This review may contain spoilers
two stories intertwined: one of them is OK, the other one is atrocious
This drama has one huge flaw, which is like a big dirty stain on a dress.The flaw I'm talking about, is the entire secondary plot—the story of Bing Zhu and Dreamshard Immortal/Pianpian.
If they'd cut out everything related to DI, all the episodes set in her realm, then all of Pianpian’s actions and Bing Zhu’s story and decisions, I would easily give this drama an 8 or maybe even 8.5 out of 10.
Not more, because an additional (though much smaller) burden is the weak chemistry resulting from Tan Songyun’s completely unromantic performance.
But even with this flaw, the story of Hong Ye and Xiao Yao, with their time travels and the backdrop of the human-demon conflict, would be quite enjoyable to watch. Moreover, in the space purified of the pointless secondary plot, they could have add more interactions between the main characters and potentially more episodic stories, like the one with the mountain elf or the squirrel who thought it was human.
The initial relationship between Hong Ye and Xiao Yao could also have been developed so that their feelings wouldn’t appear so suddenly and inexplicably. If it weren’t for that silly Bing Zhu, in the last episode the three powerful demons could have easily survived.
If I were to change things, I’d probably change the ending too, because the current one is mediocre.
Unfortunately, the screenwriter decided to “treat” us to this nightmarish secondary plot, which consists of some of the worst-written characters I’ve ever seen in dramas. Their decisions and behaviors are so utterly illogical that it’s painful to watch. It just doesn’t make sense. Why does Dreamshard Immortal No. 1 imprison Hong Ye, and force Xiao Yao to undergo a ridiculous test where she could lose her life? How would that bring her closer to completing the mirror, which is, apparently, her main goal? It would make more sense to imprison Xiao Yao and tell Hong Ye to bring the mirror to get his beloved back.
And what does Downshard Immortal 2.0, that is, Lu Pianpian, have against demons? Why does she set Bing Zhu against them? If she cares about him, she could arrange a wonderful life for him by manipulating the emperor’s dreams. And if, as DI, she absolutely has to kill someone, why demons and not humans? Humans hurt her much more.
The same goes for Bing Zhu, who has been a victim of human scheming since childhood. But it never even occurs to him to take revenge on those who actually hurt him. Instead, he’s obsessed with killing demons. He seems like a righteous person, but without batting an eye, he follows the orders of that disgusting emperor. His direct subordinate is a vile schemer who nearly gets him killed, but after Pianpian saves Bing Zhu, he continues to serve the emperor and—what’s even more absurd—his subordinate is still the same guy whose nasty character Bing Zhu has experienced firsthand. Why is he such an idiot?
Why does he keep listening to Hei Wu? And he’s not the only one. Hei Wu is generally a hopeless fool who just flails around chaotically, stirring up trouble everywhere, hoping it will somehow harm Hong Ye. But by episode 28, everyone should have realized he’s a psycho who’s not worth listening to or cooperating with, because he just jumps from one disaster to another and causes more problems than he solves. Yet he still manages to sow discord.
And Dali? For ten episodes, she’s Xiao Yao’s close friend. She’s nice and straightforward. Then suddenly, out of nowhere, she becomes a completely different character: false and cunning. Everyone in this side plot behaves illogically, running around like chickens with their heads cut off, and ultimately it’s unclear what they even want, and the whole story is terribly unconvincing. That’s why from episode 26 onward, the drama is much better, because there’s much, much less Bing Zhu, Pianpian, and the whole gang.
So in the end, I rate the whole thing 7/10. And if Neo hadn’t acted in it, I would have dropped it halfway through.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A visually stunning and emotionally charged karmic journey among humans and demons
It is a work that captivates viewers with its visual appeal. The special effects, costume design, and characterizations—both human and demonic—are of exceptional quality and beauty, immersing viewers in a rich and detailed world from the very first moment.The cast is also up to the task, with Neo Hou Minghao once again demonstrating his magnetism in roles of this nature, looking spectacular and bringing the necessary intensity to his character. Tan Songyun, for her part, shines with a subtle and powerful performance. Her main character is neither heavy-handed nor melodramatic; she possesses a strength and both human and demonic sides that make you empathize deeply with her journey, her pain, her love, her dilemmas, and her resilience.
