Melody of Secrets

Do I need to give up on BL thrillers & Mysteries?

Every one of them has disappointed me.

Easily the best thing about this series was the cinematography.

OST was okay, I guess. I didn't pay attention to it half the time.

Watched a lot of it at X2 speed when the talking was really slow (this may have just been me), flashbacks, and when it was just music playing over moments with no dialogue.

Everyone did a good job on the acting, especially Jan (Dao) and Pu (the grandma). I hated both of their characters so much from the very beginning. The grandma was just a right bitch that I wanted to punt in the nearest lake. She was downright horrible to Tontharn for reasons that weren't his fault, and some of the problems she caused. She at least admitted that what she did was nasty, unlike Dao, who, until the very end, thinks she was in the right.

Now, Dao, I didn't like her because she was just shit at her job. I know that it was to spin the narrative, but boy, was she bad at it. I don't for a second think that she was 2nd in her class. Second from the bottom, maybe. I have 1 Forensic Science class from high school under my belt, and I knew more about how an investigation is meant to be run. This wasn't it! What made it more confusing was that the timeline of events was in order, but it was almost impossible to tell when things happened. I blame the writers for that. We start with two dead bodies found on the same day, and we aren't told the time of death, how they died, or if any evidence could be found at a secondary location, or if they were killed where their bodies were found. No one tried to backtrack their movements from the day they were killed, or if they had any other connections other than working for Botphleng's family. No one questions why this person killed and dumped two bodies in the "open" (they weren't really) like they were "playing with the police" and then stopped. I'm not saying killers can't just kill and stop; I'm just pointing out that no one thought it was strange. Did Thunphob die from the head wound or drowning? He was nothing but bones? Get an anthropologist to take a look. Also, his body was found a month before the series started, but how long had he actually been dead? Unless I missed it, no one reported him as a missing person. Then we have the fact that Botphleng could be a target, and she just doesn't give a rat's ass. She literally says, "He's strong, he can protect himself." Whether he can or can't doesn't matter; it's your job to offer him protection. He doesn't have to take it, but you have to offer it.

As a whole, crime investigation and general knowledge needed a lot of work. It would have been nice to see some of it as well, instead of Dao pulling information out of thin air like she was investigating, and not trying to spin the narrative. Honestly, for her reveal, it would have been better if she had been a likeable person who seemed to be trying to help, that way the reveal would have come as a greater shock. Just because most of the hate is going to the grandma doesn't mean that people are just going to think she's the killer. To me, she seemed too obvious a suspect, so I was suspecting everyone but her and her daughter. I also didn't think it was Tanu, Jen, Miles, or Tankoon, so that left very few people as suspects.

I'm going to be honest. I normally don't like Force or Books acting, I liked them in Perfect 10 Lines and nothing else, but they did a really good job in this one, especially Book. Book actually made me cry when he was telling Nim everything that he could remember. Not an ugly cry, but the silent kind that you don't realize is there until it's already fallen. His panic attack was also good.

Why did Thunphob continue using Tankoon's name with Botphleng after they got closer? Seemed weird.

Tankoon pissed me off (this was a script problem) when one minute he would say "I'll help you get your memories back" and then the next say "Your family doesn't want you to remember for a reason". PICK A SIDE AND STAY THERE. Also, who gives a fuck what the family wants? They are clearly hiding something shady if they have spent countless years making this boy forget who he is. Tontharn going back to the house at all after learning about the hypnosis was just wild and one of the stupidest things to do. No one put this boy in a horror movie.

Tanu also pissed me off by saving Botphleng's mom in the fire when his literal son had a large piece of burning wood on top of his unconscious body. I don't know if he knew Botphleng was in the burning building, but if he did, I'm doubly pissed off because what the fuck!? Why save the one person NOT directly in harm's way? Am I the crazy one?

The only surprising, and in my opinion, well-done thing done in this series was Tontharn being Botphleng and the reveal of it.

It would have been really interesting if the real Botphleng had followed Tontharn around as a ghost during the whole series, only to finally be laid to rest once the truth is revealed and his grave is placed next to Thunphob, then they move on together.

