drama_loverx

That's not vice versa though? He didn't even show his dance ability. The problem why a lot of people were like "huh?" is because he didn't even dance, and he got A, the very first A as well. Others showed both dance and vocal. I would agree with you if he did show his dance ability and the overall is that he did excellent in both. But he didn't. There's another trainee that was drop to B because he needed a little improvement on his vocal but his dance was excellent while this trainee got A solely just for vocal. Like I said, if they look for the "voice" then he definitely has the potential to be a soloist but he's gonna be an idol. So he has to show he can dance and sing, especially for an A. Someone who is an A should be an all rounder, at least be able to sing+dance or rap+dance or all 3 of these- sing, rap and dance.

I saw on Twitter that his rank will drop because he can't dance well. If this is really true, I hope it won't shatter his confidence.

I went to watch the season 2. So far, the mentors in season 2 had more chemistry together and it seems like they really care for each other, working as a group. I don't know if that's because of the editing that makes this season 3 like this. But yea for their scoring, it actually made more sense to me. Like that 1 girl that had good voice but didn't get an A because she couldn't dance.

Yea. If Kun was in this show, he would definitely agree that that trainee should get B instead of A. I don't hate that trainee. I like his voice and I think he could be a soloist. But for idol group, he definitely not an A if he couldn't show he can do both.

I thought they're looking for idols that can sing, rap and dance, especially during live? Some trainees showed they can sing and dance but didn't get A because they need a little improvement for their vocals. But the 3 mentors actually gave A to a trainee that didn't even show his dance and he said he isn't good in it but could improve. Like, how could you give A to a trainee that didn't even show he is good and capable of singing and dancing? I'm confused on their scoring, but then I could see they focus more on the vocal. But he isn't debuting to be a soloist or sing while standing though. He is gonna debut to be an idol where he's gonna dance and sing. So the trainee that got A is gonna get a lot of pressure if his dancing is bad or he couldn't dance. I was glad that Lisa didn't agree with them and pointed this out because that's my exact thought when I watched it. It could be that the other 3 mentors are soloist while Lisa is an idol (just guessing). I honestly thought it's not fair to other trainees that can dance and sing but didn't get A. Btw, his vocal is good, I like it.