Deirdre19

Someone already explained this further down... I think it was from before the drama started airing and people kept asking how this was related to Song of the Moon.

That's true. There are tons of dramas with equally bad writing/editing that still managed to get an 8+ rating, but I guess they had a small army of fan-girls that go for anything sparkling with a romantic idol-boy in it.

There isn't really a love triangle, but lots of annoying people, paired with bad writing and choppy editing.

Yes, he was the only reason I managed to finish it! The plot holes were just massive! I've seem quite a few dramas recently (Unchained Love, Song of the Moon, The Journey of Chong Zi...) where the bad writing is ruining everyone else's efforts. It seems to become a pattern to then just blame the sloppy writing/editing on "all the cut scenes".
I've never seen Song Yi in anything, so I have not opinion on her.

Let's hope it will be better than the last one with iQIVYI (And the Winner is Love). That one was an insult to the viewers' intelligence!

Yes, CZ character in the first arc is definitely childish (and not much better in the 2nd...), but the visuals of TJOCZ aren't all pink and sparkly like a Disney production aimed at children.

Try watching Warm on a Cold Night. It's a lot more fun!! The ML is also a bit gruff and cold in the beginning but at least he isn't boring and overall the drama feels a lot less childish than TSL.

Describing the ML as a werewolf is not quite correct. In werewolves the transformation is usually triggered involuntary (either by the full moon and/or strong emotions) and often means a loss of control over their actions, whereas this Qi race is able to control their transformation at will. In the drama they are described as shapeshifters, which seems more accurate to me and also avoids any association with the werewolf-genre as depicted in some Western dramas.

Despite the genre the way people (especially group dynamics) are shown is quite realistic. They managed to avoid a lot of the usual clichés both regarding the tsundere ML and the prejudice that people have towards anyone not like them.
I think this is part of what makes this drama so refreshingly different.

I don't like the CGI in TSL at all. The quality may be better but the colour palette and all that sparkle just scream "I'm a 15-year-old-who-still-plays-with-dolls".

This is due to the way the screen-writers have changed the source material. These guys seem to think because it's Xianxia no logic is required.

I didn't say that the CGI is bad, but that it is kitsch. The colours (mainly pink and turquoise) and the sparkles make it look like the decoration on a 15-year-old's fantasy poney. Maybe that was the target audience?
I get it that there is supposed some development to his character, but just looking at that boring face of his gives me the urge to fast-forward all his scenes.

Started watching this because everyone seems to be raving about this drama...
Well, after 4 episodes I can say that it is rather silly for a xianxia, not really funny enough for a comedy and the CGI is looking at kitsch in the rearview mirror. The story is quite interesting, but the ML must be one of the most boring ones I've seen in recent years, just looking at him makes me sleepy.

Not only that, it also has the better ML... he may be a bit stony-faced in the early episodes, but at least he is interesting! I had a look at The Starry Love because everyone keeps raving about it and OMG that ML is so BORING!

The rating on MDL isn't very reliable... plus how much you like something also depends on personal taste.
I have really enjoyed quite a few dramas with a rating below 8 and there is a good number of dramas with a rating of 8+ that I've dropped because either the acting or the writing was so bad that I couldn't finish them.

Sadly, not enough pretty-boy fan-girls around who vote up any ol' sh*t no matter how bad it is.
Just compare this to (for example) Legend of Yun Xi, which had equally bad writing, massive plot-holes, an annoying, obsessive SFL and a card-board-like ML yet still managed to score a rating of 8.1. or the equally overrated Blooms at Ruyi Pavillion where the whole story relied on the idiotic premise that nobody could recognise the SML when he was wearing a half-mask (without changing his hair, clothing or voice)!

Also, I presume, the people who actually stick with this drama will only give their rating once they finished all the episodes, so the score may go up a bit again (I hope!).

Haha, it finally gives JT a chance to show us some acting!

She annoyed the hell out of me in WoH!! I understand that this is the way the character (playful and immature) was supposed to be in WoH. Based on the novel the FL in BFTB is very different, she is headstrong and wilful but she isn't stupid or immature.
I hope that for once the script writers were able to resist the urge to turn every FL into a moronic dumbwit who keeps falling over her own feet.

There is romance, but it is in between the lines. It doesn't use the usual tropes of lingering glances or FL tripping over her own feet to be caught by ML.

Overall the writers have been very creative in this drama. They managedto avoid many of the usual tropes and instead came up with lots of cute ideas to show us the romantic connection of the couple.