
This review may contain spoilers
Started good
I liked the idea of the premise in general with the pendants and « dying-coming back », I found it I interesting. I liked the leads and I thing the second couple was cute. I really like ML. Sometimes FL was annoying. Both strong leads who knows how to fight.It’s good that their identities were out pretty early.
The brother (ML’s brother) was so annoying, he was there for comedy relief, but personally I wasn’t laughing, I was annoyed.
Also that princess who wanted to marry ML, she got on my nerves. This is one of the worst kind of character. Has one side love for one of the leads, but the leads never showed any romantic interest or interest at all in this person and this person is obsessed in love, want to marry them at all cost (even ready to force it), thinks the leads « stole him », etc…. Completely unnecessary to the plot, to drag and add nonsense angst. Just like the annoying brother.
I enjoyed a lot the first eps, when I got to like ep16, it’s like my motivation and interest dropped so bad. I almost forced myself to finish ahah I got more invested again at the end. I don’t know ahah I was getting stressed at the end with the general. I went through different stages : oh he betrayed them, then no maybe not and he killed the uncle (Chen guy) I was surprised, then finally oh he’s against them after all ahaha
I liked that his brother the emperor never became a bad guy and they stayed close till the end.
Decent ending, happy ending for the 3 couples, I think it was good they went to FL’s country.
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
So, I am no novel reader, I’ve read some comments here about the book, so that’s it, I am not getting opinion regarding that.So, does it leave up to the hype and the long wait??? Personally no
I am gonna finish when the drama is over.
Some positive point to me :
- I like how ML found out very early on that she's a women (ep. 4)
- The leads have good chemistry
- ML is looking very good and definitely fit these kind of role (a general)
- Don’t really see any flaws in term of acting from the cast
- I like the costumes
- Music is not bad
- Some fighting scenes are looking good
- I appreciate the story between the leads, how the romance flow. Their closeness, the building trust. I always thought it was funny how she was handy, touching him (mostly when drunk) and he was just letting her. The soft looks from him, only for her. Eyes speak a lot. Both actually. I really liked the episodes they were undercover as husband and wife, their quality time together, they were very cute. Many good moments, like :
1) Doing her eyebrows
2) Crossing the bridge
3) The dance with the mask and "I love the moon, but the moon doesn’t know"
4) the boat scene,
Etc...
- I like the friendship between FL and her camarade in arm. It was touching in ep 25 when they went with her and how they knew she was a women, kept her secret and didn't care.
- Friendship between the leads and the 2 doctors is also good
- I like ML's soldier, it's funny when he witness the moments between the leads
- they have very few scenes, but the second pairing is cute, always bickering. I hope they make it and actually get married. It was cute ghe bridge scene, they are a good match.
- the moon reference
- intelligent and capable leads
So, this drama is definitely not without flaws. It's hard to overlook, you can close your eyes and logic ahahah, but some thoughts :
- There is some weak editing, directing, transition and pace. I know some will say, "they had to cut some scenes", yes and? I am still wondering, did they actually cut scene because of the side actors? They did some scenes with AI and cut some? Why not doing AI completly ? Does this drama lack budget.
- The writing is questionable at time, Some exemple, I am trying to remember some moments 😅:
1) Still feel off how no one recognize that HF was not the same person
2) The battle and underwatwer kiss : we clearly saw that in was not deep water at all and she fell a few meters away and it was so damn deep, make 0 senses. And ML was very far away and just appeared.
3) ML breaking through Rundu, how? Could have make more sense they are already fighting and he arrives to help.
4) In these story, it’s always unbelievable how poeple cannot see she’s not a man, when she 100% looks like a women. It’s the same in every drama😅 cannot really complain on this, but still an observation
5) The master and the princess fell a bit random story
6) the past between ML and that school friend (what happened after ML's father death), feel like what happened could have been shown before, when we were seeing literally the scenes regarding his father's death and then they meet later. Feel like could have made the flow better. All of this also feel like kinda random
7) SML : it's like writer wants to make SML more present, but at time it’s just feel off and stupid. Like in ep 25 : we were having an emotional and good moments between FL and her friends, then bro randomly appear, "I will come with you too" and ruining this good moment. Why the hell would he go there? For what? More scenes of these 2 and making him fall even more for her? Because it doesn’t make any sense. Why would he go there, he is useless. And don't talk about him playing the flute while the others were fighting. What is this stupid writing. He pups up at time randomly. They also don't make FL straight rejecting him. Most conversations feels vague. He’s always showing everywhere and in every cities where the leads are, does that make sense? Not really and some scenes have 0 purpose
- Honestly, some key scenes don’t really make me feel anything. The actors did okay, I think it's just how it's written. Like the revelation of her identity. Some are complaining about ep 26, the hug during battle. I don’t really see a problem about that. Maybe why was she this panicking? He just disapeared of sight, no indication he was death or hurt. I didn’t feel much here either, but their eyes and smiles speaked a lot. A bit disapointed with the general, she wanted to save him and he felt like a good guy and a great general (on of the 7), but he just felt like an asshole
- felt kinda off how he found out she's a women
- it kind of feel almost dragging, confess and get together already ahaha the little ansgt after he found out how she is, looked a bit like dragging getting them together a little
- I am not that into it unfortunately
I have been loosing a little bit interest, but still enjoying I guess, it's an okay drama. I paid again for the damn express, so I’ll finish it
Eps 27-28 : majority of screentime on SML and the brother, nothing much interesting to see here. I mind less the brother, but SML, I don’t give a damn about his sad past.
