News
This review may contain spoilers
I have many questions...
The script isn't really clear to me. There's so much missing, and I was left with so many questions.I really missed seeing more of Big Jane's life. It feels like the story focused more on Little Jane's life, while Big Jane was made to seem like a bad person, but he really isn't. That's just the way he lives his life.
The opening song is, of course, amazing. No words! I've been playing it on repeat. ❤️
PUT's death. Nobody mentioned it, there was no sadness, and they just completely glossed over his death. Why? He was the best person in the entire series! ❤️
Dan's life also needs its own story.
Rating: 7.5/10 Only because of Big Jane and his incredible acting. Also, PUT, Dan, and the OST. ❤️
Was this review helpful to you?
ENGAGING STORYTELLING, AMAZING ACTING, UNPARALLELED CHEMISTRY
Editing after completing the series:The acting is PHENOMENAL, the chemistry between the leads is natural and downright SIZZLING, the romance is realistic, these people actually act how people in love are supposed to be acting. The writing is solid and it is obvious every little detail in the story has been carefully thought out.
I have watched maybe every bl there is to watch and I can confidently say this is one of THE FEW BEST out there. I'm so looking forward to what Auau and Save and DMD gives us next. I'm sure it will be something to look out for..
This is an extremely fascinating look into the industry, and it has also very interestingly resulted in a life imitates art situation with all the toxicity certain fandoms (you know which ones) are currently engaging into, which would be hilariously ironic if it wasn't annoying, toxic and probably damaging to the artists' mental health.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
I WILL REWATCH
i love this series SO MUCH, ThomasKong and AuauSave are sooo good with their chemistry. I will definitely rewatch this series because of how enjoyable this was, loved every second!it's also a really good series if you're not that big of a fan of spice, of course there were some kissing and nc scenes but they werent explicit.
I loved the storyline of this bl, which made it one of my favourites. it's really easy to follow and truly a comfort series if you're feeling down. I definitely recommend this if you want a heart lighted and fun bl to watch.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A Cinematic Masterpiece Misunderstood
The drama ( in my opinion) is a Cinematic Masterpiece Misunderstood by the Masses While many casual viewers fast-forward through the slow-burn pacing or get distracted by the explicit rating, The drama (Again in my opinion) is a brilliant, layered masterpiece of psychological tension. Director Jung Ji-woo did not create a commercial, fast-paced K-drama; he crafted a meticulous, character-driven tragedy that explores the dark, messy corners of human desire, jealousy, and social constraints within the rigid Joseon era. The plot execution is precise, treating physical distance, fleeting glances, and subtle touches as an entirely separate language. For those on kisskh who complain about a "lack of plot," confusion should not be mistaken for a lack of direction. The narrative web is tightly spun, and every single scene serves a structural purposeA Masterclass in Acting: The Main Trio at Their PeakThe true pulse of the drama lies in its phenomenal cast. Ji Chang-wook, Son Ye-jin, and Nana deliver absolute acting masterclasses, providing subtle, understated performances that require the viewer’s full attention to appreciate:
Ji Chang-wook (Cho Won): His transformation into the ultimate Joseon libertine is spectacular. He balances the playful charm of a notorious playboy with an intense, vulnerable undercurrent. The shifting layers of his performance—especially as he begins to realize he is drowning in genuine, dangerous emotions—are breathtaking.
Son Ye-jin (Lady Cho): She portrays her character's internal contradiction beautifully. There is a chilling calculation in her gaze, yet a profound, aching loneliness beneath it. She manipulates an entire room without ever raising her voice, breaking away from conventional, loud drama villains to give us a multi-dimensional, brilliant noblewoman stifled by her era.
Nana (Hui-yeon): Nana infuses the virtuous young widow with a quiet vulnerability that completely elevates the character. She is not just an innocent, helpless pawn in a game; Nana plays her with her own distinct desires and emotional agency. Her gradual emotional awakening and the complex "push-and-pull" chemistry she shares with Ji Chang-wook are among the most gripping elements of the show.
