News
The AI Wasn't Giving But The Chemistry Was
Wow, finally a decent CBL! And unfortunately, it comes with AI editing and an AI-generated OST. I'm very 50/50 when it comes to AI. I understand that it has its advantages, but I'm also very aware of the harm and downsides that come with it. Personally, I try to avoid using it as much as possible, although I recognize that AI has already integrated itself into so many aspects of the online world that avoiding it entirely is becoming increasingly difficult.That being said, I generally try to stay away from AI-generated series because I struggle to feel any genuine connection to something when the actors, performances, and entire production are artificially generated. Thankfully, this series only uses AI for certain editing aspects and its OST, which I can somewhat understand if we're working with a limited budget and trying to cut production costs. However, that doesn't necessarily make the execution any better. At times, the editing looks noticeably cheap and sloppy, and it occasionally pulls me out of the experience, regardless of how invested I am in the story.
I also agree with the comment by Rike regarding the OST. A lot of the music sounded incredibly robotic and lacked any real emotion or personality. I even noticed that one of the songs incorporated the lyrics from "Feeling Good," although the actual composition sounded completely different from the original. It was essentially the same lyrics presented through a different arrangement. And honestly, it makes me wonder where we draw the line when it comes to AI and copyright. At what point does using AI to recreate or reproduce existing artistic work become an infringement on the original creator's rights? The idea that practically any piece of art can be recreated with a few clicks is something worth discussing, but I'll save that conversation for another day.
Now, putting all the AI-related issues aside, this was actually a pretty enjoyable series! I genuinely liked the overall storyline, and the acting was surprisingly good. The chemistry between the leads was REALLY good, especially for a CBL. Wow, they did not disappoint in that department! I also really enjoyed the NC scenes, and overall, I don't have many actual complaints about the story or its execution beyond the AI elements.
Honestly, I could easily see this being a 9 or even a 9.5 if it had been edited by actual people and featured a properly produced, human made OST. Considering what I assume was a relatively limited budget, I think they did a pretty decent job with the resources they had. The casting, number of people involved, and sets were all handled quite well, and those aspects genuinely added to the experience. My biggest issue was that the AI-generated music occasionally made everything feel lifeless and artificial, while the editing sometimes disrupted the flow of the series and made it difficult to stay immersed.
But yeah, aside from the AI slop, this wasn't a bad watch at all! I almost ended up binge watching the entire thing in one day, but it got too late, so I settled for finishing it over 2 days instead. I'd definitely recommend giving it a try if you haven't watched it yet!
Overall: 8/10
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
This is not for the faint of hearts
Disclaimer: I stopped at episode 39. 😁 I know my limits, lol.First, if you don't like your main leads dying, STOP YOURSELF BEFORE YOU WREAK YOURSELF. Or do what I do and stop before the last episode. 🤷🏾♀️ Second, this storyline is NOT everyone's cup of tea. It certainly isn't mine. I prefer fun, bubbly, hot-and-heavy romances with LOTS of kisses. This drama was steamy at times, but rarely fun or bubbly. If you're a normal person (rather than a 15-year-old teenager trapped in a 38-year-old woman's body like me) who enjoys "Wuthering Heights", "Jane Eyre", and other moody classics, this might be your thing. Third, the ML is hot because, well...Cheng Lei. 😍 But he's deeply unlikable, especially during the first half. I'm not talking about a green flag disguised as a red flag. I'm talking about a man who will manipulate EVERYONE to get what he wants. And the Fifth Master ALWAYS gets what he wants. 🫠 That said, this was a STELLAR production. Amazing cinema! It reminded me of the old telenovelas I watched with my family. Shout-out to "Rosalinda" and "Marimar"! 😂
Anyway, here's my "superficial" review.
1. Production
This wasn't your typical idol drama. The production clearly invested heavily in costumes, sets, and historical atmosphere, and it SHOWED. The costumes and locations reflected the progression of the Republican era beautifully. The houses were gorgeous, and the ladies served some ICONIC looks! Now, I'm no expert in Republican/Warlord-era Chinese history. 😬 I generally avoid the genre because everybody seems to die tragically. I've seen people online speculate that censorship makes happy endings for warlords difficult, although I haven't verified that. Regardless, the production felt convincing and carefully constructed.