The plot is the beating heart of the drama. It is a bittersweet and deeply karmic story that masterfully weaves together three lives intertwined by fate. The narrative skillfully explores the concept of time loops, where every encounter and sacrifice seems predestined. The central conflict between humans and demons transcends Manichaeism, showing complex characters who, in their struggle, betray their ideals and become what they swore to destroy, adding layers of tragedy and philosophical depth.
The secondary characters are wonderfully drawn and add emotional weight to the main plot. Special honorable mention goes to the last three demons, whose loyalty and ending are not only narratively justified, but whose deaths genuinely hurt.
The ending is a bittersweet masterpiece. While the narrative decision to have the protagonist return to the beginning is understandable, this conclusion is not triumphalist. On the contrary, it imbues everything with a deep melancholy and raises the most devastating question: Can anything really change? The series suggests that, in such an intricate karmic cycle where everything is connected, actions can be an echo of destiny, leaving the viewer wondering whether the outcome, however painful, is the only possible conclusion to a story where love and sacrifice are doomed to repeat themselves.
Conclusion: “The Unclouded Soul” is much more than a fantasy drama. It is a complete narrative and visual experience, a moving reflection on destiny, free will, the cost of war, and the cyclical nature of love and pain. With outstanding performances, a plot that hooks you from the first episode, and an ending that will haunt you long after the credits roll, it stands as a must-see for lovers of the genre and well-told stories.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Round and round to the end
Somewhere buried in the chaotic mess of these 40 episodes is a fairly straightforward message and commentary on the duality of human nature - its inescapable fallibility and simultaneous potential for achieving greats acts of goodness. These are perennial themes often seen in xianxia stories, and they are worthy of exploration. But 40 episodes to tell this tale was not needed. Every arc essentially said the same thing, and by the end, the devastation that was perhaps meant to wring the audience's tears only made me cringe in how poorly the story was executed.I think the main failings of this drama stemmed from its confused story structure - it is a story told in reverse to bring out a big reveal, which ends up not being so impactful because there are 20-30 episodes leading up to it that dance around it while not saying much of anything in the meantime. The human emperor? Red herring - he doesn't really impact the story. Dream Shard Immortal? Even Zhao Liying looks bored in her scenes because the meat of her story isn't shown, it is merely said in a monologue by another character. But the most critical story is the one from 10,000 years ago - depicting the humans' struggle against much more powerful demons that builds up to Hong Ye, the human prince at the time, and his betrayal of the demons (Although, the way the story is written, those demons deserved some of the badness that came to them given their equally despicable behavior).
The story of Ning'an and Hong Ye 100 years prior to the present story is also redundant. Perhaps it would have been wise to cut out either this whole storyline or the one from 10,000 years ago and focus on developing the human-demon struggle and characters. By the end, only Bingzhu and Pianpian are somewhat developed supporting characters.
In any case, this was an unfortunately dull and derivative xianxia story that did not afford the otherwise capable cast any great opportunity to craft interesting characters. Instead of being moved, I was exasperated at the end. Hong Ye's sacrifice is hollow because the story is riddled with holes. This story affords only a superficial pass at what could have been a powerful story about two very different people putting aside their prejudices and grievances to heal the world of war and hate.
Fans of the cast may still want to check this out - I was myself really eager to see Tan Songyun again in a costume drama - but prepare for a very long 40 episodes.
Was this review helpful to you?
So many mixed feelings..