An Example of Brilliant Symbolism: The Widow's Room (Confucianism vs. Christianity)To truly understand how deep and complex these characters are, one only needs to look at the powerful, symbolic set design in Hui-yeon's room. Pay close attention to her wall: it is covered in wallpapers of Confucian texts, representing the suffocating conservatism, rigid social expectations, and moral duties forced upon her from the outside as a widow in that era.Yet, hidden beneath that layer is Catholic Christianity. In Joseon at that time, Christianity symbolized the underground, the yearning for freedom, and a faith born from the heart rather than establishment dictates. This wall is a perfect reflection of her psyche: outwardly, she is completely imprisoned by the public expectations demanded of her, but deep down, her heart is somewhere else entirely, longing to break free and experience genuine emotion. This is visual storytelling at its finest.
The Pansori Soundtrack: Cho Won’s Hidden Monologue (Episode 4)Another brilliant creative choice in this adaptation is how Director Jung Ji-woo anchored the show's entire sonic palette in Pansori—the classic Korean musical storytelling medium.A prime example of this genius is found in Episode 4. Instead of using conventional, lazy voiceovers or forced dialogue to explain Cho Won’s inner world, the director uses the rhythmic, aching cadence of the Pansori singer as a direct proxy for Cho Won's internal monologue. As Cho Won pursues Hui-yeon, his playboy facade begins to crack, revealing a hollow void and a desperate longing. The Pansori doesn't just play in the background; it acts as the raw, unfiltered voice of his subconscious—vocalizing the intense emotional conflict and hidden desires that he cannot speak aloud. It is pure cinematic poetry that demands a patient, attentive audience.Bottom Line: If you watch this drama at 2x speed or look only for conventional, comforting K-drama tropes, you will miss the brilliant nuances in speech delivery, musical metaphors, and micro-expressions. The Scandal is an artistic triumph meant for audiences who appreciate high production values, complex grey characters, and raw human emotions.
I've already seen it twice to get to the bottom of the little nuances. I recommend not rushing to dismiss it or criticize it because of the comments. 10/10
Was this review helpful to you?
How a close friendship between two boys has nothing to do with the subject of being gay.
I really don't understand why it has this rating!!! How is it possible for such a superb series to have a rating of only 7.9?!? Are only romantic dramas truly worthy of appreciation?It was a funny, emotional, and meaningful drama. I absolutely loved every single character. To see genuine friendships, to witness how a son's rebellion is softened by an absolutely wonderful friendship... that really touched me deeply.
I not only liked the characters, but the actors also gave outstanding performances. Although I don't know any of the actors from this drama, I already plan to watch some projects featuring Xin Yun Lai, who plays Gao Yang.
I liked not only the relationships between the students but also those between the adults—such as the one between the principal and his childhood friend, the PE teacher Gao Bin. Although one of them had advanced in his career and had a stable family situation, he did not look down on the one who was faring poorly in every respect.
This drama is anything but superficial; it captures the humanity, the sincerity (such as the moment Zhao Jia Bao declared his feelings for Jin Bei Bei in front of everyone, and her quick, honest reply that she didn't like him back- a moment that made me laugh out loud) and the effort to do whatever it took, even studying!!, to remain with friends who were like family.
Everyone grappled with their own inner conflicts, but the focus was on the beauty of love and friendship, regardless of status or age. When a drama portrays this, I personally consider it a worthwhile way to spend my time watching it.
I appreciate that there wasn't even a hint of a gay undertone. Friendships between boys do exist, not just the erotic romantic relationships I see increasingly often in dramas.
