Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: Oct 14, 2026
  • Location: Dramaland
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: August 9, 2024
  • Awards Received: Flower Award2 Clap Clap Clap Award1
On She and Her Girls • Oct 20, 2024
Title She and Her Girls Spoiler
It's been years since I lost all confidence in reviews and ratings on Douban, when I realized that the majority of this audience tends to rate a drama very simply because it meets the "niche" characteristics, a pseudo elitism which is actually just a matter of appearance, and not a matter of sincere appreciation.
But I do believe Douban still give merits and highlight dramas that deserves so therefore I decided to try this drama.
I watched the first 10 eps but I have no motivation to continue.
The ideas and themes are very honorable and inspiring, however the conception of this drama has nothing interesting in its global construction, the directing is very very basic, there is no artistic element... which bothers me , because imo a drama must include some, even if the writing is good.
The narration also bothers me, I find the rhythm monolithic, there is no movement in the writing that would allow a necessary focus in the nuances of the psychology of the characters.
You can very easily feel that the goal of the drama is to follow a precise guideline/goal/aspiration... and it feels very forced. The way the story is told and filmed has no natural substance ... You can feel they want the drama to be seen a particular way ... you know the very inspirational kind of one (just like Mr Sunshine tried to be and failed). They want you to cry so bad but it isn't working for me, I'm way too sensible of those kinda of forced tricks to be able to find the story real (even if the storyline is definitely realitic and also happened in real life).

To conclude my observations, I would add that the drama is very "academic" in its construction, which makes me understand why the drama gained that high rating on Douban .
Unfortunately, I was not able to connect with the characters despite such honorable themes, if they would pick another director for a new adaptation, I would definitely tune in.
2 0
Replying to Dramasama • Oct 19, 2024
Have you seen Jane Austen’s Emma before? The dynamic is very similar where the FL always treat the ML as a brother…
I forgot to mention that in Emma, at no point the leads were thinking they were sharing a father together ... so that's why I don't think the situations are comparable but I understand your questionning around the feelings being similar during those different situations, which is definitely interesting to point out.
0 0
Replying to almondyi • Oct 19, 2024
I don't know why it's so exciting to me when the marquis and the fl has scene in the drama. I'm also excited to…
You're not alone, I don't ship fl with 2nd ml but he's definitely bringing some good tension in the drama !
12 0
Replying to Mstique • Oct 19, 2024
Sometimes, there is no transition at all. The ml goes from not liking the fl to loving her instantly and after…
"She of course thinks him as brother till now", lmao this is literally my whole point, you just argued for the sake of it.
Pay more attention to what I wrote, you just wasted my time ... I never wrote they were real brother and sister but the fact is that the narrative around the fl is that she decided he was her third brother. At no point in the drama, the female lead is showing ambiguity in her feelings. That's why we were talking precisely about the transition, especially in relation with the family.

You just chose to not only misunderstand me but also to force your delusionnal perspective.
Next time, please do not engage with me.
0 0
Replying to Mstique • Oct 19, 2024
Sometimes, there is no transition at all. The ml goes from not liking the fl to loving her instantly and after…
She had doubt about his identity but after that, even without clear answers, she accepted him as her brother. It was sincere.
So what you are saying, is that she don't think she's her bro, and she has romanticc feelings, but they are cosplaying being brother and sister?
I don't think so, at least for now. But later they might have to pretend, and that's might be the transition the writer will be using, we shall see ...
0 2
Replying to Dramasama • Oct 19, 2024
Have you seen Jane Austen’s Emma before? The dynamic is very similar where the FL always treat the ML as a brother…
I have read Emma multiple times. And I don't think the situations are comparable.
There is a huge difference between thinking a man as a brother figure and actually believing he is your real brother ....
I feel like the situation in Emma is more similar to the situation of the leads in the cdrama "Go Ahead".
1 1
Replying to Mstique • Oct 19, 2024
Sometimes, there is no transition at all. The ml goes from not liking the fl to loving her instantly and after…
She grew up with him before leaving the household, so course she's gonna believe he is her brother?? how do you expect her to not believe it?? She wasn't and still not aware of the secret around her identity ...
Thinking that it is completely normal to fall in love with the man you thought was your brother in few days will mean she had romantic feelings for him when whe was believing he was her brother ... and this is highly problematic lmaoo ?? how can you not understand the issue?
1 4
Replying to sunshine75 • Oct 19, 2024
I agree, and I hope that the scriptwriters found a credible solution for this, as she is now completely in this…
The solution definitely exist but we are wandering how many more episodes are we gonna have to wait for the revelation ro happen, to then make the female lead see the man she thought was her brother, the man she will love romantically ... It can't happen that fast, so I hope they won't rush the process, and give the characters enough time to transition into their new dynamic.
3 1
Replying to sunshine75 • Oct 18, 2024
I agree, and I hope that the scriptwriters found a credible solution for this, as she is now completely in this…
I agree !
0 0
Replying to Mstique • Oct 18, 2024
Sometimes, there is no transition at all. The ml goes from not liking the fl to loving her instantly and after…
You can't compare those situations to a story about two leads thinking they were brother and sister, to then only the fl thinking she is the sister of the ml while he falls more and more in love with her ...
2 6
Replying to sunshine75 • Oct 18, 2024
I agree, and I hope that the scriptwriters found a credible solution for this, as she is now completely in this…
I really hope so, but knowing we're already halfway throught the drama, I hope we get a transition of at least 5 eps ...
4 2
On The Rise of Ning • Oct 18, 2024
The more they drag the brother/sister thing, the more I'm questioning how they're gonna build a decent transition for them to become lovers ...
7 25
Replying to EsteYnCent • Oct 18, 2024
Title Kill Me Love Me Spoiler
Same for me, unfortunately. I’ll probably run through it when all the Eps have completed release just to see…
I really appreciate the synthesis you made, which partly traces the lack of coherence in the writing. I agree. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.

