batatatamusic

This is not a drama you can watch in the background. :)))

I know, I understand, I myself don’t like endless love triangles, etc... However, I've noticed that many people actually enjoy the presence of these clichés. It's also what makes the style of k-dramas successful and distinctive, I think, just like Bollywood style for example (I’m French, just to say). Everywhere, the real issue is how much to Americanize and how much to keep cultural character in a work to reach the mainstream. I think Lee Min Ho (I really like him) has the mission to make this series evolve globally, which is why the series has a lot of ‘Western’ elements. However, it’s also important to keep the drama-loving audience. So, I think the problem with this series is that people who are fans of dramas no longer identify with it because it’s too Western, and for Western fans, there’s not enough experience to reach the same high level as Hollywood in terms of sci-fi.
and For someone who is quite open in both senses, there is no problem mixing genres and experimenting this experience

I really like a lot of things in it; it's a heavy job in many aspects of k-dramas (actors, casting, cinematography, writing ideas), and it's very interesting to watch. If I like it or not, I'll let you know at the end :)

ep 10 ..
Personally, I love the fantastical side of this drama. What I’m hoping for is that the script takes it to the next level. I’d love for them to go back into space for another mission (like Armageddon, lol ), with the same team—that would be amazing. And at the end, ML opens a sort of clinic, as he mentioned at the beginning to his future father-in-law, to allow more people to heal their issues if needed.
This would give a broader perspective on the question of why go so far for a wealthy heiress. It would raise a bold or controversial ethical point, but from a biased standpoint, allowing the series' sci-fi aspect to conclude in an interesting way."

You can definitely watch it and form your own opinion. In any case, right now, it’s the best ongoing series of 2025.

You’re right, but there’s a subtlety. In this dorama, the cliché elements are used in a way that turns them around, making them more realistic and mature. Clichés initially help place the work within a certain 'genre,' but what makes the whole thing original is how these elements are treated—or not—which we’ll see at the end of the series.

Thank you! I find that on this page "When the star gossip" , there are very interesting people. Reading the serie and discussing becomes an enriching experience, as if we were watching together, collectively, in an exchange that is both social and human. :))

Not being afraid to judge a film for yourself means claiming your own critical perspective without being influenced by the dominant opinion, professional critics, or current trends.

In a society where opinions are often shaped by algorithms, influencers, or specialized media, it is easy to follow a consensus without truly questioning "WHAT WE PERSONALLY THINK" . Yet, each viewer experiences a work differently, depending on their cultural background, emotions at the moment, and expectations.

Judging a film for yourself also means accepting that art is subjective.

Review of When the Stars Gossip – Episode 9

By far the best k-drama I’ve watched in 2024-2025! The storyline develops slowly but with great originality, offering a good mix of suspense, unconventional romance, comedy, and action.

Regarding the science-fiction aspect, it’s true that this genre is often judged more harshly, as it appeals to a more discerning audience. However, let’s not forget that even blockbusters like Armageddon, Jurassic Park, or Gravity (and many others, whose major scientific flaws I could detail here) contain inconsistencies. Yet, when it comes to Hollywood, we believe in it? The secret to their success? When a film or series manages to fully captivate and immerse its audience, these details become secondary.

That’s exactly what When the Stars Gossip achieves: despite taking some creative liberties with science, the action, and emotions are so well executed that we are completely drawn into the world of the drama.
I hope that this series, in terms of the sci-fi questions it raises, will dare to fully explore its
concepts.

yes !!!

For me, that would have been cheating if ML, while telling the first girl that he loves her, etc... continued his relationship with her but also had something going on with the second girl. This is exactly the case with FL’s ex-boyfriend – that’s cheating ! I think the author should develop each of the four characters in more depth more quickly. So far, we don’t have much information about them, which is why everyone interprets things differently...and 2 week's fact .... it’s just the style of narration... A perfect example of narration is Hamlet. He’s also an "imperfect hero" with flaws, but we understand and accept him because his character is well-developed. Perhaps we just need to wait until the end of the series ...??

Oh wow, this looks incredible! The cinematography, the actors, and the music all come together beautifully!

Regarding the fact that he found someone else while still in a 'couple,' it’s not badly executed, but it's written in a very realistic way, much more than the fantasies often depicted in dramas where a boy and a girl in their 30s can sleep together chaste while still loving each other. It’s an idea I would even say is dangerous in the consciousness of young people... but then again, it leaves room for us to dream... and maybe that’s what we like too.

If you look at it that way, the first girl also showed the same spontaneous behavior and rushed commitment, so there’s equality on both sides :)

CHEATING....

It's easy to judge a situation like this, but human emotions are often complex and unpredictable. The boy seems to have acted with honesty and sincerity towards the first girl, even though he may have hurt her in the process (when he called to tell her). He respected his own feelings by choosing to follow a path where he felt authentic and honest for the long term, rather than staying in a relationship devoid of true love. However, on the other hand, he broke an implicit promise to remain engaged without feeling true love. At the beginning, he wasn’t sure of his own feelings for the first girl, but now he seems to have found a deep and mature love, which doesn’t rely solely on physical attraction, and he’s willing to sacrifice his life for her in such a short time.

On the other hand, the first girl shows possessive and narcissistic traits, which could have unbalanced the relationship. However, what troubles me a bit in the narrative is the speed at which he seems to have felt this true and absolute love in just two weeks (considering the training before the departure). A connection like that in such a short time... After all, why not? I don't know.

The only real valuable thing is intuition," reminding us that what feels true or important can shift based on our viewpoint. It’s a reminder to consider other angles before forming conclusions. "Everything is relative"

I don't see the point of this article gathering only negative comments to influence others. A review should always be fair and present both sides. For me, this kind of approach is useless, and I’m surprised by how many similar examples can be found online.

That's a valid point! The director clearly took a risk stepping out of his comfort zone, but sometimes even the best intentions don't match what the audience expects. It's a bit like ordering a dish at a restaurant that sounds amazing on the menu, but doesn't quite hit the mark. But in the end, it’s always about readjusting, and each experience brings us closer to the right choice. Maybe next time, he'll find the perfect balance between his own desires and yours as an audience! :))) As a viewer, you have more power than the director.

I love your 1st comment, however I think all the actors you mentioned ( Gong You Lee Dong Wook Lee Min Ho or Gong Hyo-jin are on the A-list actors , and the director (who is much more important than an actor) is also on the A-list. Success is never predictable, but trying to diversify projects and step out of one’s comfort zone is always appreciated in the art of filmmaking. And yes, a script with flaws is something no one can truly fix during production or post-production. But this script also has good aspects; it's not something to discard entirely either.
And sometimes the audience may strongly reject a film upon its release because their expectations were different, leading to a strong reaction. But later, years down the line, they might come back to rediscover and appreciate the work. Conversely, a film might be a success in its time but fail to stand the test of time and fade from memory.

Yes, exactly, I agree with you! I love healthy discussions, and I’m sure having different ideas makes a conversation even better. I’m going to add this thought :)
Watching a movie, a series, or looking at a painting reflects our quest for identity and meaning. If a work doesn’t resonate with us and we can’t relate to it, then it simply isn’t meant for us. What distinguishes a universally recognized masterpiece from a mainstream product designed to please everyone lies in its authenticity and depth. A quality work explores emotions, themes, or universal questions that resonate with humanity on a lasting level, whereas mainstream productions primarily aim to meet immediate audience expectations, often by following predictable formulas. One transcends trends, while the other conforms to them.