2. Storyline
Very good, well-written story. The characters were fleshed out, their motivations generally made sense, and their personalities felt like normal, complex people. The plot progressed naturally, with a few holes here and there, but nothing that ruined the story for me. What interested me most was the relationship between the FL and ML, which I interpreted as an analogy for the tensions between the peasant/proletarian classes and the aristocratic, military, and warlord elites of Republican-era China, particularly around 1916–1930. Their romance reflects that unequal relationship, and we're never truly allowed to become comfortable with it.
The ML was a WALKING red flag. His love was paternalistic, possessive, and authoritarian. He manipulated, bullied, shamed, and schemed against the FL, supposedly because he loved her. Yet he also demonstrated extraordinary devotion. There is a scene where he risked his life driving up a dangerous mountain to find a doctor who could operate on her mother's lung. Here's the thing for me. His sacrifices and his controlling behavior aren't necessarily contradictory. Both reflect a paternalistic understanding of love in which protection, provision, authority, and possession coexist. Similarly, powerful elites could act as benefactors to poorer people while simultaneously reinforcing the inequalities that deprived those people of independence. And that's the fundamental discomfort of this romance. He genuinely loves her, perhaps profoundly, but loving someone doesn't automatically mean respecting their autonomy or recognizing them as an equal. His sacrifices are real, but so is the harm he causes. The drama gives us a relationship in which affection and oppression coexist rather than allowing grand romantic gestures to erase the imbalance of power.
3. Acting
The acting was stellar! We had quite a few industry heavy hitters, which almost felt unnecessary. 😂😂Some highly respected actors, including one portraying an antagonist general, had roles that didn't fully justify their talents. And then there's Jeremy Tsui. I LOVE Jeremy Tsui (although you'd never know from the amount of crap I talk about him), but...what exactly was his purpose here? 😂 Was he the guiding narrative voice? The ML's conscience? His therapist? The mediator between rich and poor? The voice of reason? I understand the possible intention, but understanding a character's function doesn't necessarily make their presence satisfying. Perhaps the drama was originally intended to be longer than 40 episodes, and some characters lost important development. I don't know. But several scenes simply didn't resonate with me. These are fantastic actors. I just wish the writers had given them more meaningful material. But hey, money is green, and everybody needs it. I ain't mad at them! 😂
Now, the female lead! I actually love Ruohan. I've enjoyed several of her dramas, but I'm not convinced she had the emotional range this particular character required. She did her best, no doubt. What I wanted, however, was innocence layered with richer emotional textures, contradictions, and psychological depth. I don't know whether this was an acting limitation or a directorial choice. If we're interpreting her character as representing the oppressed classes being courted by the wealthy elite, her suspicion and resistance make perfect sense. But here's my problem: she never convincingly made me believe she loved or desired him. 😂I wanted a tortured, reluctant lover. Someone slowly realizing she's falling for a man who represents everything she resents. I wanted confusion, hesitation, unexpected tenderness, suppressed smiles, and anger at herself for developing feelings she didn't want. During those earlier scenes when she supposedly began falling for him, I honestly wouldn't have known what to feel without the flashbacks of him practically begging her to admit her feelings.
I wanted her to ACT the confusion! Instead, she kept giving me "EWWWW!" when I needed "Ewwww...wait...MAAAAAYBE?" You know that Kombucha Girl meme? THAT! 😂😂😂She could admire his courage while resenting his arrogance. Appreciate his kindness while rejecting his control. Fall in love with him while remaining uncomfortable with everything he represented. THAT was the emotional complexity I wanted. Instead, her romantic development sometimes felt asserted through dialogue, flashbacks, or amnesia rather than earned through her performance.
The female antagonist/love rival could also have been stronger. You can tell the actress is still relatively green, lol. I wanted considerably more subtlety. Her villainy would have been far more effective through fleeting cracks in her carefully constructed "nice girl" persona. A disappearing smile. A momentary expression of contempt. A subtle shift in her eyes when nobody's watching. Instead, we got...whatever she was doing with her teeth. 😭😂 Girl, why was your entire dental arrangement participating in the villainy?! Her expressions sometimes announced her malicious intentions before she had even done anything. I wanted to catch glimpses of the monster beneath the mask, not watch her repeatedly remind us that she was wearing one.
