AshesandDust

When i first heard of the show and saw the initial trailers, i was like meh. Thought it would be similarly to melancholia (no offense to anyone who liked melancholia, its just not my cup of tea). so i decided not to watch it. But then the recent trailer came up in my feed and im intrigued. It looks interesting. Still not a fan of noona romance and i doubt I'll ever be. But the mystery seems interesting

Would you mind spoiling the end for me please?

As i have stated already, i watched scenes from both versions when i was deciding on which one to watch. These were 10-15 min long scenes so not your usual 30 second instagram clips. I felt that the acting and direction was better in the korean version which is why I decided to watch it. I made an informed decision and you are no one to tell me how to do so. For me watching segments of a show is how i decide whether to watch it or not. So no, my opinion is not formed out of a lack of "knowledge" as you put it. Please respect my opinion as im respecting yours

I mean that may be your opinion but doesnt make it a fact. I may not have watched the Japanese version but i have seen clips. It did not appeal to me. For me korean version is perfect the way it is

Could you spoil if the end is satisfactory and happy?

Has anyone watched this yet? If yes, how was it?

And plus it doesn't even sound like my kind of show. Sad but I'm going to pass on this one. But she did say "reconnecting with old Comrades" in her post. Wonder what that was about

Ahh so that's what her instagram posts were referring to. And here i thought it was about voice 5. Oh well

I watched go ahead! Loved her in that as well. Especially when i found out she was much older than the male lead. Made me appreciate her acting even more. I didn't really enjoy the latter half. Maybe some things were lost in the translation but the dialogues weren't as amazing. Also the male lead did well in some scenes, but in some scenes i feel like he could have done better. Seven tan though was amazing from beginning to end. It was a nice show as a whole :)
But i dont watch a lot of Chinese dramas so havent seen her in anything else.

Yeah she did well in the action sequences but that's about it. She really has two expressions. One is the im a badass expression which i think is not exactly her acting out a part but rather her being herself. And the second one is eyes slightly widened and mouth slightly open. Kinda like kristin stewart in the twilight series.
Also I see you're a seven tan fan. Same here! Loved her acting in with you!

Kim so hyun is a really underrated actress. I first saw her in the drama missing you. Hated everything about that drama except for kim so hyun, yeo jin goo and yoo seung ho. I was amazed at how kim so hyun was able to completely over shadow yoon eun hye. And that was when she was a child actress! I feel like han so hee is someone who blew up after My Name because it came right after squid game so the international audience immediately jumped onto the next kdrama. There have been other shows with amazing action sequences by female actresses. But because my name came so soon after squid game, she gained a lot of popularity. But popular does not necessarily equal good actor/actress
However this is just my opinion as a viewer and obviously people who like her enjoy her acting. But for me, she hasn't really shown something that makes me go "oh wow".

When i said i couldn't feel any of her emotions, i wasn't just referring to this drama. Admittedly i havent seen many of her shows, but the ones i have seen have not impressed me so far. But you could be right about the right script not having come her way. My point though, was about how the praise she was getting in 2021 made me think she was the next big thing (some articles even compared her to Gianna Jun). But when i watch her act, i dont see what others are seeing. She really only has 2 expressions. She showed more variety as a villain

I've only ever seen song kang in sweet home. He wasn't the one that grabbed my attention though.

Umm clearly it's not? As can be seen from the replies?

Am i the only one who thinks han so hee is...just an okay actress? I dont really see what the majority is raving about. She did well with her action scenes. I will always praise actors when they do their own action scenes. But thats about it. I feel like she does better in villain roles.
I don't feel any emotion from her characters. Don't feel her pain when she cries.
Park hyung sik is a good actor and i wish we had a better actress opposite him in this. Im not hating on her. I definitely see that she will eventually grow as an actress but for now i dont really get the hype

Same 🤣

Gonna follow this thread for spoilers 0_0

Lee Hana on her instagram 19hours ago:
"Comrades, last week i had a really meaningful and wonderful time with people who reconnected after a long time, and new people. #job #meeting"

Could it be for voice 5? I know that's not the only show she could be referring but when she writes "people who reconnected after a long time" makes me think it might be.
And i hope she means lee jin wook when she says "reconnected after a long time" 😭 please please let him be back! Please bring him back in voice 5. It would truly make it an excellent end to an excellent series

Yeah exactly! People are like "don't judge the drama based on its ending" and "they'll give us a realistic ending". Like why would i watch a drama if i wanted reality 🤣 i get enough of reality from my depressing life, the whole point of watching a drama is to escape from this and enter the world of fiction.

Yeah exactly! People are like "don't judge the drama based on its ending" and "they'll give us a realistic ending". Like why would i watch a drama if i wanted reality 🤣 i get enough of reality from my depressing life, the whole point of watching a drama is to escape from this and enter the world of fiction.