Finishing this drama felt like an accomplishment for me 🤣 i gritted my teeth for the most part of this show.. I always love a show with Neo in it.. and they added Wang Duo an added bonus.. and there were other guest actors that i also love watching.. but even with all that incentive i had to fast forward alot of eps especially around ep30 on. And im usually against fast forwarding cuz whats the point of it right?!.. But the story just got so messy for me.. the back and forth travel through time and so much filler eps.. it lost it's grip on my attention and the story went all over the place around eps 20ish.. and it kept going down.. I believe this show couldve been done in 30 eps or less. If you want to know how the acting was.. all the actors/characters did well in acting.. they did their best. Its the directing and story telling that was the downfall in my opinion. This couldve been better if the directors and writers thought about a better execution of this story. Now would i recommend it? As always i tell people sure cuz you might like it. But would i rewatch it? No. The story isnt enough for me to rewatch and keep me coming back for more. Once was enough to say i watched it 💜Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
When True Love Feels Contradictory
Omg, The Unclouded Soul really messed with my head 😭. XY and HY meet across three lives, same people but different circumstances. But here’s the thing… XY kills HY more than once. In the first life, she’s the Dragon Lord, fully aware she’s her future self, and she still kills HY because he killed “innocent demons.” WHAT? That literally doesn’t match her character! She’s supposed to hate bloodshed and value peace between humans and demons. And yet, she kills the man she supposedly loves. How is that pure love?Then, in the second life, she kills HY again. fine, under external control, like a puppet but still… that’s two times HY is killed by her hands! In the third life, HY sacrifices himself to atone for his mistakes in their first life even though XY had already killed him twice. So why does he even need to sacrifice himself? Isn’t it already fair and square? And just to seal the Kunlun Mirror? I feel like there should’ve been another way. It should have been BZ who got sealed in the mirror. Why did he escape and survive when he’s the villain? Why did the director make HY die?? Oh my god, I just can’t handle this ending. Why did HY have to take on all the risk and bear all the consequences, even though it wasn’t 100% his fault? He’s just way too selfless.
The ending is bittersweet. XY lives on three years after HY’s death, and then XY time travels back to a happy moment from their last life. But here’s how I understand it:
• When XY time travels back to the moment before HY dies, she basically enters a loop of happy memories, reliving the moments they can enjoy together.
• In this loop, HY is still there; they can meet, talk, and experience happiness. But this isn’t the original timeline, the tragic future, where HY sacrifices himself, still exists in the main timeline.
• Emotionally, XY doesn’t have to face the reality of her loss while in the loop. She can escape her grief for a while and simply be with HY.
So, the ending is essentially an emotional escape / bittersweet closure: the audience and XY get a “happy moment,” even though the reality of tragedy remains. It’s more about emotional satisfaction than logically rewriting fate.
Honestly, the acting is amazing. Neo is heartbreakingly perfect but the plot? Messy. XY’s love for HY feels contradictory. She’s supposed to be someone who avoids killing, protects others, and values peace, yet she kills her lover twice. It’s hard to reconcile her actions with her character.
💔 So much love, so much heartbreak… but also so confusing.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A Beautiful, Flawed Fantasy
Initial Expectations vs. Reality 🎬After Love in the Clouds, I genuinely looked forward to Unclouded Soul. I loved Hou Minghao’s pairing in LITC, so I went into this drama determined to be fair and open-minded. Unfortunately, despite giving it multiple episodes and trying to understand the narrative direction, this drama never truly worked for me on an emotional or logical level.
Main Couple: Individually Fine, Together Mismatched 💔
Let me be clear first: both the ML and FL were okay as individual performances. I neither dislike nor strongly favor the female lead actress here. However, as a couple, they simply did not make sense to me.
There was a persistent lack of romantic chemistry. Their emotional beats felt forced rather than natural, and I never felt convinced that their bond had grown organically. Ironically, the chemistry between the FL and the SML was noticeably stronger, more emotionally grounded, and far more engaging to watch. That contrast only made the main romance feel weaker.
Romance Logic: Love That Came Too Easily ⏳
The biggest issue for me lies in the emotional logic of the love story.
