ShortCircuit

So theory no. 1: the loop is tied to him, not to her. The longer he lives, the longer the loop. She got caught in it and is the first to remember, but I guess this time - the 6th - the loop is long enough for him to remember what happens, too.

Can't wait to see the rest of the episodes TLed. It looks very high quality, and it's rather short (by cdrama standards anyway), so it has the potential to be a great scifi series :D

Go Bai Jing Ting and team!

Wow, the first episode is amazing!

It only took less than half an hour for him to go from "this guy is a psycho, something's wrong with him" to "yo, psycho, you're my best and most trusted friend, let's do crime solving together!"

Why?!

After he opened the door in his memory, K was completely gone for the rest of the episode. At least that was interesting.

The Heart Mender and the strange lawyer-ex-prosecutor with the crazy mom came back, I like them.

But something's changed, and not for the better, IMHO, with the flow of the drama. I hope the final act is worth it.

What a 180 turn for RSY in just 20 minutes of drama :(

Like, OGT and Jae Seong just... clicking together as a team and having a sweet moment here and there wasn't too bad in the previous eps, but this time OGT is JS's "wife". That being said by JS's actual wife. And repeated by RSY too. I get it. I got it the first time, loud and clear. But it cheapens the whole thing somehow. IMHO it worked way better when it was left unspoken - OGT peeling off apples for JS in the hospital was way more cute than JS's wife calling him a wife, too. It's demeaning to both characters, they're becoming caricatures of bromancey fellow cops.

Then the whole truck thing with RSY and K. They're supposed to be the same person, what IS IT with the dog&pony show? They won't be in any kind of romance with each other - other than RSY's narcissism - so why would they need to compliment their OWN ****, or play it so crassly on the topic of having to go to the bathroom where no bathroom is available? That's such a school-level joke. I really expected more, because the drama was a bit more leveled than that, despite the crazyness.

And that brings me to the DID. WHAT? Now RSY is supposed to go to another shady psychologist who has his own agenda (you could see him being a main antagonist from the door to his office, LOL) and what? Talk about his feelings? In front of a camera? I have this impression the new guy doesn't give a damn about his "patients's" privacy. Why would RSY accept it? Why would the police send him to this guy, when he's not in any way affiliated to a professional office of the police?! I very much preferred the Heart Mender, he at least - despite having lost his licence - showed he deeply CARED for RSY. Even in a hilarious manner.

At least they got rid of the corrupted Narc, though after that the love plot came out of the blue somewhat.

I'm starting to be a bit uncomfortable with the pretty callous manner the drama presents some things, from DID to bromance. It's supposed to be hilarious, but I keep getting thrown out of the scene every time they jump the shark...

For something that's supposed to be based on a real case, this is a copy-cat of 12 Angry Men that really missed some easy marks with me.

First off, it didn't know if it wanted to be serious or a comedy - that music didn't fit any scene and kept grating on my nerves.

Second, if the movie wanted to portray the SK legal system in a positive mark, it managed to imply basically the complete opposite (shoddy investigation, shoddy defence/prosecution, strange involvement of the jury in the actual discovery of how things happened.) The only thing that sounds about right is that innocence must be presumed and guilt has to be proven.

For a cast pretty studded with known actors, it didn't manage to stand out a lot.

The good parts - well, it's a feel good story in the end, so I guess that's okay. And it was an enjoyable throwback to 12 Angry Men, as I said, though that does make me wonder how much it actually resembles that first jury trial case it's based on, LOL.

Edit So I googled it - the first trial by jury in SK did happen in 2008 and it involved a man in his 20s who robbed a woman (70 years old) in her own home, to pay for some debts he and his family had, or whatever. He admitted to his guilt, there was no murder involved, the jury found him unanimously guilty but recommended a short/light sentence due to his circumstances. The judges agreed with the jury and so it ended.

This movie then IS basically a SK take on 12 Angry Men much more than a reflection of any actual cases in SK, LOL.

I got hooked from WWX standing on the cliff and letting go, LOL. Basically from the first half-minute of the drama. Because well. Xiao Zhan and that degree of desperation.

When WWX is recalled by MXY, and I got to actually see him looking cute and that wide million-watts smile, it was just icing on the cake :D

What can I say, I like a pretty face and a tortured hero. I'm shallow that way. :D

I watched it last year LOL. It's one of my favourites, actually (despite the suspension of disbelief parts, and the parts left unsolved - like what happened to DHS's mother in the end? My theory is that she's his father's first victim, but the drama doesn't say anything about it to clear it up.)

I also actually really liked the ending. The fact is - Hyun-Soo basically dies. His body just keeps on breathing. His whole BHS persona and all the memories he's created under that name are wiped out, so he's mostly a blank slate left to take up with Ji Won again, if he so feels like. And he can do so while NOT lying to her about who he really is - the person (probably on the autism spectrum) who can't understand or recognize emotions, but is capable of feeling them, their kid's father (she would be too young to understand if there's any significant change with him, anyway), a person who isn't afraid to be a little cold if he needs to be and someone who doesn't carry the whole blame&guilt for things he never did.

Because TBH, DHS in his BHS persona really had a lot of weight to carry around.

