Regarding potentially problematic elements of KinnPorsche:
Stories can have problematic elements, but it is the director's responsibility to contextualize them. For example, as another commenter mentioned, sexual assault happens in real life. However, most of us recognize that sexual assault is morally and criminally wrong and we would expect it to be shown as something wrong in the story. A great example of how this was done *wrong* is Addicted. The whole kidnapping thing is shown as a cute quirk based in love and not the huge violation that it truly is. Or, Ohm and Toey's characters in Make It Right, their relationship starts with what is essentially a rape scene, to the point where Ohm has to take Toey to the hospital the next day because his anus is bleeding. This is presented as a sweet moment in a flashback with cute music playing in the same episode.
The best directors don't shy away from depicting real-world issues that can be very triggering for people, however, they do have a responsibility to show that these things are in fact wrong. The characters should show remorse, other characters should be angry or hold a grudge or be traumatized. BLs in the past have had a bad habit of showing *potentially* problematic scenes and completely ignoring the need to contextualize these scenes and show the viewers that we are supposed to feel conflicted. We can still like people who do problematic things, but we should have to wrestle with our own consciences, and figure out, has this character gone too far for us to still support them? Sometimes characters do things that are unforgiveable, and that can be appropriate as well.
Stories that involve crime, sexual assault, social problems like poverty, etc... should be shown in media, even in stories with heavy romantic elements, as KinnPorsche will undoubtedly have. However, what I will be looking for is to make sure that director (Uncle Tong from Bad Buddy!!! Who knew???) shows us these scenes in a way that makes us understand that these things require us to make a moral judgement. The director should not present these things in a way that makes us think the director sees them as normal or no big deal. The best media require us to care about complicated characters and, to some extent, take on their moral choices as our own. What would we do in that situation?
That is what I want to see in this series, and I hope it delivers, because I have been waiting a looooong time!
the way everyone is saying how they coudnt care less and hating kinnporshe in twt bc the novel is so problematic,…
Stories can have problematic elements, but it is the director's responsibility to contextualize them. For example, as another commenter mentioned, sexual assault happens in real life. However, most of us recognize that sexual assault is morally and criminally wrong and we would expect it to be shown as something wrong in the story. A great example of how this was done *wrong* is Addicted. The whole kidnapping thing is shown as a cute quirk based in love and not the huge violation that it truly is. Or, Ohm and Toey's characters in Make It Right, their relationship starts with what is essentially a rape scene, to the point where Ohm has to take Toey to the hospital the next day because his anus is bleeding. This is presented as a sweet moment in a flashback with cute music playing in the same episode.
The best directors don't shy away from depicting real-world issues that can be very triggering for people, however, they do have a responsibility to show that these things are in fact wrong. The characters should show remorse, other characters should be angry or hold a grudge or be traumatized. BLs in the past have had a bad habit of showing *potentially* problematic scenes and completely ignoring the need to contextualize these scenes and show the viewers that we are supposed to feel conflicted. We can still like people who do problematic things, but we should have to wrestle with our own consciences, and figure out, has this character gone too far for us to still support them? Sometimes characters do things that are unforgiveable, and that can be appropriate as well.
Stories that involve crime, sexual assault, social problems like poverty, etc... should be shown in media, even in stories with heavy romantic elements, as KinnPorsche will undoubtedly have. However, what I will be looking for is to make sure that director (Uncle Tong from Bad Buddy!!! Who knew???) shows us these scenes in a way that makes us understand that these things require us to make a moral judgement. The director should not present these things in a way that makes us think the director sees them as normal or no big deal. The best media require us to care about complicated characters and, to some extent, take on their moral choices as our own. What would we do in that situation?
That is what I want to see in this series, and I hope it delivers, because I have been waiting a looooong time!
I'm pretty torn on the first episode. The line delivery at times is... Really forced. Mainly when speaking English.…
The delivery on the mandarin was not very good either, although, since they were supposed to be speaking it as a second/third language, that makes sense.
I did not have high expectations for this series, but the first episode was actually really enjoyable! Art and Mikey are completely adorable, the pacing is good (I hate BLs where it takes 5 episodes for anything to happen), the music was good, it all gave me a musical theatre vibe (especially the over-acting, that is sooo musical theater). Obviously, there were parts where the quality wasn't as good (some of the acting is low quality), but it all worked for me. I grew up in the era of low-budget, queer short films, so I am happy to excuse some bad acting as long as the overall product works, and, to be honest, I just really liked this episode! I can't wait for ep2!
