Okay so after 2 days, i’ve completed it! My rating is a solid 8/10! Great show with a few things that bothered…
So the story was great but there were only 3 things that i didn’t like which bumped my rating down from a 10 to an 8!
1st: The time skip. That’s nothing too crazy but I wasn’t really a fan of the starting the show in the future and then 2 episodes in were suddenly transported back to the past. Of course the “past” had a great story and it was really nice to get to know wei yings backstory, but I wish they would’ve just started the first episode from the past or even just had the future be a tiny snippet in episode 1. As a new watcher, it was really confusing to get introduced to bunch of new characters and engrain their names in my head, only for us to go back to the past and meet a slew of new characters and not see our other characters (mainly the disciples) until ep 33. Wasn’t really a bad thing just more frustrating for me.
2nd: The (lack of) Romance. So i know this is a “censored BL” which means we should take this as a bromance but they also made it very obvious that the 2 MLs felt something romantically even if it wasn’t said. I know that’s the whole point but it was also really frustrating. In the beginning, you had Wei Ying chasing after Lan Zhan like an elementary school kid with a crush and then in the end, you had Lan Zhan doing the chasing after Wei Ying. There were also moments that I just wanted to scream at my screen “WHY WONT THEY JUST KISS??”. For example, when Lan Zhan got drunk and gave Wei Ying the 2 male chickens (in my opinion it reminded me of the 2 ducks that are present during korean weddings) & then both of them carved their name on that pillar. Also, the day right after that, Lan Zhan asked Wei Ying if he said anything weird while he was drunk and Wei Ying teased him by going “You said you like…” and trailed off and Lan Zhan got so afraid as if he was worried that he confessed his feelings. Like COME ON, it was so hard to watch this and think “they’re just bros”.
And finally
3rd: The Jin Ling storyline. This one isn’t super big or anything, i’m just really disappointed that we didn’t get a REAL wrap up with his nephew. Like they built this whole thing up where Wei Ying & his nephew were getting along & then Jin Ling stabs Wei Ying when he finds out who he was but then once the truth comes out that it wasn’t even Wei Yings fault for what happened to his parents, Jin Ling didn’t even get the chance to apologize. It really irked me because I was enjoying the Uncle/Nephew dynamic between the two of them and i would’ve loved to see him ask for forgiveness from his other uncle but we got nothing :/
But yea, those are the only things that bothered me about this drama. Other than that, great show and a great watch over all!! 8/10!!
P.S: JUSTICE FOR WEI NING! My poor baby, he was the victim throughout this whole show. Half his soul got snatched when he was a child, then he was always sick growing up so people bullied him, then he turned into an almost ghost puppet and went wild and killed people he didn’t want to kill, then his sister died and he was used by other people as bait by putting nails in his brain and finally at the end he was able to walk his own path but omg. My poor baby was used by EVERYONE in this show, even Wei Ying! I’m glad Wei Ying realized at the end that he couldn’t let him keep following him forever but ugh, i just wish the best for Wei Ning. Ironically, he was the purest soul in this show!!!
i have been putting off watching this since i started watching dramas 4 years ago because of all the drama that…
Okay so after 2 days, i’ve completed it! My rating is a solid 8/10! Great show with a few things that bothered me but nothing too crazy!! Spoilery review below.
is there a second couple? if so could you tell me who?
Okay, if you’re okay with spoiling then here it goes:
There’s a plot point in the show where an evil guy from a different sect who was obsessed with linglong (in this weird hate/love thing he had going on) that managed to separate linglongs primordial spirit from her body and create kind of a spiritual clone of her. Her clone ended up “being with” the evil man and they were a couple. But linglongs body was still back at her sect and her friends fought hard to return her primordial spirit to her body. When it returned, people around her ridiculed her for being with the evil man even though it wasn’t her fault as she had no control over what happened. People also ridiculed minyan for wanting to stay with her when she was “tainted”.
So that’s why I said it’s complicated but beautiful because for the first like 15-20 episodes they flirt and make each other jealous and it’s very obvious that they like each other but then that happens to her and it ruins things for a while but when she recovers, he still wants to stay by her side no matter what.
is there a second couple? if so could you tell me who?
if we’re still talking about the second couple, their relationship is complicated but beautiful. The only thing i can say without spoiling is that minyan has been loyal and has only had his eyes on linglong from the beginning. I can’t comment on skinship because i was mainly focused on the main couple but i do remember the secondary couple having a beautiful romance story with a lot of ups and downs!
i have been putting off watching this since i started watching dramas 4 years ago because of all the drama that was surrounding it plus i’ve never watched a BL before (even though this one is apparently censored). However, I have nothing left to watch that is highly rated and this keeps popping up so i’m finally going to give it a shot. I just want to enter a new fantasy world and get attached to some new characters. Super excited!! I will come back to this comment and leave my review depending on if i complete it or if i drop it!!
