This review may contain spoilers
Is this really a spin off of Hidden Love??
While watching The First Frost...i really wondered,would this drama be this much popular if it wasn’t connected to Hidden Love?Cause if you enjoyed Hidden Love,this drama compels you to compare both of them and guess what,Hidden love wins and its not even close! When I watched Hidden Love, everything got me hooked to the screen,the story,acting,chemistry,direction,cinematography... everything. I could see Sang Zhi's yearning for Duan Jiaxu,her slowly turning from a rebellious teen to a mature adult who can definitely be a support to Jiaxu....Jiaxu's perspective changing when he realized its not the same girl he once saw,she has grown as a woman,as a person,She's strong and can take care of him and thats where the story shone. You can see them growing as person,being in love from both sides,building a very healthy relationship.Everything was evident,the innocence, the yearning, the support,the care,the love,the understanding... everything. This is where TFF falls flat,this drama couldn’t show the depth of the bonding between Sang Yan and Wen Yifan.
The plot in TFF is quite darker than HL... and thats what bothered me in the first place,why making this dark story into a sunshine rainbow with so many filters when it itself had the capacity to stand strong as it originally is?It could become much more touching,heart wrenching love story if everything didnt look so perfect, so polished, so much filtered.Wouldn’t it be so much better if they made it into a more dramatic way instead of following the same filtered dreamy tone??
If i come to character writing, both male and female lead lacks substance. Male lead had no other personality, character arc except being in love and it became boring after some episodes. He's arrogant, cocky but in a middle school teenager way.His whole life revolves around Yifan,he does everything only for Yifan.He spent his whole high school and uni life travelling to Yifans city,he took a job for Yifan, opened restaurant for Yifan, cooks for Yifan, leaves his family meetings for Yifan,plays games for Yifan,is left heartbtoken by Yifan, waits for Yifan,looks for Yifan.... in his life,there's nothing but Yifan which is really unrealistic and very much one dimensional character writing.It wasnt clear why he became so obsessed with Yifan in the first place when female lead was practically showing no emotions towards him in their early age..It really felt like a one sided love story cause it was all him,always him,yearning,loving,caring,living with broken heart still never forgetting and always forgiving.
Female lead is a victim of sexual assault and many other abuse in her extremely traumatic life.... But somehow this drama made her without personality too with little to no expression. She leaves whenever she wants without explaining anything.... she cant express herself,she can't talk,she lacks emotion... At some point you will feel bad for Sang Yan for being so much invested in her... like,why??? Sang Yans emotions towards her could be felt to some extent,he possibly did everything to be with her,but I couldn’t feel the same emotional attachment from Yifan.Even the dialogues doesn’t deliver anything, you can't feel the depth of Sang Yan's desperation or Yifan's communication... There is not even a proper I love you from Yifan's side when Sang Yan was ready to burn the whole world only to save her. She was cold to Sang Yan's action, lost in her thoughts...and mostly unsure. Everything that happened between them will leave you in confusion about the base and depth of their relationship.
I couldn’t care less about the grandpa plot or second lead couple or that annoying ass intern... They're just not entertaining. Had to skip Everytime they showed up on the screen.They also wasted so many times of the show which could be used to make a better plotline for main leads.
Another thing that was really annoying was the amount of repetitive flashbacks they used....it became boring and hard to focus at some point.And the slow pacing wasn’t helping either.Many things happened for no reason,could've avoided easily and added nothing to the story. The whole thing would be much much better if ended within 25 episodes.
Also,was the Hong Kong arc really necessary?? Haven’t yifan and sang yan suffered enough already that they had to give them more sufferings? There could be thousand more possible better ways to show the character development of the female lead than her just leaving everything and running away. This part really bothered me. Sang Yan is right there,she could just always talk,at least try to talk.Its understandable her trauma took a huge toll on her and the way she expresses herself...but this plotline really made me question the whole buildup of their relationship... wasn’t there any other way?? What was the need??Sang Yan had every reason to be angry with her....I really wish there was at least one scene of him being angry with her. When she did it first time,understandable, she was helpless, probably couldn’t think of anything else. But doing the same thing again without any explanation.... So unnecessary... The story writing had no logic here.
I really wish this drama was made by the same team of Hidden Love. The story had potential, it really did. But poor direction,screenplay,lack of depth of the characters,dialogue writing ... everything made a hot mess.Its not a bad drama,not at all. I could see the actors trying to make the best out of whatever they're given which is really appreciable. Many people enjoyed it, i also tried. But just couldnt.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A Drama that Will Stay with You
I went into this drama with high expectations, and even so, those expectations were far surpassed. There are certain dramas that stay with you long after you've finished them, that consume your thoughts and emotions. This drama is unquestionably one of those. It’s not just the plot, but the depth and connection between the characters that will stay with you for a long time.From the very beginning, it’s evident that the cast and crew poured their hearts into this project. Every element was thoughtfully crafted, designed to resonate deeply with the audience. It was clear that there was a genuine love for the story and the characters. The way every detail was brought to life made the entire experience feel intimate and personal, almost as if the drama was crafted just for you.
Let’s talk about the OST—it’s absolutely beautiful and haunting. The music elevates each scene, enhancing the emotions being conveyed. It’s not just background noise, but an essential part of the storytelling, weaving through every moment and making each one more poignant. I found myself deeply moved by the way the music added layers to the drama, enhancing both the sadness and the joy of the characters’ journey.
