Nepeta 22

I think it goes back into the territory of making all other women except for the FL are shallow and thick. This is written too often and especially more so in historic setting. Often the FL is "dragged" unwittingly into this, but truth is a director in China said, female audiences eat up this stuff. That's why it's always in most storylines! Who knows. I find this stuff offensive and boring. So many dramas make up so much of this as filler. So maybe it is true...

I think you will like him in Follow Your Heart. Plays similar to here but with more comedy and flair. He also uses his real voice to good effect.

No worries, it happens to us all. One minute not much, then next all of them pile up. . .

I haven't seen your original posts but if you just say annoying without much explanation, then it will look like you have issue with FL full stop.

Personally I think many on here are aware this is an idol drama and not in anyway expecting realism. I had hoped a bit more realism myself because the title states "legend", but since after 3 episodes in, it's clear, she will get masses of plot armour and it's just a lightweight comedy set in the army. It's nothing to do with the message, females can excel in a male dominated world. If so, she wouldn't act like a little girl (mainstream view of how women need to be to get approval of men) most of the time, & mainly pre-occupied with the ML's plight than her own. No doubt her own revenge will be crammed in the last 6 episodes where the joint couple fight justice together. Happy ever after.

If you haven't seen him in Follow Your Heart, I urge you to see it. It's light comedy and one of the best. If you liked his persona here, on that drama, he plays similar but with more wit and natural flair.

If you read my spoiler just below this comment, it sorts of explains it.

I have also queried this yesterday and was told that most of the explanation was in the early part so it seems in this version, they have decided that's all that is needed for us to know and see. This feels like the missing link.

This is strange since the drama's hook is revenge and we do need to see more of her past family dynamics, her family structure. When I mentioned her father seemed a bit indifferent they said it's because in the novel it was her uncle who caused all the trouble and her half brother was in actual fact actually her cousin, so there are parallel family dynamics going on in the novel. By what they have done here is made it more dramatic, they made it her father and brother so even more backstory is needed, otherwise, FL's character looks really lightweight with her banter and carefree attitude right now. The real reason of why she's returned seems like an excuse just to carry on with her love-fest with the ML. This detracts from the original novel's intention.

I have to be honest, this drama in its own right is a light comedy with a chance to see a modern day girl transported back in time, that is all it is right now. The villains are written in a way to allow her to jump through a few hoops whilst the ML plays the classic stoney faced CEO and she just pushes the boundaries of their status. Easily fit into any other setting. I really feel it should have dropped the english title of "legend" and kept it as "star general". That is more fitting right now.

Thanks for all this info. Very interesting to see if they make any changes in the end. Happy drama watching!

Thank you once again, this is helpful for me. I hope this is somehow added in this drama because up to now, it feels a lack of information on her family set up and spending too much time with her talking army tactics and playing with the commander. Just makes her character seem so light-weight. I'm sure it's not meant to, but the way the drama unfolds feels all wrong for her character.

Her motivation looks like a knee-jerk reaction because she's upset her title was taken from her. The family also didn't see a big thing of her brought up a boy so in a sense, she came to be who she is by sheer accident, it's not her own choice, but once she's now tasted it, and to have it taken away, it feels like her own quest to get it all back and also get those that tried to kill her to justice? But at this stage it doesn't seem like she's got a plan on that yet.

Totally agree. I wasn't sure what kind of drama it would be, but after 3 episodes, it made itself clear. But it's OK, I will just sit back and watch the comedy and stop thinking about females being generals and all this latest fad of 'female empowerment', since much of this is performative and doesn't really tackle or know what it really is.

Maybe there will be one, but it's not this one I'm afraid. This is first and foremost a love story just set in the army. She gets masses of plot armour and gets saved a few times, so there is nothing unique about her character.

Being able spin and wave the sword is just like any other wuxia fight scene. Viewers are mainly captivated by her funny cutesy scenes. Pushing the boundaries of being cheeky with her favourite man and getting away with it. These scenes are easily transferable to any era and any type of workplace set up.

As for the novel, perhaps it was a little dated and too earnest they felt they needed more humour to make these scenes more palatable. Only novel readers will know.

