I'm not complaining, but I'm surprised a guest star/special appearance like Choi Hyun-wook is doing so much promo for this? Obviously Lee Jae-wook is in the military (though he did appear at the event the other day), but where are the other main cast members?
~The film raises the possibility that someone other than Moon Se Kwang may have been involved in the shooting,…
Fiction has no obligation to adhere to "the actual truth" by its very definition, made clear also by the disclaimers at the beginning.
"If you stick to the truth, there's no room" ... let me stop you right there. These people don't care about the truth. There's plenty of room. There's as much room as they want. Look to America, their executive branch has essentially made a sport out of entirely ignoring the truth of every matter. You yourself referenced the post-truth world earlier, did you forget? People live in different worlds, consuming entirely different media, and as such have entirely different ideas of what the truth is.
But specifically in terms of historical fiction, it's just become an easy target. For knetz to get the attention they crave (see Perfect Crown), or for cheap political point-scoring in the case of this film. And it seems intertwined with certain aspects of Korean culture, which is why it's so prevalent there.
Meanwhile you have the fictionalized Oppenheimer with plenty of artistic choices not aligned with the facts winning Best Picture at the Oscars and Fjord, a Romanian film fictionalizing a Norwegian child services case in an often provocative way, winning the Palme d'Or in Cannes this year. People aren't up in arms about it, because they understand they're not documentaries.
~The film raises the possibility that someone other than Moon Se Kwang may have been involved in the shooting,…
I don't think the bad-faith actions of conservatives should dictate how art is made, especially because we have seen this exact slippery slope elsewhere. It doesn't matter if you try to placate them, because they will just move the goalposts, find something else, or make something up.
But sure, let's remove everything that could be misinterpreted and any kind of artistic license from all fictional films and dramas; let us only make art that is unimpeachable and cannot be poked holes into or used as some sort of banner-like thing by those with certain political motives.
~The film raises the possibility that someone other than Moon Se Kwang may have been involved in the shooting,…
Maybe certain politicians and conservative groups are the ones who should simmer down considering the very event you are referencing and their support of various anti-democratic currents within the political landscape.
If this is the line drawn for what is "too far" in Korea, they are truly even more conservative, anti-freedom of expression and anti-art than I thought.
~The film raises the possibility that someone other than Moon Se Kwang may have been involved in the shooting,…
This is exactly why the Korean film and TV industry will shift away from historical fiction. If you cannot introduce fictional elements but have to strictly adhere to what is known to be "the facts", then all that's left is to make documentaries.
Based on what you say this film is doing, it seems like another storm in a teacup.
We are going to see a shift away from historical projects in Korea, because the risk of someone shouting ~distortion is becoming too big. This time it's especially egregious because none of the news stories are even saying *what* exactly is being distorted; it's just a vague accusation from conservatives who don't like the story that's being told. Policing fiction in this way is detrimental to art.
Can't make anything historical anymore without this happening. Knetz really need to get a life. Did Koreans somehow collectively forget how movies work? It's not a documentary.
Hopefully no nonsensical "historical distortion" controversy here, but you just know knetz will comb through this drama with a magnifying glass. It's too bad, because if they keep doing this with historical dramas, despite the "work of fiction" disclaimer, broadcasters may shy away from doing historicals.
https://x.com/NetflixKR/status/2108481999975678188?s=20
"If you stick to the truth, there's no room" ... let me stop you right there. These people don't care about the truth. There's plenty of room. There's as much room as they want. Look to America, their executive branch has essentially made a sport out of entirely ignoring the truth of every matter. You yourself referenced the post-truth world earlier, did you forget? People live in different worlds, consuming entirely different media, and as such have entirely different ideas of what the truth is.
But specifically in terms of historical fiction, it's just become an easy target. For knetz to get the attention they crave (see Perfect Crown), or for cheap political point-scoring in the case of this film. And it seems intertwined with certain aspects of Korean culture, which is why it's so prevalent there.
Meanwhile you have the fictionalized Oppenheimer with plenty of artistic choices not aligned with the facts winning Best Picture at the Oscars and Fjord, a Romanian film fictionalizing a Norwegian child services case in an often provocative way, winning the Palme d'Or in Cannes this year. People aren't up in arms about it, because they understand they're not documentaries.
But sure, let's remove everything that could be misinterpreted and any kind of artistic license from all fictional films and dramas; let us only make art that is unimpeachable and cannot be poked holes into or used as some sort of banner-like thing by those with certain political motives.
Let's see where *that* gets us.
If this is the line drawn for what is "too far" in Korea, they are truly even more conservative, anti-freedom of expression and anti-art than I thought.
Based on what you say this film is doing, it seems like another storm in a teacup.
https://x.com/ggonigone/status/2102794574569816175