Lee Anha

I also feel weird that BJE hates the priest for revenge so much, I get it but also you steals his stuff first. Her sister ill because she is ill, not because of him (or maybe they'll do it that way). He told her how important this event and why he needs to inspect the quality of the fabric, she knew he doesn't let anyone near the shrine and she runs away.
She runs away like thief that knows what she did brings harm to them. She said he can just make a new bell but , why can't she ask for a new bell to be made? He had said that the timing is important for his ceremony, he had prepared it for long time cause the dye took like more than 15 days and she is being angry because he doesn't prioritize her? He doesn't know her more than that, it make the acting felt over the top since it's not supported by the plot.

It's the same as you said with their connection. There is no need for 18th life tragedy in this story at all. She'll meet cho won and seoha again like how the 18th life makes them unknowingly related

Thanks, I'll guard myself for the ending then

I think the last 10 minutes of almost every episode is the main story of this drama. It's like they only shot for that scenes and had to fill for the other 30 minutes scenes.

yeah, this whole episode 11 and 1st life story somehow makes the drama worse. I mean what was the reason seoha in the 18th life special if he was already special in the 1st life? Why are you emphasizing it in the first half of the drama?
Also what's so wrong about tragic romance?
I felt like kdrama writer loves their righteous hero but also like to pretend that they are anti hero until the last episode.

SHS acting save BJE character in this drama. I can't warm up to her 19th life and I felt her revenge is kinda cheap script trick cause she did it by herself but she sells the performance. Character wise though, it feels like she always act like she is The Protagonist while she is being unreasonable.
The more we have flashback, the more it makes the 18th life looks like less impactful and it makes me second guessing the entire first half, like would I care about the 18th life if they shows the 1st life first?
Also why can't she remembers? the script is not consistent and does seoha really means anything at all? all his plot ended with an anticlimax resolution.

The execution is better this ep but it just fundamentally dragged down the whole drama.

Your title hits the spot.
Thanks

Does the romance has the typical xianxia ending where viewer can imagine the ending (and add their own flair/interpretation) or the ending is clearly shown at the last episode?

hahahaha, I know what you mean

I think the same too, I think they feel the same

I am being truthful (as I've always been), idc if you'll believe me.
It just funny in my point of view to see that people make up conclusion out of nothing,
like you are so wrong but you don't know it and I don't think you'll believe me.
It just your assumption is wrong and I know it, I didn't swear on my mother if this is a joke but come on, name calling is low and you resort to fake name calling, it's even sadder.

oot, are you the same user that also in Dramabeans? I've seen your username on the site with all the comment about Love for Suckers - Jijon fans. I want to say that I always enjoy your comment in that drama

I can swear on my mother that I am not LittleFallOfRain or Maia,
gosh, this is so funny. It's fine to not liking my comment but this name calling username is way funnier. I am being serious, I am not them and I reply cause this is just so funny. I'll show you my pc if that's possible.

Don't mind me, this is just too funny on my side.

Have the same thought as you, around 6-7, mostly because the editing and background music is a consistent flaw in the series. I like to rate a show 10 and then deducted the point, like with this show, -1 for directing, -1 for bgm, -1 for chemistry and writing, it will not passed 8 for me

It has always been weird, once you notice it, you can find it every where

It just the drama I think , I didn't read the webtoon and I even tired of this drama bad writing.

There is a 10/10 review 5 days ago who have watched all of the episode while the drama hasn't even ended. The review for each episode is already there on episode guide. It's definitely an inflated review because people rated the unaired episode

Eh, see how you break your own argument?
- Revenant is : 9-11% (3 % increase)
- Dr. romantic 3 :12.7% - 14.9% (2.2% increase)
- Tale of the Nine Tailed 1938 : 6.4% - 8% (1.6 % increase)
- It's okay : 6% -7.3 % (1.3 increase)
This drama is not stagnant, they are increasing their share every episode to the end , even by 1%.

- See You in My 19th Life : 4.2% - 4.5% (0.3 increase)
What I mean is this 0.3 increase, which means the quality is not generating any good feedback from the viewer.

- Devil Judge is actually a good choice because the viewership of this drama increase every episode, 5.5% to 7.9%, it shows that drama that start around 5% is still consider good when it has increase viewership.

Not many dramas is in stagnant phase, your own example is flawed,
my initial comment is about this miniscule increase in viewer of this drama each week. The higher viewership in this drama so far is 5.5% in ep 6 but then it dipped again while drama that you shows to be good quality above don't have week or episode where the rating is suddenly dipped. It's not that no one watch drama or viewership is stagnant but this drama just not making buzz and not getting good feedback which in my comment correlate to the quality of the drama.

The drama you give as example in my correlation will correlate to good quality and feedback because they are increasing their viewership. not the same as see you in my 19th life, so read my comment again.

lol, thought the same too

I agree that this drama has stagnant trend, doesn't generate much buzz.
I just want to point out that if the fans are mad with 5/10 rating, then what about the regular viewer who don't agree with the 10/10 rating?
OP wants to uplift the viewer by bringing rating while both side is doing the same things. People who they call as trolls in the eye of regular viewers is the same things as the fans inflated rating. 5/10 is not even that bad, it's not like the 0/10 review bombing.

My comment is about how your argument about the rating to shows it's quality makes no sense, especially at this point where the drama is not even ended. Why would you be mad at 5/10 rating while your 10/10 rating is also based on your "personal judgement". I can see it as deceiving the positive press.

"The user who gave 5/10 even after watching 10 episodes simply doesnt like the drama at all, comeon drama is not evn that bad to give 5/10, and if you have given 5/10 instead of dropping it, which clearly implies that you hate this drama and come to just spreading hate here."

5/10 is not a bad rating, it's 50% good which means that they acknowledge that the drama did something to gain that 5 points. You said it's bad while the one who give it 5, thinking that it really is 5, how is that so different with your 10/10 in every episode?

Why is it double standard only when people say they dislike something and not when they like it?
Several of episode of this drama legit have sounds problem, multiple annoying flashback that don't add up to anything. If you count this as a flaw, this already down from your 10/10 score.
Bunch of comment is about they don't feel the chemistry, this add more to the flaw.

I wasn't going to comment until I saw the rating as I am one of the viewer who watch this because I saw it at the top of the chart in MDL. Your comment is just patronizing because you can't see that this drama is not 10/10, at least other drama fans is aware of its own drama fault but the fans of this drama or maybe just the actress is delusional.