Macy

Like another comment said, Gorya stepping into Thyme’s world is always going to be harder. Thyme was easily accepted by her family and also easily bought a whole ass house. Thyme’s mother is obviously not welcoming to Gorya. She has to prove herself to be ‘worthy’ of Thyme’s world on top of her family problems. I don’t blame Gorya for giving up.

Hmmm if your partner's right that would mean Talay is based on a different "rival" character from the manga. Personally, I'm thinking Talay is a mix of this character and the one everyone else is thinking about.

I've always liked the fiancee character, but I don't think the dramas. Taiwanese and Chinese versions were the best at showing her being supportive of the main couple as she's only engaged to ML for a couple episodes. But the other versions show her hanging on to ML for too long, which makes her seem like a bad friend lol. Anyway, I think people like her because she's not the typical rival seen in dramas.

Totally agree with you! I think Nani is just getting more attention because he's sooo good-looking and they're playing up the bad boy image. Anyway, MJ's character in the manga and all the different versions has always been my favorite so maybe I'm biased xD

Oh, she's playing two different characters. I didn't catch that. Thanks!

Yeah, it's unofficial but they claimed it was a remake at first. Guess I should've known it was going to be bad as soon as they switched to "inspired by" lol. They could never make a real American version. Like you said, they would try to make it like Euphoria and then stretch out the story for too long so it'd last multiple seasons. American TV can't be trusted with some storylines.

The trailer left me confused about Grace's character. Is she trans? Also lots of insensitive jokes. I think this show will prob offend a lot of people. Anyway, I'm watching for Luke.

Thyme’s mom seems the closest adaptation to the manga. That women was never kind lol. She only has a short moment of humanity, when you realize that she’s also a mother who cares for her child. F4 Thai will probably go for something similar.

Ugh I hope they don’t drag it out that long. I always like the fiancée character, but the dramas drag her character arc out too long. I like her better in the manga when she becomes a supporter of the FL and ML.

I’ll never understand shipping people in real life. I think anyone doing this doesn’t really care about the actor. They only care about seeing their fantasies come to life. Ship characters, not people!

Unfortunately there is a American version called Boys Before Friends. It was terrible lol.

Agree about An Eye for an Eye and Irresistible. Both series started good but had lackluster endings. I also think the same of Nabi. I haven’t finished The Player yet, so we’ll see..

Thanks for letting me know! Yeah, that would be a lot of work lol.

Shouldn't this series be separated into seasons like other multi-season shows on here, and also for simplicity?

High school students are more subject to peer pressure. I just feel that college students have more to worry about since they're becoming adults. At that age, you also don't care about what others think. Whereas high school students have plenty of time to think about all of the petty/useless things we cared about back then lol.

Anyway, this could also be a cultural thing. I just read an article that said bullying in Thailand is a huge problem (similar to Japan). I'm guessing that students feel a lot of pressure from school and getting into a good college. Like Thyme said in the 1st ep, they want a "release" which they get from hurting others.

I think you make a fair point. That scene was really scary and intense. Tbh I'm not really sure whether the scene should've been included or not. I'm on the fence.

Anyway, I love that you mentioned Hana Nochi Hare. Anyone dislikes the problematic parts of Hana Yori Dango should definitely check it out. In some ways I prefer it to HYD.

I don't really think Ren is the un-problematic choice tbh. In terms of behavior, he's just the least worst of the F4.

I feel that college kids wouldn't really care enough to do all of this bullying, especially to the extent that we see in this version. When you're older, the high school politics seem petty lol. And the school doesn't care what the F4 does because their families give them so much money. This works for any type of school I guess.

Also, I don't think that they're implying that Thyme will immediately become a CEO upon graduation. It's more like high school is his time to be free and then when he graduates he will have to start preparing to take over when he's older.

Tbh I’m really picky about the second lead couple. In the manga, it’s sweet and a bit heartbreaking. There’s a connection there but it’s not romantic.

*Taiwan version does the storyline the best in my opinion . I can tell that the tried to be faithful to the manga, showing all the nuances of their relationship.
*Japanese version kind of butchers it :/ Yuki comes off more as having an obsessive crush and it’s played for laughs.
*I haven’t finished Korean version yet, but Ga-eul is more likable than the Japanese version. I can tell the story greatly diverges from the manga from what others have said.
*In the Chinese version, I didn’t find them ending up together realistic. Ironically they followed the manga too much so Xi Men doesn’t really seem that into Xiao You imo.
*Finally, Thai version. For some reason, right now I’m feeling that I wouldn’t mind Kavin and Kaning end up together. They seem to just click. And I can believe that Kavin will fall for this girl. I’m so curiously about how their relationship plays out.

I think so too. Probably at the last second tho.