I honestly wanted to smack White too when he was justifying capitalism, I felt exactly like Gram lol
Seriously, your brother is a leader in an anarchist collective that is fighting against privilege and power and then you start apologizing for capitalism and don't think your friends are going to be suspicious??? C'mon, White!
The trailer was very well shot and produced, the cast are all cute, and have good chemistry, but the plot was all over the place! I hope it makes more sense in the actual series, but I will definitely be watching
The trailer was very well shot and produced, the cast are all cute, and have good chemistry, but the plot was all over the place! I hope it makes more sense in the actual series, but I will definitely be watching
I'm confused, are we supposed to think Theo might end up with one of the other guys? Akk drags him around, almost kisses him, etc... throughout the whole trailer. Unless the show is drastically different from the trailer, aren't they the leads???
Damn, this show has so much drama! I love it, all the backstabbing, the blackmailing, the hot guys, the hot girls, the outfits, the shade! I can't wait for the big reveal!!!
This was a great first episode. The quality of the cinematography is in the top 5% of BLs. I am so intrigued and I want more! It's rare to see a college BL so well done!
"Are they going to get in trouble with the government???"You know we have to get rid of those governments with…
I have no idea what you are talking about. What is the Covid scam? I fully support reforming all governments, but I don't what Covid scam you are talking about.
Stories can have problematic elements, but it is the director's responsibility to contextualize them. For example, as another commenter mentioned, sexual assault happens in real life. However, most of us recognize that sexual assault is morally and criminally wrong and we would expect it to be shown as something wrong in the story. A great example of how this was done *wrong* is Addicted. The whole kidnapping thing is shown as a cute quirk based in love and not the huge violation that it truly is. Or, Ohm and Toey's characters in Make It Right, their relationship starts with what is essentially a rape scene, to the point where Ohm has to take Toey to the hospital the next day because his anus is bleeding. This is presented as a sweet moment in a flashback with cute music playing in the same episode.
The best directors don't shy away from depicting real-world issues that can be very triggering for people, however, they do have a responsibility to show that these things are in fact wrong. The characters should show remorse, other characters should be angry or hold a grudge or be traumatized. BLs in the past have had a bad habit of showing *potentially* problematic scenes and completely ignoring the need to contextualize these scenes and show the viewers that we are supposed to feel conflicted. We can still like people who do problematic things, but we should have to wrestle with our own consciences, and figure out, has this character gone too far for us to still support them? Sometimes characters do things that are unforgiveable, and that can be appropriate as well.
Stories that involve crime, sexual assault, social problems like poverty, etc... should be shown in media, even in stories with heavy romantic elements, as KinnPorsche will undoubtedly have. However, what I will be looking for is to make sure that director (Uncle Tong from Bad Buddy!!! Who knew???) shows us these scenes in a way that makes us understand that these things require us to make a moral judgement. The director should not present these things in a way that makes us think the director sees them as normal or no big deal. The best media require us to care about complicated characters and, to some extent, take on their moral choices as our own. What would we do in that situation?
That is what I want to see in this series, and I hope it delivers, because I have been waiting a looooong time!
The best directors don't shy away from depicting real-world issues that can be very triggering for people, however, they do have a responsibility to show that these things are in fact wrong. The characters should show remorse, other characters should be angry or hold a grudge or be traumatized. BLs in the past have had a bad habit of showing *potentially* problematic scenes and completely ignoring the need to contextualize these scenes and show the viewers that we are supposed to feel conflicted. We can still like people who do problematic things, but we should have to wrestle with our own consciences, and figure out, has this character gone too far for us to still support them? Sometimes characters do things that are unforgiveable, and that can be appropriate as well.
Stories that involve crime, sexual assault, social problems like poverty, etc... should be shown in media, even in stories with heavy romantic elements, as KinnPorsche will undoubtedly have. However, what I will be looking for is to make sure that director (Uncle Tong from Bad Buddy!!! Who knew???) shows us these scenes in a way that makes us understand that these things require us to make a moral judgement. The director should not present these things in a way that makes us think the director sees them as normal or no big deal. The best media require us to care about complicated characters and, to some extent, take on their moral choices as our own. What would we do in that situation?
That is what I want to see in this series, and I hope it delivers, because I have been waiting a looooong time!
He could have just never said anything to White at all.