FL meeting ML's brother and wife. They seems pretty close, why is he not telling them she’s a women? I liked ML telling hid parents he found someone. Still didn’t make feel much, I saw a clip, someone was crying over this, that wasn’t me at all🙈🙈 I am not emotionally attached
Ep 29-36 :
- feeling stupid how SML keep getting promoted for nothing
- confession scene, the dialogue was beautiful. Kiss was also looking good
- FL’s mom death and the little scenes regarding that. Again, why is this drama making me feel nothing, I had a straight face
- wedding scene between second couple was cute and they were looking good. It was funny how he throw his bride over the horse, fist time I see this in a cdrama. Wish they could have had a little more screentime in the drama. Little bickering couple
- luckily they didn’t kill anyone, well except that one general who should have survived. Pregnant wife, I feel bad. Honestly, could have been one of the friend soldier, I am sorry🫠 his death was nothing surprising though. Like they were showing these happy moments with his wife… I literally said to myself, this guy is definitely dying.
- ep 35 : the little angst and the marriage decree felt unnecessary, but at least the leads reconciled in less than 1 episode.
- They turned SML is the pathetic cliché obsessed guy. Girl gave him absolutely no signs that she liked him and bro was like « she loves me » does she bro🙄🙄 Exile for his ending…. That’s that, at least they didn’t went for the stupid plot of SMl playing hero and sacrificing himself for FL. Why was he lurking and looking at the leads intimate moments from afar. At least it was satisfying how FL was reacting after the marriage decree, she was not taking it. That was good
- The maid : these kind of death always feel stupid. You are a good fighter, but a knife is coming, what do you do ? Fight, trying to stop her or whatever, doing something. But no, I am just gonna put myself in between to get stab
- Brother and villain minister in prison…
- Last fighting in episode 36 was looking okay, the CGI was looking a bit meh with the horses scenes, but nothing can be perfect
- the wedding was pretty
- everything felt a bit rushed in the last ep and for conclusion, I wish we could have gotten more of happy moments. I was also hoping the wedding wasn’t in the last ep, but a bit before. Cdrama writers tend to rush their ending unfortunately. Pretty underwhelming ending
- production and writing was pretty weak till the end
- why do I feel like I was maybe enjoying more the romance before the leads were even dating 🥲
Ending with the moon, which makes sense I guess
I almost forced myself to finish, my interest was low. Not sure how to rate, I always give ratings that are too high. If I compare to some rating I gave, maybe I’ll still give it an 8
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
not like those high budget drama but
The reason I was waiting for this drama was mostly the poster that immediately caught my attention. Happy that this finally came out.Let’s start with the good :
- the osts were honestly so good, never skipped the intro or epilogue
- I liked the plot in general, found it pretty engaging, I was waiting and watching everyday. Feel like I was more hooked by this drama that other popular ones that aired in January, that’s mostly why I gave it a 9, because I rated the other January drama 8-8,5. it wasn’t without flaws obviously, but I still liked it. I will talk a bit about that below. I looked a bit away from plot holes and flaws😅😅
- I liked the romance in general, I think it was focus good on the leads, we got enough of them together, from enemies-hatred to working together friends? to lovers. first kiss in ep 13, another kiss and sleeping together in ep 14, I think the pacing of the romance was good. the kissing scenes were good. I think they had chemistry. After they got back together, I liked how good their communication was. fighting for their love, but also not forgetting their responsibilities, I like that too and how each understood. That was pretty mature. The proposal was cute and how her family accepted him was good. ML became a bit lost in love… she was more clear headed, but both leads pretty strong and intelligent in general. FL was the pillar of her family, handling family business, intelligence, handling second family scheming and saving her family. Her family was pretty weak in those aspect, wouldn’t have made it without her. she gave years of her life and pretending to be a man for her family. Now doing business proudly has a women. I like the conversation between ML and her dad, he knows how much sacrifice she made.
- the costume were mostly good and I liked the men hairstyle, the raids and outfits. ML was very handsome (he had ML aura) and FL pretty.
- the acting : I thought ML did good, never really saw him before, but I’ve seen complaints before. FL is not the best, but wasn’t horrible to me. Supporting cast was okay. SML surprised me with his acting (never seen him before), like I’m ep 24, he expressed good all the emotions during the wedding. His expressions and face acting were good, didn’t need to talk to get how he feels.
- Luo Qi : I really like him, he was kind, loyal and a good character. We didn’t got a lot, but his pairing with FL little sister was cute, made me smile. That was a better second couple…
- Qi Min : though he was an interesting character. good guard and friend to FL. Good fighter. He wasn’t the bad kind of SML. Once he like captured her to take her away to protect her, but like he never force her to be with him or anything. He also accepted at the end he would never be with FL. He lied to FL and her family about his identity, but he protected them and defied the king. He was the king puppet, now poisoned, I think death was peace. Sad he died and felt bad for FL and her family, they were longtime friends and her father, he was like a son to him. Not gonna lie, he annoyed a little with some remarks to ML after ep 20.
- The sister’s bond : I liked the sisterhood, how they loved, supported and protected each other. When they learned about FL situation (pregnancy), reputation didn’t matter to them
- Sun Shao Min : another good character. Strong and intelligent women in a world of man. I like her friendship with the leads. Glad they showed her again in the last ep. succeeding against the bandits. Wish though she was more recognized and gave a good position, she deserved it. But the king is still prejudiced again women. It was sad when her dad died, he was a good man.
- Luo Zhi Zhou : didn’t hate his character, I actually think it was a good twist him actually being an adversary of ML (and doing what he did), but he also didn’t actually want to hurt him and in the end, help him get the title. A fool in love, betrayed his friend for love. He just wanted to protected her and get her out of this life. At first, I wasn’t sure if she still had some feeling for him and also think she was using him. But I think she actually liked him still at the end. When she died, she imagined him, when he died, he imagined her. Their story was actually sad, impossible love. But they found peace in death, that was the only ending. I hated the king when he separated her from her kid, she died without seeing him again. I honestly think their characters were somehow interesting and the acting was good. When he found out she died, I felt his pain and almost cried. the maid screwed up a few things, but she was loyal and another fool in love ahah we saw at the end she liked him. But I liked how she never hurted FL and even went to help her
- I liked how they made it with the leads, both felt the pain of loosing the other, when they both faked their dead. After ep. 23, FL kept pushing him away, saying heartful things (and it became annoying), but after she thought he died, we really felt how much she loved him.
