A precious pearl within a hard shell.
First and foremost, this drama is a risk worth taking to give Princess Agents (2017) the closure it deserves. This is a gift for fans who have been left on the edge of that cliff in the Frozen Lake incident for years. The frustration of endless waiting for the official end is finally over, no matter what controversies it creates.1# What is in the past
Princess Agents is among the first C-dramas that brought me into the world of Chinese dramas. As I recall, the production quality isn't great, but the story itself is a gem. For me, it is not the romance or wuxia that keeps this story engraved in my memory: it is the tragedy finally revealed in the last three episodes. Chu Qiao recognizes Yuwen/Zhuge Yue’s love and sacrifice when it is too late. The selfless Zhuge Yue meets his death. And Yan Xun, once so free-spirited, eventually becomes consumed by vengeance. And, Princess Chun’er fails in her revenge and is cast down as a commoner.
My afterthought is that it is actually easy for the director to give a happy ending rather than a tragic cliffhanger. Just need to add one more episode! Chu Qiao leaped out of the frozen lake with her hidden martial technique activated. It may feel like a deus ex machina, but she managed to pull Zhuge Yue out of the lake and single-handedly defeated Yan Xun. She then transferred her inner energy to save Zhuge Yue and so on. They got married and lived together in seclusion in cold Ximeng. The badass story would end happily like a typical wuxia story, even though this trajectory won't solve the political problem.
#2 What has changed now in a good way
In Rebirth (2026), they chose to follow the novel to some extent to give more room to address the political problem. This drama thus experienced a tremendous change. The most striking aspects are the shift in genre and level of conflict, evolving from romance-wuxia into a more political and military-driven story, and from interpersonal conflict into conflict between nations. The story expands in scope and deepens in theme. What was once centered mainly on personal freedom becomes a broader commentary on societal issues, power relations, and peacemaking.
For me, this shift is worth appreciating because not many C-dramas are willing to venture into a territory less favored by mainstream audiences. This is precisely what makes Rebirth feel like such a precious pearl. While watching it, I found it deeply satisfying and would even consider it on a par with dramas like Swords into Plowshares (2026), which has a similar theme. And, for a "female general drama", it is so much better than "that overnight female general" in Pursuit of Jade (2026).
This shift also reflects the director's and screenwriter's ambition. To support the premise they set out to deliver, even if the drama does not fully reach an epic scale, it is still produced with strong cinematography, a soundtrack that effectively supports the atmosphere, and clear line delivery. Its worldbuilding is also carefully constructed, with fairly distinct cultural differences established among the states of Yan, Biantang, Ximeng, and Yong. Even, they added a cult of a faceless god! The storyline, plot, and events are fast-paced and efficient, advancing with clear discipline. Because it is set in a dystopian world, the director also does not hesitate to present brutal and bloody scenes. The story does become dark and intensely serious, with relatively little comic relief. The atmosphere is intense and high-stakes in almost every moment. They let you see the beast among men with power, those who treat human beings like dust.
3# What are the problems
Even so, it must be acknowledged that this precious pearl is not easily obtained. Viewers must struggle to crack open its hard shell. And many viewers, it seems, fail to open it, and therefore cannot appreciate what lies within. This drama’s "failure" is largely shaped by the circumstances surrounding it, rather than its story and production quality.
The main problem is premature disappointment driven by: (1) nostalgia for the original main cast of Princess Agents (Zhao Liying, Lin Gengxin, Shan Dou, and Liqin). Getting the original leads to come back is practically not possible, (2) the new actress cast as Chu Qiao, who is considered too young to portray such a mature character, even though she is actually quite capable, and (3) the accusation that Rebirth is a newly invented story that departs from "the true Princess Agents".
People may think differently. For me, there is no such thing as a true Princess Agents (since it is an adaptation, too). The changes made to Rebirth were the director’s and screenwriter’s creative efforts to restore the promise in the face of an impossible circumstance. The cool wuxia elements in Princess Agents—martial techniques and inner energy—as well as Chu Qiao’s personal backstory, particularly her mother's role as the leader of an underground spy group, were largely omitted, as they are invented additions that did not come from the original novel. If those elements were kept, they would be forced to write a completely new story, with zero grounding in the source material.
The next problem is the different opinions among fans and (new) viewers over whether Rebirth is a standalone or a continuation. Each perspective carries significant consequences for the viewing experience. Those who deeply loved Princess Agents and its original cast are unwilling to accept this continuation, burdened as it is by disappointment. They watch unwillingly, may not really watch at all, and skip or jump right to the ending. They take pleasure in mocking this project, ignoring its strengths and denying it the appreciation it deserves, and use this moment to praise the former drama as if it were perfect.
Meanwhile, new viewers who do not have the time to watch Princess Agents as a prequel tend to treat Rebirth as a separate, standalone story. Skipping the prequel and jumping right into Rebirth is indeed more practical. But the downside is, important context is lost—the background that explains the present events, the reasons behind each character's relationships, and the emotional weight behind "the more serious and dark" Rebirth. Without proper contextual knowledge, they are bound to feel confused. Another thing: their first expectations are often “how is the romance and chemistry in this drama—is there kissing, is there a love triangle, is it a happy ending?” or “when will Li Yunrui from Blossom (2024) appear?” They easily become disappointed with the several early episodes, which show little of what they expect and serve more as a buildup before Rebirth reaches its momentum again.
So, if you see the low rating, it is not the drama itself that is a failure; it is these two camps of people who deliberately make it fail. It almost becomes a movement where one voice follows another in unison, without adding anything new to the discussion. So unfair and ridiculous, but that is how the viewers' "politics" are at play. Seemingly, they won't stop until this drama hits a new low.
4# Why still love it and what could've been better
In the end, only a small number of viewers seem willing to embrace it as a re-adapted continuation. I am part of this small group. If asked why, my answer is: The value of Rebirth lies not in its perfection or its ability to please everyone, but in its courage to continue a story that was once left unfinished. Even though, in the end, some of my hopes were left unfulfilled, I feel enriched after enjoying it. Having this drama is still better than having nothing at all.