The Plot
The plot is excellently written. It’s a story of love, but also a journey of healing and self-discovery. I found myself feeling for the leads in a way that felt both heartbreaking and rewarding. The pain they went through was so real, especially because they are both such beautiful souls who truly deserved better. It’s a delicate balance between tragedy and hope, and the way the story unfolds is nothing short of captivating.
The Male Lead (Sang Yan)
Now, let’s talk about the ML. Sang Yan—what a character. His character brought to life by BJT sets the bar so high that I can’t imagine any other male lead coming close. His presence on screen, his visuals, and his performance are captivating. But what truly sets him apart is the depth of his feelings for the FL. The way he expresses his love through his eyes and actions makes every girl watching swoon. His devotion, his longing, and his commitment to the FL made my heart race. This is the kind of love we all dream of, and I truly hope every one of us gets our own Sang Yan someday.
The Female Lead (FL)
The FL is someone I deeply admired. Her strength, her resilience, and her ability to rise above the challenges she faces are truly inspiring. She’s a character I could relate to on a personal level, and her journey of healing felt incredibly authentic. She deserves so much more than what life has given her, but fortunately, she has the ML by her side to help her heal and rediscover her worth. Their connection and the way their love story unfolds is raw, emotional, and beautiful.
Themes of Healing and Love
While the central theme of the drama is love, it is also about healing. It’s a journey of confronting past traumas, battling insecurities, and learning to trust someone else to catch you when you fall. This drama also explores the importance of self-acceptance and knowing when forgiveness is not enough. Sometimes, the only way to heal is by letting go, even when it’s someone close to you, your family. These deeper layers made the drama more than just a love story—it became a profound emotional experience.
In conclusion, I am absolutely in love with this drama. I know I’ll be rewatching it countless times, and each time, I’ll be just as moved as the first. Even though it’s fictional, the unconditional love and the profound emotional journey it offers feel so real and meaningful. If you're on the fence about watching, I wholeheartedly recommend it. But dear viewers, keep a box of tissues nearby, and prepare to swoon over the ML—you won’t regret it.
Was this review helpful to you?
Watch for ML and FL
Plus; Chemistry between ML and FLMinus: Story lacked depth. Dragged for 32 hours when it could have finished within 13-16 episodes. ML FL kissed just for the heck of it. I didnot feel like they were needed. Sleep walking episodes too many and became boring and slot fillers after a while.
ML was handsome and with his ability to express nuanced expressions - director should have used him up more. Felt like a female oriented drama with limited story line for ML.
Was this review helpful to you?
Bad pacing......... over hyped....... unbelievable characters
I belong to those minority group that did not like " The first frost "....... let me explain why :1. the biggest show stoper for me was the FL..... many might criticize me but hear me out..... the fl faced may hardship in her life, but some of them could have been avoided if she had just faced them.... every time a problem occurred the first thing she did was run away.... most of the time I was frustrated because she never speaks out her problem, the show just shows that she is so miserable she cant say any thing..... there was so much build up up to episode 19 were the leads were finally able to behave like couple but then suddenly her uncle came back and started blackmailing her..... she initially showed some spine by warning them to not interfere with her life but then in the next episode she runs away without saying any thing to any one, even the ml...... so what was the point of everything..... the ml was miserable for those 6 months and she was trying to forget everything and move on in her life.... the show only focusses on portraying the fl as weak and miserable where as they should have also shown how she fought back her misery...... she was basically sheltered by the ml........ in her previous work place where her boss misbehaved her and the wife of boss slandered the fl, the fl was just standing still there listening to all the accusations without replaying any thing.....
2. the ML in a nutshell : a guy who helped fl endlessly but the fl dumped him ( with the excuse if she goes some where far away then her problems might stop ), after he got dumped by the fl he remained single for 8 years, after meeting the fl again after 8 years he again supported her but then got dumped again searched for fl for 6 months again....... this kind of person even for a story is unbelievable.... the ml was there in the show just to help the fl....
3. the pacing : the show has pacing issue but i watched the first 16 episodes at 1.5x speed.... the cinematography, music were great, but the show focused too much on the hardship of the fl rather than her fighting her problems.....