- during the competition, that guy death, don’t remember his name ahaha but the son of that bad guy. It was brutal but good how his plan turned against him, his actions (and his father) lead to his death, deserved. (those 2 are actually one of the few ones who actually got what they deserved).
- In general, good fighting scenes and badass men
- short and not that satisfying, but happy ending
so now the negative:
- everyone noticed that ahaha but bad CGI and special effect, it was very noticeable in the first episode.
- be warned, contains misunderstanding, keeping things from each other, not good communication in a big part of the drama. It was frustrating at time, example (I know it was to lead to the cliff scene but) waiting for so long, the wedding had already started, to tell FL the plan, that was stupid😅anyway wasn’t that annoyed, but it’s present.
- it was unsatisfying both kings no punishment, absolutely nothing happening to them, but at the same time, expected and maybe realistic, what could have happened? what could have the leads done? maybe it would have been more possible the king of ML’s country. Both annoying and power/money hungry, selfish. He was damn annoying when he wanted to force ML
- The ending : disappointed we didn’t get a wedding and we didn’t get to see their kids
- All that time and build up on ML to be the wolf clan leader (Am I even saying the good title😂 I don’t remember the name), to lead to mostly nothing. we didn’t get actions or anything with him with this title, I was waiting for something
- the worst part of this drama is definitely princess QingKou and the second couple. The princess was annoying and spoiled from beginning to end, even if maybe she was less bad in the last few eps. She was doing whatever she wanted without thinking about anything except herself. She added mostly nothing to the drama except annoyance. They missed an opportunity with her and this couple though, it was not written well. We could have gotten somehow good character development, but no. For these 2, for example, the scene when she was having ptsd? not feeling well, they said to get Qi Ming to her, but they didn’t showed any of that. could have been interesting to see him learning about her trauma. This relationship was one-sided till the end. There were some scenes that weren’t horrible, like during the festival. I just couldn’t root for them. She treated him like a dog, a slave for most of the drama. He had to do everything she said, she threatened him, she forced him to stay and be with her. She was acting like he belonged to her. At the end seems like he stayed because he wanted too, but just felt forced. The wedding scene in ep 24, that was horrible. I’ve seen positive reactions on TikTok, « I loved them - how cute - married life starting » I don’t remember exactly but people were liking this. This was just a hard watch and bad, poor guy. He was so happy to marry the FL, the shock, disappointment, sadness, anger after he found out it was her. Both actors did good in those scenes, but SFL is honestly an horrible person. SML had FL in his heart till his dead, hard to believe but maybe he did have somehow some affection developing for SFL, but he loved FL till the end. There is no denying that! Their ending wasn’t a bad outcome, thought it’s good they didn’t end up together. Felt no pity or not really pain for her😬😬😬 Anyway rant over ahaha but disappointing since they looked good together and their story could have been interesting if it wasn’t for the bad writing
So to conclude, I would recommend, it’s not a bad watch, this drama had a different vibe to me and we don’t have often dramas during that period of time
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
turned out so disappointing
what can I say… I enjoyed this a lot at first. The leads chemistry is the strongest aspect of this drama. I watched 16 complete eps, after that only reading comments, watching some parts of eps and spoilers videos. + checking out the last ep. I was waiting for more eps, but turned out too annoying to watch complete episodes later on.pros :
- the leads chemistry
- such passionate kisses, probably some of the hottest kisses I’ve seen in a cdrama.
- FL’s parents, I actually like them. I knew from the beginning the dad was acting and that he wasn’t a bad guy. He loves his family and he wants to protect them. they aren’t the annoying type of parents and they just wanted to live happily together.
- I enjoyed the workplace scenes at first, FL’s journey in the company and her getting recognition for her work
- them being neighbors / landlord ML. I like this trope
- them bickering and the interactions between the leads before dating. I liked their first encounter too
- they had cute moments while dating
- « happy ending » … we will get to it
cons :
- so many annoying and insufferable characters. Who ? :
-> FL’s family (grandma, uncle, aunt, cousin). I hated them, but in the end, they weren’t the most annoying characters surprisingly
-> ML’s sister… she was insufferable, crazy, annoying… name it. wtf seriously. her being in love with her “brother” (adopted brother), obsessed and jealous. trying to break the leads up, scheming and doing some crazy shit, like faking being r*pe by FL’s cousin… the plot around her was horrible and ruined the drama
-> another character that ruined the watch : FL’s friend. Again with this annoying trope that never go away… the friend in love with the lead, that have 0 chance, has been told no and that she only sees him as a friend… but no he can’t accept it and he needs to get her. Again, with the scheming and trying to break up the leads, even trying to work with the enemy. no respect for boundaries and doesn’t know his place as a friend. it’s crazy to me that some people wanted FL to end up with him
- the plot turned out so annoying to watch and the script so bad. so many people scheming against the leads and with the relationship with the second leads : like
-> why was FL spending this much time, staying friend/as if nothing happened with SML after he confessed his love to her. Weird and she didn’t set boundaries with him after being in a relationship with ML. that whole thing wasn’t enjoyable, we know he still wanted her
-> again but now with ML and his sister. he was too much protective, always taking care of her and putting her first (which ended up screwing up his relationship with FL). She’s a grown ass women and also he didn’t put boundaries either with her.
-> the villain were “forgiven” as if nothing happened. no consequences… like what the hell. In the end, they still hang out with the second leads which makes no sense, again as if nothing happened. I know from the beginning it would turned out like this. like why were they even there in the end for ML’s proposal
- ML’s sister and FL’s cousin romance… really weird and uncalled for. completely unnecessary
- such an unsatisfying ending even if the leads ends up happy together and engaged.