Now, Cheng Lei!! 😍😍😍 He was GOOD. He's gained enough experience to deliver solid, convincing performances, and I think he's a dependable male lead. With stronger scripts, more challenging roles, and continued experience, I can see him becoming a serious contender for major acting awards. My advice? Stay away from these characters, sir! 😂 A LOT of work for relatively little reward. You spend an entire drama portraying an emotionally constipated, manipulative, possessive man, only to work twice as hard convincing us there's someone lovable underneath all that nonsense. Cheng Lei did his job, though. The Chinese romance girlie in me simply didn't like his character. Lol.
4. Romance
Now comes the embarrassing part. I ACTUALLY LIKED THE ROMANCE! Hehehe. 🤭😂 I KNOW! After everything I've said about the ML, you'd think I'd hate their romantic scenes. But no. Apparently, I contain multitudes. 😭I still don't like the ML as a person, and I'm not excusing his behavior. But I genuinely enjoyed how he treated the FL later, particularly when his affection became less about conquering her resistance and more about loving her. And listen, with a father like his, is anyone surprised he grew up to be an emotionally dysfunctional asshole who doesn't know how to love properly?! That explains his behavior. It doesn't excuse it. Blame my romance-crazed mind, but there's something SO attractive about a reformed rake who becomes hopelessly devoted to the woman he loves. 😍🤭REFORMED being the important word, thank you very much. I don't want manipulation and bullying disguised as romance. I want a man who learns to channel that intensity into tenderness, respect, and genuine devotion. And when we finally got that version of him? OH, I ATE IT UP! 😂
Also, can we discuss Ruohan's romantic chemistry?! That woman could generate chemistry with a ROCK if you told her it was her male lead. I don't know how she does it! 😂 Whatever reservations I have about her emotional range here, she is exceptionally convincing during intimate scenes. She can portray a demure, innocent girlfriend while delivering genuinely passionate romantic interactions. She allows physical intimacy to unfold naturally, without making every movement feel choreographed. I also appreciated how their physical closeness developed progressively. The ML was ALWAYS on top of her. 😭😂 Always touching her, pulling her closer, wrapping an arm around her, keeping her beside him, and doing those adorable little boyfriend things men do when they're completely obsessed with their girlfriends. UGHHHH. I LOVED IT! 😍 Those little affectionate gestures made the relationship feel lived-in. Rather than relying entirely on declarations or dramatic sacrifices, they communicated attraction through familiarity, touch, and increasing comfort. Cheng Lei brought intensity and longing, while Ruohan brought softness and natural physical responsiveness.
Ironically, I found their physical chemistry more convincing than the emotional development that supposedly brought them together. I believed they enjoyed being close. I believed the tenderness and attraction. What I struggled with was the earlier psychological journey that transformed her resistance into genuine desire. But once they started behaving like an actual couple? Listen. Sometimes the romance girlie wins over the literary critic, and I'm NOT apologizing. 😂💕
5. Would I Rewatch or Recommend It?
Would I rewatch the romantic scenes? ABSOLUTELY. 🤭The entire drama? HELL NO. 😂 As stellar as this production was, I skipped A LOT of the war stuff. Bro. SO MANY PEOPLE DIED. 😭 And some of those deaths were GRUESOME.
THAT MACHINE-GUN SCENE?!
IONLIKEDAT! I knew that man was going to die. I had accepted it. But did they REALLY have to do him like THAT?!
And the sexual assault scenes? No, thank you. These men were NOT good people. That's all I'm finna say. I understand that the brutality served the historical and political themes. But understanding why something belongs in a story doesn't mean I want to watch it.
Now, the romance was great. TO ME. 😂 To be fair, I grew up reading Danielle Steel, Barbara Cartland, and all those sweeping romance epics featuring complicated, emotionally dysfunctional, and sometimes downright unlikable characters. The dukes were ALWAYS assholes for some reason. Like, sir, is that a requirement for inheriting the title?! 😭😂 So I'm familiar with the arrogant, possessive romantic hero who eventually falls hopelessly in love. I understand the fantasy. But do I actually LIKE these men? ABSOLUTELY NOT. Because outside fiction, you KNOW this ML could have spent his life being a "soft" narcissistic menace to every woman romantically involved with him. Manipulating, controlling, and emotionally tormenting people while insisting everything was motivated by love.
NO THANK YOU!