Coming back for my yearly comment to say this is still the greatest cdrama ever and still remains in my number 1 spot despite seeing it for the first time 4 years ago!
I also just realized today as i’m about to do my rewatch that my all time favorite OST, which is the theme song for this show, WAS SUNG BY LIU YUNING???
Like you guys don’t get it, one of the biggest reasons i love this show is that the theme song is ENGRAINED in my brain and I never looked up who sung it but it’s literally my favorite OST ever. Now years later, I just realized it’s sung by yuning, aka one of my new favorite actors AND he’s the lead role in Prisoner of beauty which holds the second place on my greatest cdramas ever list. That’s so crazy!!! Fate is so cool!!
This is why every tiktok edit you see on that app is not 100% trustworthy. I started this because I saw an edit about how these 2 have such good chemistry and this is such an “amazing drama” but they really lied. Not only are the tags misleading because this is a “Female chases Male first” drama but the writing was horrible. This grown woman quit her job and moved back home and suddenly ran into this younger guy and was just obsessed with him out of nowhere! It was so strange like no matter what he was up to, she somehow had to insert herself into his life. Even after he literally told her “stop messing with me”, she still found a way to insert herself into his business. I hate FLs like this like… do you have no dignity? This man is telling you to go away and you’re just vying for his attention, even when he’s not interested in you. It’s sad. I was literally hoping she would take the hint and back off & then maybe he’d realize that he actually wants her or something and we’d get him chasing her but nope. She’s 2 years older than him, yet she’s following him around like a lost puppy. This was a mess, i’m so annoyed.
The murder plot was poorly written. 1. Why did the police automatically assume that the earing belongs to the…
This show still gets a 9/10 from me because it was still really good even though i do agree that the murder plot was kinda wonky lol. The biggest part for me was at some point, they claimed that the stab wound was a clean stab straight to the heart, and said that Laik couldn’t do that because he was drunk at the time and wouldn’t have been able to stab him that cleanly while inebriated. So how the hell did the person who it ACTUALLY was, manage to perfectly stab him in one go right in the heart while they were falling? That didn’t make sense to me tbh. It would’ve made way more sense if the person who did it was professional or a hired hit. If it was an accident like they say it was, wouldn’t the stab wound be more sloppy? And it being sloppy would make it more likely that it would’ve been Laik because he was drunk.
But i guess it doesn’t really matter tbh, I enjoyed the romance way more than the other plot.
People hate on her because they still can’t get over somin and that’s so sad. I feel like we can all be sad…
You don't have to accept her but there's no need to send hate to someone who's trying their best. And just like it took 200 episodes for you to get used to somin, im sure you can wait another 200 to get used to yeeun. Unless you just want to make up a reason to dislike her.
I do agree with you. I don't know why but i just can't stand her. I don't hate her but i don't like her either…
In no way is she an "F tier" member. Actually, she's right on par with all of the other members. Each member on that show has their own concept and she's right on par with everyone else. The only thing she isn't that great at is games but she's been improving. People forget that she isn't a variety show veteran like everyone else on that cast. All of them having been doing running man for 5+ years while she just started out. Criticize her all you want but saying she doesn't deserve to be on the show or "shoved down your throats" is a stretch because even if they decided to replace her with someone else, no one would be able to be good right away. She fits perfectly in the cast and y'all having a problem with her makes absolutely no sense. I get maybe thinking shes rude because of her gen z personality but she's literally the sweetest person ever and the entire cast loves her so there's no quarrels or awkward moments. Literally what is there to dislike about her besides the fact that she's not so good at the games (which she's actively trying to get better at)?
I don't know why there is so much hate for Ye Eun. Personally, I really like her. I know she is different to So…
People hate on her because they still can’t get over somin and that’s so sad. I feel like we can all be sad that somin left and understand that she doesn’t want to come back because she’s focusing on acting while also uplifting the new member who’s doing her best. The whole cast adores her so much, idk why people can’t just accept that and accept her. She’s such a sweetheart.
I do agree with you. I don't know why but i just can't stand her. I don't hate her but i don't like her either…
calling her “rude and entitled” is such a stretch. The house episode was completely normal with her saying she just didn’t want gifts that she wasn’t going to use because then she would end up discarding them, which would defeat the purpose of the gift. It’s insane that you’re only calling her entitled when in the last episode, JaeSeok himself even said he worried that the Christmas gift would be things that they didn’t want. And all of them even clowned some of the gifts for being “useless”. Where is the outrage for the rest of the cast then? Or is that hate only towards ye eun because you simply don’t like her and want a reason to hate on her?