I wouldn’t recommend or maybe yess with some fast forward past ep like 20
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Waste of time
Another drama that I was eagerly waiting for that left me with disappointment....It started with an interesting premise. The first half was okay and the only enjoyable part of the drama for me. I liked the dynamic between the leads and how they started to work and scheme together against crown prince and the Meng family. That was honestly pretty fun to watch. We also got some development between the leads and some moments going into the direction of romance. Then we got the cliché stupid cliff scene and amnesia. Honestly, this after the cliff scene, it was just so boring and annoying. Almost nothing was happening... we has FL ''Spying'' on SML (in which lead to mostly nowhere and a waste of time. Finding out he works with the empress, but other than that nada), her being saved by ML and her saying how many times!!! ''we shouldn't see each other again'' or whatever similar things, again and again. That was damn eyes rolling. FL somehow felt pretty stupid in the second half too. What did she even think she can do, a weak women with 0 support. ML also became somehow a fool in love, lost some appeal I don't care. Angst and some problems are inevitable, but how it was done was just so eyes rolling and annoying. We could have had some few eps of angst and after that the leads working together sooner, but that took forever to happen and for them to get together. At this point, my interest was just gone.
Just like in dramas like ''The Glory'', the romance didn't felt much believable at all, after what we've seen and the flow of the story, their romance was questionable to me. I don't believe you can be madly in love after what we've seen and risk his life for her. Chemistry was average. Maybe it was a director's choice, but on another note, not good kissing scenes (well there was only like 2), but not surprising... Liu Xue Yi, we know this man can kiss. no hate, but Meng Zi Yi cannot do kissing scenes. If you have seen some of her past work (even Blossom which maybe was the least worst), you know she can't deliver on kissing scenes. Even in her next project ''Blossom of Power'', if you saw that leak behind the scene of the kiss on the like bridge, you see ML moving his mouth, if the kiss somehow look decent, it's gonna be because of him.
The drama totally went down after the death of crown prince and the cliff scene... That reminded me so much of ''Kill me love me'' in which I also thought the drama died half way after the crown prince death. It is quite similar when we think about it, we have in the middle of the story getting ride of the crown prince (first like villain), then the lead separate and we have FL going with SML for many eps.
The prince and empress were such doll and uninteresting villains, totally forgettable characters. We can be happy that they didn't went for the cliché of him being in love with FL, but that was damn weird making him being groomed and obsessed with her.
36 eps was too much, many fillers and not interesting eps, felt really dragging.
I didn't really mind ML's sister and the younger prince, they didn't annoy me like they did for some. ML's and FL's guards were cute for the little we got.
Some things that I liked :
1) I liked how it went for the divorce with main wife and concubines, pretty amicably. It was all for the best and the little talks between the ladies.
2) Costumes were fine
3) Most of everyone did good in term of acting. ML carried this, he never disappoints in term of acting. Also the Meng girl, the actress did good.
Other rants :
1) First kiss was filmed damn awkward, a shame it had potential. We went from them kissing standing to her on top on him on the bed ?? No in between, that was weird and made no sense for them to sleep together.
2) In the last ep, ML with the poisoning was just annoying nonsense
3) When we first saw FL's brother, he looked so much like a young child and they looked to have a big age difference, but few eps later, he looked like a grown man after how much times ? few months? made absolutely no sense. Flashbacks of them younger, they looked similar in age.
4) It should have been over for the empress on the wedding episode. After that, an episode or 2 for a conclusion, poison issue and ML's revenge. Unnecessary drag. I rolled my eyes. Also, there was no satisfaction in her end.
5) Ending : complete ass ending. Some will call this a happy ending, but that was such a BS ENDING and you can't tell me otherwise. We have ML poison and we don't know when he will wake up, she plant a tree and waiting for ML, the tree has blossom, how much time as past ???? It looks like a dream with how it was filmed and the background. A reunion of a few seconds, a hug, no dialogue, nothing.... How is this a good ending ? A saw someone before in the comments saying how the ending was satisfying. Excuse me, how is any of this satisfying. These are such horrible kind of ending that gives us absolutely nothing, I would rather a sad ending at this point. Also, no conclusion for side characters and what the hell happened with the 2 kingdoms. Some cdramas writers are so lazy and have no imagination or they don't want to give us the endings we want. I have seen some low budget 10 min per ep mini drama that had a better story and ending
We could totally see that this drama had 11 screenwriters and that the main one of the first half wasn't involve in the second half
Do I recommend this drama ? Simply no
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Arranged marriage trope at it best
Ongoing review ahaha I’ll finish later, just wanted to start for myself with some pointers after finishingGeneral points :
1) the costumes were gorgeous to me. Also like the hairstyle
2) fighting scenes were well done and filmed. I like this director style and work, it’s my third drama of him. Impatiently waiting for Shadow Love.
3) Music was okay, not the best osts to me, but the closing song grow on me
4) Great landscapes and scenery
5) I think everyone in term of acting did a good job, top acting from leads to support cast
6) Good cast and I think they fitted the characters. Also the characters had chemistry
7) No love triangle or third wheel
- Qiao Man :
- Wei Shao :
- Qiao Man & Wei Shao :
* First look : the first time they met and say each other, the expression on both their face spoke. His face was like softening and I said how he is probably thinking how beautiful she looks. Even her, she seemed I intrigued or something
* Wedding: I like how early it was, episode 5.
- Wei 4 guards + advisor :
- Wei Liang & Xiao Tao :
- Lady Xu : I pretty much liked her character.
- Wei Yan :
- Bi Zhi & Qiao Fan :
- Qiao Ci :
- Liu Yan :
- Su E Huang : feel like this was a good ending for her, the realization. The actress played this scene very well. How she wasted all that time, scheming and whatever she was doing. She missed 3 times, 3 man who actually loved her. All her fault and bu her own bad choices.
