I have to agree with your assessment, though my enjoyment really plummeted in the second half of the season. Zhu…
I don't mind the Warehouse 11 doings. I enjoy the detective side of things there and Zhu Yilong did a good job carrying a lot of it on his own. The ideas there are decent and as for Xiao Bai, she serves her purpose there as Wu Xie's guide which makes sense although I am surprised that there aren't at least one or two more females. Given the nature of the work there, I can see why it is a predominantly male sphere. The downer for me was Piaopiao in those last few episodes. I don't doubt the censorship issue prevails. But I think the C drama industry needs to be a lot cleverer about getting past the scrutiny of the censors the way Hollywood did in those early days.
Agree!! I hate her character. She tells Pangzi that she doesn't require his help but than turns around and takes…
The part where Piaopiao assumed Xu Wu was the one who helped her find the bone marrow donor really took the cake. I thought to myself... Wow... this woman can't possibly be that silly. The way the writing demeans the character is mind boggling. I also don't understand why she won't accept help from Pangzi who has been so good to her.
Even though I think this show suffers from similar problems to Mystic Nine with regards to the kind of slash and churn censorship that C dramas are subject to, it's still a much better production overall. For the most part I have enjoyed the drama despite the uneven pacing. And of course Zhu Yilong covers a multitude of the shows sins with his performance. There are even glimpses of brilliance here and there. Somewhere in there there's a great story aching to be told. I'm not bothered by the fact that this story doesn't focus on the Iron Triangle in the second half but I am bothered by how the women (Xiao Bai the notable exception) have been included here. It's not just Piaopiao although she's the most egregious example. I can see how they all fit into the story and why they've been included. But their personalities stink. This is a problem I have with a lot of C dramas especially where women are peripheral or supporting characters. It's downright annoying.
There's really no other word for it. Piaopiao is stupid. Her character is such a grave disappointment. I feel very sorry for Pangzi (Fatty). And what is the show implying about mothers... *shakes head*
I don't think you need to. They're all standalone stories but playing out in the same universe. MIght be better if you don't actually. Just watch it like you're watching anything that's new to you.
Despite all its flaws the reason why I keep coming back for more isn't just because Zhu Yilong is wonderful as Wu Xie but ultimately this is a detective drama with Indiana Jones trappings. I haven't seen the others and I don't feel the need to. But there are good and even original ideas driving the narrative. I am enjoying the Warehouse 11 stuff and surprisingly I'm enjoying the partnership with Xiao Bai.
I can't even begin to understand the Legend of Yunxi comparisons. Yunxi wasn't perfect by any stretch of the imagination but this show is not even half the show that Yunxi was. The storyline has very superficial similarities. I like Merxat but honestly the chemistry between the leads here can't even compare with YX
This drama is like the best Cdrama I'm watching right now (well I'm experiencing drama drought so there is that)....I…
I am also watching this primarily because of Zhu Yilong. I persevered through a lot of filler because of him. I've loved him since Bordertown Prodigal. He has a way of giving a character much more dimension than most. It's not a bad show overall but there's too much filler for my taste. But I like the main iron triangle enough to keep going. And the Warehouse 11 arc is an intriguing concept.
In my opinion, if you want to know more about the background story, especially about Wu Xie and Xiao Ge's background,…
I've seen Mystic Nine. But honestly I can follow this show without any understanding of the previous incarnations. I didn't even need to draw on my knowledge of Mystic Nine. I just follow the White Rabbit. ;) The show has been constructed as a standalone story.
Sounds like it's better not to have seen any of the previous iterations of the drama. Honestly there's really no need to watch the earlier ones. It's like watching another version of Justice Bao or Dee Renjie.
I don't think there's much doubt who the villains are. It's not your typical whodunit or police procedural. The point of the drama is really the Columboesque cat and mouse game that's being played all over the map. There are all kinds of agendas going on that's gradually unfolding. That's really what's driving the show IMO.
It's a really good drama with a fantastic cast. The leads are great... Son Hyun-joo and Jang Seung-jo (both fine actors) play off each other rather well.
My only beef with this otherwise intriguing show is its inconsistent pacing. At times it moves at snail's pace and other times is moves along frenetically. The lack of discipline in C dramas is really their undoing. There are a lot of unnecessary bits of dialogue. Zhu Yilong is great as always. Fatty is generally okay although he talks too much at times. And the kid that played the General in Dr Cutie is much much better here.
I don't doubt the censorship issue prevails. But I think the C drama industry needs to be a lot cleverer about getting past the scrutiny of the censors the way Hollywood did in those early days.
*shakes head*
It's not a bad show overall but there's too much filler for my taste. But I like the main iron triangle enough to keep going. And the Warehouse 11 arc is an intriguing concept.
The show has been constructed as a standalone story.
It's a really good drama with a fantastic cast. The leads are great... Son Hyun-joo and Jang Seung-jo (both fine actors) play off each other rather well.
https://lilyroots4love.blogspot.com/2020/07/ancient-detective-2020-puppet-motif.html