Also, this drama feels like an interesting experiment: how a director continues a story from a post-climax point after almost a decade, while facing the reality that audiences and trends have already changed. In the era of easy and fast access to information and communication, we no longer have patient audiences. Bad-mouthed spread faster, fan wars are everywhere, and people have more power to make demands or to destroy figures they hate. Also, romance is almost everything. Even if the overall story is crap, people would praise any drama with a heavy dose of romance.
Even so, I am not a viewer who watches with blind love while closing my eyes to its flaws. As a matter of reflection, I also wish there were certain things in Rebirth that had been executed differently. For examples:
(1) They shouldn’t have started right from the Frozen Lake incident. They should have gone a bit further back to show why Chu Qiao and Zhuge Yue ended up in such a desperate situation. What made the final episodes of Princess Agents so devastating wasn’t just the bloodshed or Zhuge Yue’s fall into the lake, but his one-sided confession of love before—after Chu Qiao said that they would meet again on the battlefield as enemies, and she reminded him: if you didn’t want to be hurt, it would be better not to make a move (to love). Zhuge Yue replied solemnly: he actually had already been hurt for a long time (ever since Chu Qiao chose to follow Yan Xun and become a rebel, leaving him behind).
That scene was the true emotional bomb, the real reason Chu Qiao is shattered, knowing Zhuge Yue falls into Yan Xun's trap. It should have been preserved and carried forward as the foundation of Rebirth. So, when Chu Qiao awakens after sinking into the Frozen Lake, what should have happened to her was not amnesia but hysteria. Whether she later became amnesiac or blind as a result of emotional repression, the story would have been far more compelling. In that way, her reunion with Zhuge Yue would have become a deeply meaningful release and resolution of their previous conflict, rather than merely a simple recognition of someone once lost and finally returned.
(2) Rebirth should also not test Chu Qiao and Zhuge Yue with a merely “typical breakup” like that of newly formed lovers in a romance drama. They are not just a couple who have recently fallen in love, but a husband and wife who have perfected their marriage. Two people who love each other deeply, even when faced with differences in belief and ideology, do not easily cut their bonds. Trust and commitment should become the foundation of their actions. Even if tragedy repeats itself, and they end up hurting each other, everything must lead to their unshakable reunion, not another separation, and a solid cooperation to face the final war. This positive dynamic is a bit missing. Actually, many C-dramas fall short in their portrayal of married main couples. Here is not an exception.
(3) Although Rebirth focuses more on political and military, the dynamics it builds are often no more than moving troops here and there. There is no real discussion of geopolitics, military strategy, tactics, diplomacy, or efforts toward peace beyond force-on-force combat. The heads of state (three in Biantang, one in Ximeng, and two in Yong) are also easily toppled by a single person's hit behind the curtain. And later, a new entity (the Quanrong people) is introduced without proper foreshadowing and serves only as a device to unite the fragmented existing political entities. This makes Rebirth fall into the trope of a military story that is more about brawn than brains.
There are several wars throughout the story, but they are handled through telling rather than showing. Even when the wars are depicted, the action sequences are simple, involving only a few extras. Moreover, there is no clear sense of distance between locations or the cost of time. Armies move from place A to place B with ease, without logistical constraints or other practical difficulties. The peace itself feels somewhat cheapened, as it is achieved too easily—through the destruction (killing) of the old structure to build a new one. In reality, things do not work that way. Peace is achieved through justice and negotiation, where the old and the new reach a compromise or middle ground. Because of this, Chu Qiao and Zhuge Yue’s ambition to end oppression and slavery feels more like a dream or rhetoric.
Once again, this drama was not designed to be epic in a political or philosophical sense. Maybe the director didn’t really invest in this area (as they did in The Double (2024). They focused more on plot progression than on believability. But I wish whoever tries to create political-military drama would first learn about psychology, politics, war, and peacebuilding, etc., to avoid oversimplification. That will be the new statement of professionalism that improves the story's realism.
5# What should be more balanced
Lastly, the drama is too heavily focused on developing its villains/ antagonists rather than the virtues of the protagonists. On the one hand, this is a strength, as it allows us to understand the origins of evil and serves as a mirror, reflecting just how corrupt the world is. However, goodness and virtue should also be explored in a balanced way—at the very least by giving each character a meaningful redemption. In fact, there are many moments when characters could have been steered toward a more hopeful path rather than continuing down a darker alley. All it would take is a brief scene.
Li Ce, the womanizer who once cared nothing for the state, now learns statecraft, governs wisely, and holds his son with Ziming (before his death). Li Yan, who loves Chun’er wholeheartedly, spares her further violence and becomes king in order to restore her dignity and elevate her status (before his death). General Huan Huan does not die easily, but instead engages in a true sword duel with Zhao Che and proves her worth as a badass military general (the side of her that reminds Zhao Che why he falls in love with her). Instead of suicide, Chun’er realizes the full consequences of her actions and is killed while trying to protect her baby (in her delusional state, or in an alternate reality?) and the people of Yong, who are torn by another great war. Chu Qiao learns to temper her steel-hard idealism and steady her emotions so she can look at Zhuge Yue with eyes shimmering with love. And Zhuge Yue learns to love himself and to stop letting his body and his heart get wounded over and over again.
The strongest character transformation is only found in: Queen of Lingyue, who solves her conflict by eventually choosing the righteous path; General Chen, who remains steadfast in his loyalty while being true to himself; Helian Ling, who learns pure love and moves on by embracing her new role as the Queen of Yanbei; and Yan Xun, who lets go of his ego, accepts Helian as his reality, and ultimately achieves the unification of Yanbei.
This redemption, which leads to the character's transformation, should be the true meaning of "Rebirth": not only physical rebirth but also existential one. The transformations on a personal level are truly the ingredients of the freedom and peace they are all seeking so badly. It should be found inside themselves, not from the battlefield.