4. the chemistry : for me the chemistry between the ml and the fl was ok.... they had their sweet moments in some episodes which i felt wasn't enough ( especially if you are marketing the show saying romance genre)
It was just my personal opinion regarding the show.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Loved the novel...but definitely not this drama. Huge Letdown :(
I came in with lots of high expectations because I love Sang Yan & I read the novels of both Hidden Love and First Frost...so imagine my surprise that I would dislike this drama this much. I may prefer Hidden Love's drama & novel more because of the sweetness, but I also loved the First Frost novel for its own charms-- none of which met my expectations, to be honest. I went in not comparing Hidden Love with First Frost because I really wanted to love this drama for what it was, Sang Yan & Wen Yifan's story (which I also adore). I know that First Frost is from Wen YiFan & Sang Yan's point of view, so he isn't going to be as silly as he was in his big brother role, but in First Frost, he is still supposed to have a realistic goofy side to him besides his fake nonchalant/charmingly narcissistic persona. I have lots of respect for Bai Jingting's other works, but I didn't feel like he suited Sang Yan, nor could he connect with this character enough for it to feel genuine. As for Zhang Ruonan, I don't usually enjoy her dramas, but I love her in real life. However, I do think that this was the first drama of hers that I liked the best out of the rest.First Frost is supposed to be more serious because the themes involving the FL are traumatic to her directly, so obviously, she would be more guarded against opening up...but dang, they really made her look flighty with that Hong Kong plot. She never did this in the novel but instead followed Sang Yan to Yihe when he discovered Sang Zhi dating Duan Jiaxu. It was more romantic because it wasn't just Sang Yan doing all the chasing, but her finally taking steps to join him in the fight for their love. The drama's version of their reunion in Hong Kong was also...stale. They really dulled down the love in the drama adaptation to make it seem like Sang Yan loves her so one-sidedly that his whole life decisions creepily revolve around Wen Yifan because of how he constantly follows her without her knowing over the years, & they never really portrayed why he fell for Wen Yifan well either. It makes his feelings look shallow, like puppy love for her appearance at first sight, which became obsessive. Wen Yifan didn't really do much to show how much she loves Sang Yan in return besides standing up for him a few times & since she was in a vulnerable state in their youth, she never showed much interest in Sang Yan (understandably), so I can't understand how Sang Yan fell that deeply with how they made it seem in the drama. Many of the men in the drama were either creeps or obsessed with Wen Yifan, and as hard as it was, she really should have opened up about her problems to her friends/Sang Yan to avoid so many unnecessary misunderstandings. One of the best things about Hidden Love was how open the main couple communicated despite having misunderstandings as well, but their misunderstandings were never big because the second one of them had doubts, they talked it out clearly.
I also couldn't feel any chemistry between the main couple in this drama. The acting felt very robotic, like they were simply going through the motions rather than the micro-movements that make all the difference. It felt like Sang Yan did all the heavy lifting in the relationship, but even with him, I couldn't see much emotion beyond just through his actions (like I felt there was a disconnect with how much he did for her vs how much emotion he showed in his eyes/face, but that may just be the acting). Sang Yan is more emotional than the drama gives him credit for & so is Wen Yifan. Her love is supposed to be more cautious but warm, not silent/non-existent. I initially tried to watch this drama but didn't like what I saw from skimming it while it was airing, so I dropped it...I felt like I should at least get through it once fully, just so I could give a proper review. Thus, I finally watched it fully this time. And my oh gosh, it was torture. They added things that made the story boring, like the 2nd couple's story & the grandpa...like what was the point. This drama needed to cut out lots of scenes or replace them to show more relationship buildup, but even then, no more than 25 episodes. Some stories need a longer run, but this drama didn't, so it didn't feel like a slow-burn-- it was a letdown.
It honestly felt like every slow-burn ever, but without any refreshing elements to help it be even remotely engaging. I typically love slow-burn dramas, but this drama made it look painfully one-sided till the very end so the slow pace & long episodes didn't feel worth it. In conclusion, I will say that this may be for people who like dramatic darker stories with a ML who is obsessively in love with the FL (ML falls first and harder), but for those who like more of a balanced relationship, Hidden Love may be more your cup of tea (FL falls first, but ML falls harder) even if the first 8 episodes are a bit boring since it's about FL's innocent teen crush on ML before they meet as adults which is when he finally falls for her. Just because I didn't like the drama version of First Frost doesn't mean it's still not good for other people since we all have different opinions/preferences. :)
Was this review helpful to you?
THE DRAMA I WATCH WITH 1X SPEED
I really pat myself on the shoulder for watching The First Frost in real time. It's challenging but this is an experience to see everyone being so passionate abt it ! And this is the best drama I've watched in a looong while. Bless. the first frost is literally everything I've been looking for in a drama and it's the best feeling when you've been waiting for something for so long and it absolutely exceeds your expectations like it's literally so so good!!! im obsessed!!No one could have played wen yifan and sang yan better than zhang ruonan and bai jingting, their acting was so good, felt natural and they had great chemistry together. I am so glad that they got casted as the leads of the first frost🥹❤️Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Zhang Ruonan & Bai Jingting Shine in The First Frost
I finished the first frost a month ago but i’m still emotionally wrecked in the best way possible. This drama hit all the right notes — from its quiet emotional depth to the beautifully layered love story between Wen Yi Fan and Sang Yan.Wen Yi Fan is such a complex, quietly strong character, and Zhang Ruonan absolutely nailed the performance. You could feel her pain, her hesitation, and her growth so clearly — especially in those subtle moments when she’s just trying to hold herself together. She made Wen Yifan feel raw and real.
And Bai Jingting as Sang Yan? Easily one of the most emotionally grounded male leads i've seen in a while. He brought this calm, steady presence to the character that made all of Sang Yan’s little acts of love feel incredibly impactful. He’s not your typical male lead — there’s no over-the-top drama or flashy gestures. His love is quiet, patient, and unwavering. Bai Jingting portrayed Sang Yan with such sincerity and warmth.
Their chemistry is the kind that simmers — not loud or overly dramatic, but full of longing, warmth, and emotional depth. You really believe in their bond and root for their healing, both individually and together.
Also, the drama’s cinematography and music add such a nostalgic, dreamlike vibe that it honestly just pulls you right in. If you're into slow-burn romance with a lot of heart, emotional storytelling, and characters that actually grow, this one’s for you.
