Adding it here Bcz damn I wanna talk about this so much:Ep 4 theory after that shocking glimpse into Woo Hak's…
How I look at it is, there are clues pointing to both WH and BG being Ki-ho but the clues that point to WH can either be explained away or they feel like a misdirect. Some of the clues that suggest BG is Ki-ho can also be explained away but some of it can’t (for now), so on balance I think BG is Ki-ho. I’ll keep following the clues and see if that changes.
On a side note, I thought I was the only one who thought WH was in a cupboard in that flashback. Others have said it was the front door and I thought I interpreted it wrong. I thought the father was looking down at WH at kid level so I thought he must have been a child in his flashback and hiding i.e. in a cupboard. For this reason the flashback makes it seem like this is a memory of Ki-ho’s but I cannot shake the feeling this is another misdirect as the father says, “where is Ki-ho?” instead of “where are you, Ki-ho?” However, we know how subtitles can be.
at Episode 2 right now, I have a question.will Ran Joo be the good guy and support Mokha, or just exploite her…
The problem is that Ran-joo is easily led and manipulated by the CEO. Mok-ha may get hurt by Ran-joo unintentionally because the CEO is Ran-joo’s weak spot.
A part of me honestly thought Ki ho's father would be a changed person and is genuinely looking for his son so…
That might be the case. He could be looking for his son to make amends. I wouldn’t put it past the writers even though they continue to make him menacing.
I'm still trying to understand that scene in which that random grandma talks about her past like she is ran joo,…
This threw me for a loop. I have so many questions. Was it real? Is it a flash forward? If so, will we be getting more flash forwards? Who is the girl standing next to her and why do I feel like that was Mok-ha’s daughter and not Ran-joo’s daughter? How does this fit in with the current plot?
this is difficult because since the beginning of where they’re older, i’ve felt that woo hak was ki ho. probably…
Lol Ki-ho was always rude. He only started being nice to Mok-ha when they got closer and found they had the abuse in common. He’s always had a prickly personality.
But he’s trying NOT to be Ki-ho. In fact, he wants everyone to forget about Ki-ho and stop talking about him.…
Don’t worry. We’re all delulu. I like hearing theories even ones I disagree with as it’s all speculation until a theory is confirmed. In this sense, we’re all right and we’re all wrong. Like Schrödinger’s cat. 🙂
I don't know why it's easier for me to jump on clues that point out Bogeol being Kiho than it is for Woohak...like…
For me, certain clues already rule out Woo-hak completely. That’s the difference between his clues and Bo-gaol’s clues but I’ve been burned once before with K-dramas. I know writers sometimes betray their own logic, so they can easily write in that he’s Ki-ho and that’s that even if they’ve ruled it out themselves.
when Mokha asked him if he knows Kiho. Bogeol eyes holding pain, guilt and softness at the same time Woohak's…
It may just be me but his memory looks like the POV of a child so I will stick to my theory that Woo-hak is the younger brother who was taken away with the mum as a child.
In ep 3, I feel something about that rameon and water. Bo geol must have been hoping that mok ha might be alive…
I also had that thought but thought it was crazy. Imagine if that’s the case though, and he’s been sending care packages off to sea in case one of them ever drifted onto the island she was on. I’ve have inklings like this each episode but never shared because I thought they were too far fetched. I also had an inkling watching the previews of last episode that the person Mok-ha saw at the train station was the father because it looked like she was shocked (bad shocked) and she even slightly gulped, but I thought it was too far fetched. Turns out it WAS the father.
Even if Bo-geol isn’t Ki-ho, he knows who is but I’m more and more convinced it’s him now because he was hiding his face from the father. Why would he need to do that if he wasn’t Ki-ho. A lot of us suspected that his cold behaviour towards FL was because he is hiding from his father and this episode seems to further suggest that. I’m now convinced 100% that Woo-Hak is not Ki-ho and unless the writer decides to deviate away from the clues they’ve already given, I think it will stay that way even though I think the writer will continue to make it seem like it could be either of them until the end.
K-Drama 
1 
On a side note, I thought I was the only one who thought WH was in a cupboard in that flashback. Others have said it was the front door and I thought I interpreted it wrong. I thought the father was looking down at WH at kid level so I thought he must have been a child in his flashback and hiding i.e. in a cupboard. For this reason the flashback makes it seem like this is a memory of Ki-ho’s but I cannot shake the feeling this is another misdirect as the father says, “where is Ki-ho?” instead of “where are you, Ki-ho?” However, we know how subtitles can be.
I love a good mystery. 🤗