(I wrote this after ep. 39. I am so happy, in ep. 40, they show us alternate reality of every beloved character if they decided things differently)
6# The key to opening the shell and enjoying Rebirth is an open mind.
Despite its relatively low rating, this drama remains phenomenal and is able to maintains quality. It may not be a viewing experience that satisfies the masses, but for those willing to go beyond surface expectations, it offers something that lingers long after the story ends. Its flaws are there, and its execution is not without weaknesses, yet its core still carries weight for viewers who choose patience over haste, substance over appearance. Breaking through its outer layers is not easy, but what lies within offers a value that makes the effort worthwhile.
Was this review helpful to you?
I also loved how he treated Chu Qiao. Their relationship wasn’t overly dramatic, but full of subtle and meaningful moments. Those small romantic gestures and quiet scenes when they were together made their bond feel real and heartfelt. Chu Qiao herself was amazing—strong, beautiful, and highly skilled in swordsmanship. Her acting really stood out and made her character even more compelling.
Another thing I appreciated was how well-written the supporting characters and villains were. Characters like Chun’er, Li Yan, the Queen of Biantang, and the Majesty of Yong added so much depth to the story. They weren’t just there to oppose the leads—they each had their own presence and impact. Even the second male lead did a great job and contributed emotionally to the story.
I also enjoyed the side stories and interactions, like the moments between Princess Helian and General Chen, and General Huan with the Majesty of Yong. These added richness to the world of the drama. The Black Eagle scenes were memorable too, and the OST was beautiful—it really matched the emotions of the story and made the scenes even more powerful.
Even though many characters met tragic endings, their journeys were still meaningful and well-portrayed. I know there’s a lot of negativity surrounding this drama, especially about the ending, but I’m really glad I watched it and formed my own opinion. For me, the experience was worth it.
Because the ending felt a bit confusing and emotional, I created my own version to give myself closure. In my mind, Zhuge Yue saves Chu Qiao on the battlefield, riding in on his horse. After everything they went through, they leave behind the chaos of war and live a peaceful, simple life together as husband and wife, raising a son and a daughter happily.
At the end of the day, this drama made me feel so much, and that’s what truly matters. And without a doubt, Zhuge Yue remains my favorite—he’s just incredible to watch.
Was this review helpful to you?
That said, everything else about the drama was truly remarkable.
Lin Yunrui as Zhuge Yue was almost perfect for the role. He didn’t just rely on his looks—though he is undeniably handsome and charismatic—but he fully embodied the character. Zhuge Yue came across as incredibly intelligent, calculating, and composed, yet underneath that cold and strategic exterior was someone deeply caring and capable of profound love. What I appreciated most was how his actions consistently spoke louder than his words. He protected Chu Qiao in his own quiet way, often sacrificing himself without expecting anything in return. He wasn’t just a brilliant strategist; he was also an awesome warrior—skilled, fearless, and commanding in every fight scene. At the same time, his softer side showed through in subtle moments, proving that he was not just strong, but also deeply human. That balance made his character unforgettable.
Chu Qiao was equally captivating. She’s not just beautiful—she’s powerful, independent, and incredibly skilled, especially in swordsmanship and archery. What makes her stand out is her resilience and unwavering determination. She doesn’t rely on anyone, yet she still allows herself to care deeply. Watching her growth throughout the drama was inspiring, and her strength never overshadowed her emotional depth. The chemistry between her and Zhuge Yue is one of the strongest aspects of the series. Their connection felt natural, intense, and earned, making it impossible not to root for them.
The supporting characters also added so much richness to the story. The second male lead brought emotional weight and complexity, while the villains were written and portrayed in a way that made them feel like real threats rather than just obstacles. They created tension and pushed the story forward in meaningful ways. Chun’er, in particular, stood out with her emotional depth—her character was layered, tragic, and unforgettable. Princess Consort Helian also brought a unique charm and strength, adding balance to the narrative with her presence.
And of course, the OST deserves special mention. The music elevated every scene, making emotional moments even more powerful. Each song perfectly matched the tone of the story, and even after finishing the drama, the soundtrack lingers and brings back all the feelings.
Overall, Rebirth is a drama I genuinely loved. Despite the confusing and somewhat open-ended conclusion, the storytelling, performances, character development, and music made it a deeply satisfying experience. It’s the kind of story that makes you think, feel, and hope—and even wish for just a little more at the end.
Was this review helpful to you?
depends on each person's taste.
I know many people dropped this drama because the acting of the fl actress, but honestly this drama is very interesting for me, even though I have never watched Princess Agent before, I don't think this drama is that bad, maybe some ppl criticizing the director, the role casting, and the screenwriter, but I think the criticism sounds quite harsh. (This is just my personal opinion, sorry for bad English.)Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
too sad
The gap between expectation and the actual drama is too wide. To make it watchable, Yuwen Yue should lose his memory, and Princess Lang’s aid should spark a tense, mystery-driven alliance that naturally pulls viewers forward. Chu Qiao must actively leave Yan Xun, reclaim her mother’s sect, and step up as its leader, no memory loss, no stagnation. When she hears crucial news, she heads to Lang State with clear purpose. Meng Feng’s war with the Seventh Prince should tie into the larger conspiracy, not float as a disconnected subplot. Season 1 succeeded because of its mystery, slow-burn romance, cinematic beauty, elite combat, and secret-agent tension. Season 2 must return to that core: every episode advances a clue, tests loyalty, delivers precision action, and moves the board forward. Otherwise, even heavy spending feels wasted and tasteless.🧩 HOW IT PLAYS OUT (Watchable, Purposeful, S1 Spirit Restored)
Element
Your Fix
Why It Drives Viewers
Yuwen Yue
Loses memory after a targeted ambush. Princess Lang finds him, hides his identity, and trains him back into a shadow operative.
Creates immediate mystery + forced proximity. Romance builds through unspoken trust, coded missions, and shared danger.
