why is the rating low🥹🥹? I am on ep 12 and still enjoying it.
I think I was enjoying it at that point, too, but for me the story/characters stopped making sense and it turned into a full-blown majang (melodrama). The MDL rating seems more than fair now that I'm one episode away from being done.
If any other actor played ChangXuan, it would have been cringe. So excited for ChengLei's new shows. The thing…
There was one particular scene that highlights the vast gap between Cheng Lei as an actor and pretty much any other actor: The scene where Chang Xuan finds out he was responsible for his brother's death. The mental torture he had to portray, the crying, the grief, the disbelief: In the hands of a less experienced actor it would have been so cringe and embarrassing. Crying is always a risky gamble and very few can pull it off without looking like they're trying to convey the emotions but it just isn't working. Cheng Lei aced that scene so hard I could feel every ounce of his tortured thoughts.
Like any good story, "The Lament of Autumn" divides opinion, provokes, traumatizes, enchants, makes you…
I've always thought Cheng Lei is one of, if not the best, actor today and what impressed me most is that even people who hated this drama and thought it was trash spoke about what an impressive actor he is. That's something I don't think I've ever seen happen before.
So happy that ChengLei is finally getting all the love he deserves. Cnetz have been unearthing old photos, clips…
You and me both. I've wondered since I first saw him in his short dramas why he wasn't recognized by more people. He's far and away at the top of the acting pool so it just mystified me for a long time. Now, finally, he's getting that recognition and I'm happy for him, but also a little sad that he no longer makes those short dramas.
He's always seemed like such a decent humble, quiet kind of person that I'm almost a little afraid of his newfound fame. I hope he doesn't experience any adverse effects from it and can still do all the things he loves (such a talented person!). Always looking forward to his next drama.
It’s been a year that China has a regulation about AI it should be encoded + mentioned on all content created…
Thank you for that information. Interesting that they failed to mention it. People still underestimate the public's ability to sus things out! Much better to come clean about things upfront rather than risk destroying your credibility.
Are all scenes that use AI clearly labeled so viewers know that? I'm fine if that's the case since I can decide not to watch a drama that used AI if I want or I can decide I don't mind.
Does the AI interfere with immersion in the drama? If I'm going to suddenly start laughing at how ridiculous a scene looks because of AI or how messed up a character's face looks or how distractingly perfect it looks then I'm going to seriously question whether I want to watch said drama.
I haven't seen this drama yet, but any drama that uses AI already has a mark against it in my desire to watch it. AI may be here to stay, but that doesn't mean I have to willingly accept it.
Btw, I suddenly thought of how long PingJun took to get back to Nanhuai. Yu'er is probably around 15 month old…
I just watched this part and I was wondering why she didn't have any money to hire a faster, more comfortable way to go since Xie Ting was apparently quite wealthy. Surely there was money somewhere in that house.
can someone recommend me republican era romance that doesn't get so realism / war heavy or where that's not the…
I just finished rewatching a drama that might fit what you're looking for. The very beginning scenes are a bit rough, but if you stick with it I think you'll like it. And it's humorous which I always love in a drama. https://kisskh.at/766639-grab-your-love
From the list one commenter linked I can give you my views on a few I watched:
I think it's a pretty fair rating. The whole drama starting falling apart well before the end and getting through…
I've thought about that, too. There is one drama in particular that I thought about while seeing the rating on this one. I skim-watched it up to ep 24 and don't think it deserves the rating it has. I think that one was artificially inflated because of the ML's huge fan base, not because of his acting. But we're never going to get fairness in reviews and I'm only rating this one based on what I think of it, not in how it compares to any other drama. I wish I could rate it higher.
I think it's a pretty fair rating. The whole drama starting falling apart well before the end and getting through…
I agree that there are a lot of dramas that I feel are rated unfairly and I know there are people who don't watch much of a drama before rating, but I don't agree that every drama rated under 8 is quite bad. I've watched many dramas rated under 8 that I thought were great.