The First Frost is 100% worth watching. Beautiful story, beautiful acting — especially by these two. Definitely a standout in the modern romance genre.
I love this drama so much and Sang Yifan will forever be in my heart.
Was this review helpful to you?
"The First Frost" – A Beautiful, Poetic Journey Through Time and Emotion
The First Frost is a Chinese drama that captivates not only with its stunning visual aesthetic but also with its emotionally resonant story. This series beautifully balances delicate moments of love, personal growth, and the passage of time, all while weaving a narrative that is rich in symbolism and cultural depth. From its mesmerizing cinematography to its poignant themes, The First Frost is a must-watch for anyone seeking a heartfelt, visually enchanting drama."A Visual Masterpiece"
From the very first frame, The First Frost envelops its audience in a world of beauty, where nature plays as important a role as the characters themselves. The titular "frost" is not just a seasonal change; it becomes a metaphor that the series uses to explore themes of time, memory, and transformation. The crisp, frosty landscapes serve as a canvas for the emotional and physical journeys of the protagonists. Snow-capped mountains, delicate frost patterns on windows, and the soft hues of early winter mornings are expertly captured, giving the drama a dreamlike quality.
The careful attention to detail in the cinematography is one of the defining aspects of the show. Every scene feels like a painting, every gesture of the characters as subtle and fleeting as the frost on a morning leaf. The visual metaphors of the changing seasons tie perfectly into the narrative, reflecting the inner transformations of the characters. The coldness of the frost in the beginning gives way to warmer moments, mirroring the thawing of hearts as love and understanding bloom. It’s a beautiful visual metaphor for life’s inevitable cycles.
"A Story of Love, Loss, and Personal Growth"
At its heart, The First Frost is a love story, but it is so much more than that. It’s about the quiet, intimate moments that define relationships and the difficult, often painful, growth that comes with them. The series explores the notion of change—not just physical change, but emotional and spiritual transformation. The characters are multifaceted, each with their own personal struggles, dreams, and fears. Their paths are not easy, but each challenge they face becomes an opportunity for growth.
The central romance is tender and slow-burning, built on moments of shared vulnerability and understanding. The chemistry between the leads is undeniable, but what makes their connection even more compelling is how their relationship develops. There is no instant love here; instead, we see two people evolve, both independently and together. This is a slow-burn romance in the truest sense, but it’s all the more rewarding for the patience it requires from the viewer.
Beyond romance, the series also dives deeply into themes of loss and longing. Characters grapple with the ghosts of their pasts—decisions they regret, people they've lost, and paths they wish they'd taken. The emotional depth of the characters is one of the drama’s greatest strengths. Each character feels real, flawed, and painfully human. This realism creates a connection with the audience, making every triumph feel hard-won and every sorrow feel deeply personal.
"Rich in Symbolism and Cultural Resonance"
The beauty of The First Frost is not only in its visual presentation and emotional storytelling but also in its rich symbolism and cultural depth. Frost, in Chinese culture, often represents the end of a season and the beginning of introspection, a time for reflection and renewal. In the drama, this symbolism is used to perfection, with the "first frost" acting as a turning point for the characters, a moment when everything seems frozen, but within that stillness, new growth is quietly beginning.
The series also beautifully incorporates elements of traditional Chinese culture, from its music to its philosophy. The quiet wisdom of the characters—often expressed through subtle dialogue or introspective moments—gives the show a depth that goes beyond surface-level drama. The interplay between personal desires and the broader cultural and familial expectations adds complexity to the characters’ journeys. This rich cultural backdrop creates a sense of timelessness, as if the struggles and joys of the characters have been mirrored in generations past.
"A Soundtrack That Speaks to the Soul"
Complementing the stunning visuals and emotional depth of The First Frost is its hauntingly beautiful soundtrack. The music perfectly encapsulates the mood of the drama, with soft, melancholic tunes that underscore the emotional weight of the story. The music is never overpowering; instead, it lingers in the background, amplifying the more poignant moments and adding layers to the scenes. The way the music intertwines with the frost-heavy imagery is poetic in itself, enhancing the feeling of winter's quiet embrace and the gradual thawing of hearts.
"A Story that Transcends Time"
What truly sets The First Frost apart is its ability to convey universal emotions—love, loss, and self-discovery—through the lens of a uniquely Chinese cultural perspective. While it is deeply rooted in its cultural and seasonal metaphors, the themes of the drama are universal. It speaks to anyone who has ever had to face the coldness of the world or their own heart, yet found solace and warmth in the quiet moments that follow.
The way time is explored in the drama is also remarkable. The title, The First Frost, hints at the fleeting nature of time, capturing the sense that no moment lasts forever. Just like the frost that graces the earth but soon fades away with the rise of the sun, the drama reminds us that every season, whether of the year or of our lives, eventually gives way to something new. The subtle passage of time within the story gives a nostalgic feel, but also a hopeful one—after the frost, there is always the promise of renewal.
CONCLUSION
The First Frost is a captivating blend of visual beauty, emotional depth, and cultural richness. It’s a series that will leave a lasting impact on anyone who watches it, offering a reminder of the fragility of time, the power of transformation, and the quiet strength found in love and personal growth. Its slow-burn romance, heart-wrenching moments, and stunning visuals make it a memorable viewing experience that resonates long after the final episode.