Chu Qiao
Actively breaks from Yan Xun after witnessing his ruthless shift. Rebuilds her mother’s sect, becomes its leader, and forms an intelligence network.
Gives her clear agency, progression, and tactical purpose. No reset buttons.
Convergence
Chu Qiao hears news of Yuwen Yue’s disappearance + Lang State’s political crisis. She mobilizes her sect and marches north.
Natural cause-and-effect. Three arcs pull toward one location with rising stakes.
Meng Feng & 7th Prince
Campaigns aren’t just battles, they’re layered with intelligence gaps, supply sabotage, and moral compromises that tie back to the main conspiracy.
Keeps war relevant to the central mystery, not filler.
Tone & Style
Returns to S1’s strengths: espionage tradecraft, intricate clue-dropping, fluid martial choreography, atmospheric visuals, romance earned through risk and choice.
Restores the “why we watched” factor. Every scene has purpose.
PACING HOOKS (Episode-by-Episode Drive)
Eps 1–3: Ambush → Yuwen Yue’s memory shatters → Princess Lang extracts him in silence. Chu Qiao cuts ties with Yan Xun, takes the sect seal, and begins rebuilding. Hook: “He forgot his name. She remembered her war.”
Eps 4–7: Chu Qiao trains her sect into a covert network. Princess Lang uses Yuwen Yue’s fragmented skills to uncover court spies. Meng Feng’s campaign hits a supply mystery that points to Lang State. Hook: “Three shadows. One truth. No one is safe.”
Eps 8–12: Chu Qiao intercepts intercepted letters, realizes Yuwen Yue is alive but compromised, and moves north. Princess Lang and amnesiac Yuwen Yue execute a high-stakes intelligence op together. Meng Feng faces a command betrayal. Hook: “Memory fades. Instinct remains. Loyalty is chosen.”
Eps 13–16: All paths collide at Lang State. The conspiracy behind Yuwen Yue’s fall, Yan Xun’s expansion, and the 7th Prince’s war converge. Chu Qiao and Yuwen Yue’s reunion is tense, earned, and mission-driven. Hook: “The past broke them. The next move defines them.”
Was this review helpful to you?
If This Is All You Can Write Then You Should Have Let Zhuge Yue Marinate Under The Ice
Positive Points1. Cinematography, direction and editing were top-notch. It was probably the reason I could bottle down this absolutely messy, vomit-worthy writing.
2. In terms of casting, only Li Yun Rui managed to pass with flying colours as Zhuge Yue. He was one of the reasons that I managed to finish this shit show. Though his character was not spared from "Operation Turning Every Rational Character Into An Impulsive Clown", he still managed to make me feel that the cool, composed, smart planner Zhuge Yue was still here, somewhat. He was the saving grace of this sinking ship. May he be blessed with proper written scripts in future.
Negative points
1. The main problem (I would rather say crime) of this drama is the script itself. This is probably one of the most horrible butcherings of characters I have seen in dramas. The most intelligent and rational character here was the pet donkey of General Huan. Even if you had to change the script and could not follow the novel due to plagarism issue, this is no excuse for turning every rational character into a love brained imbecle in the drama. The main beauty of season 01 (And the novel of course) was its complex characters (at least for me). The producer and production team claimed this to be based on the novel. I have read the novel, and I definitely did not find any resemblance except for the name of the ML, Zhuge Yue. This is severely misleading and insulting for the viewers and fans. If they could not follow the novel, why did they even make a S02? Were they trying to mock the fans of S01? The writer and everyone related to the script writing should consider changing their profession, if this is all they could come up with.
2. Except for Zhuge Yue rest of the casts were mediocre. The producer and casting director should have paid more focus while casting Yan Xun and Chu Qiao. This is completely unacceptable. While I agree Zhang Kang Le and Huangyang Tian Tian were given a very poorly written script, but it cannot be denied that they were hardly capable of handling the weight of their characters. The comparison with the season 01 cast was bound to happen, especially when the entire cast of S01 had given one of the best performances of their careers (at least in my opinion). I tried to watch with an open mind, and still I hardly felt they were playing Chu Qiao and Yan Xun. The producer adamantly had cast a minor FL with a grown man 10 years older than her, just because she resembled the FL of S01, is utterly foolish. Unfortunately, she could hardly act like the FL of S01. She felt more like a child trying to act like an adult to me.
3. All of the budget got used up in cinematograpgy it seems, as the drama lacked a proper dialogue writer who could write better than these plain, straight cringe dialogues. Except for Li Yun Rui, none of the others had a good makeup or proper costumes. Why did they even think that making everyone's complexion dark for no reason was a good idea? Moreover, who the hell wrote the dialogues? Especially, Chu Qiao sounds like a naive child. No one will believe this one is a military general fighting wars.