- Wei Liang’s death : it’s even more sad to me watching edits on TikTok, I was crying earlier. I was hoping he wasn’t death a few times, but when Wei Qu got him, I knew it was real. The scene of the 4 generals admiring the moon and how they were like they hadn’t done this for a while and they should do it again. Like that whole scene, we could feel that meant something was going to happen, I was expected at least one death because of this scene. When Qiao Ci I told them he was death…. That room was like filled with some guilt and everyone reaction got me. Wei Qu, who was suppose to go, but made him go instead. Wei Shao who is the one who send someone there. Qiao Ci, who think he should have died instead. Qiao Man, her uncle’s betrayal lead to the death, etc…
- the scene of Wei Qu getting Wei Liang’s Body : that scene was very good to me. Felt the heartbreak and emotion. The actor acted very well. Very cool scene, him puting him on his back, no matter what he will bring him home, when he was fighting too, that looked awesome to me. He is badass. I was so scared for a sec that he would die.
- liked how the 3 women, FL, ML’s mom and grandmother become closer and closer has the drama progressed. His mom finally accepted her at some point and in the last ep, how the 3 of them stayed strong together. After she gave birth, the 3 lady of Wei. The mom was annoying at first, she got some character development.
- Plot in general :
- Ending :
* Happy ending
* Felt a bit rushed to me :
* Disappointed we didn’t saw ML and FL reunite after war was over or him seeing for the first time their daughter
* I liked the scene of Xiao Tao and the 3 Wei general, saying their goodbye to Wei Liang. Their bond is still strong as ever and I appreciate how she’s also close to them. Beautiful scene and emotional.
*
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
a good watched
pretty good for a mini serie. I was watching while airing and I was waiting for new eps.pros :
- I liked the leads. they were good together. Good chemistry and kissing scenes.
- I really liked the relationship between the leads and I enjoyed watching the development of their relationship, them falling in love. From strangers to « fake relationship » to friend ? to dating. they loved each other a lot, trusted each other, pretty healthy relationship. The ep when he asked her to marry him, I loved this ep a lot and made me emotional. Their first interaction got me hooked.
- I like the plot in general and the action
- ML is so handsome and bad ass
- the acting
- happy ending, even if it lasted like 10 sec ahaha
cons :
- the music wasn’t always to my taste
- like some people, I didn’t really like the closeness and skin ship with the second FL, feel like it was a bit too much, even if ML’s didn’t have interest in her. Made me uncomfortable sometimes because he was dating FL, but he’s undercover… so I understand. at the same time, too many scenes with SFL, I would have like less of them and more of the leads romance
- ending was really too short and a bit rushed at the end
I would recommend
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Typical romcom Chinese drama and could have been shorter
In general I like it, there are things I liked and things that I didn’t. It made me smile and laugh, but also annoyed me at time. I also like a drama with multiple couples. I think it’s more interesting then a drama concentrating more on a love triangle, with like the 2 leads and a side or 2 SL with unrequited love. That was here a bit, but not for the entire drama.I didn’t want to start at first because I wasn’t feeling this pairing for the leads. But it wasn’t that bad, they were kinda cute together. The kissing scenes were good, much better outside the drama though. Annoying censorship, they were shorter with not good angles for a lot of them in the drama. But still great skinship and moments
I was annoyed at both of them after her secret was out (how she was using him at first) :
- she was making no efforts and only thinking about work. She lied for so long, she deserved the silence treatment in the beginning. Also, her spending time with Yi Yang was so much annoying, like girl should have told him from the beginning that she’s not interested in him and she should have told him no to hang out (she told him later, but should have done it in the beginning). That guy was so annoying and weird. Bro literally showed up at her parents place and try to get with her went she was already and a relationship, in love with someone else.
- I agree that he had the right to be mad and ignore her, but he still could have let her try to explain too after a while. The breakup was too damn long, both of them incapable of talking was annoying.
The plot was a bit draggy, too many episodes, but still enjoyable. It’s a romcom, you can’t expect much more than that for a plot.
The third couple could have had a better and more interesting story. Their chemistry was amazing, but the misunderstanding and their story kept going in circles before they got together. Since they were already in love at the very beginning of the drama, they should have made them get together sooner, since also all the couples got officially together quite late.
I loved the second couple, I think they were cute. I was looking forward to their scenes, I was patiently waiting for YY to realize is feeling and get jealous.
Anyway too many ongoing dramas, time to pass to another one😂 but I think I would recommend this drama, not everyone would like it. It can be cliche, cringe and dragging misunderstanding for like all the main couples, but it’s an okay romcom
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
I was left disappointed
first of all, I started this because I wanted to watch a BL and OffGun… but in both, it was disappointing for me. It was not BL focus, which I wasn’t expecting. I wish I knew before starting, maybe I wouldn’t have been left disappointedI will keep it short, not motivated to write a review right now
I really liked the first few eps, I thought it was funny and we were getting to know the characters. My rating was like 8,5-9 at some point
what I liked :
- the friendship
- seeing the development of the trainee at work to at the end becoming mentors to their own trainees. even if we didn’t get much with Ryan character I think
- the comedy, had some good funny moments
- I absolutely loved Off character (minus maybe for the last ep a bit) and he looked so good here
- the acting was decent
- I also liked Pah and Pie, Baimon too actually
- chemistry, the few good scenes we got of Jane and Ryan
- Ryan after work
what went wrong for me :
- Bah-Mhee was mostly unlikable
- The hole plot with Tae and Ba-Mhee / Tae, Ba-Mhee and Judy : that was really uninteresting to me and it took to much screentime. It really felt more like a straight couple story with a side BL couple. And how it’s all turned out… how their relationship was, the cheating, them getting back together… couldn’t care less. Annoying that they got a better and longer ending
- Feel like the relationship between Jane and Ryan wasn’t written, development well. We really didn’t see enough of them and the development of their story. And what was that stupid time jump at the end, it was also 5 years… that’s a lot! and they just got back together just like that as if nothing happened and the love is still there as if they never separated? We almost got nothing of them dating and they get back together in the last part of the last ep… didn’t get a proper scene or dialogue either
I watched 4 BL with OffGun, sadly my least favorite unfortunately. Many people said Cooking Crush was bad and boring, but I think it was much better
I guess I could still recommend even with the plot kinda weak, lacking of BL,…. It was still funny.