A century ago, the ML was betrayed and killed by the woman he loved. That kind of trauma should leave a deep psychological scar. Yet when he meets a girl who looks exactly like her, he:
conveniently forgets the pain
falls in love again far too quickly
shows almost no internal conflict
Even in fantasy dramas, emotions must follow logic. This wasn’t tragic romance—it felt rushed and careless. There was no convincing buildup, no meaningful struggle, and no sense that the ML truly processed his past.
Plot Structure: Familiar, Predictable, and Disjointed 🔄
I watched five episodes in one day, and that alone says something—I wasn’t confused, just underwhelmed.
Many scenes felt overly familiar, almost recycled from other xianxia dramas. I could often predict where the story was heading, which removed any sense of tension or anticipation.
Worse, the narrative progression felt jump-cut and fragmented. Important motivations, consequences, and transitions were either rushed or skipped entirely, making the plot feel illogical rather than complex.
Demon Valley & World-Building: A Missed Opportunity 👹
The Demon Valley should have been one of the strongest elements of the drama—but instead, it felt strangely unserious.
The demons often behaved like comic relief rather than fearsome beings, and the ML, despite being the Demon King, lacked the authority, menace, or gravitas expected of someone in that position. His behavior didn’t match his title, which weakened both his character and the world-building.
Time Travel & Ending: Conceptual but Unsatisfying ⏳
The FL experiences three flashback events. In the first two, she fails to change the past—understandable, since she lacks foreknowledge.
But the final time?
She does understand future events—yet we’re supposed to believe everything will magically turn out differently.
Personally, I couldn’t trust that outcome.
I don’t mind open endings. I don’t even mind tragic endings. What I mind is an ending that feels emotionally unearned. This one left me unsatisfied—not because it was sad or ambiguous, but because it lacked conviction.
Side Characters: Confusing Choices ❓
The actions of the SFL and SML in the final episode felt unclear and unnecessary. I struggled to understand their narrative purpose at that point, which made the conclusion feel even more scattered.
Ironically, the SML was one of the more compelling characters throughout the drama—his motivations, inner conflict, and emotional restraint felt far more believable than the ML’s arc.
Production Value: Mixed Feelings 🎨
CGI & costumes: acceptable and sometimes visually pleasing ✨
Background settings: personally not appealing
Visuals couldn’t compensate for narrative weaknesses
Final Thoughts: Why It Didn’t Work for Me 🧊
Unclouded Soul had potential—a strong cast, a fantasy premise, and philosophical ideas about fate and desire. But in execution, it felt:
emotionally rushed
logically inconsistent
narratively predictable
Even if the creators intended a complex Möbius-loop structure, complexity only works when clarity exists first. Without emotional grounding, the drama felt cold rather than profound.
In the end, this wasn’t a drama I hated—but it was one that never truly touched my heart. And for a romance fantasy, that’s the most disappointing outcome of all.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Final Review: Enjoyable, colourful, and fun. Some issues towards the end but still worth a watch.
A vivid story with likeable characters that you end up rooting for, a great score accompanying it, and beauty everywhere you look. (From the actors to the scenery to the intricate costumes. It's all very bright and colourful and pretty.)
Pros:
- The characters are interesting. They all exist in a world at war, so none of them are free of biases and vices, but that makes them human and relatable.
- The main female character is charming. Often I find the main female character grating because she's written to be childish or unaware of what's going on, but even at the very beginning Xiao Yao is ingenious and likeable. She suffers from 'everyone likes me and most male characters are in love with me' but then almost all main female characters in Cdramas like this do.
- BingZhu is a fascinating character and is a highlight of this show for 90% of it. He's tortured, conflicted and principled and those three things don't work well together, leading to him having a horrible time throughout. (He's also fucked up and does some horrible things, but you understand why he does them.)
His friendship with Xiao Yao is also rather nice to see, because for once in a Cdrama like this I'm not stuck watching the second male lead pine for the main female lead and eventually realize she won't ever love him back. He liked Xiao Yao, but not like that and it was a delight.