4. Now lets come to the writing inconsistencies. Princess Chun, who was discarded, suddenly became very powerful, who can kidnap Chu Qiao and Yan Xun in Yanbei. When did any character, especially Zhogue Yue was so expressive? His main trait was caring from behind the scenes always. He never showed it directly nor said it in words. Zhuge Yue, who was an utterly calm planner, suddenly became impulsive and had poison to save Chu Qiao. What happened to Chu Qiao? She is suddenly all about Zhuge Yue, forgetting her own dream of a slave free world (she later remembered her mission towards the end, but only for giving speeches). Suddenly, everything is about love. She is losing her memory, losing eyesight, all because she fell into a frozen lake. She is risking her life and setting herself as bait to confirm Zhuge Yue is alive. Yan Xun is jumping and falling in lake for love. He suddenly left his ambition for love. Is there any character here who is not foolish and an idiot, except for General Huan's pet donkey? Yan Xun leaving a traitor like Cheng Yuan alive is even more unbelievable, and he even agreed to give away his consort to him for love. Cheng Yuan objected Yan Xun's marriage with Chu Qiao at every opportunity he got, but later ran away with Yan Xun's consort, whom he had conspired with and had done everything to appoint her as Yan Xun's Princess Consort. Drunk writing totally. Moreover, this new Li Ce is actually foolish instead of the S01 Li Ce who was actually pretending to be a fool. It was so painful to watch. Who thought it was a good idea to replace a pretend-to-be-foolish crown prince with an actual, useless crown prince? Disaster after disaster. The empress doubted right from the start about the identity of the FL, but let the FL and Li Ce enough time to prepare and rehearse their fake story. Chu Qiao was injured and unable to hold a sword properly. But baam she drowned in the pond and suddenly can fight once again. Water is playing a supporting role here. What even was that poison drama, drawing all attention to Chu Qiao. Wasn't she sneaking out? Then fighting outside, coming back, playing the role of a patient by actually taking poison. There was no decoy, so who was the doctor treating even this whole time? Furthermore, is she even training a private military or a band of circus, even I am confused. What even happened at episode 19? A 3-person palace coup. You must be joking. After all the drama of running away, drowning in water and memory loss, the best war strategy this so-called famous lady general came up with is to surrender to Yan Xun just because people told her to surrender. The general in charge just surrenders even though she can win as she has the geographical advantage. She is a general, purely driven by emotions. She took revenge for Li Ce but has now caused the entire command chain in chaos. After creating the entire mess thinks about who will solve the mess. Later she appoints herself as the acting empress or whatever and plays dressing up for a while and leaves for her love once again. In the entire drama all battle strategies our so-called genius female general came up with were disguising herself as a slave/ princess/ giving herself up for exchange. What an upgrade. A military general entering an enemy camp alone right before the battle for whatever negotiation (as if it is believable). Fighting all and getting injured, and the mighty hero came to save her at the right moment. Who made this imbecile a general with this small brain? Now Yan Xun is coming to take her away and Chu Qiao's husband Zhogue Yue is leaving his wife in his mortal enemy's care. I am having a headache.
What is with this 7th prince and General Huan romance angle? Who attacked them out of nowhere just to create this gaging moment? (Oh the enemy brother of the pitiful prince). Ahh now another female general is abandoning her duties temporarily and escorting an injured mortal enemy while war is on the horizon. The 7th prince turned bad and killed his brother and took the throne but suddenly became good again as soon as he heard the self-righteous speech of Chu Qiao for a few minutes. Zhao Che is so smart that he even made plans for the king. But he blindly trusts Zhuge Yue. Ordering Zhuge Yue to arrest his wife Chu Qiao and Zhuge Yue obliges and abandons his wife immediately. What a foolish crown prince or king whatever. Also, Wasn't Zhao Che is a military general who was well-trained with vast experience? You are expecting me to believe that Zhuge Yue managed to defeat him within 2 to 3 moves. Furthermore, what even happened to that fake faceless god? What the hell was even that ending? Who died and who is alive I didnot even understand as I was banging my head out of frustration the entire time. I wish to shake up the writer so badly. How drunk do you have to be to write this high-level shit? Here, all the fools are competing to see who is the biggest fool. What is this drama even about? I have no idea.
This drama is an absolute waste of time, and I would suggest to all, especially if you are a fan of Princess Agents (like me) or even the novel fan; do not watch this drama to maintain your sanity.
PS. Who thought making all the actors floating like dead goldfish in an aquarium was a good idea for the opening title?
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
✨An Epic Written in Dust, Glory, and Contradictions and a Descent I Didn’t See Coming✨
Okay… where do I even begin with this one?This drama came in with a lot of noise around it—and not exactly the flattering kind. So I went in cautious… and somehow I am more entertained than I expected.
Let’s start with what it does right.
✅The cinematography is genuinely stunning. This isn’t soft or whimsical—it leans fully into that rugged, historical, almost mythic and tribal atmosphere. Wide landscapes, grounded textures, and a strong, earthy color palette make everything feel weighty and immersive, like you’re watching a legend unfold rather than a polished fairytale. Visually, it’s one of the drama’s strongest assets.
✅The BGM also deserves a mention, because it carries. I always pay attention to how music supports a story, and here it does a lot of heavy lifting in amplifying tension and emotion. When it hits, it really hits. Though—no explanation for this—but my brain kept randomly hearing echoes of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2 in certain moments. Slightly distracting… but overall, a very solid score.
✅Character-wise, this drama is surprisingly rich. While the leads are central, it’s the supporting cast that really rounds out the world. There’s a strong sense of presence across the board—distinct personalities, layered motivations—and I found myself invested in more than just the main storyline, which is always a win.
✅The plot itself is engaging enough to keep you watching. There are twists, shifting dynamics, and despite the intimidating episode count, the pacing holds up better than expected. Watching it while airing actually worked in its favor—two episodes a day felt like the perfect rhythm, and the story never really dragged for me.
Now… onto the more complicated part😢
The female lead.
I went in aware of the situation, so my expectations were already adjusted. And to be fair, she does okay—she doesn’t break immersion completely and holds her ground in many scenes. But when the narrative asks you to see her as a feared and respected general… that’s where it becomes harder to fully buy in. Especially when the characters around her often carry a much stronger, more commanding presence.
And then there’s the romance—specifically in terms of the main leads’ portrayal.
For me, this is where things don’t quite land. The emotional depth just isn’t there, and the dynamic feels off more often than not. Instead of adding to the story, the romantic moments felt like interruptions to what was otherwise a compelling narrative. Separately, the characters work. Together… not so much, again, personal take.
Interestingly though, I found myself far more invested in the dynamic between the female lead and the second male lead. There’s a natural ease there that makes their interactions feel less awkward and, in my opinion, far more convincing. The chemistry simply flows better.
And I have to say—Zhang Kang Le as Yan Xun is adding an unhinged, chaotic kind of energy that I did not know I needed. He’s unpredictable, slightly feral, and honestly just so much fun to watch. Every time he’s on screen, things get instantly more interesting. He’s crazy… but the entertaining kind of crazy—and I’m absolutely here for it.