Still, Cheng Lei gave this otherwise difficult character a modicum of likability. And it's ALL IN THE EYES! I don't know what else to tell you, but that man has **puppy-eyes acting on LOCK!** 😭😍 The longing! The vulnerability! The way his expression softens when he looks at her! SQUEEEEEAL! He could make this menace look like a wounded puppy desperate to be loved. That's TALENT, ladies and gentlemen. 😂
Final Verdict
Look, man. Lol. Food and gas prices are hella high. Can't nobody afford to buy a house. And we've got all kinds of nonsense going on with the people governing us. WE DO NOT NEED THIS KIND OF SADNESS RIGHT NOW.😭 Life is already doing entirely too much. If you absolutely NEED to watch Lament of Autumn, wait until we have another president. If you're in the United States, that is. 😂 You deserve a happy show, and THIS IS NOT IT. Was the production excellent? YES. Was the acting largely fantastic? ABSOLUTELY. Was the story compelling? Definitely. Did I enjoy the romance despite wanting to fight the ML half the time? Unfortunately, YES. 🤭 But did I need all that emotional devastation? NO, MA'AM.
In my head, the drama ended when she came back home. Everybody survived, our lovebirds lived happily ever after, and THAT WAS THAT. Whatever happened afterward? I don't know her. She doesn't exist in my personal canon. 😂
If you can appreciate a beautifully produced tragedy, enjoy the romance, and mentally rewrite the ending to protect your peace, go ahead! But if you're emotionally invested in fictional characters, dislike tragic endings, or simply don't have the bandwidth for this much suffering? It's a skip for now, friend. There are plenty of excellent romances that won't leave you needing three business days to recover.
And with the way things are going in the real world, I think we've earned a little fictional happiness. 😂💕
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
To be a Double , you have to Double the Revenge!
Can't believe I completed watching this series in less than 3 days. It was a good story but pretty ambiguous ending. I mean I saw the 6 minutes special, but I assume it to be an alternate story instead of canon. So canonically, he died on battlefield right? Also, did she indeed have a daughter or was that wishful thinking to just satisfy audience with an special episode.Also, if the ending was left as it is without special episode, then yes, this was indeed a great story and daring writing.
Loved all the characters, the costumes, the color grading and especially the music.
This is indeed one of the best costumed/historical fiction Cdrama I have watched.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Happy overall drama
Of course the main storyline of the drama is about the survival of a small orchestra through politics, music. Along the way some great character growth of individuals (musicians, including the leads). This drama is also about the triumph of classical music, mainly the romantic era classical music. So love stories and romance as subplot are natural and expected.With excellent filming, actings, it is overall a happy, light hearted, very easy watch drama, not necessary only for those who love classical music. Highly recommended.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A Short Situational Drama
It's a cute situational drama that you can watch on your down time.•❅✧❅✦ STORY •❅✧❅✦
Because it's a short situational drama nothing really romantic or dramatic happens. The plot literally revolves around our ML starting a new job and meeting a senpai that catches his eye, and that's it. There are a few cliche trips and falls that out them in odd situations that turn "romantic" in the eyes of our ML, but other than that no real build up. Everything is in the POV of our ML, so we don't see what the senpai thinks about our ML. However, this is a short situational drama, so it doesn't really bother me too much as the drama did what it set out to do.
•❅✧❅✦ OVERALL •❅✧❅✦
If you over-analyze the drama, then yes, it's a short low budget drama with a cliche and subpar script. But if you actually take the drama at face value and view it as a short situational drama, it actually gets the job done. It wasn't bad, nor was it good, but it did keep me occupied for 30 minues. So, in that aspect, it did get the job done.
I enjoyed watching watching this short drama. It probably won't be rewatching it ever again, but it did accompany be during my lunch break and I had a good lunch while watching it.
Was this review helpful to you?
A great concept but a disappointing presentation!!!
A drama with good concept attracts viewers but it frustrates them if you failed to present it well!!!I deeply regret my emotional investment into this drama for over 2 months...i am burned completely by watching their toxic relationships - that being said ,i don't like any couple relationship in this drama( most toxic fl-sml to least toxic ml and sfl, none i liked in all honesty)....
i am more disappointed with writer about character growth in this drama which keeps me frustrated throughout the series...
i don't like writer not addressing importance issues of suicidal thoughts and ignoring it completely..
i don't even like the ending of long term relationship - coz it ended in a disappointed note with couples regretting meeting each other..why ? atleast give a sweet farewell to all the memories shared..
i am also disappointed with dialogue writing in this drama...
i am completely disappointed in this series...i understand the concept they were trying to present but the way they presented i can't give more than 3.5/10 rating ( only coz of great concept)to this drama...