I gave this wonderful series a 10 and wouldn't take back a single point.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
What a chockhold
Let me start with the obvious: The props are plasticer than plastic and the budget is so low they couldn't afford extras to fill the empty spaces in the open air scenes. So why such a high score? Bc it's a rewatch and not only I didn't skip a scene, but I binge watched!!! Blame it on the stars (have the planets aligned?), autumn 's coming, summer's over, the world has turned upside down, I am in a parallel universe or maybe under a spell, blame it on the boogie, because why am I crying over the supposed improbability of their love???? It's the second time I'm watching this, I know how it ends!I spent the last 15 eps struggling along with them to overcome a set-in-stone fate, shedding tears bc their chemistry is really believable ( though the kissing scenes need some redo) and their love makes sense. Or not, I'm not sure anymore. I'm actually appalled at myself, I used to have cdrama standards but I was humbled by a web series. How the mighty fall... I'll definitely rewatch.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
This is what happens when your intrusive thoughts invade while writing a fanfiction.
The story itself is actually boring, but the acting, that still somehow manages to be mediocre, is what makes it all gloriously unhinged. I burst out laughing a lot purely because of the ridiculousness of the plot. And still, they somehow managed to play one of the best enemies-to-lovers trope I've seen so far. Not because the acting was good, but because it was insane.The actress playing He Weilan was really good at portraying being hopelessly in love. The switch to assassin-self was meh, but her cover-identity was spot on.
Lots of neck grabbing and biting. Honestly, after episode two I just kept watching cause I wanted to know who else is going to get bitten. You have to totally suspend your disbelief regarding anything and then you will enjoy this series.
Unfortunately all the themes of womens empowerment and equality in relationships get lost in the slew off other nonsense. With long teeth I will admit that the FL keeps true to her character throughout, but only barely. One think I will say, the leads, as a couple, have very good chemistry, once they get to the lovey-dovey phase.
Was this review helpful to you?
Cuts show
I’m so glad that I finally went back and watched this show. I had accidentally watched the second half “Sky in the Clouds” first and felt like I was missing a part of the story, so its nice to have the full story now. In general I found this show a quick and easy watch and I actually felt that 8 episode length was perfect for the story. I enjoyed the characters in this show and most of them were familiar faces for me at this point. Im a fan of Joong and Dunk so it was nice to see their first work together as a main couple. Dunk’s character was very cute and had some funny moments and he also really did well in some of the more emotional scenes. Joong also did a really good job as well, I did notice that he tended to be a bit stiff at points but he has improved alot since then in his other roles. I couldn’t stand Typhoon he was very pushy and just couldn’t accept that he was being friend zoned, also I feel bad for Pepper who plays Typhoon as every show I’ve seen him in he has played a character I didn’t like. The side characters were all really great, but it was a little weird they were all trying to date Daonuea.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Fun
The villain plot really lost me. I get really annoyed at Chinese shows who redeems bad parents. Like you wrote them as an insane person, then at the end you're doing everything you can to make all the insane things seem pitiful because "actually they did all that insane stuff because they love their children too much." This kind of propaganda is exhausting.But otherwise, the drama is quite humorous. I love Ren Su Xi, and you can always count on her acting to be natural. Guo Jin Fei is quite funny.
Was this review helpful to you?
YinWar Are Back
...and better than ever. No shade to their past productions but it's obvious that they have evolved so much.Take the action scene in the first episode for example, the quality is so good.
Overall, the actors are doing an exceptional job, the pacing is great, the jokes land and YinWar's chemistry is through the roof!
I'm very much enjoying this ride!
Was this review helpful to you?