If you’re looking for a drama that is as poetic as it is profound, The First Frost will not disappoint. It’s a reminder that, even in the coldest of times, there is warmth to be found—sometimes in the most unexpected places.
Was this review helpful to you?
Becoming Each Other's Sunlight: A story about growth, healing and enduring love
The First Frost is easily one of the most well-produced Chinese romance dramas of 2025. From its brilliant acting and plot progression to the impressive official soundtrack and meticulous attention to detail, The First Frost takes viewers on a journey about what it means to love another, and oneself. If you were waiting for a Chinese modern romance drama with enduring love, the most loveable couple and healthy character growth, say less. Although much more “melo” than Hidden Love, The First Frost will leave you looking forward to every loving interaction between the leads (and perhaps swooning at Sang Yan’s good looks).ꨄ OVERVIEW------------
Adapted from the novel of the same name by Zhu Yi, The First Frost documents the decade-long romance between Sang Yan and Wen Yifan. Despite becoming close friends in high school and agreeing to attend university together, Wen Yifan breaks the promise, leaving Sang Yan questioning their relationship for years. Their reunion is bittersweet yet provides the leads with the new opportunity to say their unsaid words, feel the unfelt love, and truly be together.
The structure of each episode is unique and appealing, as it starts with flashbacks that dive into scenes that molded the leads into who they are today, and end with scenes in Sang Yan’s perspective. The beginning flashback ends with a timeline that documents how many days the leads have known each other for, as well as an unfinished sentence that is completed at the end of the episode. The novel is written in Wen Yifan’s perspective, an aspect that the drama maintained. While some have expressed disappointment over the supposed imbalance between the leads’ efforts into their relationship, I would argue that Sang Yan and Wen Yifan’s romance is one built off of immense mutual respect and care. However, Sang Yan plays a pivotal role as the sunshine that melts the frost. Growing up in a successful family that has showered him with love, he aims to do the same with Yifan. One of my favorite quotes from the drama is Wen Yifan’s response after the nagging Mu Chengyun asks, “Has he (Sang Yan) ever confessed to you?” to which she answers, “He treats me so well that it’s like he’s confessing to me everyday.” The way both leads treasure one another is the sweetest thing ever. We also see Wen Yifan’s outpouring of love towards Sang Yan, the immense worry she has for his safety as she regains confidence in herself.
ꨄ ADAPTATION------------
While TFF is set in the same universe as Hidden Love, the timeline between the two dramas is slightly different. There was much debate over the leading roles of the drama adaptation, especially among Chinese netizens, as the original web novel is extremely popular. When the lead casting was announced to be Bai Jingting and Zhang Ruonan, the news received extremely mixed reviews. Never having watched Zhang Ruonan in a drama before and looking forward to another Bai Jingting hit, I dived into the first few episodes of TFF with curiosity and basic expectations (coupled with excitement after having watched cute Hidden Love). 10 episodes in, I could simply not imagine another pairing embodying Sang Yan and Wen Yifan as remarkably as Bai Jingting and Zhang Ruonan. As with all novel adaptations, whether shows or movies, it’s impossible for the entire progression to remain the exact ‘same,’ and quite unrealistic. Having read the novel, I was pleasantly surprised by how true to the original story the drama was, down to the small details. Despite certain scenes that may have fared more preferably if aligned with the original plot, the overall story was well-paced and sprinkled in the sweetest scenes at the perfect times. Given the nature of the leads and their history together, their reunion starts off slow, but their relationship and romance quickly picks up from there.
ꨄ SECOND COUPLE------------
When it comes to the second lead couple (portrayed by Chen Haosen and Zhang Miaoyi), the leads’ best friends, they were certainly cute, but I couldn’t feel much chemistry that kept me on my toes. Perhaps this is because they have a much shorter history than the leads, having known each other for much less time. However, much of their screen time together was partially overshadowed by the grandparents arc, which quickly turned dull IMO and took away screen time from both couples that could have been utilized to better develop and expand on their relationships. However, given the time allotted to side characters, I do have to say that Sang Yan and Wen Yifan’s relationship was developed very well.
I’d also like to take a moment to address the drama relationship between TFF and Hidden Love. While established in the same universe and both dramas have the same characters, a major concern among Hidden Love fans was the total change in casting. While I greatly enjoyed Ma Boqian’s portrayal of Sang Yan, an annoying older brother, Bai Jingting fully embodies the other side to Sang Yan, the composed yet loving man who silently stayed at the side of the only girl he has loved, and the only girl he will ever love. Given that Bai Jingting and Zhang Ruonan weren’t present in Hidden Love, it makes no sense that Zhao Lusi and Chen Zheyuan would even make a cameo in TFF. Sang Zhi and Duan Jiaxu are also not a main focal point in TFF, and I personally enjoyed watching the bantering interactions between the Sang siblings, as well as the strong bromance throughout. Liu Chutian and Wu Yuheng were satisfactory as Sang Zhi and Duan Jiaxu. If the connection between these two Zhu Yi romances does capture your attention, however, you may or may not have noticed Sang Zhi’s phone case in both series, which have been the same.
