Mariaaa13

they're just trying to make it seems as if it's him but it's not....

what episode are you on ? i need to know because i have the answer but it might spoil things for you i'm at ep 10

Yeah but we’re at like episode 10 and theories and guessing is based on all we know so the info here is half accurate if not fully accurate ( that’s if we guess right ) and watching the show with it being half soiled is no fun

i just wanna give ji hoo a long hug .................. :((( awhhhh

the sister is yoon jae's sister and she's dead.. whatever happened to her that night ended her life that night . she's fragile and she was probably either raped or beaten brutally and could've died from that they aren't gonna try to tend to her wounds and def. they wouldn't have sheltered her and good enough for her to give birth and in sung may look young but not young enough to be her son .. it all happened like 20 years ago .. he'd been 19 and in highschool or like maximum in college not an established young man engineer so no , the skeleton that was found belongs to her for sure

if he wasn't treated for a long time and it's one of the characters that we know .. they all walk fine .. so either has a scar or a prosthetic leg because there's no way it survived through without infection or problems

yeah but if you're planning to watch the show .. it will be no fun if you read all the guess and watch based on someone else's opinions and guesses

no the culprit is just one person ..... son of the lost sister what ???
in sung is the most sus for me ,, tbh as well as maybe the chef or his bro

that's not " THE REVEALLLL " it's not him plus they've been trying to sell it on us almost every episode giving lil reveals about him in each but no there's more to it

nooo that's not really "the reveal" reveal .. it isn't him

diving deeper

i'm hella convinced ...... the culprit is either in sung.. the chef or the long lost brother of the chef but if there's no long lost brother then it's def the chef like there's no way they're gonna bring another character we haven't seen yet and make it the murderer .. we def have seen the face of the culprit .. for sure
yoon jae isn't dead and he's one of the above mentioned .. someone died and yoon jae's name was registered instead of him and it happened after the hope welfare was closed and that's why baek didn't know about it ... this proves that only the sister died and number 24 at that time but other 4 boys survived it .... number 12 has a prosthetic leg ... mark my words ... or like a scar or something proving that it's him

ummmm yes big chance it's happening remember wen they were young sung hoon was always trying to calm yoon jae down and look out for him so if so they he's always really still attached to that memory and he doesn't know which side he should be on .... feels like he should protect both ...

hey i also added more theories jut about now in then same comment so check it out. i agree but i've always liked analyzing and trying to guess things in thrillers

i don't buy the theory where more than one of the kids are working together idk ..

i feel like if they are they should've gotten in touch with sung hoon too and tried to get him to help ..
remember yoon jae always looked up to sung hoon and loved himm and sung hoon saved yoon jae when he fell in the first episode and stayed with him to hide him although the other kids ran away

spoiler for ep 9 + 10 and theories

- so if yoon jae died according to the nun then it could either be a lie or maybe another boy died and they said that it was yoon jae .
- now we know for sure that ryu sung joon wasn't one of the five boys nor was he yoon jae
- the chef's brother definitely was at the welfare center although the parents looked for him the chief yeom must've lied to them about it... now we have one more person that could be one of the 5 boys and could be the culprit but if so why bring his brother into it .. or number 12 is either the chef's long lost brother or the chef himself but he's lying
- i call bullshit on in sung's amnesia there's no way he's got no recollection of his childhood or else he wouldn't have came back to korea and stayed in the states.... he must've had a motive to come back to south Korea ... eun gi's mom gave in sung a look as if she thought that she had seen him before so he's def either 13 or 12 i'm so sure and if not 12 then he's def the murderer
- the owner of the restaurant is also connected to the case.... in sung might be her son big chance he is .... however in sung's eyes drifted away in thoughts when he heard about her story so idk it's sus
- that reveal isn't THE REVEAL Plus we all already knewwwwwwwwww that gabriel was sung hoon
- i have no doubts that we already know the face of the murderer.. they are just trying to confuse us with sung hoon that's it
- now the next victim isn't eun giii she's safe i'm convinced ...... but the next one is either the reporter since he hasn't gone to work or that shaman that was in the forest near the murder scene cause we haven't heard much about them yet so def something happened to one of them

that's okay dude. oh nooo that's an absurd theory i didn't know about it but there was a scene in episode 8 shot from a far and he looked short like short and thin so that's my speculation .... oh i agree about the hood thingy but they better make it accurate he can be looking short in one scene then huge and muscular in another when revealed i'd call bullshit on that

go back and read dude .. i didn't judge the kids' size i'm not that absurd.... besides i have a medical field background and i know what you're saying like very well .. i said the supposed killer that drugged sung joon before he could get to ahn tae ho looked short and skinny and pretty close to in sung's body type sooo i was judging based on that .

the killer is fairly short and thin the one that drugged sung joon in episode 8 and he could be in sung he matches the body type however the voice isn't really working but honelsy what are the odds that the killer isn't one of the character that we know ??? it's defintely among them and i have a feeling we gonna be surprised but not really.... maybe and if the chef and engineer really are the rest of the kids then i have to say one of them must have an artificial foot because there's no way his foot survived that trap and not being treated for a long time and he def didn't die because we all know that the kid that died was hit by a car. that's my theory.. i think both kids were adopted " sung joon and sung hoon " because tbh there's no way they aren't and they have so much recollection of it especially sung joon but now we know they're all connected each and everyone of them to the case which leave very little room and it will be easier to guess the killer ....
now their mom is def very aware of what happened 20 years ago and maybe even her husband cause she gave him a look so idk ..
now i don't think sung hoon is the murderer, when sung joon saw him leaving after the bride was found dead.. his hands weren't bloody .. it just looking as if he was chasing someone but not killed someone and ran ... (tbh that case seemed like one of those detective conan cases ahahah ) but then if sung hoon isn't the killer then how come they were all intentionally choosen as jurors and brought together so it's defintley some that can tamper with things and do it like that and i can't think of any of the characters we know that can do that other than sung hoon or maybe someone from the inner court n such