Really fun suspenseful and thrilling drama
This kind of everything-goes-wrong-and-the-mess-keeps-growing template is not new, but they managed to keep it interesting. I think it was quite natural despite the general nature of these types of drama (over-the-top / exaggerated, which is part of the humor). It helps that the main cast's acting was spot on.Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
A promising drama, yet too dry emotionally and too much lecturing
Against the Current starts with a strong title and themes. The premise is promising, and the story sets a clear direction as a career drama, a social commentary, and a story of women’s empowerment. ATC could have become China’s Jewel in the Palace (2003) or Oshin (1983) if only it had stayed true to its promise instead of going off track. Unfortunately, after episode 20, everything starts to fall apart. Calling ATC a masterpiece would be an overstatement, given how much it still has to learn about telling a meaningful story about women.Admittedly, there are aspects of this drama that deserve appreciation. First and foremost is its impressive production quality. It reflects a significant leap in Chinese drama production, showcasing the producers’ growing technical ability to create something aesthetically pleasing and elegant that still feels modern and contemporary rather than dated. And what I love most about ATC is how it manages to capture the beautiful side of humanity despite the dystopian world it portrays, where slavery exists, and women are treated as property, denied the same rights as men. Even in a society shaped by oppression and inequality, there is still room for kindness, compassion, and human connection. Moreover, ATC realistically portrays ordinary people and family life. It gives its community real substance. The city is not merely a backdrop for the characters’ stories or a temporary stop along their journeys. It feels like a living, breathing place where people build relationships and find support. It is somewhere they can return to, call home, and feel safe.
However, the drama has serious flaws that steer it away from its intended direction and ultimately undermine its aims.
First, all viewers know the central question posed in the very first episode: “Why do some people become slaves?” The question comes from a young noblewoman, and the story unfolds as she herself becomes a slave and comes to see the world from the bottom up. However, the story that follows offers little reflection on this social issue. Instead, it shifts toward a feminist narrative in which women are portrayed as victims of a tyrannical society who must be liberated, even though men suffer under the same system of oppression. This imbalance is genuinely frustrating and makes the story feel contrived. When the FL finally rises to become a high-ranking lady herself, we don't even get something as simple as her helping the poor escape the grip of poverty, giving alms to low-ranking servants, or showing kindness to their families. By this point, the protagonist should have learned the answer to the very question that started her journey in the first place.
Second, ATC focuses on women's achievements as they become more empowered and gain greater freedom. Strangely, it barely shows how they learn or what they go through in the process of learning. This entire aspect is missing, and its absence feels particularly jarring in a drama that aspires to tell a story of women's empowerment. There are no scenes showing the FL learning anything new, as if she had already become a perfect woman under her grandfather’s guidance back when her noble family was still thriving. Nor do we see her friends making an effort to learn to read or develop skills beyond domestic work. In this drama, people seem to become accomplished overnight.
This is where ATC differs so profoundly from the legendary Jewel in the Palace, for example. The learning process is at the very heart of Dae Jang-geum’s story: we follow her journey from a low-ranking palace cook to a physician serving ordinary people and eventually a royal physician. Even by the end of the series, she never stops learning, exploring, and discovering new things. Her achievements feel earned because we get to witness the struggles, grit, curiosity, and continuous learning that make them possible. Everything feels super rewarding, and viewers get the chance to celebrate every milestone of her journey from zero to hero.
On the contrary, in ATC, after the FL is freed from slavery, she works at a shop, but the drama never shows how she actually runs it as an entrepreneur. She just somehow manages to bring in huge profits. Later, she becomes an opera singer, but we never see her explore the art form or learn to sing. She just happens to have a beautiful voice. Eventually, she becomes a playwright, yet the drama never shows her learning the craft or going through the creative process. She simply becomes successful. In the end, the only answer the audience is left with is, “Because she used to be Shen Jialan.” Even when she was still a slave, there was barely any trace of who she used to be as a learning person. There was no sign of her secretly learning new things, being curious, or trying to better herself.
Third, the FL’s perfection is another problem that makes the drama increasingly boring. There is simply no character development. She reacts to changes in her surroundings, but she herself never really changes. Her worldview, thinking, skills, and personality remain just as perfect as ever. As the story’s moral anchor, she is too righteous, too self-righteous, and too preachy toward the people around her. Yet she never seems to learn from them or allow herself to be challenged or corrected. She comes across more like a goddess or a saint who comments on everything happening in the story rather than someone who is actually part of it. Meanwhile, the other characters keep singing her praises, leaving the audience wondering exactly what makes her so deserving of all that admiration, since we never get to see the process by which she becomes the person they claim she is.