I've seen quite a few Thai thrillers, and so far the only one that hasn't disappointed me is Triage. I won't stop watching them completely, but I'm going to be very picky from now on. I went into this with zero expectations, and the only reason my rating isn't lower is because of the acting, and Botphleng's real identity reveal was well done.

Read More

I Dropped It

I see a lot of people in the comments so eager to defend their favs they can't even tolerate people not enjoying this.
So let me tell you right now before you use your predetermined defense to ignore my points that I LOVE a good mystery. I loved the 1st half of DFF, all the Knives Out films, am thoroughly enjoying GBYFD and also sorta intrigued by DYTD; I watch murder mysteries and documentaries all the time, one of my all time favourite series is The Haunting (both Hill House and Bly Manor).
The problem with Melody of Secrets? The mystery simply hasn't proven itself to be good.
Nor did anything else, really.
The chemistry is non-existing, the plot doesn't move one bit, the characters barely even work at their jobs. They keep trynna sell you confusion but what they're selling you is actually frustration because nothing happens, nothing changes, nothing moves.
And then after this lukewarm still water 3 episodes they try to get you with a predictable plot twist and a hand full of nothing. How am I supposed to say it's good? Honestly? It sucks. That's it. It just sucks.

Read More

A ForceBook series that is one of a kind.

The storyline was so good. Makes you think, predict, or theorized what really happened in the past. Something that would make you think critically while having fun watching the series. Actors acting skills were very good, too. Really served us with different emotions that makes us, viewers, felt satisfied. ForceBook as actors are really doing great and put a lot of effort not just MOS but also all the other series they have. From episode 1 till episode 7, I am still hooked up with this series.

Can't wait for the next episodes.

Watch it. You'll love it too.

Read More

Definitely not boring.

Ok so I want to start by saying that this series is not for everyone. I’m sorry but if you want a easy/funny BL series to watch only to see your faves and for the NC scenes, this is not for you! In my opinion Melody of Secrets it’s not for everyone, it’s for a more mature audience who can understand the characters, dynamics and plots. It’s a murder-mistery romance, has heavy elements and you need to watch it with an open mind to understand it. The acting is amazing, every one of them made an excellent job in the interpretation of their role. For me, this is the best ForceBook acting work, they really put their hearts into this and improved a lot. I want to point out especially Kasibook’s acting especially since, in my opinion, his role is the most complex and emotionally challenging and he really did an amazing job into conveying his emotions/ feelings in such a natural way, and sometimes only with the help of his eyes. In these kind of series, the eyes and micro expressions are the best way to convey the importance of the moment, and he is really good at it. And please, for the love of God please stop saying that they don’t have chemistry! The chemistry is there and it’s amazing, the intimacy scenes are well done ( a little bit short sometimes hehe) and the love story is sad but beautiful. The only thing I did not like, and that has nothing to do with the actors, was the editing of some episodes.
If you want to see something different with an amazing cast and good storyline and a beautiful love story please give it a chance, you will not regret it.

Read More

When Chemistry Hits but the Mystery Keeps You Guessing

Okey, This is my first time reviewing! i had to do it because people are sleeping on this series
I’m literally hooked. Four episodes in, and this drama has me completely curious about how the story is going to unwrap as it progresses. Every episode leaves me wanting answers while also throwing more questions at me, and honestly, that’s part of the charm.

The plot feels fresh, especially for a BL. The memory loss angle combined with the mystery element is something I haven’t really seen explored like this before, and it immediately sets the drama apart. Each episode has its own impact, making me feel more intrigued and, at times, confused in a good way. The kind of confusion that makes you replay scenes and analyze every detail.

The pacing, though, is a bit mixed. It feels like a strange combination of slow burn and rushed at the same time. While I do enjoy the kisses and romantic moments, I personally wish the story slowed down a little more. I’m very much into yearning, desperation, and emotional tension, and I feel like the angst of Tanpleng could have been explored more deeply if the pacing allowed it.

The mystery layer is definitely on the confusing side, especially for viewers who don’t analyze much. Since I already know some major spoilers, I can follow where the story is headed, but I can see how people with less concentration might struggle. That said, this confusion only makes me want to watch more and connect the dots myself.