Hoping i never get tricked into such drama ...
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A Drama That Offers Both Entertainment and Insight
Themis is such a great drama that provides us with both entertainment and valuable insights throughout its storyline.It is a legal drama in which the protagonist is a judge who strives to uncover the truth, rather than simply making judgments based on the evidence presented in court. The storyline introduces various cases, with a particular focus on cases involving minors. These cases may seem simple on the surface, but they carry much deeper implications because today’s minors will become tomorrow’s adults.
One thing I particularly appreciate is how the drama connects the first case to the final case. The way everything comes full circle is incredibly satisfying to watch. It makes the entire storyline feel meaningful and well-planned.
Moreover, the conflict between upholding the law and protecting one’s own children adds another layer of emotional intensity to the drama. It raises difficult questions about justice, parental love, and whether we can remain objective when our personal feelings are involved.
Overall, Themis is more than just a legal drama. It encourages us to reflect on justice, responsibility, and the lasting impact of our actions on the next generation.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A quirky story of redemption
Amber is an ambitious, unscrupulous barrister that is all about the money. She finds herself in front of the King of Hell who has terminated her time on earth early because of her fast track to wrongdoing for pay. As the story progresses she has to examine herself and her opinions of others and is strongly encouraged to make better use of her time if granted a redo. This fantastical tale gives us a view of her experiences between worlds as she takes baby steps to redemption. It takes a look at relationships, biases, and personal character to pivot perceptions in a different direction and have clearer views of how others feel and why. Her route to redemption includes helping both the living and the dead face their mistakes and regret to make amends and/or change course to a better version of themselves. When that is not possible, how to continue on to our best life anyways even if not accepted by those we care for most. I would really love a season 2 for her to come into her own with a practice in both worlds. But if not, this is complete as is and was an entertaining watch. Highly recommend.Was this review helpful to you?
OP is very fun to listen to
First off, I love the OP and the club music that they used. I also liked that it sounded like they were really trying to talk over the club music, and honestly, they might have been.The pacing was slow; each episode felt weeks long. This was probably due to the fact that the story for both couples was boring. I thought they'd do more with Dean and Moth. They are low-to-mid-tier red flags, so nothing actually bad happens other than them being flippant about each other's feelings. They aren't as physical with each other as I was expecting either; they were very tame. I was expecting them to start a physical relationship and kind of go from there, or for Moth to be in on the plan (he kind of was, but also not really), but for them to start "dating" threw me off. It wasn't bad, but it wasn't expected. It felt like I was oversold on a concept that should have been more twisted than it was. Our side couple wasn't as much of a driving force to keep Dean trying to win Moth over as I expected either. That was the starting point, and it was dropped pretty much right away. All of the people Dean was "talking" to also just disappeared from one episode to the next with pretty much no explanation. It didn't help that it didn't feel like we got to know much about the characters besides surface-level stuff.
None of that bothered me much; it was more like an "okay" shrug-and-move-on type of thing. I've seen too many horrible shows to let these kinds of things bother me when the overall show is alright. The only thing that truly bothered me was the dialogue during the couples' dinner after the time-skip felt like it was happening right after Dean and Moth got together, not 3 years later. It was weird listening to a conversation that should have happened years ago happen as if no time had passed at all.
The acting was fantastic all around. William and Est had great chemistry, as always, and their hand-holding scenes are still great, though they didn't outdo the one from ThamePo that I'm still obsessed over.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Dark Mystery That Keeps You Hooked Until the Very End! ?�
🖤 DEAD-END JOBDead-End Job is an unforgettable drama that blends mystery, suspense, and psychological tension in a way that keeps you hooked from beginning to end.
What I loved most is the intriguing storyline, the dark atmosphere, and the unexpected developments that make every moment more interesting. It constantly keeps you curious, making it difficult to look away!
A captivating experience with a story that really stands out. If you enjoy mystery, suspense, and darker dramas, this one is definitely a must-watch!
Was this review helpful to you?
10/10 out of this world
This drama has everything, the plot is thoughtful, the actors are amazingThe two male leads acting does the story justice
If you think its problematic because of teacher/student trope you don't need to worry ,its not like what you think
It's story of misunderstood care and misplaced love ,where everything is wrong but no one is to blame
And an story of lost souls flocking together
It's one of the best series I've watched
Strongly recommend
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Honestly, I would give it a shot on a boring, slow afternoon.
