Why are people saying JJS wasn’t a good FL for this drama???? I feel like she was perfect and I can only think…
I feel like I would have loved this series more if SJJ wasn’t the female lead. Gosh, I think I’ll be a proud anti-fan of hers for life. Honestly, she has zero range. She tried the romance genre and failed spectacularly because she can emote, what, 2-3 expressions max if she tries really hard? Both on and off camera. Her eyes are dead—like, actually devoid of life. If she ever got botox (heaven forbid), what little movement we see around her eyes when she "smiles" would disappear completely, and we’d be left guessing if she’s happy or channeling her inner psychopath.
Look, I know plenty of people (myself included) who have RBF, but I have never seen an actor whose entire character repertoire is just RBF. Except now, thanks to SJJ. Google her images. Go ahead! I pulled up the first 10 photos, fed them to ChatGPT and even ChatGPT could only detect three expressions. **Three!** Even Han So Hee, who’s been called stiff, manages more variety in her expressions.
Honestly, Hiroshi Ishiguro’s bionic robots emote more than she does. Just get Ishiguro to build a SJJ robot, throw in some AI for voice, and we’re all set—no need for her to even show up. I actually ran another experiment and added her name with various expressions in Google images. Same photos popped up for almost all emotions. I was dying laughing. Did the same with Han So Hee, Son Na Eun, Cha Eun Woo, who are all accused of stiff acting, and guess what? Different images for them for different emotions with maybe a little overlap! Shocking, right?
Honestly, I think a block of wood could do a better job. I have zero respect for her as an artist because she’s utterly lacking in talent. She is just riding on the coattails of her boyfriend. She’s getting more chances because of him, who, let’s be real, got her foot in the door to begin with in the industry.
And let’s not pretend she didn’t have chances to show emotional depth in this series because the character is "supposed" to be strong and confident. She’s being *chased* at the end for God's sake for her life—there should be a mix of desperation, strength, conviction, fear, etc. Instead? Nothing. Even dictators like Stalin and Hitler showed more emotional complexity towards the end of their reigns. Meanwhile, here’s Queen Woo, a woman at a greater disadvantage than any man in her position in history, displaying zero emotional range. Being strong doesn’t mean you’re never afraid or vulnerable. Fear is a survival tool; without it, you’re just overconfident and dead. And that’s why I’ll die on this hill: she has zero talent. She thinks she understands the characters she plays, but really, she’s just on autopilot, which is why all the characters she plays look the SAME.
Also, her so-called "strong presence" that she is being lauded for? Yeah, it looks more like condescension in disguise. Acting is >50% facial expression and the rest is body language and dialogue delivery. If you’re missing >50%, congrats, you’re a below-average actor. Simple as that. And let's not forget, she looks and sounds like a baby wearing a costume in this drama.
Man, JCW and the rest of the team carried the 1 star I gave this drama!
Like I said, lack of effective romance or comedy in the story, at this point they might as well make it a makjang instead to make it more watchable and even remotely sensible. For a romantic comedy, every single character except the ML and the second FL are awful human beings.
You have to say why. You can call it stupid, but to stop there is crass.
@spicyme1 Hey, I am extremely happy to know someone can survive on two braincells! Congratulations. Although you havent gotten the recognition for your feat from your parents, possible siblings and other family members, and your need for validation has brought you to the internet, I just wanted to take the time and acknowledge your perseverance in the face of this challenging adversity! I would have added your friends to the list but its hard to believe you might have any, and even if you do, they are probably hanging around you for sheer entertainment they get from your struggles which would be even more sad.
@larius I would just ignore this person, they are already struggling in life, you dont want to add to their misery. Think of it as charity in kind. I know they will keep going because they need to have the last word, often the case when a person is severely neglected and unloved at home. So please let us be understanding.
r u a moron? this premise dates back all the way to shadow of doubt (1943)......
Listen, its quite clear that your parent's never loved you! Otherwise, you wouldnt be on the internet calling people names over mere entertaintment. Also help me understand: You are mad because I made a comment on a show premise being similar to another show premise that could very well be similar to another show premise?
2nd ML is absolute scum I hope by end of series he ends up arrested for attempting to kill his brother.Only 5…
I completely agree with most of what you said, especially about the SML. However, I do not agree regarding the FL. She is equally awful and selfish. I understand she is trying to distance herself from the part of her that is like her father but the blatant disregard for medical ethics on her part should also land her in jail along with the SML.