Now, the chemistry. Absolutely on point. From episode one itself, the chemistry between Force and Book is serving, and yes, I might be a little biased, but it genuinely works. Their dynamic pulls you in immediately and keeps you invested.

Performance-wise, everyone is doing a great job. Book having multiple people crushing on him is always a win, and the confession scenes were especially enjoyable. There honestly isn’t a single bad actor in this series; everyone shines in their own way. The leads, in particular, surprised me. After Peaceful Property, seeing them cry this much and deliver such emotional scenes really shows how much their acting has improved.

Visually, the drama is beautiful. The cinematography, lighting, and aesthetics give the series a special glow. The OSTs are another highlight; ForceBook absolutely nailed them, and both songs have already become favorites for me. While the pilot trailer felt darker, the current lighter tone gives the drama its true romantic thriller vibe, which works really well.

Emotionally, episode 4 hit hard. When they cried, I cried with them. The angst is finally showing up, and the actors are nailing those moments, though I definitely want more angst moving forward.

Some standout positives for me are the cameos and, of course, the kissing scenes. They’re genuinely eating up the screen every time. My only real complaint so far is the pacing. With just 10 episodes, the story feels like it’s moving too fast, and I can’t help but think it would’ve hit even harder with more room to breathe.

Going forward, I’m hoping for more plot twists, more emotional depth, and definitely more cameos. I’m even manifesting one particular actor to show up.

Overall, Melody of Secrets is intriguing, emotionally engaging, and visually pleasing. It’s already shaping up to be a memorable BL, and I’m very excited to see how the mystery unfolds

Read More

A Haunting Melody of Love, Lies, and Memory

I have always loved crime scenes, murder, and investigation stories, so pairing that genre with BL already had me excited. What made it even better is seeing one of my favourite couples, ForceBook, back on screen. Force as Tankoon, a criminologist, and Book as Botphleng, a crime journalist, is honestly a perfect pairing. Their chemistry is strong, natural, and convincing, and their acting feels more mature and grounded than ever.

We have seen ForceBook in both office and university BLs before, so getting them in a fresh mystery crime genre feels like such a breath of fresh air. The first two episodes completely hooked me. I was genuinely shocked by how many kiss scenes we got in the very first episode. The idea of kissing someone when you do not remember anything about them, yet your heart and instincts know you have loved and kissed them before, was portrayed so beautifully. It felt intimate, unsettling, and emotional all at once.

I will be honest, like many viewers, I was confused during the first episode. But it was a good kind of confusion. The title has the word Secrets for a reason. The storytelling is deliberately fragmented, and that sense of disorientation puts you right into Botphleng’s state of mind.

For anyone who felt lost after episode one, do not give up or judge it too quickly. The confusion is intentional. If everything were explained from the start, the mystery and tension that make this genre so addictive would completely disappear. With eight more episodes to go, the series is clearly designed to keep you questioning, uneasy, and constantly guessing, and that is exactly what makes it so compelling.

There is no second couple in this series, which actually works in its favour, as it keeps the focus tight and intense. I am also glad they added Boun to the cast. He is a strong actor and adds another layer of intrigue to the story.

So far, the plot feels unique, the acting is strong across the board, and the atmosphere is dark, suspenseful, and emotionally charged.

Personally, I think this series has been executed really well and perfectly captures the tone of a true psychological and suspense BL. I am genuinely looking forward to the remaining episodes, because if it continues at this level, Melody of Secrets could easily become one of GMMTV’s standout BLs.

Read More

whoever doesn't watch this show is truly missing out!

melody of secrets is actually an underrated masterpiece and i’m serious. it’s not the type of bl you can just play in the background because the story really makes you pay attention—everything connects later and the tension builds slowly each episode. the whole memory loss + investigation plot keeps you guessing, and some scenes hit harder because they don’t over-explain anything. the atmosphere is heavy and quiet most of the time, which makes the emotional moments feel more real.

and forcebook really carried this. you can tell their acting has upgraded to another level. they’re always delivering the emotions naturally, especially in the small details. it never feels forced. honestly, it deserved way more attention than it got.

Read More