Required a flow chart...
...to really get the details of what was going on. And a spread sheet would’ve come in handy too.The time travel elements were confusing, even for people like me who read a lot of a time travel novels. The trajectory of characters going backwards and forwards in time wasn’t always clear.
Two characters were sharing bodies with other characters in at least three time periods. One character, with two different names but a single identity, was hopping back and forth between decades and even managed to get together with himself at one point–so the two of them (one of them?) could figure out what to do. AAAaaarrgh!
The dubbed English actors all spoke in monotonous voices, and the acting seemed stiff, awkward, and mechanical. It was a noble attempt–with a lot of problems. Five stars.
Was this review helpful to you?
Expected more
I had high hopes for this show because I have watched both of these actors before, but it really did fall short. Maybe I came with too high of an expectation for them. The romance was good, but compared to other time travel dramas, this one really did not hit the standards like the rest. I think i was more confused with the ending than most of it. Though the cinematography was really nice, but I don’t think this show is one of the best time traveling dramas I have seen. I do wish the ending could have been played differently.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
ALOT ADO
I watched 9 full episodes than I just wikipedia'd it. It started great, then the story just devolved into something that I lost interest in. They had some scenes that didn't even make sense with the story & I especially hate when they do cameos to get extra watches ie: scene with Rowoon as gay love interest then immediately ends both just sucks & why was it relevent to the storyline as a whole. Again, the actors held up their part but the story was conveluted & too jumping back and forth into decades ust didn't do it for meWas this review helpful to you?
Everything and more
This drama right here is a masterpiece. It’s one of those very good dramas that come once in 6-7 years . It may sound like I’m exaggerating but honestly I felt a lot of emotions while watching this .It wasn’t perfect though as there were some loopholes here and there but not enough to deny or distract us from how much of a good drama it is .
I’ll totally recommend this drama to anyone and I’ll add it to my 2016 list of best dramas released . All the actors did a great job .
It’s a solid 9/10 for me .
For the best watching experience I’ll suggest you watch it on 1.5x speed but watch it on normal speed when the main leads hyo seop and yeo been are together in a scene ❤️
Their chemistry is everything and more ❤️
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Butterfly effect
This show gives a warning about suicide at the beginning but it happens in ep 11, and ep 12 is about what happened if Min-ju never committed suicide.The difference between sad and happy ending is shown to make us all think about how we treat people in our lives.
One person's act affected so many lives around her, and yet she though of herself to be so insignificant ....
She wasn't a bad person without any hope for redemption. No. She was just an emotional teenager that nobody understood and cared about.
The time travel, the search for the love lost in time ....all of that wouldn't have happened if someone was there for Kwon Min-ju to help her overcome a difficult time in her life...
This story is teaching us that every single life and person is precious, no matter how strange that person seems. We should care about the weak and shy and withdrawn persons not because we pity on them, but because they are human, just like us and try to accept, understand and include them.
Also, it is teaching persons who are like that to not overthink, not to try too hard to be accepted and to seek for help and support in people around them. Min-ju just couldn't see that people like that are already around her.
The story is showing us that Si-heon became a friend of In-gyu. Without that friendship he would have probably become to be the same as Min-ju.
Anyway...this drama is great and I hope it leaves everyone thinking about persons they meet in their lifetime as well as themselves.
Was this review helpful to you?
Bad acting and a horrible setting
This Korean remake falls short of capturing the essence of the original Taiwanese series. The leads have zero chemistry, and their acting feels super forced. It's like they're just going through the motions- it was so slow and boring. The OSTs are not memorable. They do not add anything to the drama and are quickly forgotten.Even with utmost generosity, I can't rate this remake higher than a 4. The filming location fails to evoke the sentiments of longing and loss that permeate the series. The attempt to modernize the setting detracts from the story's intended atmosphere.
Overall, this remake is just a massive disappointment. It doesn't capture the magic of the original drama, and it's just a waste of time. Honestly, I wouldn't recommend this drama to anyone. If you're looking for something good, just stick with the original.
Was this review helpful to you?
İzlemeyen İzlesin (Those Who Haven't Watched Should Watch It)
Bu dizi sanki bir çok dizinin karışımı gibi. Hem Blue Birthday hem de My Perfect Stranger dizilerine benziyor. Bir de anime olan Your Name. Özellikle son bölüm.Bu dizinin Tayvan (Orjinal) versiyonu 2019 da çıktığı için Your Name'den referans almış olabilirler.
Oyunculuklar gayet iyiydi. Direkt cuk diye oturmuşlar.
Bittirdim aslında istediğim bir söndü da içim bir buruk...
.......................................................................................
Bir dizi daha bitti :(
10/10
Was this review helpful to you?
The fact that A TIME CALLED YOU is a remake doesn't bother me...
JUST MY OPINIONI heard that this was a remake... But I don't mind, because they carried it out entirely like it was an original one! I did not know until I read the reviews, that it was a remake. Their chemistry, was amazing. I am sharing my truthful opinion right now. Although it was really confusing in between, I loved it!!
