Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 2 minutes ago
  • Location: ❉ ~Dramaland~ ❉
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: October 24, 2024
  • Awards Received: Finger Heart Award2 Flower Award6 Lore Scrolls Award1 Emotional Bandage1 Reply Hugger2 Soulmate Screamer2 Big Brain Award3
Idol I korean drama review
Completed
Idol I
1 people found this review helpful
by Sana
11 hours ago
12 of 12 episodes seen
Completed
Overall 8.5
Story 8.5
Acting/Cast 8.5
Music 8.5
Rewatch Value 8.5
This review may contain spoilers

A Murder Mystery Behind the Glitz and Glamour

First things first, the poster and title really don't do this drama justice. I passed it over several times, assuming it would be another clichéd idol rom-com where an ordinary girl somehow gets involved with a celebrity and the usual predictable storyline follows. Oh, how wrong I was!

I eventually picked it up during a drama slump, desperately looking for something to watch, and started it almost randomly. By the end of the first episode, I was already on MDL checking its genres because I hadn't expected to find myself watching a pretty decent legal thriller and murder mystery. In fact, I was so invested in the mystery that I wasn't even particularly impatient for the romance to develop.

The story follows Maeng Se-na (Choi Soo-young), a successful defense attorney known as the "lawyer for villains." What most people don't know is that she is also a devoted fan of the K-pop group Gold Boys, having supported them for eleven years. Her fangirl life and professional life unexpectedly collide when her favourite member, Do Ra-ik (Kim Jae-young), becomes the prime suspect in a murder case. She takes on his defense, but keeping her identity as a longtime fan hidden while maintaining professional boundaries becomes another challenge altogether.

**What I particularly enjoyed was how much more there was to this story than its initial premise suggested.** It has two fairly prominent storylines: the murder mystery, which drives the main plot, and the relationship between an idol and the fan who suddenly finds herself standing beside him under very different circumstances. Both work surprisingly well together, and neither feels like an excuse to push the other aside.

The murder investigation was what initially hooked me. I genuinely wanted to know who was responsible, what had happened behind the scenes, and how everything was connected. The drama does a good job of maintaining suspicion and gradually revealing the darker side of the entertainment industry. Although I think it could have made better use of its potential, particularly towards the end, the mystery was engaging enough to keep me invested.

**The portrayal of the entertainment industry was probably the most unsettling part for me.** Beneath the carefully managed public images, glamorous performances, and manufactured relationships lies an environment where power, money, reputation, and personal interests can dictate people's lives. What made it particularly disturbing was how believable some of these situations felt. People knowing the truth but choosing to remain silent because they don't want to get involved, friends protecting their own interests, and those in positions of power exploiting others are not exactly far-fetched scenarios.

And that CEO! Honestly, I was so furious with him that I briefly thought someone like that could easily inspire a person to become a murderer or at least hire one. The drama does a pretty good job of showing how frightening the people behind the entertainment machinery can be when they have enough power to manipulate everyone around them.

Another interesting aspect is how it explores the relationship between idols and their fans. Se-na represents the more genuine side of fandom: supporting someone for years, finding comfort in their work, and appreciating them without expecting anything in return. But the drama also shows how easily admiration can turn into obsession and entitlement. Some fans cross boundaries so badly that their supposed love becomes a source of fear and anxiety for the very people they claim to support.

I liked that the story didn't simply romanticize fangirling or portray every fan as harmless. It makes you think about the difference between genuine affection and possessiveness, and where support ends and intrusion begins. Being an idol doesn't mean surrendering your right to privacy or being treated as anything less than a human being.

As for the romance, I found it surprisingly mature and refreshing. Se-na and Ra-ik's relationship develops under rather unusual circumstances, and I liked how they gradually become a source of comfort and support for each other. Their conflicts don't drag on unnecessarily, and misunderstandings are generally resolved without requiring several episodes of avoidable frustration. They help each other grow while learning to see beyond the public image and personal assumptions they initially have. It's a relationship built on understanding and trust rather than endless misunderstandings.

Kim Jae-young was particularly convincing as Ra-ik. He portrayed his character's vulnerability, anxiety, and emotional struggles quite well, making it easy to understand the person behind the idol image. Choi Soo-young was decent as Se-na, although I wasn't entirely convinced by her performance. At times, her facial expressions felt a little too consistent, which made it harder for me to connect with certain emotional moments. Nevertheless, their overall dynamic worked.

My biggest disappointment was the handling of a couple of side characters, particularly the two obsessive fangirls. Their actions went far beyond ordinary fan behavior: breaking into an idol's apartment and even attempting to murder people. Yet, they never faced any consequences at all. Calling them overly enthusiastic or obsessive fans simply doesn't cut it, especially in a drama that otherwise takes legal matters and criminal investigations seriously. I found it particularly frustrating that their actions weren't given the legal weight they deserved.

The ending also loses some momentum, and I wish certain supporting characters had received more satisfying resolutions. The drama introduces several interesting ideas and conflicts, but not all of them get the attention they deserve.

Overall, Idol I was a much more pleasant surprise than I expected.What initially looked like another predictable celebrity-fan romance turned out to be an engaging legal thriller with an interesting murder mystery and a surprisingly grounded look at the entertainment industry. It isn't without its shortcomings, and I do think the writing could have been stronger in the final stretch, but the emotional storyline, creative details, and central mystery made it a worthwhile watch.

I went in expecting a fluffy idol rom-com and ended up getting invested in a murder investigation, the darker side of the entertainment business, and the complicated relationship between celebrities and their fans. Definitely one of those dramas that deserves more attention than its poster and title might suggest!
Was this review helpful to you?