ꨄ ACTING------------
As mentioned before, Chu Yuning did brilliantly casting his lead roles. I’ve watched Bai Jingting a few years ago in Reset and later in historical dramas, but he really brings out another extraordinary aspect to his acting in TFF. There’s such an obvious difference in emotions that Bai Jingting carries in his eyes. The eye candy is such a plus (and even Bai Jingting himself said that TFF captured him at his handsomest lol), but it is clear that Bai Jingting is the perfect Sang Yan.
Going back to watch the lead’s reunion scene after six years in Jia Ban (Sang Yan’s restaurant), you can see the sadness and longing in Sang Yan’s eyes, and the disbelief and denial on Wen Yifan’s face. The chemistry between Bai Jingting and Zhang Ruonan subtly increases, and if I could say so myself, this pairing is absolutely perfect, and just the couple we needed in the Cdrama romance world. The crying scenes also particularly stood out to me; The leads poured their heart and soul into their roles, allowing the viewer to feel the pain they have felt over the past decade and feel that same hatred towards the antagonists.
ꨄ CHARACTER GROWTH------------
The First Frost also effectively touches upon a very delicate topic. In the face of her father and grandmother’s death, Wen Yifan no longer has anyone in her life besides Sang Yan who really cares for her (with the exception of her best friend Zhong Siqiao, who is truly the sweetest), and even Sang Yan is far away from her, unaware of her situation. As a teenage girl with no adult family member to protect her from the threats of harassment, she is left to fend for herself. Her experience parallels those of many women in real life. The nuances in Zhang Ruonan’s facial expressions reflected that of Wen Yifan’s past experiences, encouraging sympathy and admiration for her personal growth. As the drama progresses, we witness Wen Yifan’s transformation: She starts standing up for herself, and later, others with similar grievances. She ‘rediscovers’ ballet, something so dear to her. She addresses her strained relationship with her mother. And of course, she gains the confidence to reach out to Sang Yan. I simply cannot express how much I adore Zhang Ruonan in this role. Her acting was just so realistic, from the nights of sleepwalking to Wen Yifan’s cute, bubbly moments. She nailed it all.
ꨄ PRODUCTION------------
The editing and filming aspects are also top-notch. Chu Yuning and his team absolutely found the best angles and lighting for their shots, capturing the leads in the best atmosphere possible. Filmed mostly in Chongqing, the audience was able to admire the cityscape and beautiful modern culture, from the trains that ran through tall buildings to serene night scenes strewn with fireworks and lights. The transitions were also seamless, allowing for the best-quality watching experience and satisfaction.
ꨄ OST------------
When it comes to the OST, I have to say that there are not that many Cdramas that can compare to the quality of these songs. We have well-written lyrics, a line of talented singers, and catchy tunes. Whether it’s “Willful” by Mayday, a song filled with strength and determination, or the dreamy “Like a Sunny Day, Like a Rainy Day” by Silence Wang, there’s a song for every scene. And by every scene, I really mean it. I fell in love at first sight with the OST the way Sang Yan did with Wen Yifan:
“Willful” - Mayday: Theme Song
“Like a Sunny Day, Like a Rainy Day” - Silence Wang: Romance Song
“Late” - Zhang Bichen: Past Pain Song
“Serenade” - Mao Buyi: Self-Healing Song
“It’s You” - Li Yuchun: Ending Song
“My Dear” - Zhang Zhenhao: Reunion Song
“The Invisible Man” - Bai Jingting: Waiting Song
“I’ve Never Liked Anyone Except You” - Zhang Lei + Fine Band: Longing Song
“Everything” - Zhang Ruonan + Zhang Miaoyi: Friendship Song
“Look at Me” - Yan Yidan: Heartwarming Song
“I Want To Quietly Slip Into Your Soul” - Xiao Bingzhi: Protection Song
“There Is You Amidst Raindrops” - Chen Kexin: Memory Song
“Stubborn” - Sandee Chan: Heartbeat Song
“Crush” - Chen Haosen: Adoration Song
This drama has carved a special place in my heart with its moments filled with love, acceptance, growth and resilience. There are so many admirable traits in both leads, and their love story will give you butterflies in your stomach until the very last episode, the cutest little ending that marks the continuation of their happiness together.
˚ʚ♡ɞ˚ “Besides me, there will be many people who love you.” - Sang Yan
˚ʚ♡ɞ˚ “Love is…becoming each other’s light.” - Episode 31
˚ʚ♡ɞ˚ “It’s okay. The boy you like will also think that you were so brave. He’ll thank you for protecting yourself.” - Wen Yifan
˚ʚ♡ɞ˚ “Tell me, were you sent down by my dad to be good to me?” - Wen Yifan
“No, I willingly do so.” - Sang Yan
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Finally ❤️Worth the wait 😉 i love it very much 😍💗😍 I'm so excited to watch every episode 😊 i love the characters of wen yifan and sang yan😘😘😘 Congratulations 👏 the first frost 🎉
I'm so happy now, we're waiting for a long time,
That's why i love Chinese drama all the time.
Zhang rounan and Bai jing ting ❤️
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
"I Will Always Catch You."
