oddsare

Episode 16 makes it hard to read any other way. Director Zelia appears as Director Li, the director we never see on screen.

Qinglang’s costume while filming Snow Drum Gatha (Xue Gu Ji) was criticized by public opinion as a man dressing as a woman, and the project even lost its funding. On screen appears the following untranslated Chinese text:

酈ZELIA
Director Li, Zelia

花木蘭女扮男裝替父從軍。
Hua Mulan dressed as a man and joined the army in her father’s place.

女人扮成男人，叫英武颯踏。
When a woman portrays a man, she is praised as heroic and dashing.

男人扮成女人，被說是娘炮文化。
When a man portrays a woman, he is labeled part of “sissy culture.”

究竟是文化仇視女人，
Is it that our culture despises women,

還是社會對文化不自信。
or that society is insecure about its culture?

說到底，還是人類進入父系社會，
Ultimately, it was humanity’s shift into a patriarchal society

才陷入男性崇拜的社會認同裡。
that trapped us in a social mindset that worships men.

男何妨，女又何妨。
What does it matter if one is a man or a woman?

都是一具皮囊裹著一個靈魂。
We are each a skin wrapped around a soul.

有人靈還在，有人魂丟了。
Some still have their spirit; others have lost their soul.

有人心明眼亮，有人不分青紅。
Some see clearly; others cannot tell one color from another.

什麼時候人類能放下性別偏見，
Only when humanity can let go of gender prejudice

才是真正意義上的進步。
can we call it progress in the truest sense.

Forty percent brightness is a good way to put it. I think I watched half of it that way too, before people here started pointing things out.

Thank you for reading. It means something that the writing sent you back to the show rather than replacing it.

Some winds pass through the winter sun. Only afterward do we realize the spring hills were there all along.

In Snow Drum Verse, the drum is not there to summon applause. Qinglang once called it “an instrument of torture that can speak with spirits.” When it is struck, the sound moves through flesh, through memory, through the eyes of the crowd, and brings into the light lives that never asked to be understood.

Qinglang appears in women’s clothing and the reaction is immediate. People hurry to name him, to judge him, to turn a role into a statement. But he is playing a fox spirit. A being neither human nor answerable to humans. The fox walks the borderlands. It knows that changing form is not a lie. It is simply how one stays alive.

He is not trying to become someone else. For a moment he lets us see that a person was never limited to a single form.

Then comes Dwelling in the Mountains.

Changyang and Qinglang’s secret place comes into the frame: paths dissolving into mist, unfinished sentences, light resting briefly on a shoulder. It feels like a mountain that asks for nothing. Living there is not a way of leaving the world. It is the decision, finally, to stay with yourself.

Qinglang wins again. On stage he does not reach for polished words. He comes out and says he is leaving the industry.

The applause goes on. He is already walking into the forest.

The forest wedding has no elaborate backdrop. The trees stand as witnesses. The wind turns the pages. Light and shadow pause on each face and then move on. Life and death. Meeting and waiting. Staying and going. All of it seems to settle into the same afternoon.

Buddhism teaches that everything arises through conditions and fades when those conditions change. Not every love needs to be kept forever in order to have been real. Not every farewell is a loss.

Sometimes true hope is not waiting for someone to return.

It is finding that after they have gone, you can still live gently.

The finale is called Beholding.

Not someone fixed inside a definition.
Not a story offered up for conversation.

Just this: somewhere between light and shadow, the willingness at last to see each other as we actually are.

Those lyrics are lovely, and they push back on my line in a way I like. The candle and the moth are old images in Urdu and Persian poetry, where the moth's burning is usually the highest form of love rather than a failure of sight. So your song and my sentence are arguing.

I think both can be true here. Chang Yang has some of that moth in him. He wanted Hunter School badly enough to accept the danger. But he also keeps choosing with his eyes open, which is the part that gets me.

Thank you for the kind words about the Buddhist terms. I learn as much as I share, and this page has been a good place to do it.

And yes, let's find each other somewhere else when this ends. I share your worry that something at this level will not come around soon.

I’ve reached episode 9 of this BL. The title really does fit. Perfectly, even.

In Episode 3, Fei Foon and Leuk To talk about the Hong Kong classic Comrades: Almost a Love Story (1996). Their different views on love seem to foreshadow what lies ahead.

https://kisskh.at/5297-comrades-almost-a-love-story

You’re right, and it’s a strange thing to sit with. A show this carefully made can’t be discussed openly in the place it was made and set.

So the appreciation ends up scattered. Fans overseas on pages like this one, Chinese-speaking viewers watching through whatever route they can find, people writing about it in small corners. No awards, no reviews in the papers, no retrospective in ten years.

It does make me think about how much of the craft here was done with no expectation of being credited for it. Zelia’s camera work, the writing, the way the Buddhist material is handled. Someone made all those choices knowing the show would mostly travel by word of mouth.

Which is maybe why this page feels like it matters more than a comment section should.

Thank you. That’s kind of you to say.

Honestly the show does most of it. I just try to keep up.

This BL feels much like the Chinese language itself. Chinese says much with few words. Much of its meaning lies in what is not said.

Zelia’s cinematography, the Buddhist philosophy woven into the dialogue, and the tension between life and death leave me humbled and in awe.

What makes a classic a classic is not the blindness of a moth drawn to a flame, but a certain lucidity. I find that same lucidity in the singular perspectives of the commenters on this MDL page, and it makes me treasure this space all the more.

