Aramintai

Whether they planned to swap actresses for part 2 or not is not known yet. And them actors being rookies or veterans has nothing to with what they planned for the plot or their plans for part 2. It could have been a cast full of veterans if they wanted to and still it would have made no difference for the plot or their plans for part 2.

Also, The Four Seasons are all rookies and nobody's switching them for part 2 - it' s something that's been confirmed already. And all of them are well loved in spite being rookies. Same goes for FL - the main lead. Whomever her actress would have been, swapping her for another actress would have still been a very controversial topic.

So you trying to shoehorn the rumor to initial FL actress being a rookie to be replaced by another rookie, just because they're both rookies that nobody will care about is pointless and some weird reach of logic. It's FL we're talking about here, not some minor side character - initial rookie's acting skills were subpar to what was required hence she was swapped for someone who's skillful and readily available, could have been some other talented rookie if they could have found it as fast. And that's it, there's nothing more to it and again, has nothing to do with what was planned for the plot of both parts.

Yea, I won't find it now. But it is mentioned in this article:
https://www.kdramastars.com/articles/125806/20220712/jung-so-min-not-reprise-role-alchemy-of-souls-part-2-why.htm

Quote:
"The actress appeased fans through her agency, Blossom Entertainment, and said "I'm not leaving. We are discussing appearing in Part 2.""

And in this one was another quote from her then agency:
https://zapzee.net/2022/07/12/go-youn-jung-is-leading-alchemy-of-souls-part-2-instead-of-jung-so-min/
Quote:
"Regarding this, Jung So Min’s agency Blossom Entertainment responded, “She’s not leaving the show. She originally signed the contract to only appear in part 1.”"
and quote:
"Soon after the news hit the wire, the Alchemy of Souls production team stated, “Any information regarding part 2 could act as a spoiler for part 1, which is still on air, so we can’t confirm or deny the report.”"

These are tabloids, so take anything they write with a big grain of salt. But that og JSM's reply was out there, I've seen it.

In any case, whatever it is they decided is still not known. She stays as FL/ stays as Bu-Yeon/ leaves - all up in the air until part 1 is finished.

Nothing is confirmed yet, wait until part 1 ends. Also, why rookie was hastily replaced with none other than JSM may very well have something to do with her being director's close acquaintance. There was not enough time to do recasting from scratch, so they asked a familiar actress. Other than that, you can't assume anything about who's out or not just by being a rookie or a veteran - all young characters, aside from recast FL, are played by rookie actors, og Naksu included. Means absolutely nothing.
Also, at the time of the rumor leak there was JSM's tweet reply saying she's still in and in the talks for part 2, how that ended up we will now soon enough. Hold your horses.

He may have had a rough plan coming in, but he couldn't have known what sort of people he will encounter in the house. Him finding a way to entice them to work with him and subsequently finding out about Ms. Kwon's secret is all about his quick wits. And since then his plan surely has already been altered. He's a mastermind type of character.

I like how Woo Shin came to the villain's house empty handed with nothing but his wits about him and now he already got several key characters to work with him and threw a giant wrench into Mr. Kwon's and Ms. Kwon's seemingly unshakable relationship 🤣 Maybe he won't even need to dirty his hands, maybe that crazy family will just kill each other off in the end?

Exactly. They gonna do some crazy twist at the end to keep us guessing - cliffhanger incoming. I'm betting on it being bad. But you guys stay positive, people need it here.

There are some like that. Crash Landing on You or Graceful Family, for example. But the latter is over the top makjang, not for those who want to keep their blood pressure on normal levels.
Also, I've seen a big argument about how it doesn't work well for FL being a rich bitch instead of ML in It's Okay To Not Be Okay comment section. Like, when a woman is acting bossy, 4-dimensional and is rich, while ML is a timid hardworking guy it's somehow very offputting and unattractive. Like, it's not a typical role for a woman or something. Maybe it is for conservative SK, since there are not a lot of kdramas I can recall with such a role reversal. 🙄

Actors playing evil guys are doing a very fine job, I see. Jin Mu, So-i, shaman Choi - all need to be punished soooo badly, I hate them 👿
Also, Jin Mu was so hilarious when FL thought into whom to soul shift. Personally I think his was the funniest representation.

It's Hong sisters, can't trust them with a happy ending. And the fact that there's part 2 on the way just adds more fuel to the fire.

I think it will end with a sad ending followed by a big fat cliffhanger. After all, gotta keep the audience boiling in angst until part 2 airs.

Yea, let's eat one poisonous flower to immediately (!) treat poison from another. Dosage? Usage method? Who cares, for teh science! 🤣 Also, noble stupidity at its finest here - healthy doctor tries drugs on himself instead of already deadly sick patients - he seriously could have died and wouldn't have cured anybody, would have been hilarious. I'm really starting to get pissed off about "medicinal practices" here, the most offputting element of this drama.
And why are ML's eyes bulging so often, especially when he raises his voice, which is frequent? Is it his actor's way of acting?

P.S. If you want to watch a serious kdrama with similar plot and without cartoonish overacting characters try "Kingdom".

It may be unpopular because it's a slow burn drama with no romance, but at least it tries to be intelligent when it comes to plot. I'm seriously tired of dumbassery, cartoon characters and overacting in recent detective fiction dramas, I want food for thought for once without annoying distactions.

I dunno about the boy, maybe his soul was still inside or went to master Lee's burning body. But he was dying anyway and master Lee had no body, so...
I really don't think hwansu mage can soul shift other people. But he can shift himself for sure without the ice stone or soul ejectors with no repercussions.

Ugh, what is this? Why are they copying Bruce Wayne/Batman's story here? Why ML is acting like he's some Sherlock Holmes wannabe? Why is it so cheap and cringe?

It has a few serious life questioning themes, but it's still mainly a comedy.

I don't think so. I think it only works with your own soul.
However, there is another interesting fact about Hwansu - when he meditated his soul was wandering around until he soul shifted into a dying boy when he realized his og body is being burned. This is rather weird, it's like being an invisible ghost or something.
Ordinary people there however seem to retain their souls in their dead bodies, they don't go anywhere when reanimated.

Yes.

He still has no clue. But he knows Uk and Mu-Deok have feelings for each other.

Why not post it for relevant kdrama? Also, director doesn't write the script, so if it was crap it most likely was writer's fault (I haven't watched it though). In Crazy Love both director and writer did a fine job.

There may as well be one here, they've tags for everything 😂 Or maybe not, since it doesn't tell much about the plot. There is a tag called "Drinking" however, but that's reserved for dramas about dire pro alcoholics like in "Drink Now, Work Later". Here it's just a staple "wasted for giggles" scene that can be seen in almost any kdrama.