I really enjoyed this show. I don’t even fully know how to explain it, but it just got to me. So many people called it a show about cheating, but by that final episode, I realized it was never just about that, it was about two people drifting apart. And it’s not an ordinary relationship where you can just pack up and walk away. They have so much history and their lives are so deeply intertwined that they’re almost family before anything else. That’s what makes it hurt.If I had to sum up the whole gist of the show, it’s really a story about moving on.
If you look at it from the writer’s perspective through Lee Mi Do, yes, she’s a deeply flawed character and she got so much backlash, she was actually the very center of everything. She showed us what it truly feels like to struggle with change. And to really get that, you have to look at her family, because that’s where the heart of this theme lives:
Her mother: She lost her husband young and had to raise her kids through that grief. Fast forward to the present, and we see someone who has learned how to live through loss and adapt. Mi Do has been frantically fighting and grappling with everything changing around her, and her mom gives her the exact advice she needs at the right moment: don't fight it, don't fear it, just go with the flow.
Her older brother: He came off a bit disjointed and awkward, but underneath all of that, he was just a good man who was always there for his family. It breaks your heart a bit because a man who puts family first still ends up divorced, and the show doesn't even give him a simple answer as to why. Yet, he is forced into change anyway. He has to keep moving forward, even when life isn't in his favor.
Her younger brother: This one hit the hardest. He’s drowning in grief over his late fiancée, so withdrawn that everyone thinks he's strange. But really, he's just consumed by regret. The most painful, powerful part of his story is that his fiancée actually expected him to move on. She thought he’d sell the karaoke place and find her last gift to him, finding closure years ago. Instead, he stayed frozen in place and suffered for years. It’s a heavy reminder that sometimes the very answers you're searching for are waiting for you on the other side of letting go.
So while everyone was arguing and debating over who was cheating on who, they missed the most beautiful part of the show. It was never about the mistresses or the mister. It was about two people on a painful journey where you have to make the hardest decision of all, to leave something you hold dear behind so you can actually grow.
It was about change and moving on, and the show was a masterpiece in how it showed that. If you're just starting it, I hope you view it from this angle and really feel it. It’s such good material.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
The Story of a Lifetime, of Kin, and of Women
Kind of the show of a lifetime, and what a lifetime Shen Jia Lan aka Xu Lan Xiang has had. This is a show about survival, with only little revenge although the female lead certainly had grounds to hold a grudge. However, bearing her mother’s last words in mind for the rest of her life, Lan Xiang would choose to live life to the fullest, holding people accountable only when necessary, and trying to stay out of harm’s way as best as possible. Because what is glory if you’re unsafe. The more powerful you are, the more danger you will face. What is power if you have to watch your back and protect your entire clan every step you take? It is not worth the effort because harm can come even if you’re innocent.What I loved most was this beautiful focus on kinship. Kinship means so many things, and blood relations do not automatically mean that one is kin; “Against the Current” proves this time and time again. The real Lan Xiang’s parents take Jia Lan and raise her as their own (so much so that our female lead reacts to the name in her mother’s last moments at the end of the series…) The servants Lan Xiang works with in the beginning—Gan Tang, Bao Gai, Xiao Lian—become her sisters in name, and once she marries into the Lin family, the girls and women slowly start to depend on her, knowing that she will lend a hand and be there for them. So much so that their relationship becomes second-nature once they have matured into women in their 30s, teasing each other, caring for one another, and protecting the family as a unit. The final panorama scene was absolutely shattering; all these women who at one point finally lived life on their own terms, all of Lan Xiang’s kin.
Her relationship with Lin Jin Qi is an interesting one. He takes matters into his own hands when he forces LX to marry him, however, those who thought theirs wasn’t a romance—I disagree. I think there was such an intriguing aspect to their relationship. LX and LJQ had romance, but maybe not a love story. Those are different. No grand declarations, but actions defined their relationship. Maybe out of duty and necessity, and yet it takes guts to do what LX did by saving JQ in the cold and protecting him while he was gravely injured. I also appreciated Tan Song Yun’s subtle acting in those moments when LX was clearly conflicted; I think she did have feelings for the male lead (even before it’s made more evident), however, due to their complicated history, on top of the marriage decree (and thus taking her autonomy as well as ability to remarry in the future should she wish to), LX did not waver or had her judgment clouded.