Cons:
- Hong Ye as an all powerful demon king is interesting, but it doesn't help that this means they have a deus ex machina walking around so they chain him up and remove his power for a good part of this show. it means he's just decoration while Xiao Yao does shit and if he's your favourite that might drag a bit.
- The end is a bit of a mess. Still enjoyable and we do get closure for Xiao Yao, but it feels rushed and some of the character choices aren't my favourite.
Note: Spoilers!!
For example; BingZhu's character kind of gets assassinated towards the end when he willingly absorbs demonic energy to fight HongYe even though his entire character arc is 'I hate demons to my core and loathe all that they are (so I would never willingly become one) but I learn to see that the emperor is wrong to want to exterminate them all for his own gain since they are not all evil. I have seen the error of my ways. And yet I will go and fight the demon king I have learned to respect and work with - and who Xiao Yao loves - just so i can get back in the good graces of the emperor.' (Not to mention that PianPian absorbing the crystal heart is what caused her to lose herself, yet he's all of a sudden very willing to absorb demonic energy and stop being him.)
Second, at the end of the show they introduce three very interesting characters that we grow to like and then kill them off in very quick succession and without much fanfare just to power up BingZhu.
And you might not like the conclusion of Xiao Yao and Hong Ye's relationship.
Was this review helpful to you?
Good acting and technology but...
I finished watching The Unclouded Soul last night and while I think the cast, make up and technology are really good, the story didn’t grasp my attention as I thought it would. I think, ultimately, it’s a script problem because it uses all the tropes but not in a fun or fresh way.Long time cdrama watchers will understand when I say this was wasted potential because, sadly, we have seen this story before over and over again. But new cdrama fans might want to give it a try and figure out if xianxia is for them, this is a good option if you haven't seen any before.
Was this review helpful to you?
ABURRIDO
Reseña: El tedio infinito de The Unclouded SoulHay series que te atrapan desde el primer segundo y otras que, lamentablemente, se sienten como una tarea pendiente que nunca termina. The Unclouded Soul pertenece firmemente a la segunda categoría. Lo que en el papel se presentaba como un drama épico de época con toques de intriga política, terminó siendo un ejercicio de paciencia que pondría a prueba hasta al espectador más devoto de los C-dramas.
Un ritmo que no avanza
El principal problema de esta producción es su ritmo exasperante. Durante los primeros diez episodios, la trama se siente estancada en una exposición innecesaria. Los personajes se pasan horas tomando té y lanzando indirectas que no llevan a ninguna parte. Entiendo que el género suele tomarse su tiempo para construir el mundo, pero aquí el mundo se siente vacío. "No entiendo por qué seguimos discutiendo lo mismo", me dije a la mitad de la serie, esperando que el conflicto finalmente estallara. Pero el conflicto nunca llegó, o si lo hizo, fue tan sutil que se perdió entre diálogos redundantes.
Personajes sin alma
A pesar del título, las "almas" en esta serie carecen de cualquier chispa de vida. El protagonista masculino mantiene la misma expresión de madera desde el inicio hasta el fin. Se supone que es un hombre atormentado por su pasado, pero lo único que transmite es un aburrimiento profundo que se contagia a través de la pantalla. Por su parte, la protagonista femenina cae en todos los tropos del género sin aportar nada nuevo; su "evolución" es prácticamente inexistente.
En una escena clave, un personaje secundario intenta advertirles sobre una traición inminente:
"Tengan cuidado, el enemigo está más cerca de lo que creen", advirtió con tono sombrío.
Sin embargo, la respuesta de los protagonistas fue tan apática que eliminó cualquier sentido de urgencia. "Lo tendremos en cuenta", respondieron, para luego seguir mirando el paisaje por otros cinco minutos de metraje.