Fourth, ATC underappreciates the ML and has far too many antagonists. Moreover, the ML and antagonists are poorly characterized. While ATC glorifies its perfect FL, it fails to give the other characters much depth or explore their more positive sides.
The ML, a highly capable military man, is reduced to a man hopelessly in love with the FL, spending years pining for her while being stripped of his broader social role until he ends up doing little more than staying at home. Personally, I don't need a woman-empowerment story if it ends up perpetuating a subtler form of injustice toward men, portraying them as foolish, blind, and incapable of living up to their full potential. What makes the ML’s fate even more tragic is that he keeps professing his love for the FL until the very end of his life, without ever receiving so much as a single word of reciprocation or even a thank-you for loving her. Was this intentional on the writers’ part? Why is the FL so reluctant—or downright stingy—when it comes to expressing her feelings or reflecting on what love means to her while her man is still alive? Even in her old age, she seems to have no fond memories of the life she shared with the ML to look back on. That is why the romance in ATC is so poor, bland, and dry emotionally.
Meanwhile, the antagonists are portrayed as one-dimensionally evil, irrational, crazy, and stupid, with little effort to explore their humanity or what drives them to act the way they do. The antagonists have no stories of their own and seem to exist solely to highlight the FL’s righteousness and moral superiority, lecturing the audience on what a person is supposed to look like. Another thing I don't understand is why none of the antagonists gets a chance at redemption. They all meet tragic ends, paying for their wrongdoings with their lives. One dies after being raped and severely injured, another takes her own life by slitting her throat, and yet another dies in a fire. They are women, too, so why does the story show them so little compassion? Where is the gentleness and humanity that the drama seems so eager to celebrate in other parts of the story?
Fifth, I'm not entirely sold on Tan Songyun's casting as the adult Shen Jialan. She does a good job with the role, but her facial features look noticeably different from those of the actress playing the younger Shen Jialan. The resemblance is weak enough to make it harder for me to buy them as the same person. Perhaps the production team could have found a younger actress who looked more like Tan Songyun, or an adult actress who more closely resembled the younger version.
Ultimately, what disappoints me most about ATC is not that it fails to become another Jewel in the Palace or Oshin, but that it comes so close to becoming something truly meaningful, only to squander its own potential. It has the production quality, the premise, and the world-building to tell a compelling story about social injustice, human growth, and women's empowerment. Yet, somewhere along the way, it seems to lose sight of what should have made this story worth telling in the first place. Instead of letting its characters grow, struggle, learn, and earn their achievements, it takes shortcuts, glorifies an almost infallible FL, and leaves the rest of its characters emotionally and morally underdeveloped. What a waste of such a promising story. I went into ATC hoping to watch a woman rise against the current, only to find a drama that doesn't quite understands what it takes to make that journey worth rooting for.
Was this review helpful to you?
Decent
If you've watched Chinese dramas back in the day, this style can be kind of familiar (reminded me of Gloomy Salad Days which I loved). If you're new, it can feel a little dated. You can tell the production budget was not high. But the actors do a great job, and the acting was natural. There were some stories that had my attention more than others.Was this review helpful to you?
Healing but slow paced
its a slow paced drama right at the beginning you already know its about healing and finding your place in life. Sometimes you get lost in life and it is all about finding joy and a meaning in life. I realised when watching this drama I do not have to watch everything with much attention to know what is going on. The only parts were the parts with the main leads which was interesting to me.What i like: all the main characters, scenery and the slow paced romance which is very believable.
What I did not like: slow paced, music, too many side characters which did not bring anything to the series.
Was this review helpful to you?