One character in particular had such beautiful development over the course of the show, and that was Xiu Wan. From this silly young girl, who was manipulated and used, to this strong-willed young woman. I really loved XW, and how she was a girl’s girl of her time: taking Xiu Ru’s side during the concubine debacle; wanting to help Xiu Lai without a second thought, and going to Lan Xiang because she knew LX would help and find a way. I just love how these girls grew into women with aspirations (and fighting for those!).
The last few episodes moved rather quickly, and the plot is accelerated through several time jumps. I did not mind too much, though the pirate plot and maybe even Scholar Han’s death probably took up much more time in the initial stages of editing. These plots, I’m sure, were meant to be longer, teased better, resolved better. Like I said, I don’t care too much because I still enjoyed the show very much. Visually stunning, great acting, wonderful music/score, and a beautiful life story. Truly beautiful. I think I shall miss this one…
Was this review helpful to you?
One of the best titles in 2026!
It's such an interesting series to watch, really. It was my first contact with NetJJ, and I'm hooked. Yeah, I get it, I'm getting it. Now I'm talking about the series....I think it has some little problems with the directing. It's a mix of JJ being a rookie and the direction not guiding him well enough in some episodes, because it's got way too comical, to the point that it feels embarassing to watch in the early episodes. Towards the end, that improves completely. I also think it's partly a matter of JJ sinking into the character a little more, get more used to it. Still, for his first time as a main lead, it's very good. It's not a bad performance, really not. But Net is not a rookie. He's a much more mature actor, and it really shows: his acting is so perfectly on point that it's so satisfying to watch.
I really love the whole storyline of Love Upon a Time. It's beautiful and well made. My only problems were the over-the-top comedy in the first episodes and the rushed ending. In some episodes around the middle the story moves so slowly, and then, when we get to the end, everything is squeezed in. I think the pacing wasn't distributed well across the episodes. That doesn't make the series bad, not even close, it's just that at some points I think it could have been done better.
The production effort to make a series set 400 years in the past is beautiful. You can really see that the whole team was passionate about what they were doing. Overall, it's a fun series that balances comedy and emotion really well. It's deeply emotional without being heavy.
The only other thing that felt a little off: this is a series where you have to be patient. If you make it through the first episodes, you'll find gold. But those first episodes are very confusing. I think it's a directing choice, because the main character is confused and we see everything from his point of view. So you're confused with him, but it makes the viewing experience a bit tiring. I think there were smoother ways to do it. Still, it's a very fun series, and easily one of the best I watched this year. I really enjoyed it.
Was this review helpful to you?
Doesn't go anywhere.
This will hurt me badly since WilliamEst is literally one of the couples that I am ACTUALLY a fan of, but I have to say what I have to say. It's not good. I think it's not horrible either, but it's not good. I will divide it into what I liked and what I didn't like.What I liked was their acting, because both William and Est gave everything they had to these characters. They were very excited to do them, and it's upsetting because a lot of the scenes they did, and were super excited to see, were cut. They did improvisations and gave it their all, so you look at the final piece and feel disappointed.
What I didn't like was, first of all, the whole storyline. It's not my cup of tea. I don't like the miscommunication trope. If they just sat down and talked, the series would have been 3 episodes. It was boring. The secondary couple also didn't add much to the story. I like Barcode and Kin, and I think they are good actors. I just don't think it worked here, because their storyline, which is not their fault but a screenwriting problem, bored me.
At some point, I was also bored by the main couple, Dean and Moth, because I have a lot of problems with the whole plot itself. It was a little off and doesn't go anywhere. We finished the series without knowing anything about the characters. You know the basics because you're watching them, but they don't have many layers and aren't developed as characters.
People make a lot of theories and interpretations, and I think they are being a little biased, because in the end this wasn't in the director's mind. You are interpreting that because you are a fan, but the director wasn't thinking about it, because if you really just look at it, we aren't seeing anything. William and Est were doing their best, squeezing the series to make it work, which is honestly so...
I don't even want to get into the production problems, because the sound was off in most episodes and there were a lot of errors in post-production. It's just upsetting. It should have been a lot better bcs that's one of the most important couples of GMMTV.
Was this review helpful to you?




