One for the Austen girlies
To lovers of Pride and Prejudice: I strongly recommend The Story of Minglan. You will easily find familiarity in this drama. A sharp-minded protagonist. A well-off but extremely hectic family striving for status. Leisurely pacing to match the domestic world to which Minglan is mostly confined.
The class perspective is also parallel. While there is much empathy for Minglan’s plight as the lowest on the rung within her own family, that empathy is not extended to the servants who follow the usual loyal/disloyal trope that I’ve spoken about in other reviews.
But it also feels a bit mean to make the Austen comparison. I found the Story of Minglan to be thematically richer than Pride and Prejudice. Here’s how:
1. The drama knows to condemn the Bingley character (Yuanrou) for his lack of backbone and perspective, no matter his polite manners and intent. Big thumbs up from me (My ex’s major flaw was lack of backbone,).
2. More importantly, the Story of Minglan acknowledges what so few Western romance stories do: a wedding isn’t the end. In this drama, a wedding can mark either relative freedom or eternal hell. It was quite convenient that Darcy’s parents in P&P are dead. Darcy’s domineering aunt is outside of the immediate household and so Elizabeth need not mind overbearing in-laws. On the other hand, all three Sheng sisters must contend with oppression in their new household in one form or another, whether that’s domineering in-laws or neglectful spouses. The man who Minglan ends up with is depicted as a perfect match not only because he understands the struggles of women but also because he accepts and celebrates her, warts and all.
3. The inner chambers are just as dangerous as any battlefield. While the patriarch may be the source of authority in the household, he is not always the wielder of power. These women wage war and men are factors in their calculations.
There’s much more I could praise about this drama. It’s beautifully intricate and the characters are superb thanks to exceptional acting. Give it a go.
The class perspective is also parallel. While there is much empathy for Minglan’s plight as the lowest on the rung within her own family, that empathy is not extended to the servants who follow the usual loyal/disloyal trope that I’ve spoken about in other reviews.
But it also feels a bit mean to make the Austen comparison. I found the Story of Minglan to be thematically richer than Pride and Prejudice. Here’s how:
1. The drama knows to condemn the Bingley character (Yuanrou) for his lack of backbone and perspective, no matter his polite manners and intent. Big thumbs up from me (My ex’s major flaw was lack of backbone,).
2. More importantly, the Story of Minglan acknowledges what so few Western romance stories do: a wedding isn’t the end. In this drama, a wedding can mark either relative freedom or eternal hell. It was quite convenient that Darcy’s parents in P&P are dead. Darcy’s domineering aunt is outside of the immediate household and so Elizabeth need not mind overbearing in-laws. On the other hand, all three Sheng sisters must contend with oppression in their new household in one form or another, whether that’s domineering in-laws or neglectful spouses. The man who Minglan ends up with is depicted as a perfect match not only because he understands the struggles of women but also because he accepts and celebrates her, warts and all.
3. The inner chambers are just as dangerous as any battlefield. While the patriarch may be the source of authority in the household, he is not always the wielder of power. These women wage war and men are factors in their calculations.
There’s much more I could praise about this drama. It’s beautifully intricate and the characters are superb thanks to exceptional acting. Give it a go.
Was this review helpful to you?