For all the high quality of the drama and good acting by most of the cast (unfortunately not the FL) none of those are enough for me to ignore how the story descended into a ridiculous mess. Story is paramount to me. I'll rate a low-budget drama with few of the perks you mentioned higher than this drama if the story is great and presented well.
I loved some of the side stories, too and I thought Lan Qing's story was really good and important to ML's understanding of his brother. Other people hated it.
The story stopped making sense for me around the time the man Chang Xuan had humiliated and had beaten so badly that he lost a kidney reappeared. For all the lauding of CX's character growth he somehow managed to miss that this incident was his fault and he never took any responsibility for his cruelty toward that man. I was in shock when the incident happened in the beginning of the drama and I almost dropped it then. It was only because of Cheng Lei that I stuck with it. But I was bitterly disappointed in how the story let him slide with that incident and it just kept going.
I watched ep 38 last night and the idea that Tao Zi Yi would suddenly have some kind of awakening when her father died and she writes in her letter to Li Bo Ren that she wanted to get back to the good person she was made my brain hurt. She was never a good person and this sudden awakening didn't translate into helping Ping Jun get away. Also the fact that she thought saying a pathetic "I'm sorry" after all the things she'd done to Ping Jun was so absurd it made me cringe. She didn't even bow, the very least she could have done if she was sincere. And how they had her walk off in a beautiful, haunting scene made me angry. There was nothing beautiful about her at all.
So I actually think the rating here is not only more than fair, it's probably much higher than it should be because people want it to be. I wanted this drama to be a ten. I looked forward to it from the moment I saw that Cheng Lei was in it and he pretty much held the drama on his shoulders. I love the Republican era. I love the costumes (qipao are my favorite). The sets, cinematography were excellent. The music was so good. I loved the beginning. I loved Chang Xuan's character growth until I realized that he really hadn't grown all that much considering he kept pressuring PJ after saying he'd set her free.
If the drama had continued in the way it started I would have given it a ten, too. But much to my chagrin, it didn't. It stopped making sense, it turned into a makjang and not even a well done one. All its fine points can't overcome a shoddy story and characters so over the top that they turned into caricatures.
I think it's a pretty fair rating. The whole drama starting falling apart well before the end and getting through the last few episodes has me gritting my teeth for how inane it is. I wanted this drama to be a 10 because Cheng Lei is amazing in it, but I can't rate it high just because he's a fine actor.
"CX has like 31 flavors and 500 sub levels of angst"
I couldn't love this wording more! It's so perfectly captures his character and Cheng Lei plays it so well.
"The plot is determined to make her into an idiot with a big mouth and a unique ability to need help every five minutes."
So funny, because so accurate. This frustrated me more than anything else in a drama which didn't lack for frustration. PJ started out so well, bold yet innocent, willing to confront CX without thought for the consequences. I thought she was going to be a strong woman. Turns out the writers somehow forgot that she was an actual character in their zeal to show CX's character growth. Such a disappointment.
I read about the Republican era, too. Someone on a YouTube channel said there are certain eras in Chinese history that were so awful you would never want to live in them. Republican era was one of them. Just brutal.
"Reading some of the comments and reviews about The Lament of Autumn, I can't help but notice what appears to be a generational difference in how we interpret historical dramas."
I would agree if I knew the generation of each person rating/reviewing. I have made assumptions about ages/gender, but unless someone specifically identifies those in their reviews/comments I have no way of knowing whether I'm correct or not.
How are you determining the generations of reviewers? Are you making assumptions based on something in the review? Are the reviewers identifying their generation? As for ratings, aren't those anonymous?
He's always seemed like such a decent humble, quiet kind of person that I'm almost a little afraid of his newfound fame. I hope he doesn't experience any adverse effects from it and can still do all the things he loves (such a talented person!). Always looking forward to his next drama.
Does the AI interfere with immersion in the drama? If I'm going to suddenly start laughing at how ridiculous a scene looks because of AI or how messed up a character's face looks or how distractingly perfect it looks then I'm going to seriously question whether I want to watch said drama.