It was a happy ending(?) Although I wish it was a happier one! Moreover, I felt really happy while watching this show. Definitely, the best time travel drama I've ever watched. It left me confused, hoping for a season 2, even 3! Which will not happen ig... The thing I love THE MOST was the acting. Confusing, Romance, Friendship, Time-travel, Emotion, these were the words I would use to describe this amazing show.
Was this review helpful to you?
I found this drama to be quite enjoyable. It is definitely not perfect, but still fantastic watch.
-Story
I personally have a fascination with dramas that explore time travel, so it was interesting to me right off the bat. Some people seem to find multiple and interconnecting timelines/characters confusing, I usually do not though so I was able to follow along well. There were one or two moments that through me off, but I was able figure it out pretty quickly. If you do struggle with keeping track of things though then you will find the drama confusing, luckily if you read in the comments there are some nice people who have outlined the timelines for you! I do think that everything made sense though (for the most part) and they were able to tie things up pretty nicely, unlike many other dramas out there. The first few eps were definitely the best, but the rest of the drama still held my interest. The mystery portion was done relatively well all though not as exciting as it could have been.
-Cast, chemistry, and romance
Some people in the comments and reviews seem to be questioning these to a great extent, but I disagree. I think the cast did a wonderful job and I was definitely able to feel that the fl was playing two different people. Her acting is a little off in moments but overall she still was successful in her portrayals. I also disagree that there wasn't chemistry between the leads or that the romance fell flat, I did not feel that at all. The building of the romance was pretty well done especially the portion when they were in college.
-Other
The cinematography was very picturesque, and the setting/sets were also well done, this drama is definitely very visually appealing. I personally liked the songs and OST and did not find fault in it, if you did not see the OG drama this will not bother you like it does some in the comments. Overall, I think you will enjoy this drama if you are able to keep up with everything and try to think from the characters POV in regard to their actions and motivations.
One also needs to understand that many here in the comments and reviews are not objective since they have seen the OG which they have a developed a strong attachment too so it is natural that they will be overly critical of the remake - which is of course going to differ from the OG. These people are looking to find fault with the remake from the get-go, so they are not going to look at this work with fresh and open eyes. Those who watched the OG are also not going to be as impacted by the revelations and plot developments since they already know what is to happen. If you are going into it without the OG as a refence you will most likely enjoy it as I have.
Was this review helpful to you?
Parallel Realities: A Roller Coaster Ride of confusion and intrigue in K-Drama Land
As a devoted fan of both K-Dramas and C-Dramas, I couldn't be happier that Netflix released all the episodes at once. The idea of enduring suspense, cliffhangers, and plot twists on a weekly basis? No, thank you!Watching this drama evoked memories of my four years in undergrad, studying Electronics & Communication engineering. Despite the intense coursework, I found myself in the same boat—struggling to differentiate between a diode and a transistor. Similarly, with this show, I couldn't resist watching, thoroughly enjoyed it, and can see myself revisiting it. However, did I entirely grasp every nuance? Maybe not...
Having not seen the original Taiwanese version, I embarked on this journey with fresh eyes. The narrative and pacing gripped me, though I must admit, I felt a bit like a lost puppy during those time jumps. I greatly appreciated the inclusion of the year, though it did get a tad convoluted at times.
The actors and their performances were a true highlight. Many a time, I found myself doing a double take, questioning if it was indeed the same actor playing the various roles. I even had to consult the cast list for confirmation. The character development was a joy to witness, and some of the portrayals were deliciously diabolic.
Impatience got the best of me, prompting a leap from Episode 7 to Episodes 11-12. I simply had to know if it culminated in a happy ending, so watching the show is the only way to find out. I did eventually come back and watch Ep8-12...
For me, this mirrors the experience of watching the film "Inception." It didn't fully click on the first or second viewing, requiring multiple watches to grasp the intricacies. It's earned a spot on my permanent watch list.
Lastly, this drama is akin to a mind-bending roller coaster ride. I can't determine if it's due to my non-native Korean proficiency or if the plot is genuinely a labyrinth for my humble brain to navigate.
Note: This review is written by me, edited by ChatGPT for readability.
Was this review helpful to you?
Time really flows!
I rewatched this series to rate again and give another view. It was close to perfect for me, the story and its complexities was perfect 10. The music gave the the relapse you needed and it captures you. Furthermore, the music on each highligh scene was on point.I just gave a not so perfect on acting/casting. I think Jeon Yeo-been was okay for the character but I fee there's something off. Upon rewatching, this criteria where it actually fall short.
Story wise it gave us the reality that what happens in the past or changes in the past can change the future. Meaning time really flows and it is really important not to change the past much since it is a domino effect. Time traveling was exciting but we really need to be careful if one day this will really happened (or maybe it already did but we didn't know yet). So far REWATCH VALUE is a perfect 10. Might rewatch again on the years to come.
Was this review helpful to you?
A beautiful journey throught time
The most underrated kdrama. So many plot twists and emotions. They fell in love in every timeline, and their story was so beautiful. I loved the mystery, the atmosphere and the way everything slowly came together. The story was confusing at times, but that made me even more curious about what would happen next. Definitely a drama that deserves more attention.Was this review helpful to you?



