roddib

Who's abnormal: one who expresses their sincere critical opinion or the one who wants to censor others opinions. Learn to respect other people and don't make assumptions about their mental state if they do not agree with you.

Everyone. This a comment section where everyone is allowed to comment. Criticism and praise are both welcome. This is not a fansite. Consider before bashing "negativity" or "haters". Calling people haters is babytalk. Just let everyone share their experiences pls. I might not like someone's opinion but I will fight for their right to express it. Enough of the censorship attempts.

I just want to add that Page Turner is very good indeed. I Hear Your Voice is as good While You Were Sleeping. Dream High is also surprisingly good (I didn't expect it to be).

She is that good. Really. Pinocchio is very good, I liked it even more than While You Were Sleeping. The journalism ethics topic is very interesting in Pinocchio.

I don't agree with you at all. This a chance to for me learn about the history. Not imposing my ideas on anyone though so pls just leave it. I don't like it when someone writes a comment on this drama, there's a league of holier-than-thous who come at them. Whenever someone says a original commenter was wrong (even if I think they're wrong) I block the attacker and not the original commenter.

Quite good, solid mystery drama. Although not anything particularly exciting or novel. I didn't find it boring or draggy at all. Ending is satisfactory. There are some big plot holes but I'd still recommend. The brothers' relationship is the most touching part. Ok Taecyeon and Ha Seok Jin are great in their roles. 8.5/10.

Not everyone wants a happy ending. It's a very bad idea to start changing a drama for just pleasing the audience. Happy ending would be totally out of line considering what has been going on. Their inability to communicate and sheer cruelty toward each other makes the drama very frustrating. The historical events are quite close to real events and make the drama interesting, not everyone is watching just bc of the romance.

the women taken to Qing were considered ruined. The husband is not any different from other men in that era. Having concubines was normal. Wives were owned by their husbands so the decision is not hers to make.

It gets going in ep 3. It's worth watching, imo.

I'm loving this. Not a boring moment so far. Both ML and FL are top tier actors, it's just very enjoyable to watch them. It seems this will not have those annoying filler characters that ruined Destined With You.

Yes indeed. Mingi is my bias. The most cool and charismatic man!

The Red Sleeve (but you probably already saw that). Jang Ok Jeong also, but it is a more traditional k-drama.

Additional historical context: Captain Gu is not "cheating" when he has taken a concubine. In Joseon, wives were rigidly divided into two categories: legitimate wife and concubines. (Women's Life During the Chosun Dynasty, https://ijkh.khistory.org/upload/pdf/6_05.pdf)

Men were allowed to have concubines.

Women were owned by their husbands.

Some historical context: in Joseon, women could not divorce their husbands. Husbands could divorce their wives but only for legitimate reasons (e.g. adultery). The government and king were the ones to decide whether nobility were allowed to divorce the wives who had returned from Qing. But captain Gu is not nobility so he might be allowed a divorce. Anyways, this article explains the tragic fate of the women taken to Qing. "Many women were lucky enough to be repatriated to their hometowns after a ransom was paid. But their joy was short-lived because they were stigmatized as spoiled. Married women from the noble class were not allowed to reunite with their husbands." https://koreajoongangdaily.joins.com/2010/12/29/fountain/The-tragic-fate-of-Joseon-women/2930274.html

As the seller of slaves said, amost on one ever came back to buy the women. The women taken to Qing were considered ruined, defiled, and were not wanted anymore. Here's some historical context: https://koreajoongangdaily.joins.com/2010/12/29/fountain/The-tragic-fate-of-Joseon-women/2930274.html

The series follows real history pretty closely so it's possible to read into what happened to women who were taken to Qing. The husband is not a bad person bc his ideas are the ideas of the people of that era (and not this era we're living now).

Every woman who had been taken to Qing was considered ruined and either sent back or forced to hide the fact. The husband was exceptionally decent in offering to taken her back. People should pay more attention to the actual historical context. Remember how much the scholars despise the king for succumbing to barbarians, they really considered this ruining and debasing their culture. Major trauma.

The series follows real history pretty closely so it's possible to read into what will happen.