As for the overall reception, yes—there’s been quite a bit of negativity. And while some of it is understandable, I also feel like a lot of viewers went in already decided—whether due to casting choices or constant comparisons to Princess Agents. Having seen Princess Agents a few years ago, I do think it helps a bit with the initial setup (since the first episodes throw a lot at you), but as the story progresses, this drama does stand on its own.
Personally, I made the conscious choice to treat it as a separate story—and to stay away from the comment section early on. The experience was better for it.
So, who is this for?
If you’re heavily attached to Princess Agents, this might take some adjusting. And if you’re here strictly for romance… this is probably not your drama. The strength lies in its atmosphere, characters, and storytelling—not in its love line.
In the end, I found this to be a visually striking, well-directed drama that kept me consistently engaged. Yes, it requires a bit of patience—especially early on, where the plot can feel messy and occasionally full of gaps—but it never lost my interest.
That said, this is still an ongoing watch for me, with nine episodes left to go—so final judgment on the resolution is very much pending.
Flawed? Definitely.
But still a compelling watch… if you meet it where it is.
✨Update✨
Just finished all 40 episodes and… what the actual hell did they smoke??
The last arc was a complete mess—repetitive, frustrating, and somehow looping back on itself like none of it even mattered.
And the deaths?? At some point I was like… who pissed off the director, genuinely. Are we just killing everyone for shock value now?
It stopped being emotional and just became exhausting.
This really felt like a “fuck you… just kidding… but actually no, fuck you” to the audience.
At this point, I’m honestly just here to roast myself for how optimistic I sounded in the first half of this review.
Was this review helpful to you?
1One of the Best Chinese Dramas of 2026
This is a really good drama with a strong story and many interesting side characters. What stood out the most to me is Yan Xun. His transformation into the villain feels completely justified, and you understand every reason behind his actionsI really love that he has his own storyline and depth instead of being a simple bad guy. It makes the drama much more emotional and realistic. realistic.
A really good drama with strong side characters. Yan Xun’s villain arc is powerful and justified, and I love that he has his own story. I wish more dramas had villains like this.
I honestly wish more Chinese dramas would write villains like this—complex, human, and with their own story. It makes the whole show much better.
Was this review helpful to you?
A meaningless, pointless, bad drama.
This is the worst costume drama I've seen recently. There's no plot, no story, no script. I swear, even the director wouldn't know what they were filming or what they were doing. It's such a mess. It's a shame for the actors. It's a shame for all the effort. The director probably just filmed whatever he was given, but it's unclear what he was given. There's no meaning, no plot, no one knows what they're doing or who's doing what. It's such a confusing script. The male lead appears very little, just briefly and then disappears. He's after a girl, a slave girl, who later becomes a general, but we don't see any of this. They tell the story. She appears with the enemy king, and then with the male lead on the friendly side. She doesn't like them, doesn't want them, despises them, and treats them badly. Then she's loved and desired by a prince from another empire, but she doesn't like or want him either. Then her name is linked to another prince, but that doesn't work out either. Their lovers, however, hold a grudge against her, and they keep finding each other and instigating each other in one kingdom, then another, then another principality. So, those lovers, they appear wherever the girl is wandering. All the nonsense is piled on top of each other. The girl appears on her horse in front of the castle. The enemy king, in love with her, is watching her from the forest on the other side, even his archers are ready to shoot. Normally, according to that scene, the girl should enter the castle. No, she rides her horse into the forest, meaning she's going after the enemy, they chase her and catch her at the edge of a cliff. How meaningless and pointless. Apathy prevails. At least decide where and when to do what.The male and female leads die and are resurrected, rescued, and so on, at the very beginning of the series. They fall again in the same way, and are rescued again. They die and are resurrected repeatedly. Probably because the series is called Rebirth. It's very pointless.
A king gives the male lead a potion, meaning he poisons him. He says he has the antidote and parades him everywhere. He makes him do his bidding. This character is very combative, a master of fighting, capable of defeating anyone, and hits his target perfectly. He could kill the king multiple times, but instead he's searching for an antidote, only to be sent on yet another mission. If there were a struggle, a punishment, a loyalty, a reason, you might understand. But it's a pointless endeavor, and I couldn't even watch the whole thing. I'm tired of watching such bad, meaningless, empty things. I'm sorry, but there's nothing there except effort. I could write ten times more about the pointlessness and lack of plot of this series than I can here. There's so much more; it wouldn't fit here. It's wrong from beginning to end. Didn't the director or those who read this script realize there was something wrong with the screenwriter? I'm shocked. Bad, very bad, I wouldn't recommend anyone watch it.
Was this review helpful to you?
Even the second male lead did a great job. His character added depth and emotional weight to the story. The villains were also very well portrayed—they weren’t just there for conflict, but they truly made the story more intense and engaging. The fighting scenes were another highlight—well-executed, powerful, and exciting to watch.
And of course, the OST was absolutely beautiful. I can’t stop listening to the songs—they really captured the emotions of the drama so well. “Chasing the Wind” by Liu Yuning, “Rebirth” by Curley Gao, “Flowers Drift Away” by Yan An, “Baseless” by Queena Cui, “Lonely Black Eagle” by Zhang Kangle, and “Journey Alone” by Hu Xia—all of them are so emotional and memorable. Every time I listen to them, it brings me back to the scenes and feelings from the drama.
Lin Yunrui as Zhuge Yue is definitely my bias. He almost perfectly portrayed the character. He’s not only handsome and charming, but he also gave depth to Zhuge Yue—showing him as someone intelligent, calm, and strategic, yet also deeply caring. What makes him even more admirable is how he expresses love through actions rather than words. He’s a caring man, a brilliant strategist, and an awesome warrior—strong, fearless, and always willing to sacrifice for the people he loves, especially Chu Qiao. His quiet way of protecting her made his character even more powerful and unforgettable.
