Lee Anha

I still think she act in different drama for most of the scene than other character in the drama. Idk if it's the acting but she doesn't look off to me, until she met other character my impression turn into, "she is acting right now"

maybe I have become numb to this drama, the drama forced me to be sad but I don't feel it.
I don't believe in the main lead connection, like their personality is a missmatch, he doesn't seems to like jieum and jieum feels fake.
I wish I can feel sad but the drama has overused the tragedy and all I feel is "why is every tragedy dumped on seoha?"

I get what you mean with how other character feeling conveyed better to the audience. I think SHS acting is good and touching when it's her scenes only and when she is with other character, it's like there is a pitch off, it doesn't feels like she is there with them.
Her character from life to life doesn't feel connected beside the memory and the unending flashback but it doesn't feel like her at all. Whenever the character interacted with her, all I can see is Juwon but not Ji eum but with the ahjumma, it's the uncle and not jieum, it's like she has no character unless she needs to move the plot.
I am not sure if ABH is doing a good job, sometimes he did, sometimes he feels like confused on what to show the audience, like loading expression.

I think it because of the story writing, scenes aren't left long enough to be sink into the viewer, there is hardly any buildup, they will cut some scenes halfway and continue the explanation later with extra added scenes, the mystery is in every aspect because they want to give the viewer mystery and it ends up makes the whole drama disconnected.
The kiss is good as a kiss but I don't understand or felt that seoha likes jieum, there is no emotional connection.
The funny things for me is I can see the chemistry for the 2nd couple even when they have less stake and less story, I believe their spark but the main lead is a bust.
I am here because of the mystery so I can end my curiosity but this drama is not that good.

it has a decent rating, the problem in this drama is that it failed to be consistently good and I think silent majority knows that the couple has no chemistry.
I realized that rating mostly resemble the previous episode and episode 6 is bad that ep 7 has dipped in rating.

welp, thanks for the reminder

thanks

I've caught 2 episode and I feel like I should take my time with this. It feels like the character will change a lot with the way the drama started. It start off really well.

Question : Does it have love triangle?

I just realized that they can do full review only for 1 episode,
I thought the 1 episode review is only for the 1st episode but not for the entire series

Her character and his character work as separate character but doesn't work as a couple. It feels like they have to fall in love because of the plot.
The fact that the kids has better chemistry said a lot.

I didn't even read the webtoon and gets disappointed each episode, you can even see from the comment section and rating, it's actually losing people interest no matter how it pretend to be "insightful"
I finished ep 7 and this drama becomes more cliche despite the premise is not to be one.
The chemistry is not there yet the drama like to pretend that this is groundbreaking

The drama pride itself in the beginning to not becoming a cliche but each episode is getting more cliche from the the fantasy genre. Scratching my head about this cause See you in my 19th life is also just another cliche reincarnation drama again and again.

hmm, so 18th life seoha was never that special? I guess we can see it from the story line.
This drama just love to erase its own past episode, lol

I saw someone mentioned it, Ju won/jieum never mentioned her own age, it's other people who talk about her age to describe her but she herself never stated her own age whenever people ask her directly.

Aside from that, there are a lot of direction this drama can go but since the drama don't show their clear direction, people are left with question which like you said, makes you wonder with the wasted potential in term of story/plot development.

Don't you think it's better if she doesn't know how many reincarnation that she has? Like she'll say something like "this is the 18th that I remember but Idk if there is other before"
So she has 18 memories as a different person rather than reincarnated 18th times with past memories.

Don't you thin it's better if she doesn't know how many reincarnation that she has? Like she'll say something like "this is the 18th that I remember but Idk if there is other before"
So she has 18 memories as a different person rather than reincarnated 18th times with past memories.

It's the middle of the drama and I think there are a lot of plot hole that just wasn't explained. As example the discussion about her age, the drama never makes a statement about how old is her but always implied that she is older than Seoha, when they were a kid in 18th life and also when they were older in 19th life.
The dance scene is the one that looks like MV imo, it looks super pretty but it's so random since if the viewer isn't invested in their love story, they'll see the scene comes off as sudden and random. Why don't they swim instead as it's been established that they swim as a kid before, the dance have no build up whatsoever.
Also she keeps emphasizing her 19th life fast reincarnation but there is one life where she talks that people don't believe her when she went to visit her previous life mother, the fact that the mother is still alive and not super old means that the reincarnation is fast at that time too.
There is a lot of things that was said and emphasized by the dialogue but also falls apart by the other scenes they shows.
Like the idea that she was murdered and for the remaining of her 19th life before meeting seoha, she didn't do any investigation?
The inheritance battle, I don't even know who is who and what is seoha supposed to do like are they working on the hotel cause they don't seems to work at all or are they doing landscaping instead but we don't see any project related discussion,
It's 6 out of 12, the plot is half baked, the romance is in surface level and there is mystery about their death, new character and the dreams that haunts her. It's a lot to unravel.

This drama is legit has audio problem and it's not just in one episode and apparently , that was not a good comment too.
Like your comment, my initial reason to check out was the rating,
I've started the drama and hidden love because I see both as number 1 on the list for Korean and Chinese and I don't usually drop drama since I want to know about the overall story of the drama so the reply for stop watching is weird. If you are confident in this drama, aren't you gonna make people to keep watching? who knows if it gets better at the end.

Rather than defending the drama, I don't agree with your way of saying "unintentional grooming", grooming is a problem because it's intentional, that's why it's a criminal offense.
Growing up with someone is not grooming even when it ends up with falling in love.
Even in real life, you see neighbor grow up alongside each other and then get married. Does that means, every your older sister/brother is unintentionally grooming their other younger neighbor?
Grooming is a malicious process used by to exploit minors and the behaviors are “very intentional" from the perpetrators. Your way of contemplating experience of growing up with the idea of manipulation is on its own, false narrative.

When relating to this drama, as I've said previously, they didn't grow up together, he tutor her for an exam and it doesn't take very long.

What I understand is you are forcing narrative with using words that shouldn't be use despite what actually happened in the drama and real life. I am gonna stop replying since you are already categorically wrong in your definition and when it relating to the drama, you even get the sequence of event wrong. The manhua is unrelated since this is drama discussion.

Rather than defending the drama, I don't agree with your way of saying "unintentional grooming", grooming is a problem because it's intentional, that's why it's a criminal offense.
Growing up with someone is not grooming even when it ends up with falling in love.
Even in real life, you see neighbor grow up alongside each other and then get married. Does that means, every your older sister/brother is unintentionally grooming their other younger neighbor?
Grooming is a malicious process used by to exploit minors and the behaviors are “very intentional" from the perpetrators. Your way of contemplating experience of growing up with the idea of manipulation is on its own false.

When relating to this drama, as I've said previously, they didn't grow up together, he tutor her for an exam and it doesn't take very long.

What I understand is you are forcing narrative with using words that shouldn't be use despite what actually happened in the drama and real life. I am gonna stop replying since you are already categorically wrong in your definition and when it relating to the drama, you even get the sequence of event wrong. The manhua is unrelated since this is drama discussion.