Very interesting, thanks for letting me know. That means this version seem more dramatic than the novel. In a sense, more reason to understand why she was pushed forward over her brother. I feel the father would have more screen time since this family is the main reason she is back for revenge. In order to feel her pain and frustration, we should by now have some kind of back story.

In the novel, (if you have read it), do they explain the reasons for why he was away ill? Or is it just one of those things that is not explained as we just accept it's just shallowlistic greed, he only wants the glory after she gains her position?

Did you read the novel? Don't they go into details later? I'm assuming this is a big part of the story. For instance why was her brother not around in the first place and the reasons. Why is he suddenly back. Also what does her father think about it. So far he seems indifferent.

Just so you know, ratings are usually done by ones that don't normally comment. There is a core portion of users that make accounts for the purpose of rating only. (up or down). It's something that MDL cannot control right now.

I advise that new users are not allowed to review or rate until 6 months have lapsed. That way, hopefully they will have moved on. Most ratings with big novel adaptations or with large fandoms are playing this game sadly. I am not trying to slander anyone in particular, but this is something that is so obvious.

The end result is the rating system is abused and makes a mockery of ratings as being even credible. Smaller dramas or dramas that have less romance are not touched so you will see more average ratings. I think more a realistic rating. Whereas dramas with idol actors & with romance are often inflated regardless of plot and acting. I know what I write is boring and repeated, but those that ask, I always have to say it.

The problem is the modification of her being in her own body means scars are present but her skin is still super white if she had years of training and being in the army this would not be so.

Also, her way of walking, talking is nothing like someone that is supposedly brought up as a boy being forced to be a boy her whole life. It's as if it's giving us a message she so wants to be a woman or girl because of her behaviour. I am totally confused with this message.

You might skip his parts but that's not how people should watch dramas? It's clear, he is there for a purpose? Or don't you care about the wider drama?

Without his character, there will be a large chunk of storyline missing. Aren't you interested in what brought him to be him? Aren't you interested in how he's trapped inside the world he's in and secretly in a lowkey way possibly trying to crush the person he knows is trying to control and use him? Aten't you interested in how his quite obvious weakness with the FL may be his ultimate downfall or saviour??

Anyway, this actor is heavily promoted so this time next year, your type of comment is long forgotten, or dug up for laughs. I saw similar comments for Tan Jianci in Court Lady when he played support in the early part of his career. Those that skipped his parts are long forgotten.

This is adapted from a novel aimed at a target audience. When it's made into a drama, inevitably it will look a bit weird to a wider audience. No doubt, it was made this way for leeway of growth like novels of that type.

I cringe when I watch these episodes of the her prancing around the commander. They want females to be themselves, and sadly that consists of being chid-like, pre-pubescent. Note this is not an accident but through years of a male dominated world that have seeped into the mainstream and even female authors are unaware of being brainwashed.

Knowing this persona is to serve a purpose. Most likely trying to resonate with the target audience against a back-drop of an army setting. Unrealistic, I know. In reality, we all know she would need to modify herself, but the plot armour is firmly in place. I can bet, even when she's general, she will still maintain the silliness and the cutesy persona. Why? It's a Disney-esk version of a female general. We can't have a dusty-faced brute that doesn't shave and follow a ten step facial routine. That's for another kind of drama.

The problem is many of these dramas are lifted from novels that are targeted to young teenagers/young women and when adapted they look Disney-esk because it's now viewed to a wider audience, and this one no different.

They will stretch reality to such a manner that is fit for a child to watch. Anyone over the age of 21 will just watch as a fantasy. Of course young female audiences want to see the most smallest and delicate play a "man's" traditional role & be amongst the men. Boss them about and give them a good telling off. It's pure fantasy with lots of hope. Truth is, these storylines exist because in reality, it's the polar opposite of the storylines inside the novels.

It's not normal. You tend to see this more in the entertainment industry like pop singers, boybands and idol style actors. Only a small section of men look feminine and that's picked up and more represented in showbiz. They push this ideal and it's even more so from the Korean influenced boyband look.

I keep seeing posters explaining this, but the issue is, in this version, they don't even attempt to explain that which leads non novel readers to think this is a huge plot hole that is insulting viewers' intelligence.