Chu Qiao was also amazing. She’s beautiful, but more than that, she’s strong, independent, and resilient. Even as a young actress, her performance was impressive—especially her swordsmanship, which looked so natural and convincing. She didn’t feel like a typical female lead—she stood as an equal, someone who could fight, lead, and protect just as much as Zhuge Yue.
The chemistry between Zhuge Yue and Chu Qiao is one of the best parts of the drama. You can truly feel their connection, especially in the small, quiet moments. One of my favorite scenes is when they ate hot pot together—it was such a simple but warm and genuine moment that showed their softer side. In the middle of all the chaos, war, and responsibilities, that scene felt like a glimpse of the peaceful life they both deserved.
The only thing that really confused me was the ending. I kept asking myself—was it truly a happy ending or not? For me, the perfect ending would have been something clearer and more real. I really wanted to see Zhuge Yue and Chu Qiao living peacefully together, with their son and daughter, happy and complete as a family. Even just a simple scene of him saving his queen on the battlefield and then returning to a quiet life with her would have been enough.
I also wish the hot pot scene had been shown again as part of the ending—not as a dream or imagination, but as a real moment in their future. It could have symbolized that after everything they went through, they finally found peace and happiness together. That simple scene, turned into reality, would have been the perfect emotional closure—a dream that finally becomes real.
Still, despite the confusion about the ending, I truly enjoyed the drama. It’s emotional, intense, and full of memorable characters and moments. Rebirth is definitely a story that stays in your heart even after it ends.
Was this review helpful to you?
Devotion Without Payoff
Based on a quintessential “trashy girl fantasy” novel, the series follows a slave girl turned general who commands the obsession of three rival princes. Picking up where Princess Agents left off, the story opens with a high stakes reversal: the female lead has already rebelled against the male lead’s empire and spurned the man who secretly protected her. Now, crushed by the weight of her misunderstandings, she races to save him from a lethal trap set by her own partner, a man whose descent into madness has turned FL herself into bait. It is an intriguing premise that hooked me early on.Her awareness of past mistakes does little to stop new ones. ML is once again forced to operate in the shadows, repeatedly saving her life only to be rejected because he will not, or cannot, reveal everything. Meanwhile, FL gravitates toward a third prince framed as comic relief: a charming, playboyish, and hapless man-child hopelessly in love with her, yet one she feels inexplicably beholden to in ways that feel lost in translation between the novel and live action adaptation.
The main couple briefly reconnect when ML swears he will no longer hide things from her or leave her side, a promise that should carry emotional weight. It does not. Almost immediately, FL rushes off without consulting him to marry her first love rival in a harebrained plan to protect the second love rival and his empire.
From there the story spirals. FL returns victorious to the capital largely through ML’s planning, despite both having opportunities to eliminate the rival prince and end the war sooner. Instead, sentimentality and the love rival’s plot armor prolong the conflict, demanding even greater sacrifice. FL then makes yet more life altering decisions, again hypocritically without consulting ML (because love rules apply to thee, not me), entering a tragic marriage with the second love rival and adopting his child, becoming consort regent of his empire. She chooses to shoulder the world alone rather than trust ML or honor the bond between them, even while knowing he is gravely poisoned and desperate for an antidote.
The plot grows increasingly contrived, making it difficult to feel genuine sympathy for FL even under duress. Rather than arising naturally from character choices, much of the drama feels engineered for maximum angst, weakening the emotional payoff. At the same time, ML’s unwavering devotion becomes more frustrating than romantic, repeatedly directed toward someone who neither fully acknowledges nor consistently reciprocates it. What the series presents as epic love instead drifts into emotional masochism: obsessive, self destructive devotion mistaken for grandeur. The result is a widening disconnect between what the story wants the audience to feel and what actually lands on screen.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
First of all, it's incredibly beautiful to look at.The costumes and sets are sumptuous. No surprise there. Everything is white, red and black, or in pastel shades (fading jade and orange, washed-out blue and yellow). There's a scene with a lateral tracking shot where a character walks past transparent coloured screens in red and green, and pink and blue ; absolutely stunning ! And there are plenty of moments like that. For example, the heroine drinking her tea at night with burgundy curtains matching her dark red and black outfit and soft lantern light... there was no point in creating such a sophisticated set for just a few seconds, but they clearly wanted to do it. Well done, set designers. Well done, cinematographers.
The scenes in the snow-capped mountains, the frozen lake. The red mountains covered in powder snow that they climbed while dressed in olive and burgundy fabrics (Ep. 34)... Cold weather must be the trend this year in Chinese productions. Most of it was shot on location, in harsh weather conditions, below freezing. It must have been torture. It breaks my heart to see them breathing out mist when they speak.
The elliptical storytelling works well. It introduces the numerous characters only when it serves the plot, so I never felt overwhelmed. And yet the first few episodes bombard us with information and plot twists. It gets off to a strong, fast-paced start, and then the writing simply becomes excellent... provided, of course, that you're a fan of period costume dramas.
It never stops. There's always something happening in every episode. These writers are brilliant. The only downside : it s a bit over the top. I loved following all the twists and turns, the mysteries and the conspiracies. They probably overuse and overdo the cataclysmic situations and tragic endings for each character. However, the multiple conflicts intertwine well and their resolution comes at just the right moment. It does, unfortunately, get rather complicated in the final stretch, though. (Watch it as intended: two episodes a day, no more. Beware of the overdose)
Massive spoiler : The final episode cranks everything up to the max ; everyone has to face the inevitability of war. That's too harsh to do this to us. We believed in change ! But apparently, trying to change the system inevitably leads to death… I'm not sure I'm thrilled by that message. It's the complete opposite of the series Princess Agents, of which this is a sequel. It's the opposite of what Rebirth was trying to tell us throughout its first thirty episodes. But it's a huge middle finger to censorship. Certainly.
Does this adaptation of the books differ so much from their source material (The Legend of Chu Qiao) because of the plagiarism the author was guilty of ? I don't know if that's why.