I haven't seen this drama yet, but any drama that uses AI already has a mark against it in my desire to watch it. AI may be here to stay, but that doesn't mean I have to willingly accept it.
From the list one commenter linked I can give you my views on a few I watched:
https://kisskh.at/760977-the-revenge-of-begonia I watched this for Yan Zi Xian. Angst filled. Lots of really cruel, bad people! Some cute moments.
https://kisskh.at/753247-chun-ri-nong-qing Pretty good for Republican era. Dai Gao Zheng not sadistic (sometimes he is in dramas so I was happy he wasn't here).
https://kisskh.at/51213-the-sweet-girl Really cute.
https://kisskh.at/728891-twins-detective Transmigration into Rep-Era game. Good mystery.
https://kisskh.at/738815-wen-xiang-tan-an-lu Ends with hints of a S2, but there isn't.
Heads up on this one: https://kisskh.at/764135-palms-on-love It was too brutal and I dropped it quickly.
For all the high quality of the drama and good acting by most of the cast (unfortunately not the FL) none of those are enough for me to ignore how the story descended into a ridiculous mess. Story is paramount to me. I'll rate a low-budget drama with few of the perks you mentioned higher than this drama if the story is great and presented well.
I loved some of the side stories, too and I thought Lan Qing's story was really good and important to ML's understanding of his brother. Other people hated it.
The story stopped making sense for me around the time the man Chang Xuan had humiliated and had beaten so badly that he lost a kidney reappeared. For all the lauding of CX's character growth he somehow managed to miss that this incident was his fault and he never took any responsibility for his cruelty toward that man. I was in shock when the incident happened in the beginning of the drama and I almost dropped it then. It was only because of Cheng Lei that I stuck with it. But I was bitterly disappointed in how the story let him slide with that incident and it just kept going.
I watched ep 38 last night and the idea that Tao Zi Yi would suddenly have some kind of awakening when her father died and she writes in her letter to Li Bo Ren that she wanted to get back to the good person she was made my brain hurt. She was never a good person and this sudden awakening didn't translate into helping Ping Jun get away. Also the fact that she thought saying a pathetic "I'm sorry" after all the things she'd done to Ping Jun was so absurd it made me cringe. She didn't even bow, the very least she could have done if she was sincere. And how they had her walk off in a beautiful, haunting scene made me angry. There was nothing beautiful about her at all.
So I actually think the rating here is not only more than fair, it's probably much higher than it should be because people want it to be. I wanted this drama to be a ten. I looked forward to it from the moment I saw that Cheng Lei was in it and he pretty much held the drama on his shoulders. I love the Republican era. I love the costumes (qipao are my favorite). The sets, cinematography were excellent. The music was so good. I loved the beginning. I loved Chang Xuan's character growth until I realized that he really hadn't grown all that much considering he kept pressuring PJ after saying he'd set her free.
If the drama had continued in the way it started I would have given it a ten, too. But much to my chagrin, it didn't. It stopped making sense, it turned into a makjang and not even a well done one. All its fine points can't overcome a shoddy story and characters so over the top that they turned into caricatures.
I couldn't love this wording more! It's so perfectly captures his character and Cheng Lei plays it so well.
"The plot is determined to make her into an idiot with a big mouth and a unique ability to need help every five minutes."
So funny, because so accurate. This frustrated me more than anything else in a drama which didn't lack for frustration. PJ started out so well, bold yet innocent, willing to confront CX without thought for the consequences. I thought she was going to be a strong woman. Turns out the writers somehow forgot that she was an actual character in their zeal to show CX's character growth. Such a disappointment.
I read about the Republican era, too. Someone on a YouTube channel said there are certain eras in Chinese history that were so awful you would never want to live in them. Republican era was one of them. Just brutal.
I would agree if I knew the generation of each person rating/reviewing. I have made assumptions about ages/gender, but unless someone specifically identifies those in their reviews/comments I have no way of knowing whether I'm correct or not.
How are you determining the generations of reviewers? Are you making assumptions based on something in the review? Are the reviewers identifying their generation? As for ratings, aren't those anonymous?