Diana96

maybe from the restaurant where she met hye ran after hye ran's meeting with kevin. it could have fallen somewhere there. i think hye ran would have noticed if kevin took off her brooch and again he had no need for it as he took the blackbox memory card wich is far more incriminating. you can see them kiss in the video and hear their conversation as opposed to the brooch that proves nothing.
there are only two possibilities regarding the brooch, one is that it fell in hye ran's car wich was sent to the car shop and someone took it. or two if eun joo picked it up.

this is my final conclution and i agree with what you said:
1. i think hye ran met with kevin lee after he left ji won and while they met two things were happening simultaningly.
2. first kang tae wook was watching them from a distance.
3. second, seo eun joo was meating with ha ji won who told her of the relationship between her husband and hye ran.
4. after kevin lee and go hye ran went their seprate ways kang tae wook followed kevin and met with him(although i'm still not sure exactly when they met during the chain of events, so this one is also mentioned later and i like the other one better).
5.if the meating with tae wook ocured or not, kevin came home to an angry wife. after arguing with her about having a baby and focusing on golf, he recieved a phone call from the news room and left (this one is still intriguineg).
6. eoun joo then found the memory card that fell from kevin's pocket and watched it. that led to her calling hye ran to figure thing out while also witnessing her being in an accsident on the phone.
7. while eun joo and go hye ran were meating, kang tae wook met with kevin lee who intended to show him the black box video only to discover he dosen't have it. (also not 100% positive about this one but highly likely). they couldn't have gotten in a fist fight because then there would be phisical evidence of that on the both of them.
8. while those two meatings ocured, eun joo picked up the brouch.
9. back to kevin and tae wook, i think he could have been the one to hit him with a pole but not causing his death. i hardly think he is the murderer for the sole reason he would have never framed his wife. he wouldn't have been the one to put the brouch in kevins car. he is smart enough to be able to stage it as an accsident without it leadind to a murder suspition which is too risky.
10. to sum things up, i think kevin might have been injured and found a way to contact his wife. she who had discovered the facts of his affair with her freind, had found a way to get her revenge on him, pin it on hye ran and sttay in posetion of his wealth to rase their child.

ha myung was in prison, he only got out after the news of gu hye ran being a suspect in a murder investigation broke out (well she was a suspect descised as a witness).
--i'd really hate to see kang tae wook becoming kevin lee's murderer although i have to admit that plot wise it will be a smart move. the feeling i got from ep 13 is that he might have killed him because of jealousy, and made his wife a suspect so he could eigher get her exonerated of all charges or stay with her if she got convicted. eigher way he wuold be free of charge and still get the girl (but thats not what i personaly belive had happened). only two things bother me here, the first one being go hye ran's black box chip. it was clearly enough to prove her inoccent yet her husband deleted it, so this goes for his case as a murderer. the second thing (well its a number of things together) is the brouch. there is absolutly no way kevin lee took it. he did take the black box memory card so i think he intended to use it as an extortion method to harm go hye ran or to show her husband, seeing as she told him clearly she didn't love her husban and just needed him. so i think it was supposed to be used as a tool to seperate the two. in that case he would have no need with the brouch, so he wouldn't have taken it. also go hye ran would have felt him taking it off of her or if it fell it would have than remained in her car as they met in her vieacle and not in his. the only logical explenation here would be that the wife took it (seo eun joo). this combination of facts sugests there was no one better for the murder of kevin lee than his wife. she also had the bigest motive for it which everyone seam to ignore but han ji won. the wife also went to great lengths to insure the case against hye ran continues.

why do lee seung gi's drama girlfriends die in the majority of the dramas? is it a thing for him? he always ends up alone waiting for a reincarnation. whats poor thing :(

the ending was so disappointing, kind of ruind the hole thing :(

i don't think so. she said she only did what she was told to do and followed noh myung hee. because the bridge where eun seok was ultimately left on was later flooded by the rain if the seo family hadn't took her she would have died. meanwhile secretary min would have been busy after noh myung hee's accident and wouldn't have tried to find the child. i think the sane thing to do was to follow the car that took eun seok but the noh family had no one to blame but themselfs for that incident. also she kept only the note with the car licence plate so i don't think she followed up on finding the girl otherwise she would have told me yung hee that she had known where eun seok was all along.

oh please can someone stop the excess drama here, it's too much. how many times can we watch do kyung and ji ahn take baby steps towards a relationship only to make them go on separate ways again? there were some major plot twists that i loved in the last episodes but then why do we have the main couple problems be in the way of their happiness way to the last two episodes of the show. sadly i doubt they will even resolve them until half way through the last one.

i've got to say i'm proud of secretary min for resigning and giving such a wakeup call to noh myung hee, even though her past extions could of resoulted in ji soo's/ eun seok's death.