I hate that she’s the only member getting hate when the whole cast loves and adore her. People hating her because of her “mukbang” character when jaeseok was the one that started that with her. The cast or the writers usually coin these concepts for her and no one ever hates on them for it. She always takes the fall and it sucks. She’s such a sweet and likable person yet people love to say things like this about her. Of course everyone is entitled to their own opinion but I just hate to see such a good person get bashed like she has just because people like one person over the other. She’s trying her best and that’s all that matters.
Bad acting female lead. 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮 Imagine the drama if other popular and good acting skills female…
It's super obvious that you're a zhao lusi fan just here to hate on esther and that's so sad bro. There are multiple tik toks of esther online right now, and this is coming from someone who's a casual fan of esther. I'm actually about to give this a shot BECAUSE of a tiktok I saw of esther speaking in english from this drama.
Yes, she does have her childish acting characters but i'm so tired of ya'll blaming that on her when thats how her roles are written. When she played a serious role in My Journey To You, ya'll also tried to say her acting was "too serious". She can never win with people like you around. So many actresses (INCLUDING LUSI) have roles where they've acted childish/used high pitched voice actors and ya'll applaud them but with esther, its always "ShE's sO AnNoYiNg" 🙄. Ya'll need to grow tf up and stop hating on random people that don't even know you. It's one thing to criticize her out of true constructive reasons but blatantly hating on someone is so pathetic and low & that says a lot about the kind of life you live and the type of person you are.
thinking about watching this but i have 2 questions, how long does the body switch last and does he get hung up on the fact that she looks like his dead princess? spoilers are okay!
Just started watching so i’m at episode 1 and the story isn’t bad so far but MY GOD is the lip syncing AWFUL!! It’s probably the worst lip syncing i’ve seen in a drama in a long time!! Literally the FL will say something but her lips don’t match up AT ALL. It’s so uncanny and I hate it so much! Hopefully it improves in further episodes but omg it’s ruining the quality of this show for me!
Since this show came out, i’ve tried to watch it 4 different times and each time ive dropped it. I can’t do it. Why is this rated so high? It really saddens me because Hidden Love is one of my top 10 cdramas of all time and the ML is one of my favorite actors but this show just doesn’t do it for me. It’s SO depressing. Like I feel like it’s a chore to watch almost. Then you have the fact that both the leads are so dull. I understand why the FL is dull because of everything she’s been though but this isn’t the Sang Yan i’m used to. The Sang Yan in Hidden Love was always so playful with his sister. Of course, he could’ve been hiding what he was going through but why was this Sang Yan so emo and broody. Idk. I just wish the characters had a bit more personality. That way, the depressing mood wouldn’t overpower everything. Anyways, im unfortunately just going to fully drop this. After 4 tries, maybe this super realistic and traumatizing/triggering drama just isn’t my cup of tea. 5/10.
yesss a season 2! they better keep the same FL or i will nawt be watching! The chemistry was off the charts in S1! That drunken kiss is for sure one of my top 5 cdrama kisses!
Yeeuni is confirmed to be on the show now (like i said before…) and i’m so exited!! I can’t wait to see what she’ll be like with the boys! I already know her chemistry with YJS from running man and it’s so cute how he treats her like a neice. I feel like with BWS, she’s gonna treat him like she did with Jin from BTS during Kians B&B. The one i’m most excited to see is her and Kwang soo!! I loved Kwang Soo on running man and all his other variety appearances are always so funny! I wonder if they’re going to give older brother/younger sibling vibes, especially since kwangsoos girlfriend is close with yeeun!! I’m so excited! What a great cast of people that YJS has assembled!
1st: The time skip. That’s nothing too crazy but I wasn’t really a fan of the starting the show in the future and then 2 episodes in were suddenly transported back to the past. Of course the “past” had a great story and it was really nice to get to know wei yings backstory, but I wish they would’ve just started the first episode from the past or even just had the future be a tiny snippet in episode 1. As a new watcher, it was really confusing to get introduced to bunch of new characters and engrain their names in my head, only for us to go back to the past and meet a slew of new characters and not see our other characters (mainly the disciples) until ep 33. Wasn’t really a bad thing just more frustrating for me.
