This review may contain spoilers
The Pursuit of What Exactly?
Pursuit of Jade is one of those dramas that become so popular it is deemed to be the best thing since sliced bread, leaving me to question my own sanity and preference because I think the complete opposite.
I have to admit, it starts out strong. The Lin'An slice of life story arc draws you in with its quaint little town, lovable characters, the simplicity and charm of a small town butcher girl, and the intrigue of the mysterious man she found at the brink of death in the snow. All of this make up a promising premise. You find yourself wondering about the true identity of this man and why he was found buried in the snow, and you grow attached to his relationship with the girl and the people around her. If only they were able to maintain the quality of the writing and perhaps take liberties with the original novel. Unfortunately, things start to go south writing-wise the moment Yan Zheng/Xie Zheng leaves and Fan Changyu is left without a choice but to go after him.
Enter the military camp and Wonder Woman arc, perhaps the worst part in the whole drama imho. The charismatic, polite, and down to earth Fan Changyu transforms into an obnoxious, arrogant, and insufferable super-powered woman that even Captain Marvel would envy. Never in my years of watching C-dramas did I think a character like the Mary Sues that Hollywood has made a standard for writing “strong female leads” would exist in C-dramaland. A woman so perfect, so strong, so complete that she doesn't need a man, and in fact, is better than a man. From a humble small town girl, Fan Changyu becomes the most celebrated general who can defeat seasoned warriors twice her size and armed with far deadlier weapons, with just two strikes of her short butcher blades. Amazing! Her skills become more and more ridiculous as the story progresses. Yes, yes, I know this is not real life, it's just fiction. But it's a historical drama grounded in reality where pigs are pigs and don't fly. Even fantasy stories follow the rules set in the world building. People just don't acquire powers for no reason. Changyu's super human strength just don't make sense and it's even more farfetched to make her such a natural fighter that she needs little to no training to be great at it.
And don't even get me started on the Marquis in distress who is almost always injured and needs to be saved. Zhang Linghe is nothing more than a pretty face with a feathered headdress. He barely has anything to do. For someone who is widely feared and revered as the greatest general of his generation, he has very few action scenes that reflect his true skill as a fighter. Xie Zheng exists to be an eye-candy. That's all.
But my greatest beef with this drama is the poor writing of the political intrigue. For the first time since I started watching C-dramas, I struggled to grasp the royal court politics and the players involved because the drama is heavily focused on the romance and Changyu's transformation into a girl boss that they lost the plot. The whole thing started because of the conspiracy that transpired 17 years ago, which led to Xie Zheng becoming gravely injured in his pursuit of the truth and Changyu rescuing him. That weird alternative ending proves the importance of that political disaster because if that hadn't happened, then Changyu would've been born a Wei and betrothed to Xie Zheng since birth. The rightful heir wouldn't have died and Qi Min wouldn't have turned out to be such a psychopath. But the writer seemed to have forgotten that part of the plot and just remembered it in the final few episodes, resulting in a rushed ending that didn't make much sense.
I am more pissed that they wasted an interesting premise and a great cast of actors, though. This could've been a truly remarkable drama if they hadn't botched the second half. To be honest, I mainly watched this for the villains and anti-heroes. They are the reason I decided not to drop this drama even when I was tearing my hair out in frustration. lol Deng Kai as Qi Min delivered an incredibly nuanced performance that despite my disgust for his disturbing actions, I found myself sympathizing with him a little. Yan YiKuan as Wei Yan was equally compelling. He's perhaps the most tragic character of all. I couldn't bring myself to hate him. So for the strong start, convincing acting, cinematography, and costume and set design, I give it a generous 6.5.
I have to admit, it starts out strong. The Lin'An slice of life story arc draws you in with its quaint little town, lovable characters, the simplicity and charm of a small town butcher girl, and the intrigue of the mysterious man she found at the brink of death in the snow. All of this make up a promising premise. You find yourself wondering about the true identity of this man and why he was found buried in the snow, and you grow attached to his relationship with the girl and the people around her. If only they were able to maintain the quality of the writing and perhaps take liberties with the original novel. Unfortunately, things start to go south writing-wise the moment Yan Zheng/Xie Zheng leaves and Fan Changyu is left without a choice but to go after him.
Enter the military camp and Wonder Woman arc, perhaps the worst part in the whole drama imho. The charismatic, polite, and down to earth Fan Changyu transforms into an obnoxious, arrogant, and insufferable super-powered woman that even Captain Marvel would envy. Never in my years of watching C-dramas did I think a character like the Mary Sues that Hollywood has made a standard for writing “strong female leads” would exist in C-dramaland. A woman so perfect, so strong, so complete that she doesn't need a man, and in fact, is better than a man. From a humble small town girl, Fan Changyu becomes the most celebrated general who can defeat seasoned warriors twice her size and armed with far deadlier weapons, with just two strikes of her short butcher blades. Amazing! Her skills become more and more ridiculous as the story progresses. Yes, yes, I know this is not real life, it's just fiction. But it's a historical drama grounded in reality where pigs are pigs and don't fly. Even fantasy stories follow the rules set in the world building. People just don't acquire powers for no reason. Changyu's super human strength just don't make sense and it's even more farfetched to make her such a natural fighter that she needs little to no training to be great at it.
And don't even get me started on the Marquis in distress who is almost always injured and needs to be saved. Zhang Linghe is nothing more than a pretty face with a feathered headdress. He barely has anything to do. For someone who is widely feared and revered as the greatest general of his generation, he has very few action scenes that reflect his true skill as a fighter. Xie Zheng exists to be an eye-candy. That's all.
But my greatest beef with this drama is the poor writing of the political intrigue. For the first time since I started watching C-dramas, I struggled to grasp the royal court politics and the players involved because the drama is heavily focused on the romance and Changyu's transformation into a girl boss that they lost the plot. The whole thing started because of the conspiracy that transpired 17 years ago, which led to Xie Zheng becoming gravely injured in his pursuit of the truth and Changyu rescuing him. That weird alternative ending proves the importance of that political disaster because if that hadn't happened, then Changyu would've been born a Wei and betrothed to Xie Zheng since birth. The rightful heir wouldn't have died and Qi Min wouldn't have turned out to be such a psychopath. But the writer seemed to have forgotten that part of the plot and just remembered it in the final few episodes, resulting in a rushed ending that didn't make much sense.
I am more pissed that they wasted an interesting premise and a great cast of actors, though. This could've been a truly remarkable drama if they hadn't botched the second half. To be honest, I mainly watched this for the villains and anti-heroes. They are the reason I decided not to drop this drama even when I was tearing my hair out in frustration. lol Deng Kai as Qi Min delivered an incredibly nuanced performance that despite my disgust for his disturbing actions, I found myself sympathizing with him a little. Yan YiKuan as Wei Yan was equally compelling. He's perhaps the most tragic character of all. I couldn't bring myself to hate him. So for the strong start, convincing acting, cinematography, and costume and set design, I give it a generous 6.5.
Was this review helpful to you?