"I Always thought the people here needed me. But I finally realized the truth. It's not that they need me, but rather, I need them. All along, I've wanted to build a world of true equality, a place that people like me could finally call home."
A great cast in which women and men are equally important, with one generation clashing with the next.
_The lead actress, Huangyang Tian Tian, on whose shoulders the entire story rests, is very young but already a seasoned performer. Born in 2007, she has been acting nonstop since she was 9. She plays Chu Qiao with dedication ; her role is certainly complex, but... she's still just a child ! And it shows when she's surrounded by all her co-stars, who are all taller and older than her. A 17-year-old playing an adult and commanding armies. And for good reason : she played the same character as a child in the series Princess Agents, of which Rebirth is a sequel set nine years later. (You can watch it without seeing the first one, but it's better if you have, of course)
There was talk of replacing her because she posted a photo of herself wearing extremely expensive earrings, which caused a backlash in China. It turns out they were counterfeits that her father was selling illegally. Well, irresponsible fathers, what a pain !
But she's definitely there. And she nails her action scenes (all of which are well choreographed). Her deadpan comedy scenes work just as well. As for the emotion… Her love for the ML takes a lot of effort to believe. It feels more like the friendship between an older brother and his little sister. To be honest, Zhuge Yue has more chemistry with his brother-in-arms, touching his hand in episode 21, or in his fights with Yan Xun of Great Yan, plucking a purple petal from his hair, or when he runs hand-in-hand with Li Ce to escape the soldiers. The latter ends up in his arms, like a princess. Haha, come to think of it, he really does have a looooot of affectionate scenes with other men. That’s perfectly fine by me. He's entitled to love. And I'd rather avoid a romance between a schoolgirl who should be at school and a thirty-something grown-ass, if possible. (For goodness sake ! Thankfully, they managed to avoid that)
_Zhuge Yue, the male lead, I didn't really like his drastic change in personality. After all those trials and tribulations, to end up like that ? No. I appreciate seeing characters develop, but come on, let's take it slowly.
His fight with Chu Qiao at the end, all blue, purple and grey, what drama ! It's so sad that someone has to die for peace to reign. Such a pain when that happens.
_The Empress plays a central role in the first half and exerts a certain influence on the rest of the story. She wears cream, emerald and saffron gowns in her luxurious bright-red apartments with dark wood panelling. Such beauty ! One of the cruelest characters, or so we believe, until we see the Emperor in action. A profoundly tragic role from start to finish, and a character who, in her misfortune, hurts everyone around her. We detest her for her actions, yet we feel sympathy for what she has endured.
_The motley crew of criminals surrounding the heroine brings a touch of light-heartedness and humour, as well as some elaborate action scenes. Their camaraderie is always a joy to watch. Too bad we don't see them more often. But, for them too, what a tragic end...
_Li Ce, the unfortunate boy, watches his mother die before his very eyes ; even after burying her, he still longs for a sign of her affection. It's hard to grow up without love. Yet he is kind and wise in his choices. A wonderful character with a truly tragic ending.
_King Ximei of Ximeng, who sends his double in his place to dine with the emperor. Well done.
This bloke is the polar opposite of the heroine, Chu Qiao. He, too, is a former slave, but he takes the place of his masters and becomes the new tyrant. His death is only just. All power to the Soviets.
_General Huan Huan and Princess Helian of Yanbei (a woman of otherworldly beauty with a aquiline nose) make a lovely couple. May they live happily ever after. Brave, courageous women stripped of their free will. Their scenes are pure queer baiting.
_Princess Helian's marriage to Xun Yan, so intense, it feels like we're right in the middle of a soap opera. The two marry out of obligation and give up on their soulmates.
"All because I believe there should be a place in this world where people are not divided by rank or class, where justice exists. Only such a place can truly be called my homeland." The Grapes of Wrath, Part 2.
Right. I don't really understand the negative reviews I've seen about the direction or the acting. Especially since this barrage of complaints started right from the very first episodes : so before the plot twist in the final episodes. Princess Agents was far less well made and was torn to shreds by critics and the public when it aired. Suddenly, it's become the best series in the universe ? Strange. It reeks of gatekeeping. Because Rebirth is aimed at a wider audience, I think. I hope I'm wrong.
As for me, I'm not going to deny myself the pleasure. That lighting, the entire artistic presentation, all designed to delight the eye. Those splashes of scarlet blood on the pale rice-paper doors. (Ep. 22) The comfort these C-dramas bring. The focus on entertainment. It's my safe place !
Always pushing the boundaries of censorship to tackle truly serious issues. Because, in reality, it's about women fighting to survive in a man's world. And about power that offers nothing but an obsession with keeping it all to oneself. It's the old chivalric tale of heroes who deserve to rule because they don't want to and because they care about the people. Here, the powerful are cruel and uncompromising, without merit, ready to kill or let die, ready to commit infanticide.
The heroine, by contrast, is a former slave who rises to the highest echelons of power yet never forgets her roots. She abolishes slavery (I particularly enjoyed seeing those delicate nobles explode with rage when it was taken away from them without compensation. And, oddly enough, they don't give a damn about the country anymore), she stops the wars, she spares the peasants and the thieves. (Are we talking about Jesus or what ?)
But. Whatever the social status of these women, they are always slaves to something: power, alcohol, their husbands, cults. That doesn't make them saints. The empress literally groomed her lover and right-hand man, and she has maids killed for her own pleasure.
"Men will never risk everything for women. They can only be seduiced by power."
Once again, I've written a proper novel ; pointless, too long and uninteresting. (Oh ! I've found a title for my autobiography)
---------------------
When I, too, am in a melancholy mood, I stand tall on the ramparts of my domain, my face lashed by winter gales, gazing at the night and the snow that blankets even my painful past. When suddenly ! I find myself stabbed by the one who was meant to be me.
The end credits of the last episode were awesome, with all that behind-the-scenes footage! Way better than that whole "43 years later" segment.
Was this review helpful to you?