I think there is a total inconsistency between the characters' behaviors at the beginning of the drama and what is happening now, that's what disappoints me the most.

I can't ignore the laziness of the writers, they didn't even try to give us a coherent and realistic transition from a character writing point of view, and especially in relation to the changes they made them undergo when they came into contact with each other.
Everything was done way too fast which makes the love story between the two way too hasty to happen. The pacing is way too brutal and fast ... and for no reason, it gives no substance to the way the storyline is perceived ... I really don't get it ...
I think they should have done a more concise job of developing a deep bond between the two characters...
0 0
Replying to EsteYnCent • Oct 18, 2024
Same for me, unfortunately. I’ll probably run through it when all the Eps have completed release just to see…
Yeah, I feel you. I might also binge watch the rest of the drama, as I'm still a little curious about the ending of the story... It's definitely not a mediocre drama in my opinion, but it had the necessary material in terms of storyline to be epic... but the execution is a such disappointment, that it won't be the case.
2 1
Replying to 12066953 • Oct 18, 2024
I put the drama on hold after episode 7, then dropped it after reading the comments about the following episodes.…
I completely agree.

As you wrote there is nothing wrong with this kind of dramas, if people can enjoy them, then good for them but the deceptive strategy is very disappointing and that's what is actually very annoying .
2 0
On Kill Me Love Me • Oct 18, 2024
After ep7, the drama is kinda off for me.
The pacing is problematic and especially the narration.
I thought it would've been more mature execution, where is the angst and the seriousness of the beginning ?
I do have an issue with WJY's acting. The grief and the deep pain of her charcter is less apparent on her face, especially in her eyes, and imo the actress should've done a better job making her charcter showcase different emotions at the same time. In the recent eps, she behave in more relax way, it should've been more about confidence than that ... confidence and determination to keep up with the revenge plan ... But I was already aware that she was unable to display texture in her acting ... But I got carried away by her amazing charisma during the first eps ...

I thought the drama would've a tone like the one in "Nirvana in Fire" or "Royal Nirvana", but it's looking more like your generic costume cdrama ...
8 7
Replying to Charlotte • Oct 16, 2024
I must be the only one who gets annoyed whenever the 2nd ML comes on screen, I get obsession not love from him.I've…
I can understand your opinion.
I won't say his love or obsession is the reason people are intrigued by him, at least, it's not my motivation. I think the actor is doing a good job displaying the complexity of the toughts of his characters especially when he intetacts with the fl: the complexity between his own greed for power (probably motivated by his own reasons) and his feelings for the fl, her being the only person he could trust while being unable to see properly (but it's too soon to be certain, I'm sure the writing will give us more details).
1 0
Replying to duber • Oct 16, 2024
Lol,he is nowhere near to ml...thats why its very very unpopular opinion...in china,his character here might be…
I'm glad "The Rise of Ning" is being loved by many. I do think, so far it is the best cdrama currently airing imo.
3 0
On Love in the Desert • Oct 16, 2024
It was so hard to finish ... after ep7, this drama went downhill with pure mediocrity :

The acting was highly disappointing.
The fl's perf was very superficial, she was unable to comprehend the deepness of her character. She has no range of facial expressions which was frustrating to watch. Her karisma was definitely interesting in the beginning tho.
The ml did the bare minimum with this role. He usually can showcase his skills imo but in this drama, he was boring af. He made his character look like a teenage boy ...

The story of the lovestory of the lead was absurd. They didn't fall in love, they fell in lust and that's that. It was so cringy to see them pretend they were bonded by a deep connection LOL.

The writing of the characters was honestly so basic and bland.
The lovestory of the 2nd cp was problematic as hell too.

The plot was interesting but the writer did a mediocre job with it.
8 0
Replying to duber • Oct 16, 2024
Lol,he is nowhere near to ml...thats why its very very unpopular opinion...in china,his character here might be…
It's ok, I don't aim to have the same opinion as everyone. Obviously, I stated that it was an unpopular opinion for that reason. Ml was getting more attention because of his last drama that did great in china, and good for him.
3 2