michelleoc

What a great review. Thank you. I've just finished episode one and was disappointed that virtually no time was spent for us to see how she survived on the island. And you are absolutely right about preserving her voice. A singing voice is something that, if you don't use it, you lose it. I came here for Park Eun Bin, so I may need to suspend quite a bit of disbelief in certain aspects of the drama. I'll be sad if we don't get flashbacks, the young actors were terrific.

Great review. Way to speak your mind!

I liked your review. I am not into revenge dramas, nor melodrama, but I'm going to watch this one soon. However, I would just say that if you don't care what others thought about a show, especially if they didn't like it, just don't read their review. I review things mostly for myself, because my memory is so bad. I want to be able to go back and see why I did or didn't like something. I'm not trying to change anyone's mind, nor spoil it for them, or tell them not to watch something.

Yes.

It would be hard to equal Hidden Love, especially the FL.

Your review was great. "The climax just wasn't climaxing for me" - brilliant!

That's my biggest complaint about gender benders, they think the audience is stupid.

Great review. Just reinforced to me that I shouldn't waste my time!

Are you planning on updating your review once the drama has been completed? I'd love to hear what you thought of the whole thing. A review before watching the whole thing doesn't really help me much, because as we know, things in K-drama land can start out very well but go south quickly.

I always like to hear people's thoughts. A lot of times, when adapting from another medium, they change things so much it actually shouldn't be called an adaptation. As for the acting, I totally agree with you on the ML. As for everyone else's acting, from the scenes I've watched, it seemed very over the top, like they were TRYING for overacting, maybe to make it MORE over the top? I normally don't watch melodramas, one reason being they often seem so much like a soap opera. Thank you for your review.

Isn't it sad that we always seem to have to preface our opinions with "this is my opinion"? I don't know why so many people think that if I don't think the same way they do, my feelings are wrong, and the name calling begins. Feelings just ARE - not right and not wrong. That being said, thank you for your thoughts.

Why do they have the names they have, Stud, Earth, etc.? Is it a translation thing?

I totally agree with you. I haven't watched the whole show, because I just can't spend all my time watching something for a tragic ending. However, I have watched a bunch of scenes and compilations, and she seems very selfish and cruel.

Great recommendation! One of my favorites.

I don't care for melodramas, but the clips for this have been so good, and I've especially enjoyed being here and reading what everyone is thinking about the show. I'm looking forward to hearing from you all (after the last two episodes drop) if the ending is as satisfying for you as the rest of the drama has been.

Gotta say, I love your rants! Did you continue with the drama and did it improve for you?

She's in the cast lineup for season three, so unless they just show flashbacks, she's not dead.

When you say main couple, you mean her and the office worker, not her and her husband, right? And then does she stay in the past and will she ultimately get cancer anyway?

So hoping it will actually be funny.

Great review!! I don't like historical dramas as a rule, I was going to make an exception with this one because of all the rave reviews, but it sounds to me like I'd want to kill the FL. I hate dramas where the characters never grow out of their initial issues.