Aspectos técnicos: Pura fachada
Es innegable que la fotografía y el vestuario son hermosos, pero eso solo resalta más el vacío del guion. Es como tener un envoltorio de lujo para una caja que no contiene nada. Los efectos especiales en las pocas escenas de acción que hay se sienten desfasados y carecen de impacto. No hay tensión, no hay apuestas reales y, lo peor de todo, no hay una razón emocional para seguir viendo.
Conclusión
Si buscan una historia que los mantenga al borde del asiento o que les haga sentir una conexión real con los personajes, miren hacia otro lado. The Unclouded Soul es un drama que se pierde en su propia autocomplacencia visual. Al final, lo único que queda es la sensación de haber perdido horas valiosas en una narrativa que no supo qué dirección tomar.
Lo peor: La falta total de dinamismo.
Veredicto: Solo para quienes necesiten un remedio visual contra el insomnio. No se molesten, mejor entren a buscar algo con un poco más de sustancia.
Was this review helpful to you?
This didnt hit me :(
I feel like I am the only one who was struggling with this drama. I get the storyline about 3 Lifetimes and finding each other.Here is the thing, I really like Hou Ming Hao fantasy dramas because he know how to play his roles and I like Tan Song Yun work because I have watched alot of her dramas too.
They had great chemistry, dont get me wrong and that is why I pushed through to finish it but for me, there was just something about each episode that I cant put a pin on.
Xiao Yao character was so childish and her voice in the drama was a bit annoying. I started to deal with it when she was playing a different her other selves.
And then the "little demons" were too childish for me.
I didnt really get much of Xiao Yao being a very strong FL in this series and I love a strong ML and FL.
Fast forward to the end, I knew I was going to expect an ending like but it was good and other persons seems to enjoy it and I am glad they see and enjoy what I didnt.
Was this review helpful to you?
Awesome fantasy drama - worth a watch
LIKEMy god Sui Meng Xian Jun!! - her story also touched my heart
Xiao Yao keeps on destroying Zhu Yu's wooden hut lol
Have you found your cat then? Lol what kind of question
A Li's piece of story is really so touching I want to die - cry till death
Wow the plot twist is good when the girls going through tests in "Huan Xu Jing" my tears!
The tao sha story cannot let go soso good criesss
Going back to see the pasts is such a good idea
When Ning An tries to make Hong Yan cry lol
The three big demons so funny my god and innocent
Poor Pian Pian's pathetic life
How is Bing Zu being let off so easily lol
The last idea Xiao Yao came out with was a turning point for all events which was great
DISLIKE
The timeline when Xiao Yao found Hong Yan a little wrong he is with blood but at that time she still doesn’t know him or was it a sign only?
MUSIC - personal fav
怕是一场梦 Pa Shi Yi Chang Meng - 侯明昊 Hou Ming Hao
镜 Jing - 段奥娟 Duan Ao Juan
念与劫 Nian Yu Jie - 黄霄雲 Huang Xiao Yun
燃烬 Ran Jin - 井胧 Jing Long
从此 Cong Ci - 谭松韵 Tan Song Yun
人间辞 Ren Jian Ci - 许馨文 Xu Xin Wen
裂 Lie - 菲菲 Fei Fei, 李鑫一 Li Xin Yi
REWATCH VALUE
Shall re-watch when I have the time some day
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Ending has disappointed me ?
In this drama you might feel confused from the starting but as you move further in episodes you will find their different reincarnation story and and every story is engaging cause both lead's have suffered for their love . When I first saw that she killed him i was shocked but when I saw the reason in further episode I was crying because of her helplessness and how heart broken the male lead was but he still trusted her , his eyes was filled with tears but there was love to. HAO MINGHAO / TAN SONGYUN . Best drama but I am disappointed by the ending others might think she goes in the past to meet him they are happy there but I didn't expected this ending after being through so much .And I am not into sad ending that much it would hurt for days in real to so I watch less sad ending dramas 🥰🪷🐉
Was this review helpful to you?