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Missing passion and boring drama
Waiting for damn express to be over and then I’ll finish this at very high speed, some thoughts for nowThis goes on my disappointing list of 2025. That drama didn’t hook me at all, finding it boring and I am not attached, invested in anything…. Such a lame story. Even for just 24 eps, this is too long.
Everyone talks about it, that topic will never end, but I’ll still give my two cent. A drama without kissing scenes can be okay, even if it’s not my preference (I love a good romance with great skinship and chemistry), if it’s done well and depending of the story. Like exemple, I think it was okay in The demon hunter’s romance. (Even if we got a little peck kiss in that one). It had not passionate kiss, but I pretty much enjoyed the romance either way. At the same time, that drama wasn’t main focus on romance, so we had other things going on
And if the actors can still portray chemistry well and still some kind of intimacy (can be hugs, the eyes speaking, tension, holding hands, cheek or forhead kiss, etc…). We got some of that in here, but for a drama mainly on romance, it was lacking to me, The worst in this drama is not the no kissing scenes policy, it’s that this script was definitely written with intimacy and kissing scenes…. I don’t know who made those choices, but fake weird angle kisses was such an horrible idea. I am not in this to watch a « kids romance ». And then talking about the « passionate kiss, good kisser or whatever » damn weird since we know none of that happened. Just like the hickey…. Such missed opportunity, when you know that atmosphere, scene would have been perfect for a passionate kiss, but we get ML trying, obviously see they aren’t kissing, even looks like his lips are on her nose, her doing absolutely nothing. Ruining the moment. Mistake and miscast were made unfortunately. Maybe that was the less expensive solution, I don’t know, but instead of those fake kiss, couldn’t they modify the script a little and completely getting rid of kissing scenes and having more something else ? But at the same time, would it really had been better, if she’s clearly not comfortable in being close or anything at all 🤷♀️ another possibility someone actually said in the comments, a double for kissing scene 😅 anyway, would another actress really had made this drama better for me, not sure since I don’t even like the plot in general
He’s handsome, but the second guy is completely unnecessary in the story
The leads look good together at least I guess
If we take out the romantic side, I don’t think she’s a bad actress. She just need to find a drama that have 0 romance and mostly 0 contact with male costar if she’s not confortable and can’t act the part. Waiting to see in her next drama starting next week to see how she does
Want An Yu is great. He mostly carried this. It was not my first drama of him (this one is like the fourth ?), even if it was mid, most recent one, I think he gave a great performance in « Such a good love » this year, I knew he would be good here too.
I’ve seen a few comments about it, but I agree the the music wasn’t bad
Directing, editing and all could have been better at time
To be continued…..
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Beautiful and tragic story
Many spoilers ahead.Can’t believe at first I didn’t want to watch this drama, but now it’s probably in my top 5 watch of 2025 so far. I watched more than 20 2025 dramas so far and not many succeeded to keep me really interested, waiting for more eps. I was waiting and watching mostly everyday for this one. I was glued to my TV for the last 6 eps. Made me feel hapiness and sadness. A cried a lot, that says how much I was attached to this drama and it succeeded for me
The Good for me :
- Such a good group and friendship, I enjoyed and like every characters. Their bond and friendship was great to watch. I got attached and felt for the characters
- This drama has many good love story :
1) Baimu Yao x Du Niang Jun : not much to say for those 2, there were there for a such short time, no time to get attached or feel anything for me. But he sacrificed himself for her clan and for her in the end, we can see they loved each other.
2) Yang Yang x ? (man I forgot his name and can’t find him in the cast list, anyway you know who I mean) : ep 8, such a sad episode. The second tragic love story, they just wanted to be together. Zhang Ruo Nan acted very well, I felt her pain. I hated her family, they bullied him even on their wedding day and caused his dead. That was satisfying when she cuted ties with her family and left. That father was the worst. We never say her again, be we knows she’ll alive and should live a few years.
3) Dongfang Huai Zhu x Wangquan Hong Ye : I loved the leads characters and their love story very much. I felt their love, they loved each other so bad, broke my heart at the end. I think their story flow nicely, at first as mask man and then slowly working together and falling in love. They confessed, got together around eps 16-18 ? I don’t remember, but I think it was at a good time, almost middle of the story, I appreciated that. They were cute and I think they had chemistry. The little moments, holding hands, hugs, spending time together. Like at the end of ep 28 ? the marriage proposal or when they did the firework for his sister. She was like ‘’you want to watch the fireworks with me’’. He responds ‘’no I don’t’’, she says ‘’Yes you do’’ their smiles and playful talk, ah I want what they have. They made me smile and cry. They had a pretty healthy and mature relationship, good communication in general, helping, supporting each other, working together throw hard ship. Strong, powerful and great couple. No breakup, a bit distant close to the end which is totally understandable after both and mostly him losing so much. I will talk about the ending below for everyone
4) Wangquan Zhui x Yang Yi Tan : loved these 2. They were cute and also loved each other very much. From childhood companion to friend to engaged. I also appreciated the little moments and when they finally got together. For them too, also middle of the story ? They loved and wanted to protect each other. They never got to get married
5) zhang Zheng x Quing Mu Yuan : another interesting couple. I liked his background, thought that was interesting. They didn’t have much time together ☹ She never gave up on him. the couple that had maybe the less horrible kiss.