You're right, and I'd forgotten Qing Tian eating one straight off the table. So it was termite mushroom after all, and Chang Yang was telling him it's the one you can get away with.

Which makes the soup even funnier. He knows exactly where the line is and warns him the second they cross it.

And I'm with you on the past lives. If they've been finding each other and losing each other over and over, then breaking the pattern is the only ending that means anything. Let this be the life they get to keep.

Oh that's better than my reading. Drunk, thrashing, kicking, biting. A fish out of water is exactly what he was that night.

So the hallucination isn't showing him a future Qing Lang at all. It's the one he already met, just in a form he could finally do something about.

(No shrooms. Your friend will have to make do.)

Actually, thinking about it again, I’m not sure what they were eating raw in the forest was a mushroom at all. It may well have been bamboo worms, which do get eaten fresh out there.

The soup is a different matter. Some wild mushroom varieties carry toxins that heat breaks down, which is exactly why undercooking them is what sends you to hospital, and why the hallucination talk comes up in that scene and not earlier.

Worth noting too that 雞樅 (jī zōng, termite mushroom) is on Yunnan’s official edible list, but even the safe varieties come with standing advice to cook them through and never eat them raw or cold-dressed.

You got there without needing the little people at all. The red carp reads as him even if you know nothing about mushroom season in Yunnan, which says something about how well it's built. ❤️

After the bear, they kiss. Then they’re sitting awkwardly in the hills boiling mushroom soup, and Chang Yang warns Qing Lang it isn’t cooked through yet, eat it now and you’re going to hospital.

Qing Lang says he wants to see the little people. Chang Yang says he already has.

A note for anyone puzzled by that. In Yunnan, where wild mushroom poisoning is practically a seasonal event, 見小人 (jiàn xiǎo rén, seeing little people) is the classic hallucination. It’s so standard that it’s become shorthand for mushroom poisoning altogether. Every season there are jokes online along the lines of “seen your little people yet?” So Qing Lang saying he wants to see them is him half joking about wanting to get poisoned, and Chang Yang saying he already has is an admission he’s been there.

Which makes what follows stranger. Chang Yang didn’t see little people. He says he saw a red carp in a pond that was drying up, and he tried desperately to scoop it out.

The standard hallucination is little people. His was a red fish about to die, and himself trying to save it.

Red carp sends me straight to the red pyjamas. And the image of Chang Yang lifting a red fish out of the water sends me to the Little Theatre in episode 1, where he changes Qing Lang into those pyjamas. Two hands handling someone who can’t help himself. Scooping the fish and dressing the man are the same gesture in two forms.

The timing is what I keep turning over. He’d met Qing Lang once, two years earlier, in that hotel room. Drunk, violent, kicking and biting. Nothing like a man in red pyjamas, and nothing like something small and helpless you could carry in your hands.

So the hallucination isn’t remembering anything. It’s showing him a version of Qing Lang he hadn’t met yet and wouldn’t meet for two more years.

You’re pushing back on the right thing, and I don’t think I was clear enough.

Chang Yang’s point isn’t that animals feel nothing. It’s narrower than that. Nature doesn’t perform. It doesn’t hold a service or build a grave or observe an anniversary. The bird gets returned to the system it came from, and nothing stops to mark it. That’s what he means by mourning belonging to us.

But grief and ritual aren’t the same thing, and you’re right that the first one is clearly out there. Elephants stand with their dead. Crows gather. Whatever a wolf feels when the pack loses one, it isn’t nothing.

So maybe the real split isn’t grief versus no grief. It’s that we’re the only ones who insist on giving it a shape. We can’t just feel it, we have to do something with it.

And thank you for the rest. That’s a kind thing to say. I do think this show rewards the depth you bring to it, so I’m glad you’ve started.

The promise to Director Li, yes. That makes it land differently. He isn’t just filling the year, he’s keeping his word.

And your doof doof point is better than anything I wrote. I went straight to the mystical reading and missed the obvious one. A drum through a wall at 2am really is unbearable, and it’s the repetition that does it. No melody, just the beat arriving again and again whether you want it or not.
Which is what waiting a year feels like.

The bit about the drumming stopping being worse gave me a chill.

That is the honest answer. From outside, no. From inside his life, yes, every time. He could not see the ending from where he stood. He only saw what was wrong and could not leave it alone. That is why he is worth loving, and why it ends the way it does.

Thank you for reading it. That last part is the hard one. He tried to keep Tin out of it too. That was the one thing he could not do, and it cost him the most. Wanting to protect someone is not the same as being able to.

Episode 9, from 49:08. This part stayed with me. I felt how much pain Phob was carrying, and how torn he was.

I watched it three times. The first time for the story. The second time for what he was feeling. The third time for what he was thinking.

He pushed the reforms through. He got everything he set out to get. And then he had nothing. He lost the man he loved. His ideals came to nothing. In the end he became the kind of man he had brought down.

He sees the people at the bottom still suffering. He sees the officials above still eating and drinking and partying. In that moment all his work loses its meaning. For someone who believed in something, that is a hard blow. He starts to question himself. The system changed, so why did nothing change? Why does the world look nothing like the one he imagined? He begins to wonder if he has turned into the very thing he tore down.

His pain sits close to mine. If it were you, would you have chosen the same?

A cdrama getting you through an exam question your textbooks skipped is the best thing I’ve heard all week.

And yes, vast and living is exactly it. It keeps moving, which is what makes it hard and also why it stays interesting. Sorry you had to leave that study behind. Sounds like it never really left you though.