Some comments gave a point of view I hadn't even considered and that made it much more interesting.
I'm really glad to have met everyone in the discussions of this drama. As I said to MiMo I hope we might be able to gather again for Cheng Lei's upcoming drama. It would be fun to discuss it. We'd have to come up with a new commenter group name for The Leading Stars. :)
I think this is where different people are going to answer differently. For some the writing is paramount. If it's bad the drama is bad no matter how good the other aspects are. Same with a particular character, though for me it would depend upon how prominent the character was. If it's a main character then yes, that might override the whole story.
"We all have our preferences, of course, but one character or storyline shouldn't necessarily determine how we judge the entire production."
But that's the thing. There is no right or wrong way to judge a drama (assuming people are honestly rating the drama and not hate/praise rating for their favorite actors). Some people might give equal weight to every aspect of a production and some people will consider a failure of one character enough to ruin the entire drama. Neither is right or wrong. We all start watching a drama from different perspectives and want different things from it.
I wish so much that this drama had continued the way it started. I was looking forward to the relationship developing between ML/FL because it was fun to watch him be so befuddled by her and see the powerful man get taken down by a powerless innocent. Alas not the first time a drama hasn't gone the way I'd hoped. Not to say I didn't love lots about this drama, but that just made it all the more disappointing in the way the story proceeded.
Good news is Cheng Lei has another drama coming out in the not too distant (I hope) future. Maybe we'll gather here for that one, too. That would be fun.
I think the show has more than a few bugs. The writing, FL, ML's obsession with FL, ML's brilliance in every area except containing the major villain and discovering the other major villain hiding under his nose. ML forgiving his father for his attempts to harm FL and not taking her away. Lots of bugs!
I looked forward to this drama so much. I love the Republican era, love Cheng Lei's work, the story started off so good, the visuals/music were great and some of the characters became favorites. ML's character growth was so well acted.
But gradually the story tripped on itself and I can't ignore that because so much else was good. A drama stands or falls on its story and this one fell hard.
For me it's not just one character or the ending, but when the one character is the FL that's not "just" one character. That's a major portion of what the whole drama rests on. And if one character stops making sense that can pretty much ruin the drama for me.
But that's the thing. One aspect can overshadow everything else the drama got right. If one character spoils the drama, then all those other aspects aren't going to be good enough. I often love costumes in dramas, especially Republican era. Qipaos are my favorite. But the most beautiful clothes and fantastic cinematography or music are going to keep me watching if the storyline falls apart or characters stop making sense.
I looked forward to this drama for a long time and I was prepped to love it. There are many things I still love about it, but the storyline/characters let me down and I can't give the drama an A for effort. My rating isn't going to be as low as the review I mentioned, but it's about where the drama stands now on MDL.
I've enjoyed dramas at the beginning and would have rated them very highly. Then everything falls apart and I either drop the drama or rate it low.
If you're eating a good meal and suddenly find a dead bug in it, do you give a good rating to the restaurant because you liked the meal before you found the bug?
I disagree with this, though:
"We don't have to love every aspect of a drama or every character to recognize the effort, talent and dedication behind it."
If I buy a car and it breaks down I'm going to say that the car is not a good car. All the hard work that went into the car doesn't matter because the end product wasn't good.
While I can appreciate the effort that went into making a drama I don't take it into consideration when I give my views on a drama. I assume a production team is putting forth effort in making the drama else why are they there? I also assume that actors are putting forth effort, but effort alone doesn't make a good actor.
"We don't have to love every aspect of a drama or every character to recognize the effort, talent and dedication behind it."
Here I only agree with one aspect: talent. I don't really care how much effort or dedication the actors/team put into a drama. They can be the laziest people on the planet as far as I'm concerned if the end result is brilliant.
"I won't go into a lengthy debate about this"
Please do, if you want to. I've enjoyed discussing this drama with you. It's fun to trade ideas and see how we view things, especially if we disagree! :)
That said, I'm not going to complain about the rating. I know a lot of people think the low-rated reviews are haters. I can't speak to that because I've only read one. It's currently the most helpful review (scenophile: 4.5 stars). I agree with the majority of what that reviewer said.
No matter how good I think many aspects of the drama were I can't ignore its glaring failures. The FL started as a strong, willful, innocent young woman and devolved into a pathetic, wishy-washy, brainless dish rag. That alone destroyed much of the drama. Then we have a caricature of a villain who also takes a steep dive from his original motive of fighting for justice. The faces he makes alone were so Snidely Whiplash that I had to laugh. Probably not the reaction the drama was going for. These are just two examples among many.
There were impressive highlights (when Chang Xuan finds out he was basically responsible for his brother's death. Outstanding acting from an actor whose acting was impressive throughout) followed by unbelievable lowlights (who runs away from home without a coat, luggage or plans for transportation when she's just found out she was pregnant? Is she 20 or 2?)
I wanted this to be a 10, believe me. (Bias alert: I want all of Cheng Lei's dramas to be a 10.) But honesty compels me more. A good drama can have bad aspects; a bad drama can have good aspects. Not even sure where to place this one.
This is apparently against the rules (makes sense) thus the apology.
Also interesting discussion pro/con: https://www.reddit.com/r/kpop/comments/1xmlyim/shinee_minho_apologizes_following_controversy/#:~:text=SHINee%20MINHO%20apologizes%20following%20controversy,during%20the%202026%20Seoul%20Marathon