Very proud of BJT for this role; he took his usual almost comedic persona and created a character who was deep, emotional, sensitive, and an iron wall of protection for his high school sweetheart dealing with trauma and tragedy of her past. Even though this series is in the Hidden Love universe (character names, more or less timeline, family, locations), it's a totally different world from the bubbly and happy romance we saw there. This story is so much deeper and more emotional than that one. One thing is for sure, both Sang siblings brought their traumatized yet loved significant others home to a warm and loving environment.Pros: I watched this show for BJT, I didn't know it was going to be dealing with trauma, abandonment, PTSD and sleepwalking, and a love so strong from one person, even in his darkest moments, he still made sure she was safe and ok. Sang Yan is the iron wall behind the girl he fell for at first sight. He doesn't know what she has to go through or ultimately went through until their reunion 6 years later. All he wants to do is love and protect. He doesn't know what so silently as we see in the ever well crafted flashbacks in the beginning of the series (that are essentially puzzle pieces that slowly come together as the series comes to a close) and the "the story is not over yet..." at the end (where we see something that happened during the episode that explains a missing piece of the episode). We see what they went through, what their lives became and how through becoming roommates he got a glimpse into her inner world of pain and self torment.
WYF seems like she has it all together on the outside; good job, cares about strangers, wants to improve herself, has a friend. But on the inside she's a scared, traumatized young woman with scars that run very deep. She was abandoned by her mother soon after the death of her father and tossed from one house to the next until she landed at her uncle's where a relative nearly SA'd her; she had to jump from the second floor balcony to get away from this monster at the expense of her foot and being unable to dance again which was her passion. We see her break her promise to SY to attend the same university and break up with him in a cruel manner because of the shame, blame, and fear she had. She then ran away from everything and everyone. And still ran into a different freak at her internship after college where she had to quit her job though she got justice. It was like she never had any security anywhere she went and only during her college days when she functioned like an automaton. SY though still followed her and was always watching her silently, protecting.
When the monster gets out of prison and comes after her again, we learn that she was not his first nor his last sadly, just one of two that got away with their lives to boot. Meanwhile, in the apartment the two (SY and WYF) share as roommates, SY starts to see the sleepwalking and other signs that show things are far worse than he thought originally of just an unhappy home life in the past and her not wanting to be with him. Though there is humor (more on his part as she is very shy) and great chemistry, we know that at some point she has to tell him everything so there are no more misunderstandings. As he says to her, "I will always catch you." His love is unconditional no matter what; from the moment she walked back into his line of sight in the first episode, he would always be there, hovering like an earthbound angel protecting soundlessly.
What she had to learn and understand was that she could lean on those she loved and tell them the truth. She didn't have to face everything alone. It was SY that ultimately captured the bastard that traumatized her who was on the run for an unsolved murder years prior and assault on his brother in law's wife. It was SY who safe proofed the house so she wouldn't hurt herself when she sleepwalked. He walked beside her always calmly talking to her even during the times she just walked around and cried. It was SY who had his heart ripped to shreds when she ran away a second time; this time he didn't know where she was though he chased down more leads than the cops ever did. He even went to where she actually was off a tip from her childhood friend who thought he saw her and other leads and even though they happened to be in the same locations, they conveniently missed each other. But he was the one who never gave up and she had to let him in.
The second couple is ok, both deserving of love especially the guy who went through a lot of tragedy, trauma, and self blame himself. I think as best friends of the leads, they deserved a bit of their own storyline told.
I'm glad she cut ties with her "mom" and the bastard and his sister went to prison (with him sentenced to death). Going to the Sang house for a holiday made her see and appreciate what a real warm family with caring parents looked like. Their chemistry was great and they had great kisses and decent skinship; it was just enough for this story. I was glad she found out about all of his travels to Yihe, kept all of her article clippings, and the fact that he went to her graduation. For 6 years he never left her; he was always just behind or on the sidelines. The proposal was unique and heartwarming and SY getting emotional was beautiful; definitely a tear jerker. We even see that it was he who initiated their first contact, so love at first sight it was for sure. Even the ring was symbolic because it had a ribbon on it and SY explained they were each other's most precious gifts.
OSTs, modern sets, camera angles were all good.
Cons: I don't agree with her leaving a second time. I don't read the source material but it didn't jive with her character development at all. A few days before she had confronted her "family" bastard included and told them that if they came near her or her loved ones again she would go to the police and yet still she ran? It just didn't match up. Furthermore, her reasoning was that if she left, SY wouldn't get hurt? Yeah ok, because it wasn't the bastard that was harassing a woman at SY's restaurant and then got into a fight with SY where he told him kind of what happened 6 years before. That it didn't shatter SY's heart to know how badly she was harmed, that he didn't know, couldn't help and now not knowing where she was. To a man like him, it was the ultimate heartbreak. Plus, as a journalist, she should know that predators will go after their prey's loved ones if they can't find their prey. They want to harm the ones that person loves the most. They're all hard wired like that. So her choice didn't hold water for me and shouldn't have deviated. Production could have chosen for her to tell him some other way finally and not have him and friends run around the entire country looking for her. Though he did learn a lot of what she went through in the years away from him, I just think a more balanced version of who her character had become would have been best in that situation. Then she got mad at him at the hospital after he went against the bastard and caught him; he felt like a man, the man she deserved as before he felt useless. But she's mad? Because she would have done what? Run away for a third time? Come on now. Her anger was misplaced; yes most likely more fear for his safety and worry but still, she had to see it from his side of things.
