14
22
2
3
1
1
2
1
2
4
1
1
1
2
7
4
1
This review may contain spoilers
Between a Fan’s Fantasy and an Idol’s Truth.
A quietly rewarding watch without high- stakes thrills
Idol isn’t a groundbreaking or must-watch K-drama—and that’s precisely its strength. In an era where nearly every show is labeled a “masterpiece,” Idol feels refreshingly normal. It’s a warm, low-effort watch that prioritizes comfort and empathy over shock or intensity. The murder mystery adds just enough momentum to keep the story moving.
Don’t pick it up on a day you are looking for action-packed or fast-paced romance… but tbh its all a personal perspective and experience for everyone.
I watched it during my exam period, and it offered just enough joy to look forward to without demanding emotional or mental energy. The opening episodes are easy and inviting, while the middle slows down slightly, the short 12-episode format ensures the drama never overstays its welcome.
What truly grounds the series is its cozy atmosphere, especially the FL’s home. Filled with sunlight, wooden textures, and a small garden, it evokes quiet childhood nostalgia—even without the typical cluttered “family warmth.” This setting becomes the emotional backbone of the show, reinforcing its gentle and humane tone.
The characters follow familiar K-drama archetypes, but the writing doesn’t force intensity or exaggeration. The ML’s vulnerability and unthreatened masculinity stand out, and while the drama acknowledges emotional wounds, it doesn’t feel the need to dissect them in exhaustive detail—especially as it juggles multiple themes. The thriller subplot remains engaging until the end, and although the investigation isn’t the core focus, the mystery holds attention without becoming frustrating(unless that's the only reason you are watching this).
THE CAST:
Choi Sooyoung is a clear highlight. Her acting feels natural and comforting across all tones—soft, sharp, or restrained—and her presence alone adds warmth to the drama. I do have a bias toward her, and that undoubtedly contributes to my overall fondness for the show.
The ML actor is equally convincing; despite being 37, he never looks out of place as an idol. His portrayal of fragility, quiet vulnerability, and sincere affection has always felt authentic across all his roles in the past, and his dynamic with Sooyoung works effortlessly. I wouldn’t mind seeing him play idol roles for another decade ~~` hehe
The main prosecutor’s character was engaging and layered, though I felt his potential wasn’t fully explored. Still, he remained one of the show’s strongest pillars until the end, and my favorite character.
Woo-seok, on the other hand, was the most pitiable character for me.
I also enjoyed the bond between fl and sml, who felt like two lone strangers who found a family in each other, similar to ml and woo-seok.
At its core, Idol delivers meaningful messages: idols are human, wrongful imprisonment and biased justice have lasting consequences, and second chances matter.
The show raises a few inevitable questions about where admiration ends and obsession begins. Be it relationship or idolizing; Is fandom harmless devotion, or does it sometimes cross into invasion of privacy and entitlement?
Hye-joo’s character further complicates this moral space, making us question if broken people who never received love should always be met with pity and forgiveness. Pain may explain behavior, but it doesn’t excuse it—characters like Maeng or Ra-ik show that suffering doesn’t have to translate into destruction. But it also show how vulnerable and dangerous our emotions and mind can make us.
Overall, Idol I knows exactly what it is. It doesn’t aim high, but it succeeds in being warm, sincere, and quietly thought-provoking—and sometimes, that’s exactly what you need.
Idol isn’t a groundbreaking or must-watch K-drama—and that’s precisely its strength. In an era where nearly every show is labeled a “masterpiece,” Idol feels refreshingly normal. It’s a warm, low-effort watch that prioritizes comfort and empathy over shock or intensity. The murder mystery adds just enough momentum to keep the story moving.
Don’t pick it up on a day you are looking for action-packed or fast-paced romance… but tbh its all a personal perspective and experience for everyone.
I watched it during my exam period, and it offered just enough joy to look forward to without demanding emotional or mental energy. The opening episodes are easy and inviting, while the middle slows down slightly, the short 12-episode format ensures the drama never overstays its welcome.
What truly grounds the series is its cozy atmosphere, especially the FL’s home. Filled with sunlight, wooden textures, and a small garden, it evokes quiet childhood nostalgia—even without the typical cluttered “family warmth.” This setting becomes the emotional backbone of the show, reinforcing its gentle and humane tone.
The characters follow familiar K-drama archetypes, but the writing doesn’t force intensity or exaggeration. The ML’s vulnerability and unthreatened masculinity stand out, and while the drama acknowledges emotional wounds, it doesn’t feel the need to dissect them in exhaustive detail—especially as it juggles multiple themes. The thriller subplot remains engaging until the end, and although the investigation isn’t the core focus, the mystery holds attention without becoming frustrating(unless that's the only reason you are watching this).
THE CAST:
Choi Sooyoung is a clear highlight. Her acting feels natural and comforting across all tones—soft, sharp, or restrained—and her presence alone adds warmth to the drama. I do have a bias toward her, and that undoubtedly contributes to my overall fondness for the show.
The ML actor is equally convincing; despite being 37, he never looks out of place as an idol. His portrayal of fragility, quiet vulnerability, and sincere affection has always felt authentic across all his roles in the past, and his dynamic with Sooyoung works effortlessly. I wouldn’t mind seeing him play idol roles for another decade ~~` hehe
The main prosecutor’s character was engaging and layered, though I felt his potential wasn’t fully explored. Still, he remained one of the show’s strongest pillars until the end, and my favorite character.
Woo-seok, on the other hand, was the most pitiable character for me.
I also enjoyed the bond between fl and sml, who felt like two lone strangers who found a family in each other, similar to ml and woo-seok.
At its core, Idol delivers meaningful messages: idols are human, wrongful imprisonment and biased justice have lasting consequences, and second chances matter.
The show raises a few inevitable questions about where admiration ends and obsession begins. Be it relationship or idolizing; Is fandom harmless devotion, or does it sometimes cross into invasion of privacy and entitlement?
Hye-joo’s character further complicates this moral space, making us question if broken people who never received love should always be met with pity and forgiveness. Pain may explain behavior, but it doesn’t excuse it—characters like Maeng or Ra-ik show that suffering doesn’t have to translate into destruction. But it also show how vulnerable and dangerous our emotions and mind can make us.
Overall, Idol I knows exactly what it is. It doesn’t aim high, but it succeeds in being warm, sincere, and quietly thought-provoking—and sometimes, that’s exactly what you need.
Was this review helpful to you?