2nd: The (lack of) Romance. So i know this is a “censored BL” which means we should take this as a bromance but they also made it very obvious that the 2 MLs felt something romantically even if it wasn’t said. I know that’s the whole point but it was also really frustrating. In the beginning, you had Wei Ying chasing after Lan Zhan like an elementary school kid with a crush and then in the end, you had Lan Zhan doing the chasing after Wei Ying. There were also moments that I just wanted to scream at my screen “WHY WONT THEY JUST KISS??”. For example, when Lan Zhan got drunk and gave Wei Ying the 2 male chickens (in my opinion it reminded me of the 2 ducks that are present during korean weddings) & then both of them carved their name on that pillar. Also, the day right after that, Lan Zhan asked Wei Ying if he said anything weird while he was drunk and Wei Ying teased him by going “You said you like…” and trailed off and Lan Zhan got so afraid as if he was worried that he confessed his feelings. Like COME ON, it was so hard to watch this and think “they’re just bros”.
And finally
3rd: The Jin Ling storyline.
This one isn’t super big or anything, i’m just really disappointed that we didn’t get a REAL wrap up with his nephew. Like they built this whole thing up where Wei Ying & his nephew were getting along & then Jin Ling stabs Wei Ying when he finds out who he was but then once the truth comes out that it wasn’t even Wei Yings fault for what happened to his parents, Jin Ling didn’t even get the chance to apologize. It really irked me because I was enjoying the Uncle/Nephew dynamic between the two of them and i would’ve loved to see him ask for forgiveness from his other uncle but we got nothing :/
But yea, those are the only things that bothered me about this drama. Other than that, great show and a great watch over all!! 8/10!!
P.S: JUSTICE FOR WEI NING! My poor baby, he was the victim throughout this whole show. Half his soul got snatched when he was a child, then he was always sick growing up so people bullied him, then he turned into an almost ghost puppet and went wild and killed people he didn’t want to kill, then his sister died and he was used by other people as bait by putting nails in his brain and finally at the end he was able to walk his own path but omg. My poor baby was used by EVERYONE in this show, even Wei Ying! I’m glad Wei Ying realized at the end that he couldn’t let him keep following him forever but ugh, i just wish the best for Wei Ning. Ironically, he was the purest soul in this show!!!
There’s a plot point in the show where an evil guy from a different sect who was obsessed with linglong (in this weird hate/love thing he had going on) that managed to separate linglongs primordial spirit from her body and create kind of a spiritual clone of her. Her clone ended up “being with” the evil man and they were a couple. But linglongs body was still back at her sect and her friends fought hard to return her primordial spirit to her body. When it returned, people around her ridiculed her for being with the evil man even though it wasn’t her fault as she had no control over what happened. People also ridiculed minyan for wanting to stay with her when she was “tainted”.
So that’s why I said it’s complicated but beautiful because for the first like 15-20 episodes they flirt and make each other jealous and it’s very obvious that they like each other but then that happens to her and it ruins things for a while but when she recovers, he still wants to stay by her side no matter what.
I also just realized today as i’m about to do my rewatch that my all time favorite OST, which is the theme song for this show, WAS SUNG BY LIU YUNING???
Like you guys don’t get it, one of the biggest reasons i love this show is that the theme song is ENGRAINED in my brain and I never looked up who sung it but it’s literally my favorite OST ever. Now years later, I just realized it’s sung by yuning, aka one of my new favorite actors AND he’s the lead role in Prisoner of beauty which holds the second place on my greatest cdramas ever list. That’s so crazy!!! Fate is so cool!!
But i guess it doesn’t really matter tbh, I enjoyed the romance way more than the other plot.
I hate that she’s the only member getting hate when the whole cast loves and adore her. People hating her because of her “mukbang” character when jaeseok was the one that started that with her. The cast or the writers usually coin these concepts for her and no one ever hates on them for it. She always takes the fall and it sucks. She’s such a sweet and likable person yet people love to say things like this about her. Of course everyone is entitled to their own opinion but I just hate to see such a good person get bashed like she has just because people like one person over the other. She’s trying her best and that’s all that matters.
Yes, she does have her childish acting characters but i'm so tired of ya'll blaming that on her when thats how her roles are written. When she played a serious role in My Journey To You, ya'll also tried to say her acting was "too serious". She can never win with people like you around. So many actresses (INCLUDING LUSI) have roles where they've acted childish/used high pitched voice actors and ya'll applaud them but with esther, its always "ShE's sO AnNoYiNg" 🙄. Ya'll need to grow tf up and stop hating on random people that don't even know you. It's one thing to criticize her out of true constructive reasons but blatantly hating on someone is so pathetic and low & that says a lot about the kind of life you live and the type of person you are.