It always felt like though she said she loved him and trusted him, there was a hesitation and the running away the 2nd time was a huge example of that. Communication with her character was lacking; she would declare things and then take two steps back. No wonder SY felt less than even after all this time. Also wish WYF when kissed or just in a general conversation with SY didn't have her eyes roll around on her face like she didn't know where she was or what was happening, again didn't quite fit her characterization.
Several characters were completely unnecessary like that Mu guy, his whole point of being there was what? And the grandparents love line was unnecessary too. They could have just been there to bring the 2nd leads together and let SML get past his own trauma. Their entire point was lost on me. Also the once in a blue moon HL storyline that didn't quite match up in timeline sequence could have been overlooked.
Would I recommend it? Definitely. I gave .5 higher than HL because this one was darker and deeper and the ending was much more satisfactory (not knocking HL, as that one was also good but just a much lighter version) and totally came full circle in more ways than one. BJT is definitely the perfect SY for me. Give it a chance.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
"Love that Waited, Pain that Endured: The First Frost’s Silent Strength"
In a television landscape often dominated by conventional storytelling, The First Frost emerges as a breath of fresh air — a drama that trades fast-paced plots for emotional depth, and grand romantic gestures for quiet, patient love. It is a drama about trauma, recovery, and the slow journey of healing, all wrapped within the emotionally rich romance between Sang Yan and Wen Yifan.The love story between Sang Yan and Wen Yifan is not one born of fantasy, but of real, lived emotional experiences. Their reconnection is marked by unhealed wounds and years of silence, and what follows is a process of rediscovering each other through empathy, patience, and emotional intelligence.
Sang Yan, portrayed with understated brilliance by Bai Jingting, is not your typical romantic hero. He is steady, warm, emotionally intelligent, and, most importantly, patient. His love for Wen Yifan is never performative; it’s quiet yet powerful, rooted in understanding and genuine care. His journey — from a heartbroken teenager confused by a painful breakup to a man willing to set aside his pride to protect the woman he loves — is a masterclass in nuanced emotional writing. Bai Jingting brings layers to the character: vulnerability, restraint, and fierce devotion. His performance, particularly in pivotal scenes such as Episode 27, is a standout — communicating anguish, fear, and love with just a glance.
Zhang Ruonan as Wen Yifan delivers a quietly devastating performance. Wen Yifan is a complex character — traumatized, guarded, yet fiercely trying to survive in a world that has not been kind to her. Ruonan’s portrayal captures this duality: the dead-eyed stares of someone numbed by pain, and the flickers of warmth when she begins to trust again. Her arc — from a woman running from her past to someone finally learning to stand tall in spite of it — is executed with grace and empathy. Zhang Ruonan makes Wen Yifan not only believable but deeply relatable, especially to those who’ve known what it means to live with invisible wounds.
The core of The First Frost lies in how it explores healing not as a grand moment of catharsis, but as a slow, often painful, and deeply personal process. Wen Yifan’s trauma is not something love instantly cures, and Sang Yan’s devotion is never about "fixing" her. Instead, the drama beautifully illustrates what it means to hold space for someone else’s healing. Their relationship is defined not by romantic highs but by emotional intimacy: shared silence, gentle confrontation, late-night conversations, meals cooked and eaten in quiet company. They grow, stumble, and slowly learn how to coexist with their pain while reaching for something better together.
Flashbacks to their youth further enriches their bond, showing the youthful innocence they lost and the maturity they gain. Sang Yan’s POV moments at the end of several episodes serve as emotional anchors that allow us to fully empathize with his quiet but unyielding love.
Visually, The First Frost is a work of art. The cinematography — soft, grounded, often wistful — perfectly mirrors the emotional tone of the drama. The use of natural lighting, muted color palettes, and subtle framing adds texture to each moment, especially during emotionally charged scenes. The soundtrack deserves its own praise — emotionally resonant, unobtrusive, and deeply tied to character beats. The opening song, which initially feels skippable, grows on you and eventually becomes a part of the storytelling itself.
The directing and writing team clearly approached this project with deep care. There’s a remarkable attention to detail — from character expressions to scene transitions — that reflects their understanding of the source material and their commitment to doing it justice. While the supporting characters add texture, though the balance between the main and secondary arcs falters at times. The second storyline, particularly the Qiao Qiao-Haoan dynamic, feels underdeveloped, and the drama could’ve benefited from showing more of Qiao Qiao’s emotional landscape. Despite these hiccups, they do not undermine the power of the central story.
FINAL THOUGHTS
The First Frost is not a story for those in search of lighthearted entertainment or fast-moving plotlines. It is a drama for those willing to sit in silence, to feel deeply, and to embrace the messy reality of healing. Bai Jingting and Zhang Ruonan deliver some of the best performances of their careers, breathing life into two flawed, beautiful characters. And behind them, a production team whose dedication is felt in every frame.
In a world that often celebrates grand gestures and instant resolutions, The First Frost reminds us that true love is found in understanding, patience, and the quiet act of staying.
To the cast and crew, especially Bai Jingting, Zhang Ruonan, the director, writers, and everyone who made this story possible—thank you. You didn’t just make a drama. You told a story that stays with us long after the screen fades to black.
“Wen Shuangjiang, I’ve finally waited long enough for you.” — Sang Yan
Was this review helpful to you?