6) Jiu Huo x Ji Lan : I liked how they gave almost an episode on their backstory. It made us understand more the villains and how they became like that, how the Black Fox came to life. He did everything to get her back, sacrificed, but in the end he lost her a long time ago. Also the betrayal, she has been dead long ago. He had no will to live anymore and I felt it when he said he wishes for her to be free. We could somehow appreciate these 2 in my opinion even if they lead to our beloved characters downfall, I’ll get back to it when I’ll talk about the villains.
Love in Pavillon has a great main couple and romance, I think that this is one of the things Red Moon Pact failed at.
And 0 love triangle or much of third wheel at all, only that senior who was obsessed with FL, but that was very minimal and very limited screetime in general
- I liked the costumes, setting, scenery
- CGI was good in general
- Some were maybe less interesting at time, but I enjoyed the different arcs and the story, character we saw amount the way,
- Other relationship :
1) Dongfang Huai x Dongfang Qin Lan : I liked the bond between the sisters. Heartbreaking when they lost their father, FL did everything to get her out and save her. Sadly they never met again before FL died. She was a bit annoying to me when she was between the leads, but at least the writer did not get far with that and she wasn’t too much.
2) Wangquan x Hong Ye : another great sibling dynamic. Since they were kids, he has been protecting her, he failed in the end. I cried again when he was in the cave with the masks and when he got to her mask, he broke down crying…
3) It was interesting to see the story of FL’s parents with the flashbacks
- The actors : I think everyone did good. I think I will praise a bit Zhang Yun Long. I think he did a great performance and expressed well the emotions
- The villains of the story :
1) Jiu Huo x Ji Lan : strong, powerful and intelligent villains. Black Fox was such an evil villain. Like damn, that was crazy to see, how she made them kill each other. I actually could appreciate a strong and very evil antagonist. I think in the end, these 2 characters were pretty interesting to watch. Some dramas, the villains can be annoying or boring or whatever, that when they appear on the screen, you want to skip them, but I didn't felt this here.
2) FL’s senior : that was a bit of a led down, just an annoying and not really interesting villain unfortunately. Bro was delulu ahah
Ending: (eps 32-36)
First off, I like how it’s a clear ending, still a bit tiny open because the story is not over, Sword and Beloved coming next, but no BS everyone who is dead is dead, no weird open ending (like cough cough Red Moon Pact). I actually liked the ending. ML and their son, hope for the future, every clan and everyone preparing themselves for what is to come next, getting back on their feet. the Black Fox will come back again some day too.
Also I already knew even before the drama started that almost everyone will die and what is the ending, so I was prepared for what was to come and can’t complain about that.
ML tried to go alone, but they still all followed. They were not prepared enough or ready or strong enough in my opinion. All went to sh*it fast, it was doom anyway with the third eyes already possessed. ML succeeded alone in the end ☹ I like the little talk between ML and his father.
Let’s go down one by one :
1) First off, we lost zhang Zheng x Quing Mu Yuan : His death was a bit of a lead down, I was so happy when he resisted the black fox's control, but died pretty fast and easily at her hand. Even her, she tried, but way to weak to defeat the black fox. Anyway, how to live after this, she liked her lover, at least they died together. I wasn’t that affected by their deaths honestly.
2) After that, the Li brothers : damn these 2 got me crying☹ so that is how he came to be in a wheel chair. I liked the flashbacks, how much the older one loved and protected his younger brother. Sacrificed his hand and life work to save him back then. Now younger brother wanted to be the one to protect and save. He decided to become the vessel and sacrifice himself, but plot twist, the brother exchanged his life with him to save him. The talisman his brother gave him was not a life-saving talisman, but a life-exchanging talisman. I liked how they wrote this. His fate didn’t change, he still lived. And like seriously, how he was so close to see Qui Lan again, not nah, they will never meet again.
3) Next, Wangquan Zhui x Yang Yi Tan and the other group member (I am so bad with names) : how tragic, they made Yang Yi Tan kill his love. The little flashback of the life she dreamt for them, sadly that will never come true. He killed their friend. His daughter will never see him come back as a hero, when that dialogue came up… so sad. Then he decides to destroy his third eyes and kill himself, tragic but the way to stop the black fox from controlling him. Now they can rest in peace together.
All those sacrifices, was it worth it?
4) ML losing them, that man is left broken after killing Black Fox. No will to live or continue. Poor FL also suffering and wondering if he is alive. She just wants to go to the pavillon again with him. Then ML shows up, save her and wedding. Concubine was a bit nah, but it was the plan, FL understood and in the end, she's just like an official wife. Distant a bit at first, which I think is understandable, he lost his sword spirit, depressed? broken, name it… She was so glad he came back. They reconcile and FL made that plan with their child. Their child will be so strong. So sad, they love each other so bad, she knew she was dying and wanted to spend the most time possible with him and their child, but that was short lived. ML was so happy to be a father and motivations. When she talked to the child and said he has to stay with his dad and keep him company, because she knows she will be gone and won’t be able to do it (and he lost everyone else), I lost it and cried again. Honestly cried a lot in the last 4 eps. They never got to go together to the pavillon either. Then her last wish, last hug and it’s over. Their story touched me.
Other points:
1) kissing scenes for every couple were bad
2) Wish they have shown again Qui Lan even if we know she’s alive.
3) The couple in the future: that could have been better and it was stupid how they made her kill herself to get blue eyes back
4) Music was a bit meh at time, but I particularly liked a lot one of the ost
5) I liked how FL found out early that ML is the mask man
6) Had maybe some more boring moments or eps in the first half, but seriously pretty much every drama to me has those. Don't know if I ever watched a drama that had zero boring or less interesting moments
7) they really should not have released Red Moon Pact first
Anyway, to conclude, for me a great watch, likeable characters, friendship and great love story. glad I watch this drama. You need to prepare for the sadness, but I definitely recommend this drama anyway
Was this review helpful to you?