And I really liked how the memory wipe worked - the whole memories-to-dust scene was done perfectly IMHO. I was afraid he'd get his memories back in the end (because that would have cheapened the whole use of the trope in that kind of ending) but they did stick with it and gave it meaning after all. I appreciated they had the guts to keep with it to the bitter end (because yet, it felt a bit bitter, too. After all, DHS struggled so hard only to lose it all - except it didn't feel like he lost everything in the end.) If he had died instead - well then I would've sharpened my pitchfork and readied my torch :D

So I don't know, the whole drama - including the ending - did work for me very well. I do like LJG a whole lot, and he did his outmost in this role, so that may be a part of it, but he really IS that good an actor, and the role fit him very well. I hope his next drama is as good as this one, I've been missing him for the past year :D

It's not huge once you get invested LOL. It's one of the most bingeable dramas I've ever watched.

Be warned the first two eps set up the present timeline, so if you get confused with the names and character introductions, don't worry, they'll be revisited. The first half of the series is going to start at the beginning (in a very long flashback) and lead you to those first two eps in a logical manner, once you're in. Don't skip them - by the time you're in the present again, they'll make a lot of sense.

The series is on Youtube for free, from WeTV: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6GVDlK0Sxb0

The novel it's based on is danmei (yes, that's BL). But the story moves on its own accord until the romance blooms in the last few chapters, so if BL is something not your thing, you can pretend they're just soulmates in the platonic sense, LOL, because Chinese censorship of the drama will help you with that, a lot. If you do like BL... it's pretty obvious, what's going on. Well, for the watchers, not for one of the main characters, who's been born with the nickname Captain Oblivious LOL.

Erm... I didn't get to invent mouth-to-mouth LOL. That's how they transfer SOME air to people who are in danger or drowning and can't be pushed out of the water immediately or something. It's also a basic stage in CPR anyway (which she also gives him once he's out, but he's already not breathing on his own at that point), beside cardiac massage and other measures.

If this were real life, and he were really drowning (and saved in the last possible second), the chances of him surviving would already be in the less-than-10% numbers. IF he survived, he would also stand a good chance to have some brain damage, too. If you want to be picky about CPR and dramatic rescues, pick on those statistics, LOL.

RE: If I think it helps... Well, I know the real-life statistics of CPR success, and ALL the movies and dramas I've watched have those statistics basically reversed. So yes, suspension of disbelief is required. But they're not actually lying either - it COULD work, given a number of conditions were met. Unless you want to nit-pick at each and every thing - but it's fiction so they can get ignore some hard facts from time to time. This is not a medical hard-fact drama.

Much harder to suspend disbelief, for me, was with the fast recuperation of BHS from his years-long coma than DHS's almost-drowning... But again, this is not a medical drama, so there.

She's not giving him CPR yet, she's giving him air (because he's still at least partially conscious,) You can see the bubbles escaping while she makes another dive or two to get him enough air to breathe until she can drag him out.)

She IS giving him CPR after she has him by the pool side.

That is disheartening to read :( I was hoping that after that whole uproar, they'd give back his plotline and (considering the time spent on it, it's probably a lot of the filmed scenes) re-edit the whole thing to include more of him.

Oh well that only helps me wait for the end more - I am happy he got top billing again, but it DID look like they were using his name to get the people's attention, but not planning on letting him show off his skills much (so a PR stunt on their side, doubled with a huge dose of f-u toward XZ). So if they generally edited him out of half the series, then they'd better be ready for the probable consequences in terms of ratings (if it matters to them.)

What are the new rules being introduced? They get involved in TV&web dramas so much lately, it's hard to keep up to date :(

I'm not watching this yet until it's certain XZ did get back most of his scenes in it, and that he's not SL-but-posted-as-main-cast-for-PR-purposes (I remember the situation last summer.)

But - and I'm sorry if it's been asked before - does he sing the ED song? (The duet with the female singer.) It definitely sounds like his voice, and I don't know how to look for it in YT. (I didn't even know it aired until I saw the notification on MDL T_T)

PS. From the snippets I've watched, it definitely looks properly era-aged, LOL. It definitely caught my interest, and I'll watch it... provided there are no shenanigans with XZ's top billing. I don't like HJY enough to watch a whole drama just to see him get the girl and be the hero in the end.

K acts separately, outside RSY's knowledge - like his letters to the FL or his donation of RSY's money.

It looks more like DID.

He let go because the other cop - the witness - hit him over the head and then destroyed the phone. He could only go try and save the FL after that.

But then this series doesn't rely on too much inner logic anyways LOL.

Jae Seong + Gyeong Tae = LOVE

I just love how everybody's adopting the rookie as their little brother LOL.

Also, the plot is going a bit crazy right now, I have no idea how it could be solved rationally... then again, there was a lot unreasonable about this drama anyway, so, oh well :D

Zombies, 8 episodes... Everybody ded.

I am still on the fence about her, though. The only parts she's in that I kind of like are the parts where K is bashfully in love with her and I can only imagine what comes through RSY whenever he (K) is in his lovey-dovey phase LOL.

But mostly I forget what they're doing in that scene and just consider her eye-to-eyebrows ratio and wonder if her eyebrows are left that thick by accident or it's actually a very well planned form so that her eyes' arc*** can be better shown. (This might be beer talking LOL, nevermind me, I usually don't start calculating actors' appeal during the episode... if it's enticing enough. Unless it's Xiao Zhan. Because he's Xiao Zhan. I can't help it.)

*** In case this doesn't come clearly (because beer), her eyes look pretty Renascentine to me. Like she's a maiden in a Renaisance or Byzantine painting, if you know the kind I mean.

It improves from ep 2, and gets right up my alley from ep 3. The first one was a bit frustrating for me too :D