I think Jing said it best somewhere in the novel, I can't remember exactly when. He tells FFYY that she didn't…
That's what I love about his story, lots to discuss and there can be different viewpoints. I don't think anyone is condoning her wrong actions, but the feelings of sadness and even empathy for her character are definitely meant to be evoked. It just probably works more for some people than others. It's written into the original novel, and I think much more apparent when it's seen on screen.
I see a lot of FFYY sympathy here which I findβ¦.. odd? She was perfectly fine with TH torturing TSJ and assuming…
I think Jing said it best somewhere in the novel, I can't remember exactly when. He tells FFYY that she didn't do anything wrong in falling for Hou, but she did sin greatly in killing Hou's wife. I think that conversation sums up a lot regarding her character. She is pitiable in the sense of a woman suffering more for her wrong deeds versus a man committing similar crimes, but I agree, she did bad and should answer for her deeds, which she more than does in my opinion. Hou, on the other hand...utter trash. Dude is seriously messed up in his head. He's so busy planning mind games with himself because he cannot break out of his childhood trauma inflicted by his so-called mother. But that's another conversation. In today's terms, he really needed therapy early and often my goodness.
I don't have sympathy for FFYY because sympathy would imply I've had a similar experience, which I don't. I can't really say I have empathy for her either because I agree with you in the sense that she committed great evil in attempting to and being complicit to murders. I'd like to think that I wouldn't let some guy lead me to live a life of crime. But what I do feel is tremendous pathos for her especially in that scene when she is by herself in the dark with her thoughts before Jing comes in the room. Somehow, in the novel, that really didn't come through for me, but through the actress' performance, I feel much more sadness in seeing all these Qingqiu scenes brought to life.
Interesting observations! I'm not so sure of the last one. I think the chess match between Jing, Grandfather Emperor…
You're right, the game with Jing/Grandpa/XY is probably better as a parallel with the scene in S1 as far as playing Go. I guess it's more of the whole sequence of the 3 of them (Jing, XY and CX) together that reminds me of them together in Qingshui.
Lirong Chang is such a good friend to Jing!!LC: Jing, I have an idea. I will find a chance to castrate Tushan…
Even Jing chuckled after he said that. I love Lirong Chang in this, the actor really has great comedic timing - I don't remember Jing's friend in the novel being this funny, if at all.
There have been some great visual parallels between S2 and S1. Some have already noted the scene between FFB and XY on the bridge with the lanterns and the boats going by underneath (compared to the scene in S1 when XL and WXL are in the boat looking up at the bridge). Another is when XY and TSJ are looking at each other and time seems to stop for them, but everyone else is bustling about (also seen in S1 at CX's first wedding). Another one, more subtle, is the chess game with CX, WXL and YSQ in S1 vs the 3 of them eating grilled meat at the restaurant in S2. This last one is interesting, showing how so much as changed since those days at Qingshui Town.
I don't have sympathy for FFYY because sympathy would imply I've had a similar experience, which I don't. I can't really say I have empathy for her either because I agree with you in the sense that she committed great evil in attempting to and being complicit to murders. I'd like to think that I wouldn't let some guy lead me to live a life of crime. But what I do feel is tremendous pathos for her especially in that scene when she is by herself in the dark with her thoughts before Jing comes in the room. Somehow, in the novel, that really didn't come through for me, but through the actress' performance, I feel much more sadness in seeing all these Qingqiu scenes brought to life.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OTOHi5YI94Q