light and fun BL
I wasn’t sure at first, but this BL surprised me. I’ve already watched a few bl with offgun, so I know this pairing and their chemistry. Also it was a comedy relief when it was airing at first with the other more depressing BL airing at the same time.I love the friendships and the relationships. Green flags/supportive boyfriends and healthy relationships. No break up also. I also enjoyed the cooking aspect.
Love grandma and samsee’s parents. Fire and Ten parents had development. Ten’s father could be an ass, but he wasn’t a bad guy. He didn’t mind that his son was gay, he didn’t want him to suffer and him being used and in the end, wanted him to be happy. The step mom was weird and annoying.
Prem’s sister and Samsee being in a relationship was a cute surprise, even if I still ship him with grey hair guy (forget his name for a sec ahah), their bickering and dynamic was hilarious. That would have made an interesting enemies to lovers, but in the end friendship, it’s okay.
I liked the comedy and not many problems or drama. Good kissing scenes from her main couple. I also absolutely love Fire and Dynamite. Their dynamic interested me from the beginning. I liked the development when Fire realized that he liked him. Also a cute relationship.
Happy end perfect ending.
Waiting for the next OffGun drama. Also, get Neo a leading role and his own BL, he deserves it. I’ve seen many BL with him as the side character or the second couple. I really like his acting.
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Love through seven lifetime - beautiful drama
I really love the concept of this drama. I love romance and this dramas gave it. We got to see them falling in love again and they were so cute together. They also have good chemistry and they were together for lots of of episodes in my opinion compared to other dramas. There was no misunderstanding, no break up also.They loved each other so much, they were truly fated and it’s was beautiful to see also the past when they first meet and fell in love. All the details too, like the red string and the soul protector spell. I absolutely loved that
I really loved the ML, he was so cute and handsome. I love his acting. The FL was good too.
It’s was sad and beautiful, made me cry, smile and laugh. The second couple broke my heart too.
CGI and costumes were beautiful. love the ost
Some negative point for me :
- the kissing scenes were horrible
- the second lead was so annoying for most of the drama, I just wanted him to go away and die. He was always in the way and he was delusional if he ever thought he had a chance. At least he got useful at the end.
- happy ending, but I hate 1 min happy ending, it makes me mad. Like the ML died early in the episode, the could have show a lot more of the happy ending of the main leads. I didn’t care about the others and the people in the heavenly realm, they showed too much of them. I read somewhere that in the novel they get married in the end, we needed more. Also, all the talk about completing their wedding, travel together, etc and we got nothing
- also the ending for the second couple, why ? It’s like an open ending, I wanted him to recognize her and run to her. They both left their way.
- so I don’t know in general the ending wasn’t good enough for me, so…. had to give 9,5 and not 10/10
I would recommend this drama
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Not my cup of tea
I think I am gonna drop this for now and maybe watch it in spare time in the background, at least English dub available, it’s easier for that. When I get to the point of watching with English dub while doing something else, it’s not a good signAfter the first 1-2 eps, I thought this could be interesting and I mostly liked it. But I honestly forced myself to watch after that. It is like the story is not clicking to me, it quite boring and I think 16 eps on only one case is not interesting to me. I don’t like much either the main characters and I am not into them. Maybe Kim Jong Hyeon is the character that interests me the most.
I don’t like to compare, but I think a concept like Flex x cop, with in the first half solving different cases every ep was more engaging. Like here we have everything related to one case for 16 eps… I don’t know
Also, could have passed on the cliche of ML having a crush on FL for years. There could have been a way more interesting way to add the romance than this… Should have made them meeting for the first time in ep 1 and the team in general.
I know it’s comedy, but this feel stupid at time and childish? I know ML has trauma and his behavior can be understandable, but I just don’t like him that much. Not my kind of ML
At least the action scenes are pretty good and I think acting is decent
Anyway, to be continued. *** or not, few weeks lager, I am definitely not finishing this👋
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
started off good, but went a bit down hill for me
I was looking forward to this drama. I was like « something different » and I like fake dating trope.I enjoyed more maybe the first half, I think it was funny and I liked where it was going. But around ep 7, I started to loose some interest and became boring for some reason even if I still enjoyed the comedy in general. I think the writing wasn’t that good. The romantic story of the leads became less interesting and not that develop well.
I think the leads have good chemistry and look good together. maybe not enough romance for me.
I also liked :
- the friendship between the sisters
- assistant-ceo duo
- brothers duo
- in general I liked the second couple, but I’m not sure them falling in love made sense with such few scenes. they were cute and think had chemistry. the office date was perfect, when they had matching energy by playing the novel’s character. they had a good ending too
- the fake wedding was beautiful
- ML fake proposal was so cute
- I think the acting was good
- SML coming to save SFL and fighting her dad
- few romantics moments between the leads
- 3FL finally ending her relationship and deciding to raise her child alone (with her sister of course). That relationship was just weird and very uninteresting to me.
SML was a bit annoying but not really
FL’s ex, he was trash. they didn’t give proper closure. what happened ? guy is living happily and getting recognition at work (unsatisfying) and what happened with his wife ? who seemed like a decent and kind person, still think it was trash of FL to not tell her she dated him, he literally dated both of them at the same time and wanted to have an affair with her.
The conflicts between the leads in the last few ep were just cliché and unnecessary… don’t talk to me about the stupid breakup in the last ep and 5-10 min reunion-happy ending. that was trash and lazy writing. Actually, the leads in the last ep in general was bad writing to me. Rushed and unsatisfying ending. The leads dated for real for like 2 sec
And feel like no proper ending regarding the brothers and their father(SML parents I could say too) even second couple and his parents
Was this review helpful to you?