chicago typewriter was in my opinion a better and more original than SWDBS or Weightlifting Fairy. also yoo ah in did a fantastic job there as always. for the best script or best korean screenwriter chicago should have won. although both goblin and chicago' had a very unique script but personally chicago outshone goblin script wise. i don't get how SWDBS won 3 categories. sure i loved it while watching it and it was very romantic but it had many plot holes and a bomb that turned into fireworks.... wouldn't say it is the most believable one even considering the small supernatural element here.

this drama deserves some serious awards, numerous ones. it certainly became my number one favourite drama ever. jun ho and won jin ha deserve a daesung for a marvelous job here. seriously the hole drama was superb and the ending, it is so rare for korean dramas to have even slightly descent endings (they always find some way or another to lessen what could have been a perfect drama). i was so nervous in the final two episodes and prayed so much for gang do, glad to sea it all raped up as no short of a masterpiece (well at least for me) <3

Still, a lack of explanation for this is a plot hole. Viewers shouldn't geuss why things are the way things are. It should all be directly understood from the plot. Also i hardly think the disapearance of her ability is the only questianable aspect of this drama. Personaly im quite disappointed in the hong sisters here.

has anyone noticed the major plot hole in the episodes this week? jin sun mi could see ghosts even before becoming sam jang after releasing son oh gong from that mountain prison of his, so how come she blames him for ruining her childhood? i mean beside the fact her blood became tasty wich i sea how it can complicate things, not much had changed, but nether less she saw those ghosts anyhow. also exactly how do her abilities disappear if the book owner takes the sad child in sun mi? i figured it will make her forget her unhappy childhood but instead it took away her special powers, i can't seam to find a link between her memories as a child and those powers? still it's nice to see lee seung gi and cha seung won in a drama together again :)

i really hope it wasn't him dying they showed in the preview. you don't usually give such spoilers in priviews or so i hope

I'm not watching it on viki. I know how the subbing process works on viki, but many dramas there require a viki pass or have to many comertials so i usualy don't go there for dramas. I was talking about regular sites that upload the ep' either raw or subed, and suddenly this week there were episodes with 70/80 % sun only, so it was kindly of strange for me as they didn't reuploud them later full subed and i had to do a little searching on the Internet....

well mow the episode is out with subs but just the 70 %. i can't figure out a reason as to why they would upload the ep' not completely subbed other than to torcher viewers :(

honestly i don't get why koreans have to make an ilness something so outrageous. why is it worth geting fired for or being published about on the news? seriously in what world do you get punished for bring sick. this logic is lost on me.

JTBC - the network, is also not that popular. i think it is partly to blame too/

never seen so much love for a drama in it's comment section on mydramalist than this one. so loving this drama, everyday since ep' 8 i check how many days are left for ep' 9 (i mean not enough days have past, still so many to go). waiting isn't fun at all:( :( :(

it's a pitty that the koreans don't :(

i think you need to rewatch inoccent man because kang ma roo didn't spend 15 episodes on torturing, using/abusing the female lead. his interest in her for the sake of revenge ended i think even before the show was halfway through. after the scene on the beach when they were driving on oposite lanes and she crossed to his while he kept on driving. i think that was his turning point a witch he had already realized his wrongdoings and his developing feelings for her, thats why he didn't have the surgery early on as a self punishment for his sins and asked his mentor doctor friend to treat her. he didn't want to be envolved in her life anymore after she lost her memories and forgot the bad things he did to her. then, when it turned out he has to help her rebuild her life that he himself contributed to its' ruin he did his best to help her get to her rightful place as an heiress nd "fight" against his gready ex'g.
also kang ma roo was origenly a standart "hero" charecter. he took the blame of a murder for his exgirlfriend not knowing the whole story wich originated from her greed. he was sent to prison while leaving his sister who almost died from a sickness while he was gone, and not to mention him losing his medical profetion. all that for the sake of his love who was like a family to him since they were young. thata the classical self secrefing hero for you. after he learned the true nature of that girlfriend that's when things turned sougth and he became an antihero.
but even his antihero days havn't lasted that long and most of the time he was sort of in between those two.
lastly lets not forget that seo eun gi wasn't exactly your tipical "hero" type and isn't without foult. and honestly for the last qourter or so of this drama after she regained her memory it was her missunderstandings of him. he couldn't tell her the truth knowing she will probably forgive him when he hasn't thought of himself worth forgiving. lets not forget those charecters were in love with each other almost from the start.

sorry this is kind of my top 5 fav' drama ever... also i'm a huse song joong ki fan....

same here, i've been reading and putting like on almost every comment in this drama section and by the looks of it im not the only one to do so. this is my first time seeing junho in a drama but he is so completely utterly perfect here. <3 <3