2
7
1
This cute romance could have had more depth
What starts as an ordinary "opposites attract" romance -- Ji Won is shy and avoids public scrutiny, while Jeong Woo thrives in it -- with inconsistent characterisations and tropey situations, turns out to be a drama that has a story to tell about homophobia in professional sports. Unfortunately that is only after it's found its stride near the end of the third episode, which is late in a drama of eight episodes.
Overall, it feels as if the writers found it too challenging to adapt the original novel into an eight-episode drama, couldn't decide which kind of story they wanted to tell, and just kept it to the bare bones of the romance part.
(Disclosure: I haven't read the novel, so I can only assume that it has a much more detailed and hopefully deeper story.)
I feel more than the usual disconnect I sometimes have with the Korean acting style, and I feel it's only in part due to the actors being rookies. I think most of it is the script, which leaves large parts of the two main characters unexplored, and doesn't give the actors much to work with:
* Why does blow Jeong Woo hot and cold in the beginning? What are his emotions and his motivations at that time?
* Who is Jeong Woo, where does he come from, why does he play basketball, what does he want in life? What has influenced him so far?
* Where exactly does Ji Won's anxiety about being observed come from? Does it have to do with the (hinted at) abuse he suffered from his first coach?
* What is Ji Won's relationship with his parents like? What part did *they* play in his youth?
* Does he know he's gay before meeting Jeong Woo or not?
* How old is he, and in which year are the basketballers? (I think one of the friends said Ji Won was 22, and they are all the same age -- are Jeong Woo and his friends in fourth year then?)
* How much time passes between scenes and over the course of the drama?
* Several times there are inconsistencies or it's obvious that characters reference happenings that are never shown, or mentioned anywhere else in the drama.
With it, the most interesting parts of the story are only hinted at: How much impact the rampant homophobia in professional sports has -- and how it forces athletes to hide large parts of themselves. How public scrutiny of celebrities can affect their psyche. How abusive the system can be for minors who often are at the mercy of their trainers.
The story had the potential to be much more than another cute romance, which is a shame.
Some thoughts about the directing and editing: I wish the director had been a bit more adventurous. She shows that she is capable of making interesting decisions, like having the camera shake in one emotional scene or using background music sparingly, and letting silence speak for itself. But in more than a few scenes, dialogues are delivered while the characters are standing in front of each other, facing the other character head-on; or walking at a snail's pace -- which reminds me of the static scenes in "Light On Me". This also contributes to the feeling that the acting is seemingly not that good; which is not quite true, because as soon as the actors get to do something and their characters have a clear motivation for their actions the scenes become much more lively and approachable.
One thing that suprised me in the best way: When one character comes out to his friends, he uses the words "gay" and "bi", which is a very rare thing in BLs.
Was it good?
The drama was better than I expected, in that it didn't pretend that all is easily accepted in BL-Land, but that homophobia, especially in certain places like pro sports, exists and restricts the lives of queer people.
Did I like it?
I liked it fine, but mainly because I didn't expect much. It also wasn't the deepest of K-BLs.
Who would I recommend it to?
To those who generally get on with the style of K-BLs, like campus romance and Korean cuties.
Overall, it feels as if the writers found it too challenging to adapt the original novel into an eight-episode drama, couldn't decide which kind of story they wanted to tell, and just kept it to the bare bones of the romance part.
(Disclosure: I haven't read the novel, so I can only assume that it has a much more detailed and hopefully deeper story.)
I feel more than the usual disconnect I sometimes have with the Korean acting style, and I feel it's only in part due to the actors being rookies. I think most of it is the script, which leaves large parts of the two main characters unexplored, and doesn't give the actors much to work with:
* Why does blow Jeong Woo hot and cold in the beginning? What are his emotions and his motivations at that time?
* Who is Jeong Woo, where does he come from, why does he play basketball, what does he want in life? What has influenced him so far?
* Where exactly does Ji Won's anxiety about being observed come from? Does it have to do with the (hinted at) abuse he suffered from his first coach?
* What is Ji Won's relationship with his parents like? What part did *they* play in his youth?
* Does he know he's gay before meeting Jeong Woo or not?
* How old is he, and in which year are the basketballers? (I think one of the friends said Ji Won was 22, and they are all the same age -- are Jeong Woo and his friends in fourth year then?)
* How much time passes between scenes and over the course of the drama?
* Several times there are inconsistencies or it's obvious that characters reference happenings that are never shown, or mentioned anywhere else in the drama.
With it, the most interesting parts of the story are only hinted at: How much impact the rampant homophobia in professional sports has -- and how it forces athletes to hide large parts of themselves. How public scrutiny of celebrities can affect their psyche. How abusive the system can be for minors who often are at the mercy of their trainers.
The story had the potential to be much more than another cute romance, which is a shame.
Some thoughts about the directing and editing: I wish the director had been a bit more adventurous. She shows that she is capable of making interesting decisions, like having the camera shake in one emotional scene or using background music sparingly, and letting silence speak for itself. But in more than a few scenes, dialogues are delivered while the characters are standing in front of each other, facing the other character head-on; or walking at a snail's pace -- which reminds me of the static scenes in "Light On Me". This also contributes to the feeling that the acting is seemingly not that good; which is not quite true, because as soon as the actors get to do something and their characters have a clear motivation for their actions the scenes become much more lively and approachable.
One thing that suprised me in the best way: When one character comes out to his friends, he uses the words "gay" and "bi", which is a very rare thing in BLs.
Was it good?
The drama was better than I expected, in that it didn't pretend that all is easily accepted in BL-Land, but that homophobia, especially in certain places like pro sports, exists and restricts the lives of queer people.
Did I like it?
I liked it fine, but mainly because I didn't expect much. It also wasn't the deepest of K-BLs.
Who would I recommend it to?
To those who generally get on with the style of K-BLs, like campus romance and Korean cuties.
Was this review helpful to you?