Also, EVERY damn character IMO is a horrible person on a molecular level except the ML and SFL. The brother, the mother, the father, the agent, the friend, the love interest and the list goes on. I want all of them to be miserable for the rest of their lives with no redemption.
it's just a popular premise. check out japanese movie "world of kanako" or even recent k-drama "perfect family"…
Yeah but this one seems more similar than others with the general premise. I guess we will see how similar or different they are when it releases. Also you might want to tag your post as spoiler as it spoils one of the major points for the Taiwanese drama?
it's just a popular premise. check out japanese movie "world of kanako" or even recent k-drama "perfect family"…
Perfect Family is a convoluted mess where the writers dont know where the show is going. Also 0 character developments so far. They are trying too hard to create suspense and thrill but its just seems extremely contrived.
I am curious about two things if anyone has the knowledge: 1) What is the purpose of these 10-15 min dramas? Why such short dramas? 2) Do these actors manage to break into more primetime/longer dramas? If so how difficult is it?
I get what you are saying, but you also need to understand that Sang Yan's character in FF is not based on HL.…
I have read both the novels and hence I disagree with this take. Like I said, even if you look around you, you will hear many people that are completely different based on who they are interacting with. I personally relate to that since everyone else thinks I am extremely serious no nonsense person but the truth is that I just need to get comfortable and open up to people. And even then, the way I behave with my sibling is nothing like how I behave with my partner.
Another example is HL itself, the way the ML viewed the FL changed completely from how the brother viewed the FL, his sister even though both relationship were brotherly at the start.
Look, I know plenty of people (myself included) who have RBF, but I have never seen an actor whose entire character repertoire is just RBF. Except now, thanks to SJJ. Google her images. Go ahead! I pulled up the first 10 photos, fed them to ChatGPT and even ChatGPT could only detect three expressions. **Three!** Even Han So Hee, who’s been called stiff, manages more variety in her expressions.
Honestly, Hiroshi Ishiguro’s bionic robots emote more than she does. Just get Ishiguro to build a SJJ robot, throw in some AI for voice, and we’re all set—no need for her to even show up. I actually ran another experiment and added her name with various expressions in Google images. Same photos popped up for almost all emotions. I was dying laughing. Did the same with Han So Hee, Son Na Eun, Cha Eun Woo, who are all accused of stiff acting, and guess what? Different images for them for different emotions with maybe a little overlap! Shocking, right?
Honestly, I think a block of wood could do a better job. I have zero respect for her as an artist because she’s utterly lacking in talent. She is just riding on the coattails of her boyfriend. She’s getting more chances because of him, who, let’s be real, got her foot in the door to begin with in the industry.
And let’s not pretend she didn’t have chances to show emotional depth in this series because the character is "supposed" to be strong and confident. She’s being *chased* at the end for God's sake for her life—there should be a mix of desperation, strength, conviction, fear, etc. Instead? Nothing. Even dictators like Stalin and Hitler showed more emotional complexity towards the end of their reigns. Meanwhile, here’s Queen Woo, a woman at a greater disadvantage than any man in her position in history, displaying zero emotional range. Being strong doesn’t mean you’re never afraid or vulnerable. Fear is a survival tool; without it, you’re just overconfident and dead. And that’s why I’ll die on this hill: she has zero talent. She thinks she understands the characters she plays, but really, she’s just on autopilot, which is why all the characters she plays look the SAME.
Also, her so-called "strong presence" that she is being lauded for? Yeah, it looks more like condescension in disguise. Acting is >50% facial expression and the rest is body language and dialogue delivery. If you’re missing >50%, congrats, you’re a below-average actor. Simple as that. And let's not forget, she looks and sounds like a baby wearing a costume in this drama.
Man, JCW and the rest of the team carried the 1 star I gave this drama!
@larius I would just ignore this person, they are already struggling in life, you dont want to add to their misery. Think of it as charity in kind. I know they will keep going because they need to have the last word, often the case when a person is severely neglected and unloved at home. So please let us be understanding.
<3 <3 <3
Also help me understand: You are mad because I made a comment on a show premise being similar to another show premise that could very well be similar to another show premise?
Also, EVERY damn character IMO is a horrible person on a molecular level except the ML and SFL. The brother, the mother, the father, the agent, the friend, the love interest and the list goes on. I want all of them to be miserable for the rest of their lives with no redemption.
1) What is the purpose of these 10-15 min dramas? Why such short dramas?
2) Do these actors manage to break into more primetime/longer dramas? If so how difficult is it?
Another example is HL itself, the way the ML viewed the FL changed completely from how the brother viewed the FL, his sister even though both relationship were brotherly at the start.